They have potential, and there is clearly a loyal following of locals. The barkeep and some locals were having a great time visiting, and we found ourselves a seat. We were not sure about the ordering process, and after a few minutes started trying to find the pub website and look for a menu. Eventually a menu was brought to our table, and we put in an order for beer. Turns out, half of the items on the menu were not available. When we did figure out an order, more items were made not available. We settled on a NY style pizza. We did not get the toppings we ordered. Good news: the crust was very good, and worth another try! Even the leftovers were delicious the next day - not all pizza can do that. They do not know how to pour a Guinness - which is too bad, because that is a favorite beer of ours. We switched to another tap and had a local red. The tap selection is decent. The place has a very casual atmosphere, and many locals come and go and seem to have great conversation and know each other's business. Overall, a place with great potential, especially for regulars. Hopefully, another visit will be more successful for exploring the menu which sounds good. read more

My mother and I both got a Genoa salami sandwich and we told the bartender that it was dry and she said that's the way the bread was and it was made this morning that it doesn't have enough dressing on it so pick some dressing and it won't be dry anymore. She was rude and every time we asked for something it seemed to be a problem if I hadn't been in there before I would definitely say not to go there but their pizza was pretty good the first time I went but I've got to say that the service is terrible. read more

Lives up to it's reputation! Cold beer, good thin crust pizza and classic music spinning in the back. The service was attentive and we'll be back! read more

The Old Goat - Main Street - Pubs Near Me - Richmond, Maine

NY Style pizza was very good. Maybe a little more sauce. Negatives were that there was children sitting at the bar. One looked to be around 4, the other looked about 6 years old. At one point a lady came in with a baby in a carrier and placed the baby on the bar. Not sure about the sanitation situation with that. We also watched people order pizza and beer to go. My wife used to work in liquor licensing and says this is a no no as well as the children at the bar. read more

One of these days, I'm going to order the pizza. It looks delicious. On this particular evening, we were short on time, though, so ordered a panini, steak quesadilla, and nachos. The nachos were great. Loved the fact that they were in a ring instead of a pile. Every chip had salsa on it. The Panini's were good as well, but it took forever for us to get our food. We were 15 minutes late getting to the gardens after dinner, and we left with plenty of time. Cozy pub atmosphere. Cheery. Super convenient location, just stop in when you have time to sit for a while. read more

The Old Goat - Panini - Pubs Near Me - Richmond, Maine

See all

ABSOLUTELY THE BEST PIZZA.. and salads.. and paninis.. oh and beer.. cold beer.. the atmosphere rocks. read more

The Old Goat - Pubs Near Me - Richmond, Maine

I've not done a yelp review in many years, but felt compelled to put my two cents worth in for this one, Positives: This eatery had a pretty good atmosphere -a fun, little pub. Although we did not order a pizza, the ones that went past our table did look and smell very good. Negatives: 1) the service from BOTH our waitresses bounced back and forth between friendly and snappy/irritable 2) an hour and a half was MUCH too long a wait for 2 quesadillas, a sandwich and a salad, and 3) the food, when it eventually arrived, was just "OK". We will probably skip The Old Goat next time around. read more

Cute place in Richmond. We were staying in the area and tried this place out after arriving. Pizzas were awesome and HUGE. Other members of our party had sandwiches, salads, and one of the quesadillas and were pleased with the offerings. Seemed like a lively joint with a steady crowd throughout the evening. The kitchen area was a bit small so it took a bit for a food to come out but our server was attentive throughout the night! read more

I have had the opportunity to visit the old goat multiple times! Each and every one of them was fantastic! I even had a chance to join a wedding party upstairs and it was incredible! Plenty of space and ample lighting as well! My personal favorite on the menu is their pizza! It's very good and quality ingredients. It is certainly made with love. You can certainly tell. The service is also a key Point, as I am always served with a smile. If you ever have a chance to go here, you won't be let down. read more

Pleasantly surprised, the food was great! And the bar tender was helpful and friendly.

I am updating my reviews to reflect my changing opinion about Old Goat. I still love the food, and if you can get in there and try it, you should. What's new: take out is a no go, frequently, because of a lack of staffing or a shortage of dough. Store hours are new- closed Tuesdays and possibly more in the future- again staffing issues. Their website- absolutely terrible and non-useful- who even updates it or their social media? No clue, but I'll tell you what, whoever owns this place had better get it together and invest into the business and consider paying people more money to work there. Nugget: the people that do work there are still very pleasant and are awesome people to get to know. read more

The Old Goat - Old Goat building - Pubs Near Me - Richmond, Maine

See all

My son visited Maine from Hawaii and I could not think of a more authentic place for lunch and a craft beer experience than The Old Goat. The moment we entered we were greeted by the friendly bartender, placed our order and asked for a cribbage board While we enjoyed a fiddlehead beer we enjoyed the sun filled table by the window. The margarita pizza was fresh dough and mozzarella topped with fresh tomato's and basil. The Old Goat exceeded expectations!!! read more

See all

Great food and great service! Pizza is the best around! Drinks are great and service was great too! read more

Have been there several times. Pizza is good, but the panini sandwiches are better. service is always good and friendly. Typical bar layout, and comfortable. read more

Always an excellent pizza. We order double pepperoni and it never disappoints. The service is generally friendly and the food comes out quick. It can get a little loud at times but it's a great local hangout. read more

Outstanding local pub with the best pizza in Maine, by far. Pub menu with decent options. Service was good and the place had a local feel to it. read more

A friendly, cozy pub with some great sandwiches, pizza, good service in a historic downtown building.

What a great quaint pub on Main St. in Richmond. Friends rave about the pizza here, so I ordered a large double pepperoni for take out. A 16" double topping pizza was $23. It was New York style and perfectly baked. Crispy crust, well proportioned (sauce, cheese, and pepperoni) and delicious. Don't sleep on this place! Highly recommend!! read more

The Old Goat - Old Goat Richmond, Maine Double Pepperoni Pizza - Pubs Near Me - Richmond, Maine

Waste of money...Sunday 5pm out of pizza...asked for a drink menu..it was what you see is what we have...husband had a drink I asked for water...the taste of the water made me gag... don't sit at the bar unless you are OK with the dishwasher three feet away doing the dishes and I don't mean the bar glasses I mean the pots and pans etc...meal came...not given utensils or napkins...food was OK and the service was friendly read more

A fun place to spend an evening . Drinks,bar food and friendly crowd. Pizza was great read more

The Old Goat - Blue Dr Mc Gillicutty shots with one of the locals. Never had before. - Pubs Near Me - Richmond, Maine

Good, service and atmosphere were all awesome. Waitress was friendly and attentive. Cool old building.

Place is really great, had never been and after so many people telling me to go had to try it. Pizza we ordered was absolutely delicious. She got a turkey panini and it was also fantastic. Gray friendly staff and overall good place, we will be back plenty since we are only 15 min away now. read more

The Old Goat - Pizza - Pubs Near Me - Richmond, Maine

Delicious pizza and a fun atmosphere. Good beer selection too. Richmond is a neat little town to explore as well. Go across the street and get ice cream after dinner in the summer. read more

Best Pizza in this quadrant ... They could stand to update their draft beer selections tho!

Go to the goat! Great food and beer, friendly locals, lovely interior. The paninis are amazing - delicious and made with an abundance of great food. I had the Reubenator and its one of THE best reubens I've ever had. The varieties of beer was vast but not so overwhelm you don't get lost in a mile long beer list, half of which you don't know anyway. And even better than all that, the people there were amazingly friendly, made us feel at home. We will absolutely go back! read more

Great food, amazing selection of beer, and a quaint atmosphere! Located in the picturesque town of Richmond Maine, a hundred yards from the Kennebec River. read more

See all

Caters to Regulars: Outsiders will be treated as such I really wanted to give this place a better rating but I could not and I will explain. I've been eating here off and on for 11 years. I live in the next town over so this place is fairly close. Today,I was in the mood for pizza and beer so I popped into The Old Goat. I arrived just after lunchtime and saw a smattering of customers, one person at the bar, and two other small parties at a couple random tables. I had my heart set on a Guinness and some pastrami pizza. The service was horrible. In fact, I felt as if the bartender/server was annoyed by me. Upon sitting down she handed me a menu then she hurried off. The "menu" is a collection of four or five loose-leaf pieces of paper stacked up in no apparent order. One page was a listing of paninis, the next appetizers, salads and specials, and the pizza selection. I finally caught the bartender/servers eye and ordered my Guinness then pulled out my laptop to do some work. As my drink order was being processed - an older couple entered the establishment and it was apparent they were regulars. They hadn't even sat down before the bartender/server set about getting their "usuals" and even placed their food order with the cooks before my beer ever hit the table. Minutes later, this happened again when another regular came in and took a stool at the bar. The bartender/server was all over it. She made sure he was taken care of. He was promptly served his drink and greeted warmly which left me sitting alone feeling as if my order had been forgotten. But, I gave the bartender/server the benefit of the doubt. I assumed she was waiting for the Guinness I ordered 10 minutes ago to rest (after all there is a proper and improper way to pour a Guinness). When the bartender/server appeared with my beer I was, not surprisingly, disappointed in the lack of care my Guinness had been shown as she placed it on my table, hurriedly, lazily, last-minute. The Guinness in full separation mode as it had not rested before being topped off. I knew it should have been the first drink pulled long BEFORE two other regulars walked in. And, the fact that it had not been properly poured OR rested tells me the bartender/server either needs training, or simply doesn't care. Old Goat for shame on you! The establishment that prides itself on a wide selection of beer, letting a pint-o-the-black be served like that?!? (it wasn't even a real pint). As I drank my beer, others whom had come in after me had already received their food before I was given the opportunity to place mine. I tried to catch the bartender/servers eye but she was on her phone or chatting with the patrons at the bar. Eventually, I managed to catch her eye and placed my order for a pastrami, roasted red pepper, and kalamata olive pizza. I ordered a second (improperly poured) Guinness. My pizza took a long time to come out. I was disappointed in the quality. The crust was thin (and that's fine) but it was very dry, beyond tough, tasteless, painful in the mouth to chew, and flat out overly cooked to the point I couldn't even cut it with a knife. I resorted to eating just the toppings as the crust was stale as stale could be. That said, the red sauce is seasoned well, tangy and enhanced by the salty pastrami which gets nice and crispy while being cooked. I enjoy the way the warm roasted red-pepper provide a smooth, silky, mellow texture that pairs deliciously with the tangy, firm kalamata olives (this is a flavor combination I invented on my own as I tend to enjoy the saltier flavors to the sweet or savory). The building itself is a neat old place with minimal decor, high ceilings, brick walls all married together to create a pub-like feel. One Yelp Reviewer wrote about the dart board hanging on the walls between the women and men's restroom, this is still (dangerously) the case. The back-end of the establishment, where the food is prepared is cluttered with stacked cases of soda, beers, and other beverages that would normally be out of sight. To me, that is an unsightly mess. Overall, it felt like the owner has let things slide and has become comfortable catering to the "regulars." As a non-regular, I definitely felt like I was annoying the bartender/server. I think the reason The Old Goat has managed to stay in business is due to it's location and being the only pub in the sleepy little town of Richmond, Maine. The quality of the pizza has plummeted. I think the large assortment of beer and regulars is what's keeping the place going. My entire dining experience lasted over two hours from seating to paying the tab. read more

The Old Goat - Guinness and an average pastrami, roasted red pepper, and kalamata olive pizza. - Pubs Near Me - Richmond, Maine

The pizza is really good. Get the pizza. We loved the white pizza; it was well seasoned.

I ordered a pizza from this fine establishment and it was 10/10. there was no flop and perfect crust. The waitstaff were very kind. Definitely had an old mill vibe and I will be visiting again! read more

The food was excellent. I went with family for the first time and the staff was great. I had the Cuban sandwich and is similar to the tasty ones I've had when living in Miami. The prices were great too. I'd definitely come back here again. read more

I have lived in Richmond for years and finally tried the Old Goat. The food we had was very good. I had a Chicken Quesadilla which was delicious and my husband had the Royal Hawaiian that was made on large bread that looked homemade. I would have given a higher rating, but we had a similar experience as Desi-Rae - had we been regulars we would have been all set. We seated ourselves, a bartender came with menus, and when we asked for water with lemon the atmosphere changed. She went back to the bar where there were half a dozen customers she obviously knew, and it was quite a while before our order was taken. When taking our order my husband was going to ask for a pear cider, but she left too quickly. It took a while to get her attention to ask for one. She seemed nice, but it made us feel very much like we did not belong. We will probably do take out next time... read more

Great place. Door was good, Panni, pizza and sausage. Kent was very knowledgeable and friendly.. read more

The Old Goat - Bar at Old Goat..place is hopping! Kent Was very helpful!! - Pubs Near Me - Richmond, Maine

Food was good for what it was, beer was good, service was good. Great atmosphere, nice cozy place to have a pint and chat some locals.

First Impression: 4 Menu Options: 4 Bar options: 4 The Food: 4 Timing/Service: 4 Overall Value: 4 Our visit was over the summer. Charming pub and not too noisy. The southwest salad was on the salty side and regret not ordering the pizza, which looked so appetizing. read more

See all

Excellent food in a cool setting. We go there every 2 or 3 weeks and everything is always excellent, Shelby usually waits on us and the service is great. I recommend the cubano Tampa style, Shelby (Buffalo) Quesadilla or the nachos. The nachos are done one way very well, don't try and screw it up, they won't let you anyway. These are a lighter app, not your typical bar nachos mounded with pizza cheese, generic salsa and whatever else is in the kitchen that leave you wondering why you bought them. All the food is done extremely well, there is no deep fryer so no you can't get fries with that. You can get a meal and leave feeling full without feeling terrible like you ingested a salt lick that just rolled off a Sysco pallet. This is a pub, it can be loud and if you want water you're getting tap water. If you want soda you're getting a bottle. The owner Scott is friendly but witty and direct, I've read some take that as unfriendly but I think they need thicker skin, unfriendly is not accurate, he's a funny guy. I also saw someone noted the lack of decor, the old goat is in a historic building that used to be an old bank that had been redone into a pub setting, it's cozy and comfortable. This is a great pub, if your high maintenance or can't handle an at times loud bar then maybe it's not for you but you'll be missing out. read more

Very cool space in a town on the water that tourists don't go to.. Good beer list, strong pours, decent food. If I lived around here I'd be here a lot. read more

GOAT = WOAT (service) The food and atmosphere is good but the service is terrible. If you go prepare to wait and wait and wait. read more

The pizza was excellent! We did take out so didn't have a chance to have a beer, but the vibe was cool it was packed with locals - so I'm sure it's a great place! read more

This place doesn't give you ice...so don't ask. They do however serve chilled glasses and cold beverages. The pizza is great...like really good. Only one size is served: large. The minus point: -1 for the place not being properly ventilated. When they make pizza there should be a built-in fan above the stove. You WILL come out of the pub smelling like pizza: 100% guaranteed! So, I hope you like the smell of pizza :) -0.5 for having the dart board placed right in the middle of the men's and women's bathroom. Having drunk people throw dart as people come out of the bathroom has disaster written all over it. The owner will seem a little grumpy/mean if you aren't a local. Most people who are regulars will know Scott and just know him as "well, it's his bar that's who he is," and then they go on living their life and drinking beer. DO NOT BRING YOUR CHILDREN IN HERE, ESPECIALLY IF THEY MISBEHAVE! For starters, it's a pub, not a daycare. There's a piano in there and if your child runs up to it and starts banging the hell out of the keys EXPECT to either be put in your place or thrown out. That simple. Would I go back: I have...many times. It's great for beers and pizza and just relaxing. read more

Awesome pub serving some of the best pizza in the state. True NY style. It smells incredible when you walk in and the pizza that comes out is 100% legit. Servers are friendly as are the bar patrons and the owner. Yeah it's a bar, some colorful characters abound, but what did you expect? The other reviews maybe were looking for a bland chain. This place has character and is making some damn good pizza along the way. I actually left scratching my head that this place isn't much more well known because it has all the trappings of a place that will wind up exploding with hipster foodies looking for incredible pizza. Don't change a thing I say. read more