Cancel

Open app

Search

The Pizza Company - Baldwin

3.8 (30 reviews)
Open • 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

Order The Pizza Company - Baldwin Takeout or Delivery

The Pizza Company - Baldwin Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

More like The Pizza Company - Baldwin

Recommended Reviews - The Pizza Company - Baldwin

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

The Pizza Company Box!
Richard V.

Rating: 4.6 Stars I have been eating The Pizza Company in South Baldwin for well over a decade. I came here back in the days of Tastee-Freez. Man, I miss those vanilla milkshakes and their amazing soft serve, including the vanilla soft serve dipped in blue goo! I'd get the cheese fries multiple times a month in high school. Fast forward to 32-year-old me... ...I am visiting Pittsburgh for the holidays, and my brother requested that we order some pizzas from here. We ordered a cheese pizza and a pepperoni pizza. Glad we did! Their pizza has been INCREDIBLY consistent over the years. It always has a lot of flavor, and the sauce has a nice sweetness. The dough has great taste and a nice texture. There is a slight crisp to the crust, which is great. The three-cheese blend is yummy and flavorful. They are generous with the pepperoni slices, which have great savory taste and a nice crisp. Importantly, the pizza slices have great flop. This is one of the best pizzas in Pittsburgh in my opinion, especially for the price. My only complaint would be that there can be a little extra grease at times--nothing that a little dabbing can't fix! Finally, their business website is quite nice! Furthermore, they do a great job with pick-up and following COVID-19 protocols to protect their employees and customers. Give them the business during this pandemic!

Opened cheesesteak with ketchup added.
Pete J.

I've only ever had the Philly steak and cheese hoagie. My coworkers love this place and eat here all the time. Their favorite is the Italian hoagie and pizza. Today they talked me into ordering with them and I ordered the Philly. It's a decent size hoagie, for $12 I expect as much. It was decent, but it had a unique taste. Not terrible but just odd. I'm trying to figure it out, maybe an artificial beef flavoring? I'm just not sure what it was. I still gobbled the hoagie down, but still spent the entire time guessing what the flavor was. Despite not being wowed, I'll go back again and try the Italian or pizza that my coworkers all love.

Small Cheese Pizza
Cydney D.

I just moved to the Pittsburgh area last May and was desperately searching for the best pizza in our area. I live two minutes up the road from The Pizza Company and let me tell you....it's dangerous! This pizza is by far my number one favorite pizza place and almost tops my hometown favorites. The staff has been so friendly and their COVID regulations are super great! I am obsessed with their pizza! My only complaint is that their prices are a littttttlleeee high, however, for how much I love this pizza..it's so worth it.

Yes, I ate half of it before I took the pic.

See all

6 months ago

Pizza was very good! They do slices which was also nice. Service was quick and friendly

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

The pizza was great and so was Alyssa, friendly and outgoing to please the customer! Give her a raise Pizza Company she is a keeper!!!!!!!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of J L.
40
92
10

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Amy K.
0
44
0

1 year ago

Ordered a medium veggie pizza. It was delicious. The delivery service was great. The pizza was hot and the cheese was gooey and yummy.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Jim D.
0
13
0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Outstanding food and service!!! Really enjoyed our food order. Thank yo all again!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Noah K.
195
5
0

6 years ago

Lived in Pittsburgh for 10 years and this is the best pizza I've ever had here. Highly recommend trying their ranch as well.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - The Pizza Company - Baldwin

Review Highlights - The Pizza Company - Baldwin

“6 Stars I have been eating The Pizza Company in South Baldwin for well over a decade.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 16,827 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Lebo Subs - Italian (half size)

Lebo Subs

4.2(98 reviews)
4.1 mi
•$

Amazing, friendly staff, fast service, definitely rating my experience 5 stars…read more The environment is very clean, will absolutely be back next time I'm in Mt Washington

I'm visiting from out of town, and this place looked amazing, so I was genuinely excited to stop in…read moreand try it. Unfortunately, my customer service experience wasn't quite what I had hoped for. I walked in happy and smiling, but the initial interaction with the employee taking my order felt a little unfriendly and unwelcoming. I clearly asked for half of a sub but was given a full sub instead. That honestly wasn't a huge issue for me, but combined with the interaction, it did affect my overall experience. I completely understand that working in customer service can be difficult and that everyone has an off day. At the same time, I think a friendly and welcoming attitude can make such a difference, especially for someone who is visiting the area and trying a restaurant for the first time. First impressions really do matter, and unfortunately, I left feeling disappointed after being so excited to come in. I do want to mention that the young lady who checked me out was wonderful. She was very polite, friendly, and provided great customer service. As far as the food goes, the sub, pasta salad, and potato salad were absolutely immaculate! Everything tasted great, and I really enjoyed the food. I just wish the customer service at the beginning of my visit had matched the quality of the food. A little more warmth and attentiveness would have made this a completely different experience.

Photos
Lebo Subs - Exterior of restaurant

Exterior of restaurant

Lebo Subs
Lebo Subs - Half club sandwich with pasta salad

See all

Half club sandwich with pasta salad

Frisch's - Reuben Sandwich

Frisch's

3.5(95 reviews)
1.4 mi
•$

We included Frisch's in one of our taste-off meals. This particular taste off was for fried chicken…read morestrips. Frisch's did not win! However, I also bought the broasted chicken. That was a winner. Crispy outside, moist inside. It was a busy Sunday and they were swamped with catering orders. I was warned that it would take 25 minutes for my order to be ready. No problem because I had other competitors' chicken strips to pickup. My order was ready at the appointed time. Atmosphere is a busy deli. All food, hot & cold, is ordered from the front counter. Meat, cheeses, salads, desserts by the pound. Create your own ala carte meal or deli meats to take home. There is a dining room where your prepared food is delivered to your numbered table. I will return to eat in next time.

Not very good...dragged there by my Father who wanted soup…read more Got the fish sandwich, nothing about it was good. The bun was way too big and rock hard stale....the fish was overcooked and tasteless, no amount of lousy Kraft Tartar/Tabasco/Vinegar could save it. Fresh cut fries, which I had high hopes for were dry, bland and overcooked as well. Dining partners weren't too thrilled with their meals as well (Cajun Chicken, boring soup and salad)... I've been to Frisch's a few times, never anything special, but this was the worst. Dining room atmosphere is lifeless... After thinking about it my 2 stars is probably a bit generous...

Photos
Frisch's - Interior

Interior

Frisch's - Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

Frisch's - Exterior

See all

Exterior

Fredos Deli - Burek w/Cheese (Sirnica). So delicious!

Fredos Deli

4.3(53 reviews)
4.5 mi
•$

Fredos Deli is about kind people making great food. Both, pie and sausage links were delicious…read more I could eat it every day, it is that good. I was happy to support small business.

I've driven up and down Potomac Ave for years and never noticed Fredo's which is right next door to…read morethe Dormont Theater. I had to stop into Fredo's after seeing photos from my daughter who had just spent two weeks in Bosnia. The interior of Fredo's is like stepping into a small shop you'd find in Bosnia. The yellow walls are welcoming, and cozy. There's a small variety of snacks, and beverages on one side of the shop, and a large counter where you'd place your order. There are a few tables for dining in, but I chose to take my order home. I ordered a small Cevapi and Sirnica, plus picked up some Croatian chocolate for dessert. The Cevapi were delicious skinless beef and veal sausages, that were nicely savory and well browned. A cup of chopped onions, and what I think was a yogurt sauce came with my Cevapi which added more flavor and an overall goodness to the Cevapi. A bread similar to a pita made eating Cevapi easy, and filling. The Sirnica was equally delicious. A wonderful mix of flaky, chewy phyllo pastry, and cheese baked inside the pastry. It definitely hit the spot with a nice balance of a light pastry and mild cheese. I ate the leftover half cold, and it was just as good! The lady at the counter was friendly, and patient with me. The menu is truly a deli menu full of sandwiches, salads, and appetizers. If you're wanting to go for the House Specials, you won't be disappointed!

Photos
Fredos Deli
Fredos Deli - Inside peanut butter cookies

Inside peanut butter cookies

Fredos Deli

See all

Chimera Brewery - Nachos

Chimera Brewery

3.9(66 reviews)
2.4 mi

The food is fire. The beer selection is fantastic. My lady thoroughly enjoyed her strawberry…read morecocktail, too. The service was on point this last time with Savannah for our server. The manager told us this is her first time with full service and she's a natural- friendly and attentive. The makeover of the inside was well done and is fun to look at with the cooler doors and the God themed posters. We were sad to see Mindful close but this is quite an upgrade. We have been coming in since it reopened and it gets better every time. It has become our go-to over prior local favorites. Highly recommend the burrata pizza or brisket sandwich my girl gets the smash burger every time and never gets sick of it.

I have been wanting to try this place since it took over Mindful Brewing. I never went to Mindful…read morebut I was looking forward to a brewery being close to my home. Upon entering the place is very cute and spacious with plenty of seating both indoors and outside. Of course outside there are some games for the kids or adults. We were greeted immediately upon entering and was seated right away. Our server was nice but we had some things wrong with our order and just didn't complain. There is a good amount of options for Gluten Free people which is nice.When taking our order I asked how many sauces we could get I'd we got the 12 count of wings. He stated we could get 2. We ordered the Dry Rub and the Garlic Parm, we only got the Garlic Parm. We got the Buffalo Cauliflower for an appetizer. Some pieces were super mushy and I wasn't the biggest fan but my boyfriend thought it was pretty good. The wings though overcooked has a decent flavor. My son got probably the best deal in the menu but he said the Mac and Cheese had no flavor. He loved the tenders though he said they were really good. I like that they have a happy hour and they do have seltzer on tap which is nice. I got the Watmerlon one and it wasn't overbearing fake watermelon flavor it was refreshing and light. We didn't complain about the food because there was only one cook the day we went and it got pretty busy in there and he was doing it all himself. He was definitely overwhelmed and you could tell but he did a decent job. It did take a good while to get our food but again he was by himself. Id be back to try their burger when I looked over at the table behind me they got it and it looked super juicy, big and yummy!

Photos
Chimera Brewery - View from restaurant

View from restaurant

Chimera Brewery - Nashville hot chicken

Nashville hot chicken

Chimera Brewery - Interior

See all

Interior

Pour Johnny’s - Outside

Pour Johnny’s

4.8(12 reviews)
2.5 mi

We were so excited to learn that Pour Johnny's was opening right near the border of Bethel Park and…read moreCastle Shannon, so of course we had to try it out soon after its opening! Pour Johnny's is a locally-owned coffee shop that features coffee, different drinks, and some food items. For the drinks, the feature hot coffee, iced coffee, smoothies, quenchers, chillers, teas, matcha, and some prepackaged options. They do not have hot food items, but they feature baked goods from other local businesses, such as Brown Bear Bread, Jonesy Cakes, and more. The business is located on Library Road, very close to the Bethel Park and Castle Shannon border. Specifically, it sits between the Library and Connor Road intersection, and the Library and Rockwood Avenue intersection. It is also very close to the St. Anne T Stop. Due to the location, there can be some traffic from time-to-time getting in and out of the complex, but that is just due to the natural traffic patterns in this part of town. Pour Johnny's is in the Center 88 Strip Mall, being the right corner unit for the building on the left side. It occupies the space that was formerly South Hills Nutrition. There is adequate signage for the store both on the Center 88 road sign, as well as above the shop entrance. So, you should have no issue locating it! Since this is located within a strip mall, there are a lot of parking spaces all around. There are also some on the right-side of the building, since it is a corner unit. We had no issues finding our parking spot right in front of the entrance when we visited. My visit here was shortly after the business began operations. It was a Friday morning in October, right around 11:00 AM. My fiance and I were the only customers in the store at this time, so it was not at all busy. I imagine we came during the non-peak hours, since this is a coffee shop after all! The ambiance of this place overall is just darling. It is a quaint shop, but full of life, fun colors, artwork, and lots of goodies to explore. There is minimal indoor seating, but there are also some tables on the covered patio outside to enjoy your drinks at during nicer weather. I really like all the color and personality they brought into this space. One of the owners waited on us during this visit, and she was so kind! You can tell that she really loves what she does, and is the perfect person to be running a business like this. It was so nice to meet her, chat for a bit, and support her business. There are a lot of different options for drinks here! There are different coffee options, several fruity drinks options, non-coffee options, and more. To add to those drinks, there are several flavoring and syrup options to choose from. They even have root beer on tap! We took a few minutes to look at the menu and go through everything they have available. After placing our order, we only had to wait a few minutes for it to be ready. Considering they hand-make all of the drinks, it was prepared pretty quickly! I ordered a 16 Oz Cold Brew with light cream, which I very much enjoyed! The coffee was good quality, and it was a nice size for a midday treat. My fiance ordered the Featured 16 Oz Italian Cream Soda. I thought this was a unique menu item, and he did enjoy giving it a try. In terms of value, I believe Pour Johnny's is on-par with the other local coffee shops in this area. For our two drinks, we paid a little over $10 with tax. A 10 Oz Latte was $5, and most drinks had an option under that $5 price point. I think it is worth it to come here, when taking into account the product received along with the price. This shop is a great addition to the South Hills! I enjoyed my drink, and it is cool to see the creative features and unique menu items they carry. I can see myself becoming a frequent flyer here, given how much I enjoyed my visit and the shop's proximity to my house. If you find yourself in Castle Shannon/the South Hills and want to support a local coffee shop, look no further than Pour Johnny's! I would highly recommend giving a it a try.

such a cute place in a great location! There's plenty of parking and very easy to get to if you…read morework/live in the south hills area. everytime I come in the service is always so kind.They have plenty of syrups to choose from! They have little treats on the table as well, my favorite being the smores cookie. My coffee was great! it's never bitter and not super sweet! if you like cozy mom and pop shops this a great place to checkout

Photos
Pour Johnny’s
Pour Johnny’s
Pour Johnny’s

See all

Cibrone M & Sons Bakery - Tomatoes, pastas, etc.

Cibrone M & Sons Bakery

4.3(34 reviews)
2.1 mi
•$

A perfect little family run Italian bakery with everything you would want but not so big that…read morequality suffers in any way. From the heavenly Sfogliatelle (that Oakmont can only dream of producing these days) and other bakery items to the fantastic pizza and excellent deli - you won't leave disappointed. The staff is genuinely friendly and always helpful - just a real pleasure to visit.

M. Cibrone and Sons Bakery was founded in 1955 and sells Italian baked goods, breads, deli goods,…read moreand local and imported groceries. In-store shopping, wholesale, and fundraising are available. Baked goods include pies, cakes, pastries (cannoli, sfogliatelle, lady lock, baklava, strudel, gob, brownie, danish, cinnamon roll, coffee cake, nut roll, etc.), and cookies (Italian wedding cookies, biscotti, chocolate chip, peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, thumbprint, lady lock, etc.). Breads include Italian, sourdough, rye, Frizzelle, rolls, buns, pizza doughs, etc. Deli goods include cheeses (mozzarella, provonello, fontinella, asiago, romano, parmigiana, ricotta, American, Swiss, cheddar, etc.), meats (ham, turkey, bologna, roast beef, salmi, pepperoni, sopressata, prosciutto, capicola, etc.), pasta salads, etc. Lunch hoagies are also available. Groceries include frozen foods (lasagna, ravioli, manicotti, pepperoni rolls, pizzas, etc.), packaged foods (pastas, sauces, oils, etc.), and much more. I shopped here one time. The employee very politely served me. I selected several items: jelly cookie (4 stars), large lady lock (4 stars), almond-cheesecake cone (5 stars!), cherry-cheese strudel (4 stars), Italian bread loaf (not yet tried), and pasta sauce (not yet tried). The total price was about $29 plus a credit-card surcharge of 3%.

Photos
Cibrone M & Sons Bakery - Pizza doughs, hoagie breads

Pizza doughs, hoagie breads

Cibrone M & Sons Bakery - Oils, sauces

Oils, sauces

Cibrone M & Sons Bakery - Exterior of business

See all

Exterior of business

The Pizza Company - Baldwin - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...