Service and staff were super friendly. Food was excellent, comfort food at its best. An overall great experience that I highly recommend. This will be added to the OBX must dine list! read more

The service was great. I ordered the chicken egg benie and my chicken was room temp, same as the biscuit. Was disappointed in that. Will give it another try next time with a follow up review of the place. read more

The Pony and The Boat - Fried chicken eggs benie - Comfort Food Near Me - Kitty Hawk, North Carolina

See all

Lovely meal while visiting OBX! Highly recommend the Brussel sprouts appetizer - incredible. We were well taken care of by our server- Kim. For dinner husband had seafood medley with a delicious amber ale. I went for the vegetable Mac and cheese. Both were served piping hot and were delicious. I also admired the use of upside down boat / canoe as lighting. The owner was on site - which also speaks highly of ensuring everything ran smoothly. We will return here on our next visit for sure ! read more

The Pony and The Boat - Brussel sprouts appetizer - Comfort Food Near Me - Kitty Hawk, North Carolina

We ate here last week while on vacation for the 3rd time. We got there when it opened and even though we had a reservation there was no wait! --The cheesesteak egg rolls - 5 STARS! So good - the dipping sauce was great too! You have to order this app!! -Cornbread app - not as great as I remembered it being the last time, but still good. -Wings special - I think we had honey bbq - always good! -Fried Chicken - wasn't told there was an uncharge for fries instead of slaw but the entire meal was good! -Special Surf & Turf kabobs - 5 STARS on the taste - the chimchurri was so good but felt like it was a bit pricey ($38) for the amount of protein that came with it (4 shrimps and 3 pieces of steak) -Crabcake app - very good - nice flavor lots of crab -Filet - My daughter ordered this and again 5 STARTS! It was so delicious - the sauce and the potatoes and the cut of meat was great as well. I would order this again and again. We finished with the cheesesteak and the key lime pie - both delicious as well!! I really wanted to try the brownie sundae, but was taking mine to go and was so full after dinner - will def try that next time. read more

See all

We decided to give The Pony and The Boat a try, based on the reviews. It was excellent. Service was great and so was the food. My wife had the house salad with a side steak and I couldn't believe the amount of steak they gave her. Cooked a perfect medium rare. I had the corn and crab chowder, which my wife helped me eat. It was a huge bowl of chowder and very tasty. I also had the Shrimp and Grits. They were great and the shrimp were cooked perfectly plus they were very big shrimp. The vegetables were awesome also. We will be back. Our server did a great job also. read more

Food was ok. Server was terrific !!! The main issue ? Cockroach crawling up the wall behind our table while we armed dessert. Don't think we will return. read more

Everything was just ok. The pot pie does NOT look like the older pictures on yelp. It was a sad thin top crust (no inside crust) and the inside was soupy and lacking flavor. I was super bummed! Also said it would come with a side salad and came with sad green beans that were over salted (the only salted thing at the table). The Mac and cheese and seafood entrees were enjoyed at my table. Meh ambiance. Staff was nice. read more

Great food, great drinks and cocktails. We were seated immediately on what we thought would be a busy night. I'd call this a hidden gem

Wonderful experience! Our server, Clover, was awesome. She was friendly and attentive without being overbearing. We had the Brussels sprouts for an appetizer (not pictured), and I could eat an entire plate on my own. For our main courses, we had the fresh catch (crab cakes) and the pork chop. Both were delicious! One of the best pork chops I've had--was cooked perfectly and the jam on top was delicious. Highly recommend!! I could eat here every day. read more

The Pony and The Boat - Crab cake special (far) and pork chop. - Comfort Food Near Me - Kitty Hawk, North Carolina

First time at those restaraunt and was greeted by Tray who was also our server. Service was the best I have seen in the OBX. I had the special ... braised ribs which melted in your mouth perfect potatoes and broccoli. This is definetely a little more upscale and on the higher side pricewise.....it was worth every bite. Desert was a double chocolate brownie with sea salt caramel ice cream topped with whip cream..enough for two and we'll worth it. I will do it again soon! read more

Overpriced. Overrated. Filets were $50, tough, chewy and one was overcooked (ordered medium) and one under (ordered medium rare). And yes, I know how to order a steak and discern the temp. Waitress was snarky. Don't waste your time or your beach vibes here, find something else where your money is put to good use. Do better Pony read more

We had a great dinner here and would definitely return. Pros/Highlights: the cheesesteak eggrolls were amazing and very flavorful. I had the shrimp and grits which was the best shrimp and grits entree I've ever had. It had big chunks of bacon in it. My husband had the ribs which were huge and meaty but just a little overcooked. For dessert we had the warm brownie which was very moist and decadent. The drinks were just ok. For drinks we tried an Old Fashioned, the Orange Yum Yum (like a doctored up orange crush), the Pony 75 (their spin on a french 75), and an espresso martini. The espresso martini was pretty lackluster and had a muted flavor. The martinis were also on the small side. The drinks were the only part of meal that were just ok and that could use some improvement. All the food was wonderful though. We would definitely return and recommend this restaurant to friends and family. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious brunch! Had the eggs Benedict and the hollandaise was so good! I also recommend the cinnamon rolls read more

We were pleasantly greeted when we entered. The service was very good and the food was excellent. I had the vegetarian mac and cheese and it was fabulous. We were lucky that the place was not crowded because I think the large, open dining room would have been very loud during busy hours. We had a great experience! read more

This is an interesting spot with a lot of potential... To start, the front of house personnel are all excellent--prompt, friendly, and engaging. We were quickly sat (had a reservation) but the main dining room is VERY loud due to the open concept and high ceilings; the space is also not overly comfortable, this may be exacerbated by the feeling that you are just kind of sticking out at the tables that dot the open space with no discernible sense of "here's my table where I'm dining"--it just feels a bit disjointed. We started with drinks and the poutine appetizer. The old fashioned was decent and the poutine was incredible--creamy, gooey, exceptional pork belly and just the right amount of crisp on the fries. For the entree we did the filet and seafood medley. The filet was cooked to order and had a nice seasoning, the mashed potatoes were also exceptional. The medley was a disappointment, it was simply seafood doused in heavy butter--just a bit one note overall, especially for the price point. The sweet tea is classic south...it really is an art. For us, this restaurant could be next level with a few tweaks to the ambiance and seafood offerings. read more

We visited The Pony and The Boat on our date night while on our annual vacation to OBX. We were seated quickly and served immediately. We got the crab dip as an appetizer and I ordered the seafood pot pie and my significant other ordered the steak for our meals. All of it was delicious! I would definitely rate this in our top restaurants we have visited in the Outer Banks! read more

See all

By far one of my favorite new restaurants I've discovered while going to the Outer Banks. Top notch food & flawless service. Our waitress was one of the best! I think one of the main dishes this place is known for is their chicken pot pie. I can definitely see why. It was one of the best I've had to date. Their cornbread is also like non-I've had before. Highly recommend ordering both. The pumpkin pie is also delicious. Five stars all the way. read more

See all

It's a quaint place, we stopped for brunch on our way out of town. Very friendly host and server. Started with the blood orange mimosa and I had the shrimp and grits. Hubby had the three pig, he didn't love it according to him it was just a skillet of tater tots. I enjoyed the shrimp n grits, the sauce was good but could have used more or it. Had a side of bacon. read more

See all

I ended up here on a whim because the first two places I tried were packed. Did a quick Yelp search and found this little gem with great reviews so figured I would give it a try. We had a part of 8 and were seated right away! The dining area to the left is very spacious and open with high ceilings. The manager (or maybe he's the owner) was super nice and the waitress we had was amazing! She was constantly refilling drinks without us having to ask, very knowledgeable of the menu and had an overall positive, friendly attitude. The menu selection isn't huge or overwhelming like some other places. I had the cheesecake egg rolls which were amazing! I really didn't expect them to taste that good so it was a pleasant surprise. I also had the garden salad which was very fresh. I will certainly be back! read more

The Pony and The Boat - Comfort Food Near Me - Kitty Hawk, North Carolina

See all

Here on vacation! Fantastic service! It was not busy. Food was great and so were the drinks. I got the martini and ravioli!

Another wonderful diner at The Pony and the Boat. Seafood Pasta was creamy smooth. Crab Dip was a great start. Their desserts are all made in house. Thank you John for the great service. read more

See all

Enjoyed a delicious brunch with family! Two of us ordered the pork skillet and the third has the steak skillet. The gravy on the pork skillet was amazing. Tip: ask for it on the side. The sauce on the steak skillet was also very good. Poached eggs are cooked perfectly and the potatoes are nice and crispy! read more

The Pony and The Boat - Pork cutlet skillet - Comfort Food Near Me - Kitty Hawk, North Carolina

See all

This was my birthday dinner on the OBX - highly recommend! We couldn't go to our fave from the spring, Paper Canoe, due to being closed for the season; however, we found this one in a local magazine. We heard it's also owned by the folks who own Paper Canoe -- wouldn't be surprised! This place has been open for a little less than a year, but we'll definitely be coming back in May. We had a great booth seat, and the place was still decorated for Christmas (at the time). I got their Wedge Salad and the fried seafood combo with mashed potatoes and their Three Sisters veggie. My sister had a great seafood dish as well - beautiful presentation, and delicious! Check out our pictures! I added a picture of the front of the restaurant since there wasn't one yet -- it's in a strip mall location on the west side of road. read more

See all

Came here on a whim after a nice walk on the sounds side of Kitty Hawk. Had the seafood pasta and the Sea Bass. Both amazing. Friendly staff and great atmosphere. read more

After grabbing two seats at the bar, we quickly were greeted by the bartender. The bar and restaurant was pretty full. I noticed they take reservations and that's a welcome sight! Many places don't. We started with craft cocktails : the drop of lemon and the orange yum yum. Both drinks are fruity forward but not overly sweet! They have a cocktail and beer of the day which is a fun way to choose something new. If cocktails are your thing, they have NC craft beer (can and draft) plus a good wine selection. The fried pickles are amazing! They are lightly fried and so yummy. Not overly spiced but great flavor and a good dipping sauce. For dinner, my friend and I split the vegetarian Mac and cheese. And oh my gosh. My friend said "this is one of those dishes I'll be thinking about for a long time!" So amazingly good! It's a big serving size so no problem for us two to split. They got busy and our bartender was hustling! Definitely a place to hit back up! We will be back for more of that creamy Mac! read more

See all

Selected this off of Yelp reviews on a whim. Excellent choice. Everything on the menu looked and sounded delicious so it was difficult to select. I opted for the filet mignon special & it did not disappoint. The other guests opted for their ribs and raved as well. Portion sizes are large -- come hungry! Service was excellent. The owner (or one of) welcomed us personally and was very appreciative of our patronage. It's a relatively smaller venue probably 25 tables and a large size bar. The dining area is nicely separated from the kitchen. Definitely recommend and would come back without hesitation. read more

Nice place, great service, delicious down home comfort food. Bar serves beer, wine and alcohol. We will definitely return.

You are missing out if you have not been to this little gem! The food is absolutely delicious! What a chef! I was introduced to this place during girls weekend last fall. We all loved the food! I brought my husband a couple of weeks ago and he swears it's the best shrimp and grits ever! We came back again this weekend and it was just as good, maybe better! We even ran into a family member that also lives 3 hours away. They enjoy this place too. You will likely find the owner, Tommy, as the host and constantly keeping an eye in things. Super nice guy! Stop by to say hi and enjoy a delicious meal! read more

See all

Wow, great food & we only got take out. Shrimp & grits awesome. Was the best meal we had all week in OBX! Will be reserving a table to bring everyone in this gem in Kitty Hawk read more

I always ask myself 'would I go back ' to a recently visited restaurant? I am rather neutral if I would go back again. Now our waiter Tray was great at his job for sure. And our mixed drinks were also well made. The foods were a mix. The corn and crab chowder was very savory by way of the stock and strongly overwhelmed the flavor of the crab that was in the soup. Crab is a delicate protein that I think a clear or cream broth would be better. The corn bread was yummy. Crisp on the outside yet moist on the interior. The snow peas and carrots, the snow peas needed strings removed, but the vegetables were otherwise well prepared. The food was 'ok' but I was expecting exceptional. read more

We ate here twice during our vacation last week, and both times the food and service was great! Highly recommend the cornbread, pastas, and seafood melody. We were too full to have dessert, but they sounded really good. Highly recommend! read more

I am completely perplexed by the abundance of high reviews. The food was nice enough, but not outstanding or memorable in any way. Extremely straightforward, very basic and plain preparations of seafood. Every entree (except for one special) came with the exact same side: slightly underdone snap peas and carrots with no seasoning beyond salt. The service was rushed, our server seemed to have given up for the night, and we were made to feel like we were in the way of the closing routine at barely 8:30 pm (we had an 8 pm reservation.) read more

My husband and I had 3 appetizers and the crème brûlée. Every bite was delicious. We had the lollipop lamb, oysters Rockefeller, and poutine. We enjoyed the lamb so much, we ordered it a second time. While so much on the menu looked great, we only had the appetizers and closed out with the crème brûlée (also delicious). We sat at the bar, but took note of the general ambiance and found that it would work well for couples or families. We will definitely include a meal here on our next OBX trip. read more

The Pony and The Boat is a fantastic restaurant!! So glad my family decided to try this restaurant on a Friday night. It was hard to find a restaurant that would take reservations for a large party for dinner. The owner answered the phone and gave us an eta of 20-25 mins. It took a little extra time, but the owner was really nice and upfront with setting the expectations and talking to our family to buy the time! There are also a few benches in the waiting area that was a nice bonus. Parking: This restaurant is in a shopping center with other stores. It's a shared parking lot that had plenty of parking spaces on a Friday evening. The Pony and The Boat is a beautiful restaurant that lives up to its name. Literally a decorated Pony statue in the dining area!! The restaurant was clean and I liked that they had seating for ever party, including an outdoor patio to make this pet friendly. The decorations were elegant with beautiful hanging lights. It's hard to find a nice restaurant in the OBX that does not look divey or smells musky. Staff was professional and friendly! All servers were uniformed by wearing black and having there hair neatly pulled back. Our server was nice and quick with our big party. The only item I would have liked is if she cleared our empty plates from our appetizers to give us more table room when our entrees came out. Food: the food was amazing! I loved the dinner specials for the evening. Each item had a little twist that enticed you to order it. Appetizers: -Buffalo Cheetos Hot Wings (special item): these wings were delicious! It had a classic buffalo wing sauce with crushed up Cheetos that coated the exterior. The spice wasn't too spicy that you could still enjoy the wings. This came with ranch sauce and celery sticks on the side. -House Cornbread: this corn bread was delicious! This bread is not super sweet but still flavorful! It came with two thick squares that you can cut into fourths for sharing. Honey butter was on the side to spread over each piece. -Cast Iron Skillet Tater Tot Poutine: I loved the twist with tater tots and pork belly pieces in the gravy. It was a great balance of salty and savory. Cooking this in a cast iron took the appetizer to another level to keep this dish warm. -Crab Dip: the crab dip was amazing! It had good chucks of crab meat and came with a great portion of pita bread. Entrees: -Fried Seafood Platter Shrimp and Flounder Combo: the seafood was super fresh! Good portions of the fish and shrimp to make a filling meal. I liked that the batter for the seafood was not too thick, and the perfect coating to give you a crunch. The coleslaw and cornbread sides complimented this platter! This also came with remoulade and cocktail sauces. -Seafood Pasta: the seafood pasta was flavorful! I expected this to be more of a shrimp scampi garlic sauce however, this was more tomato based with a lot more liquid. This came with Bucatini noodles that were a little over cooked. What really made this dish was the amount of seafood that was in the pasta! They didn't short change the seafood that made this worth it. -Fried Chicken: I was a little skeptical ordering fried chicken at this restaurant, but the owner insisted that it was cooked in a pressure cooker and delicious. My boyfriend ordered this and it lived up to our standards. This is served with half of the bird including the breast and every part of the chicken had a flavorful exterior crispy coating, while the meat was moist and juicy on the inside. The classic southern sides of potato salad and coleslaw complimented this dish and made it filling! -Chicken Pot Pie: this dish came in a mini skillet with the chicken pot pie perfectly cooked! The outside of the pie dough was crispy and the inside was doughy. The chicken mixture on the inside was warm and seasoned well. We were able to also switch out the cucumber tomato salad for the twice baked potato for a slight up charge! -House Mac and Cheese: the Mac and Cheese came with Cavatappi pasta noodles and bacon. This was good but on the saltier side, especially with the bacon crumbles added to this. Overall, my family enjoyed the food and experience at The Pony and the Boat! This will not be the last time we visit this restaurant. I would say I'm a "semi-local" living in Norfolk and willing to make the 1.5 hr drive to have dinner here. LOL That's how much we enjoyed the food! read more

See all

Really great! We came in at 5pm for a reservation of 12 people. We had great and friendly service from start to finish. The drinks were great, the food was even better. The corn and crab chowder were tasty, I paired that with a wedge. My husband had the tile fish special, which was also tasty. Someone at the table had the shrimp and grits and the seafarer pasta which were also tasty. The Savy B Nautilus was great, we had two bottles! We will be back! The ambiance is fun, from beautiful sculpture horses and wooden fun boats. 10/10! Loved our visit! Thank you! read more

Loveee all the food we got. We did not dine in but picked up the food instead and they were just as good. There were so much brussel sprouts I thought it could feed 3-4 ppl instead of just two of us. Its very well seasoned. Amount is huge for each dish and there were leftovers for us to finish the next day. read more

See all

Appetizers very good including cheese steak egg rolls,Oysters Rockefeller. Salads were large and delicious. Shrimp and grits, seafood pasta, Mac n Cheese delicious. Comfortable atmosphere and very attentive staff. No problem accommodating 11. read more

I am very impressed with this place. Very clean on the inside, friendly service, food came out quickly and our meals tasted great. We opted to sit at the bar and our bar tender was super nice and friendly. We started with drinks and I had the Awww Yeah which was delicious and my boyfriend had the Old Hickory Ruby Lager. We got the crab dip to start and it was really good but definitely a plate you want to share. For our meals, my boyfriend enjoyed a medium rare prime rib which he said was delicious. I dined on the chicken pot pie which was fresh and cook perfectly: the cucumber salad that came with it was delicious as well. Atmosphere was great and we are glad we chose this place over the other places that are in the area. I gave them 5 stars because I know they're a notch above their competition. read more

See all

Great food and amazing service! My husband got the Duck and it was incredible. The crab dip appetizer was also a must have! They accommodated our 9 month old baby and made the whole dining experience wonderful! read more

The Pony and The Boat - Crab dip and Oyster Rockefeller - Comfort Food Near Me - Kitty Hawk, North Carolina

See all

Awesome food and service. We are at the bar and the service and Food were excellent. Highly recommend. read more