Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac

    3.5 (11 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Updated 3 months ago

    The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac Photos

    You might also consider

    More like The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac

    Recommended Reviews - The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Melissa R.

    This pizza was a HUGE disappointment! What went right - the pizza was ready when I arrived to pick it up and the dough was similar to what you'd find in NY. What went wrong - everything else. I ordered a 20' pizza with half pepperoni. The pizza looked and tasted like it had been sitting out waiting to be sliced and single served. They serve single slices there. The cheese was hard and glued to the pizza and the sauce was absorbed into the bread and cheese. So basically the sauce was non-existent. Also, the cost was excessive when considering the quality. Maybe it's the expense for importing their dough? I'm from New York and I can't stand behind this product. I was so hopeful.

    Jarid P.

    Picked up a pizza last night, first time trying NY Pizza Place. Placed my order online and it was ready super fast. Went in for pickup and staff was friendly, place was clean, and I love that they pizza by the slice. Very please with the pizza I got, my only regret was that I got a 14" instead of a 20" but that's on me!

    Burnt hard Pizza Yuck
    Angie B.

    I stopped in to grab a couple of pepperoni slices for lunch as I was shopping at Publix. How could you mess up two slices of pepperoni pizza? The crust is hard. The pepperoni is burnt. The pizza is dry.This was horrible. I don't know what happened. I don't know if he let the reheating of the pizza stay in too long, but this is ridiculous and unacceptable won't be back. This was just lunch.

    Sandra M.

    Excellent NY-style cheese pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was fresh, cheesy, and perfectly cooked, and the garlic knots were soft, flavorful, and delicious. Service was great and the turnaround time was super fast. Everything came out hot and exactly as ordered. Definitely coming back!" The art is amazing and fits the restaurant very well. I love that there's a lot of eating areas.

    Very clean
    Doug R.

    11/19/2025 Wednesday Night, first time here and not a bad place . Im glad I came and that we have this pizza place here, cuz sometimes I just want a slice not a whole pie. I had the 2 slice amd drink special for $11.77 the slices I had were The Brooklyn, I've never tried that flavor before but it was really good and it had me wanting a 3rd slice....but no no no, I came for 2 . Lol. This is a must try and we will be back. Oh the service was good as well too.

    Pizza has more sauce then cheese good acid reflex meal

    See all

    24 days ago

    Helpful 7
    Thanks 1
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    5 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Pizza was good, but price was $28 for a small cheese pizza and 2 drinks, a little pricey for cheese pizza.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 3,276 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Midnight Cookies & Cream Tamarac - Very upset

    Midnight Cookies & Cream Tamarac

    2.8(99 reviews)
    2.0 mi

    I was craving something sweet so I decided to stop by this place since they are open until 2am…read more Amorie was the associate that took care of me and she was super sweet and knowledgeable about all of the flavors they offer. I bought a box of 6 big cookies for $27. I ordered the cookies and cream and the Guava Maria for myself. For the other 4 cookies I ordered the birthday cake, double trouble, and a regular chocolate chip. I loved the cookies and cream and the Guava cookie. My family also loved their cookies as well. If you want an ice cream with your cookie you have the option of so many flavors. There is also a couple of Milkshakes I loved the artwork on the wall and the music that was playing in the background. The parking is close by and it is free. I will definitely come back to this amazing location.

    First time my family and I went to the midnight cookies & cream. Upon entering the place has…read morebeautiful art on which looks glow and the dark. Amora provided great customer service and experience and explained the name and the type of cookie on the display case. We ordered 6 cookies for $27. The Cookies we tried was the Oreo cookie, chocolate chip cookie, guava Maria, birthday cake and double trouble cookie. All the cookies were very delicious and especially if you dip it in milk. They also have ice cream and milk shakes. Overall the experience was great.

    Photos
    Midnight Cookies & Cream Tamarac - Top left: creme brulee, top right: butter crunch, bottom left: taste the rainbow, bottom right: s'mores.

    Top left: creme brulee, top right: butter crunch, bottom left: taste the rainbow, bottom right: s'mores.

    Midnight Cookies & Cream Tamarac
    Midnight Cookies & Cream Tamarac - Blueberry ice cream with birthday cake cookie

    See all

    Blueberry ice cream with birthday cake cookie

    The Magic Cow

    The Magic Cow

    4.8(181 reviews)
    3.1 mi
    $$

    First time coming here and it was great. Not only was the ice-cream tasty but the ambiance was…read morehomey and welcoming. Steve the icecream clerk was the absolute best. I would recommend coming here and supporting small rather than a chain like Coldstone!

    They say curiosity killed the cat -- but in this case, it led me straight to happiness in a waffle…read morecone. The Magic Cow in Coral Springs has a 4.8-star Yelp rating, and their sister store in Davie is apparently one of the top 10 ice cream shops in the entire United States. So naturally, I had to see if the local legend lived up to the hype. (Spoiler: it did. And then some.) The moment we walked in, I was hit with that nostalgic mix of sugar, laughter, and magic that says you're about to make a very good life decision. The owner greeted us like old friends -- warm, funny, and clearly passionate about what he does. You can tell every scoop that leaves that counter has been crafted with pride. Now, about the ice cream. I went with the Carrot Cake flavor -- and let me tell you, it wasn't just ice cream; it was an experience. Folded into it were ribbons of caramel and bits of pie crust that somehow made me rethink all my previous dessert choices in life. One bite in, and I'm pretty sure I saw colors brighter than usual. My wife went for a combo of Better Batter Cake Carnival and Chocolate Batter Better, and to call it "excellent" would be an understatement. This flavor pairing was pure joy in stereo. I'm pretty sure she stopped listening to me talk for a good five minutes, which is the ultimate compliment to any dessert. Bottom line: The Magic Cow isn't just living up to its reputation -- it's churning out happiness, one scoop at a time. If you haven't been, fix that immediately. Your taste buds will thank you, your diet will forgive you (eventually), and your inner child will do a happy dance.

    Photos
    The Magic Cow - Fixed combos

    Fixed combos

    The Magic Cow
    The Magic Cow - Violet ice cream

    See all

    Violet ice cream

    Let's Chill Homemade Ice Cream - Ice cream flight

    Let's Chill Homemade Ice Cream

    4.9(454 reviews)
    3.3 mi
    $$

    Walking into Let's Chill feels less like entering an ice cream shop and more like being gently…read morehugged by air conditioning, cleanliness, and good vibes. The place is bright, airy, spotless, and instantly puts you in a better mood, which is dangerous when ice cream decisions need to be made responsibly. Now let's talk about the service. Second to none. Olympic-level. Borderline aggressive generosity. The guy helping us (I'm sorry I didn't catch your name, Ice Cream Sensei ) kept offering samples like he was personally offended by the idea that I hadn't tried every flavor yet. I'm pretty sure I consumed the equivalent of a medium cup in samples alone, and he was still like, "You sure? One more?" And here's the thing. The recommendations were spot on. You can tell this dude is genuinely passionate about the in-house made ice cream. These flavors are thoughtfully crafted, smooth, balanced, and most importantly, no weird artificial colors or chemical nonsense. If the ice cream world had a clean ingredients hall of fame, this place would have its own wing. After tasting my way through half the menu, I completely understand why this is the top-rated ice cream shop in Florida and somehow also gunning for the top spot in the entire country. Ambitious? Yes. Earned? Also yes. Do yourself a favor. Go chill at Let's Chill, eat irresponsibly, and then rate them high because they deserve it, and because you'll feel guilty if you don't after all those samples.

    First things first.... Everything we had was delicious! It was good ice cream…read more - The place is veteran owned. - Everything is handmade. - The staff were all friendly. - The store was clean, bright, well lit, and had plenty of seating. - Offering a "flight" of 4 different flavors of ice cream is freaking genius!! But... Nothing here jumped out at us... * The lavender honey made Spensyr smile but neither flavor was very pronounced. * The guava was good but again, very light on the guava flavor and none of the sweet funkiness you expect with guava. * The lime basil sorbet was full of lime, but neither of us could detect an odor or taste of basil. * The caramel crunch was fine. Maybe there aren't a lot of ice cream shops in Coral Springs and so this has become the go-to spot, it's obviously better than supermarket ice cream, but I can't see it as a destination.

    Photos
    Let's Chill Homemade Ice Cream - Caramel Crunch in Waffle Bowl with extra Caramel

    Caramel Crunch in Waffle Bowl with extra Caramel

    Let's Chill Homemade Ice Cream - Cotton candy and Honey lavender flavor

    Cotton candy and Honey lavender flavor

    Let's Chill Homemade Ice Cream

    See all

    The Baked Bear

    The Baked Bear

    4.7(106 reviews)
    6.0 mi
    $$

    Great customer service from inside the mall to to the main store! Flavors were great and it's not…read moretoo loud inside. It's also well-kept.

    Free samples are a dangerous thing. One minute you're "just looking," and the next thing you know…read moreyou're standing at the counter ordering ice cream like it was your idea all along. That's exactly how The Baked Bear got me. Hook, line, and sinker. If you've never been, the concept is simple and brilliant. High-quality ingredients and a build-your-own dessert approach. Cookies, brownies, cones, ice cream, toppings. You mix, match, and create something that feels a little more custom than your average scoop shop. And the ingredients really do deliver. The cones are nicely crisp, and if you've never had one of their ice cream sandwiches, start there. They'll build it with warm cookies on the outside and freezing cold ice cream on the inside, which might be the most satisfying hot-meets-cold dessert combination ever created. Warm cookie. Frozen ice cream. Zero regrets. For my order, I went with the berry crumble and strawberry cheesecake on a waffle cone. The waffle cone had a great crisp to it, and the flavors were light and refreshing. You got a nice hint of berry without it being overpowering. If anything, I would have welcomed a little more berry punch, but it was still very enjoyable. We also tried the campfire s'mores, which absolutely popped with bold flavor, and the cookie dough, which was fine but a little more average compared to the others. The one area where things felt slightly limited was the flavor selection. They offered around a dozen choices, but many leaned heavy into chocolate territory. If you're a chocolate lover, you'll feel like you hit the lottery. If you're looking for a wider range of lighter or fruit-forward options, the variety could be better. Still, the concept is great and the ingredients are excellent. Tip: do not accept the free sample unless you're emotionally prepared to buy ice cream immediately afterward. Four stars. Great concept, excellent flavors, just a little light on variety. Definitely worth the trip even if the sweet tooth hasn't kicked in yet.... Oh, and it's okay sometimes to have dessert for dinner... and this would be the place for that!

    Photos
    The Baked Bear - Front

    Front

    The Baked Bear - Toasted s'mores ice cream with cookies and cream cookie and biscoff type cookie

    Toasted s'mores ice cream with cookies and cream cookie and biscoff type cookie

    The Baked Bear - Menu

    See all

    Menu

    Cookiehead Bakery

    Cookiehead Bakery

    4.2(65 reviews)
    4.2 mi

    We visited for their grand re-opening and aside from opening a few minutes late - everything was…read moreawesome! For the grand re-opening they had free soft serve with a mini cookie for the first 100 people in line. We were 4th and 5th! We also bought two of their special doughnookies, one cannoli cookie and one cookies & cream cookie. We've been fans of Blueprint cookies for years so hearing that they now became Cookiehead AND there's a location less than 10min from home was music to our ears.

    Dessert stop at Cookiehead Bakery (Coral Springs)…read more I was craving something sweet before dinner, so I decided to check out Cookiehead Bakery around 6 pm. I'll be honest--I was expecting a bigger variety of cookies (and maybe some brownies), but at the time they had about 8 cookie options and 2 muffins available. Flavors included: walnut chocolate chip, classic chocolate chip, sugar cookie, Nutella red velvet, golden Oreo cookies & cream, Dubai chocolate, and lemon blueberry. They also offer soft serve, milkshakes, and coffee, which is a nice plus. I went with the last Dubai chocolate cookie ($6.42 with tax). The cookie itself was a little on the dry side, but the chocolate topping was really good and flavorful. Overall: worth trying if you're in the area, especially if you want something different--but I'd love to go back earlier in the day to see a fuller selection.

    Photos
    Cookiehead Bakery - Nitro cold brew on tap.

    Nitro cold brew on tap.

    Cookiehead Bakery - Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake

    Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake

    Cookiehead Bakery - Scorch's Smores

    See all

    Scorch's Smores

    The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac - desserts - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...