This cake is heaven. I ordered it a week ahead. Cash only. Very easy experience. Try the Key Lime Pie...it is also the best! read more

See all

Got the chicken parm for our dinner the day we arrived. Absolutely delicious and plentiful. Got pies & cookies for a birthday celebration and they were amazing. So yummy and had a real homemade taste! Would return in a heartbeat! Debbie read more

WOW! Drop everything and go try their apple pie. It is to die for! We had The Painted Pie cater a lunch and everything was really good. But the pie was out of this world. read more

Cake looked amazing and tasted like trash.... It was just butter on bread. Taste was zero stars, would not recommend, do not pass go. read more

The cake was just fabulous! Extremely high quality chocolate and everyone loved the cake. This could be my favorite chocolate cake! Cannot wait to order more. read more

The Painted Pie - Birthday Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

Lauren and Jerry have been gracing our events and family gatherings for years in Stone Harbor. They have made our life so much sweeter. Everyone looks forward to the pies. My five grandchildren just polished off an entire blueberry pie tonight, and the pies are substantial with thick, amazing crusts We also ordered a lasagna which was really good. I couldn't recommend them more. Cathy Goldberg read more

We recently had a white cake with ganache frosting made by the painted pie for my granddaughters 11th birthday It was spectacular. A beautifully decorated ganache frosting with flowers around the perimeters and lavender writing of Happy Birthday. incredible tasting ganache. This 10 inch 3 layer cake fed 10 people and we enjoyed it for 3 days. You will not be disappointed to order cake from the Painted Pie!! Gloria read more

Had the "famous" sticky bun at the Farmer's market. Certainly the gooest on the island, but almost too gooey. $5 per bun is probably the most expensive in SHNJ, but was probably reasonable given one bun feeds 2 people. The flavor of the raisins was excellent. The overall taste of the bun was amazing, but I think it would have been better with walnuts vs. pecans. Pecans don't stay firm like walnuts when baked and these ended up being a bit mushy on the bun. I do like the taste of pecans though. Now I think it will take me a week to come off the sugar high of eating my portion. read more

Would of gotten 5 stars if I had more of a selection of cakes to order for my husbands birthday. Location was tricky to find and didn't realize it wasn't on the Main Street and you need to walk to an outdoor mall almost. Had the choice between chocolate or carrot cake. We picked carrot and it was honestly the best carrot cake I have ever had. Nice cinnamon taste to it. The inside shop had no pastries on display and almost didn't think it was a bakery though. The 4 stars really go to how well the cake tasted. read more

The Painted Pie - Birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

Ordered birthday cake from here a few years back. Very strange vibes, like I wasn't even in a bakery. Looked more like an office. I saw no baked goods for sale. The cake turned out to be very pretty, but the taste was nothing to write home about. All in all, while it wasn't a terrible experience, I haven't felt the urge to return. read more

I hate leaving non stellar reviews - particularly for small businesses. This is such a cute place in the square at Stone Harbor. The morning that we went there they were only offering two things for sale - an oversized tart and a strawberry scone. The tart served multiple people and it was just the two of us so we opted for the scone. I figured since it was one of two items offered it would taste good and I was very wrong. I have had many scones so I know what they are supposed to taste like and this scone tasted like well - nothing. There was some sugar crumbles on the top and bits of fresh strawberry - those were nice and made the scone look nice - but it just didn't taste good. read more

Very sweet business owner... we were waiting for the coffee shop next door to open and the owner of painted pie came out and offered us a free cup of coffee. We were amazed by his amazing work of freshly baked pies and scones! We walked out with two yummy yummy pieces of quiche! read more

The Painted Pie - Quiche, scones, baked pies - Bakeries Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

Exactly one year ago, I ordered the pink & blue starfish cupcakes from their website. Unfortunately, they looked absolutely NOTHING like advertised. The cupcakes I received were plain black cupcakes, with a white artificial starfish in the middle. No pink color, no sand, no pearls, no blue paper wrapper. They told me that the starfish would not be edible, which I had no problem with. However, you should not advertise a picture of a cupcake on your website that you cannot make. They ended up refunding my money, however, I am extremely disappointed to see that they are still advertising cupcakes that they cannot make on their website one year later... Update on 8/30/2016: Thought everyone should see what type of people own this business, as I received the below private message from the owner GG after I wrote this very honest and true review. "What kind of person is still dwelling on something a YEAR after it happened to the point of writing such a snarky and ridiculous review? An obvious miss communication on behalf of both parties, yes that means you as well. Clearly those cupcakes can be recreated given the high level of baked goods and catering this establishment produces (according to your fellow Yelp reviewers). Also, have you ever heard of the word "inspiration"...maybe that's why those cupcakes are still pictured on the website. Do you think they were magically baked, decorated, and displayed on a website for no reason? To top it all off you said you were refunded!! Move along, get over it, and find something more constructive to do with your time...one year later." How very professional of you, GG. I'm not sure how a misunderstanding on my part can occur, when I simply called your bakery and ordered the cupcakes pictured on your website. Very straight forward request. By the way, you were so rude to my in the store that your husband actually interrupted you stating that I was right! Your message is extremely contradictory, as you first state that you can in fact make those cupcakes, then state that the photos on your website are just "inspirational". Yelpers, I think that my photo evidence below is extremely clear and my complaint could not be considered "ridiculous" in any way, shape or form. Beware that all of the photos are their website are simply "inspiration" and their bakers cannot actually make them. False advertising, horrible business, horribly rude!! read more

The Painted Pie - What was advertised.. - Bakeries Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

See all

Service was fine. The pies were still warm out of the oven and looking so inviting. But the crust was so thick and no one enjoyed it. The blueberry filling was delicious and peach strawberry was a bit bland. We were all a bit disappointed. I also got a dozen sugar cookies and they were delicious. At other times we've had their sticky buns from the Sunday market and they are fabulous! read more

Guy behind the counter seemed annoyed that I was bothering his daydreaming (or whatever it was he was doing). My kids actually commented on it when we left the store. Minimal selection - but he told me it was because they'd sold out of everything even though it was just after lunch time (during the week, not on a weekend). Finally decided on some key lime pie and I watched him use his bare (unwashed) fingers to maneuver it onto the pie server and then back out into the plastic to-go container. Ick. Never again, Painted Pie. I was really looking forward to it too. Ick! read more

GREAT pies. We love the blueberry & other pies here so much that - not kidding - they're one reason we keep renting in Stone Harbor. Walking distance to extraordinary pie says "summer vacation." read more

I have been meaning to write this for a while, sorry about the delay. But I cannot say enough good things about this place. They catered a get together for us at our house, and we were just blown away by the great food and incredible service. Lauren and Gerry were great to work with. This was a memorial service and many of our guests were delayed by Saturday afternoon shore traffic. Lauren stayed at the event the whole time and made sure that the food stayed fresh even with the delays. They set up the tables, and even brought flowers. I thought that their prices were extremely reasonable, and the food was great. I should have ordered more - it was all inhaled! Thankfully we managed to have a couple of macaroons left over for us. I will use them for all of my catering needs at the shore. read more

OMG! what a surprise a truly sophisticated family owned bake with a flare for fine french influenced baking Chef made us the best chocolate ganache birthday cake Ive ever eaten read more

Hours? Days open? Email address to ask a simple question?

We ordered two cakes (chocolate/chocolate ganache and carrot/orange zest cream cheese) plus a dozen chocolate macaroon cookies for our family reunion in Cape May. They were all delicious!! This bakery is really just that: a great place to order ahead. Maybe sometimes they also have selections to buy on the spot but when we stopped in the day before our party, the store was quiet - no one around. I just called and left a message saying we wanted to order and got a call back within the half hour. We went the next day to pick up the goods and were really pleased with the service: friendly, helpful & generous. Our family raved about the cakes & cookies! read more

I have never been in the store. Not even exactly sure where it is. My cousin uses this bakery all the time. I mean like every weekend. If I am coming to visit it if there is any special occasion, she always has baked goods from here. Everything I have ever tried is amazing! My favorite is the chocolate macaroon. The chocolate chip and oatmeal cookies are fantastic. I even had a piece of their chocolate cake from a birthday cake. The design was beautiful and the cake was amazing. read more

Fantastic one of a kind baked goods! Go early because they sell out! Jerry and Lauren, owners and bakers, are a lot of fun. The mini pies are to die for, the concoction they call a cinnamon bun is what I'd choose for my last meal EVER! Everything they sell is amazing! A day in Stone Harbor isn't complete without a treat from the Painted Pie! read more

Such a delightful little shop. Great, quality ingredients in each of their cookies (their chocolate chip, for example, blow other local shops' cookies out of the water), pies, pastries. You can tell a lot of love and attentive care go into making each treat. We hope to keep this place around for a long time. read more

The Gormleys are an exceptionally talented couple, known locally for their previous excellence in restaurants. Freshly baked pastries and deserts that are voluptuous, creative, and visually appealing. The shop provides what may be the world's finest carrot cake, fruit pies made of only the freshest available ingredients, and graham cracker crusts that ae the finest I've ever experienced. Whether for self indulgence or a unique and pleasing gift, The Painted Pie's offerings are an attraction as well a source of epicurean delights. read more

Painted Pie catered my mom's birthday party on the shore. They made a bunch of appetizers for us, as well as an enormous bday cake. Everything was great. Each of us had a favorite among the appetizers -- spring rolls, bacon-wrapped dates, and fig jam & serrano ham crostini. And everyone loved the red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting. The owner was very helpful on the phone. They went above and beyond in helping to make it a special event. I told them we were doing a frog theme for the party. (Weird, I know, but my mom loves frogs). And the owner said they'd be happy to do a frog decoration on the cake. It turned out very cute. Also, they plated everything for us on these dramatic platters and serving pieces. It was a little over the top, but it definitely added to the festive-ness of the event. My husband went in another morning during our stay and had the quiche and a blueberry scone. He was lukewarm on the scone, but loved the quiche. Oh! The only bummer was that they're cash only. With all the catering, that was a lot of cash! Thank you, Painted Pie! read more

In August, 2011, we had their carrot cake for my parents' Golden Anniversary celebration. We STILL talk about that cake!!

This business is new to Stone Harbor and is a much needed addition!! The shop is located in the back of the stone harbor mall across from Seagars on 96th street. I've only had chocolate chip cookies, but they make many other desserts such as pies and cakes. This is a tasty and creative shop everyone should stop in while visiting Stone Harbor. Especially when you are tired of the many ice cream stores and want a new dessert option. It is also great to pick up treats to bring to a beach house BBQ. Enjoy :D read more

Wow! I had been meaning to stop here for the past two years and finally did. Should have stopped in sooner because the pastries here are the bomb! I got the strawberry peach mini pie, raspberry scone and some macaroons. I don't think I've had a more delicious pie, the peaches and strawberries tasted very fresh and juicy and the pie pastry was flaky and light. The scone was full of fresh raspberries and was also light and delicious. The macaroons were wonderfully sweet and full of fresh coconut. My family gave everything two thumbs up and wanted to know why I didn't bring home more but I got the last of the pies and scones. The pastries sell out quickly here which is part of the reason that I hadn't been here before but I will definitely be back here again. read more

We ordered three types of quiches (bacon/cheddar/pear was particularly good) for a brunch party and all three types got rave reviews from all guests. They were the first thing gone from the buffet table. The chocolate and banana scones were also a big hit. The owner was very accommodating and friendly. The whole ordering and picking up process was very easy which goes a long way with all the stress of planning a party! Thank you Painted Pie! read more

Everything here is amazing. The quiche are very creative and the best I've ever had. They had several gluten free options which don't taste like your average gluten free dessert. This place could rival any bakery in Philly. read more

Great new addition to Stone Harbor which lacks in the bakery area. Wonderful Blueberry pie and quiche is to die for. Coffee is the best and the muffins are superb! read more

Had a special event at our house catered by the PP and from the food to the service to the special touches they came through big time. We usually do everything ourselves but given the event and that my wife and I did not want to be struggling with food and dishes, etc., we decide to use a local caterer. It was the right decision and we chose the perfect business. I highly recommend the PP for your catering needs and if you just want some delicious baked goods stop by their shop. Great people, great place! read more

Quite simply the most incredibly delicious baked goods you will ever taste, anywhere. Unusual but complimentary pairings of ingredients for absolutely wonderful pies, loafs, scones, quiches. Get there early and see what great ideas Jerry and Lauren have come up with for their morning bake. You will not be disappointed. read more

Ordered desserts from the Painted Pie for a Bridal Shower. OMG they were FANTASTIC! The Carrot Cake is the BEST carrot cake I have ever eaten. Chocolate chip cupcakes with Chocolate Ganache, mini Strawberry - Peach Pies and Chocolate Chips cookies served out the rest of the dessert menu. RAVES from everyone who attended the shower. Everything was so good and so fresh ( the mini pies were even a little warm when we picked them up). Highly recommend the Painted Pie! read more

I'm not kidding when I say its the best chocolate cake I have ever had. We just bought a house down there and this will be our go-to cake stop. If you are looking for grand decor inside the shop, you won't find it. If you want a kick a-s cake, you found the right place. read more

LOVE this place! Jerry and Lauren are truly talented pros! Their Carrot Cake and Chocolate Cake are incredible! I never even LIKED carrot cake before The Painted Pie, but am now a fan! Their zucchini bread is delicious too. And then.....there are the CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES! SO insanely delicious! I ordered a Carrot Cake for my husband's birthday, as well as three dozen Chocolate Chip Cookies. Jerry arranged the cookies SO beautifully on a tray for presentation, and then topped them with sifted powdered sugar, a really nice touch, it felt, and looked, very special. My husband's birthday cake was so beautifully decorated. They really put their hearts and souls into what they do! Thank you Jerry and Lauren! read more

Stopped by early this morning. Truly appreciated the extra touch with the mini Key Lime Pie! Freshly made whipped cream and lime zest on top before ringing us up. We will definitely be back! read more

Our daughter purchased an incredible birthday cake for my husband--a 3 layer vanilla cake with wonderfuly buttercream icing. It was the best cake ever. I called Jerry, the owner, and complimented him on it. I hope The Painted Pice stays in SH for many years! Vicky read more

Delicious! I hired the Painted Pie to make cakes, pies and cookies for our wedding and to make quiches, sticky buns, scones and muffins for breakfast the next day. I hired them based on yelp reviews and one scone a friend had brought me (I do not live in New Jersey) and I am so glad I did. Everything was delicious AND beautiful. Jerry also takes pride in using great ingredients which I really appreciated. I originally asked for a peach pie in October but Jerry told me that he could not get peaches this year during October that he would be happy to put in a pie. I really appreciated his commitment to great ingredients and making sure he gave me the best cakes and pies possible! He also did a great job helping me estimate the amount of food we would need. His presentation was also beautiful. He made sure everything was nicely decorated and created a beautiful dessert table at our wedding. I cannot wait for my next trip to Stone Harbor. The Painted Pie will always be on my list of "must visit" stops. read more