Make reservations ASAP! Came here with friends. Price was very reasonable for a steakhouse. Probably the best steak I have had at a restaurant. So flavorable and cooked to perfection. We also added a lobster and it was cooked just right and great portions. Caesar salad also was so good. We got all sorts of desserts and everything was delicious. Would absolutely come back again read more

See all

My husband and I made a 7:30 reservation at Melrose Grill tonight to celebrate our anniversary, the hope to keep things low-key and local. When we arrived, the lobby was absolutely packed with people standing shoulder to shoulder. We battled the chaos of the hostess stand, checked in and waited patiently, assuming they were simply running behind. But as time went on, and every single group and couple - some who arrived well after us started being seated. Then more groups. Then more. Eventually the lobby had completely emptied out while we were still sitting there wondering if we'd somehow been forgotten. After 15 minutes, 30, 45, then over an hour with zero communication, no apology, no status update, and no acknowledgement whatsoever, my husband finally asked if we had been skipped. By that point, even walk-ins had been seated while we sat there feeling honestly pretty foolish. The entire evening had been soured. We were sitting in the cobwebbed infested dusty lobby for an hour bummed out and felt completely deprioritized. We decided to just leave rather than spend $200 on a dinner experience that already felt awful before even reaching a table. What's the point of making a reservation if it isn't honored or even acknowledged? No stars. Chaos. Looked dusty, staff needs training :( Lobby area needs a deep clean. read more

The Melrose Grill - Avoiding the butt sweat on the lobby seating. - Steakhouses Near Me - Renton, Washington

I really wanted to have a great experience here, but unfortunately it fell short. Our waitress, Emily, was friendly at first, and I made sure to show appreciation by leaving a $30 tip. However, I realized that our entire to-go order had been forgotten in addition to a few other things. What was most disappointing wasn't just the mistake, it happens.....but the lack of effort to make it right. There was no accountability or urgency to fix the situation, which left a bad impression after what had otherwise started as a decent visit. Customer service is about how you recover when things go wrong, and this was a missed opportunity. The ambiance was good and the food was great (lamb & steak). The overall service, unfortunately was just an absolute miss! read more

The Melrose Grill - Steakhouses Near Me - Renton, Washington

See all

We spend all of our special occasions here and we came to celebrate our 28th wedding anniversary. It's a low-key, small dining space with excellent "Ruth's Chris" or "John Howie" level steaks. I love the casual ambiance. But they were very busy, and we got stuck in the back middle table. The wait staff could barely squeeze between my husband's chair and the diner seated extremely close behind him. And once the waiter walked by and cracked my husband in the head with a pepper mill. My husband is a lovely, kind person, but he looked extremely annoyed by that. The waiter apologized twice but still. We made reservations for my husband's birthday next weekend because he just loves his Delmonico. Hoping for a booth to avoid concussions. read more

Food was delicious and customer service was A+ definitely worth all the hype! Will definitely be back again. read more

The Melrose Grill - Steakhouses Near Me - Renton, Washington

See all

Great food, every time. Book well in advance; it's a smaller restaurant. Good for conversations.

The steaks tasted delicious and were cooked perfectly! I liked that the steaks came with a salad on the side as well. I thought the additions of prawns were pretty pricey but did taste good. The slice of cheesecake was creamy and had a yummy crust! They had the original bar from when the building was built which was pretty neat! Our servers were nice and attentive as well with great recommendations. The experience was good overall and I think it's not the most overpriced steakhouse in the area. read more

See all

Note we went New Years Eve. A notorious time to dine out. Service was pleasant though not attentive. One of us ordered the spinach salad and it was swimming in dressing. We couldn't flag anyone down to discuss. When they came to prepare our table for entrées it was too late. Though they offered to remove the charge from the bill. The Caesar salads were better. Still heavily dressed, but with enough croutons and anchovy to carry us along eating it. Those who ordered steaks were happy with their meals. Especially pleased the steaks were cooked to the doneness requested. However, I was not a fan of the beef stroganoff. The pieces of meat were full of gristle and connective tissue. They must use this dish to get rid of trimmings. Very disappointing. The flavor was bland. I do not recommend this dish. The side of sautéed spinach was lovely. We tried 3 desserts and 2 were hits. The flourless chocolate cake was luscious and the apple crisp enjoyed. The bread pudding was dry and not very sweet. I'm hoping its usually better. The best bite of the meal was the warm roll. Delicious and with great texture. Loved that roll! read more

See all

Melrose Grill was awesome Mother's Day Dinner got seated 15 minutes before closing and still had a complete Steak Dinner With Caesar Salad, bread, Seafood Linguine and Delmonico Steak Coconut Bread, Pudding. Service was wonderful and the Atmosphere was bustling with laughter and loud noise read more

See all

We have consistently had great food and service from The Melrose. The environment is great for a date night or the family. Special shout out to Karen who always makes us smile read more

Epic steakhouse in the most inconspicuous place you'll ever dine at! The Melrose in my opinion is the best steakhouse in the Pacific Northwest. Located in the heart Renton "The Melrose" provided me with the highest quality of steaks I've ever eaten and you'll probably ever dine on. From the moment you arrive I'm greeted with a smile and asked if I have a reservation, which is YES. Hopefully you've made reservations cause I doubt you'll be seated. Now if you're flying solo the bar has seating and you'll have full access to the menu. Plus it's come with a beverage architect with sommelier skills to assist you on your evening journey. Ok, my favorite meals are the rib eye steak medium. It's flame grilled to perfection with char marks for verification. Franks second option is the Beef Stroganoff which is a master piece for your pallet. The stroganoff is packed with more pieces of prime rib meat than your colon can handle but it's delicious... I'd suggest you order the stroganoff & steak and share with two or three people. One more item is the side of Sautéed onions to smother your steak with should it be available. Gave me that extra splash of flavor enhancement that I'd highly recommend. And NO STEAK SAUCE NEEDED the steak has more than enough flavor for you to handle. Few side notes for you and that's salad & bread come with the meal. A few tasty deserts also can be purchased. Each night has several specials if you look for the chalk board or your waiter can share them. As I stated before this is the best steak in town and oddly enough it's very economical to dine here. So make sure you dine, drink & tip your wait person! read more

See all

First time coming to this spot. Cool history and good vibe. We had reservations and it did take awhile to get seated but that wasn't on the staff. Food was really good. My steak didn't come out ideal at first but it was made right and enjoyed the meal. Would come back to try other items. read more

The Melrose Grill - Ribeye with crispy Parmesan potatoes and asparagus. - Steakhouses Near Me - Renton, Washington

See all

Still a solid 4 stars. Lobster shrunk by about 50% this time. Had I known I would've ordered differently. The waitress was very nice and did try to make up for the smaller somewhat dry lobster. Next time it's rib eye or lamb chops. The peach dessert is a huge miss also. Should've went with the bread pudding thing that was suggested. Again as last time some employees definitely need some polishing. Well I know what im getting next time! If you like steak and potatoes you will like it here. read more

Tonight we decided to try a neighborhood spot in Renton that the wife and I last visited 4 years ago. The atmosphere in the Melrose Grill screams casual and cozy, the food is anything but that. It was a real busy evening as every part of the restaurant was humming. This space is not particularly large so when our party of 4 arrived every booth, table, and bar seat was occupied. We were eventually seated a few minutes after our reservation time. The front house staff were welcoming and kept us abreast of when a booth might become available. Once seated our server quickly engaged us, deposited menus and brought water. To begin, we ordered wine and chose our entrees. Melrose Grill is one of the few restaurants where a salad comes with your entree. Imagine that!! So, regarding the food, one person chose the Ribeye Steak which included assorted broiled vegetables and a Beefstake Tomatoes and Danish Blue Cheese Salad. Another chose the Beef Stroganoff special with a Caesar Salad. My wife decided on the Grilled Prawns with rice pilaf, fresh vegetables and the Blue Cheese Salad. I went with the Lobster Tail Dinner special including a baked potato, assorted vegetables and a Caesar Salad. I seriously considered adding a second Lobster Tail, next time I probably will. We all agreed that our selections were great! A tip of the cap to the kitchen, everything was well prepared and seasoned just right. The steak and lobster tail were moist and delicious, not overcooked. The other dishes were also tasty. Oh, and Melrose does not skimp on portions either. You will definitely get your monies worth dining there. For dessert we chose the Lemon Tart with Bourbon Caramel sauce, the Coconut Bread Pudding with Caramel Sauce, and the Crème Brûlée. We loved the desserts! If you are in Renton or looking for a spot for dinner outside Seattle consider the Melrose Grill. Great food, excellent service, and a cozy feel even on a very busy Thursday evening. We will not wait another 4 years to return. read more

See all

5/5 From the moment we stepped into Melrose Grill, we could feel the charm of this historic spot (Est. 1901!) mixed with a cozy steakhouse vibe. We started with fresh salads (included with your entree) --crisp greens with just the right amount of dressing--then moved on to the real stars of the evening: the entrées. The ribeye with sautéed mushrooms and onions was perfectly grilled, tender, and flavorful, with a generous portion size that made it impossible to leave hungry. The seafood pasta was decadent and creamy, loaded with scallops, shrimp and halibut, while the lobster tail with rice pilaf and vegetables was buttery, and cooked to perfection. Sides like the baked potato (loaded with cheese, bacon bits, and chives) and vibrant roasted vegetables rounded everything out beautifully. And the desserts? Pure indulgence--especially the crème brûlée and warm apple crisp with vanilla ice cream. Service the best. Our server was personable and attentive without being overbearing, and the atmosphere made it easy to enjoy both great food and great company. If you're in the Renton area and craving a top-quality steakhouse experience with generous portions and spot-on execution, Melrose Grill is a must-visit. read more

See all

A local favorite, the steaks here are absolutely delicious! They're cooked to perfection every time. The staff are very friendly. We've also enjoyed a wonderful meal at the bar. It's always a good vibe at Melrose with Renton regulars and visitors who enjoy this gem. read more

Classic steakhouse that has old school charm without being too stuffy. Steak was cooked perfectly, and our waitress was friendly read more

The Melrose Grill - Steakhouses Near Me - Renton, Washington

The redemption arc that no one saw coming. I didn't anticipate coming back here after my first experience over a year ago wasn't great. My new gf was trying to plan a "romantic" date night and picked this spot- we went in to it expecting it to either be really good or so bad it would be a funny memory. Thankfully it was super good. I ordered the top sirloin and it was seasoned so well I didn't need to do anything, the crispy potatoes were actually crispy (some with a char), the veggies were super good and the side of peppercorn sauce was sublime. The spinach salad was a little weird personally. The garlic mashed potatoes were better than the crispy ones and the filet was super good too. Great experience. read more

See all

We ate here with family. This place was pretty good but I should've gotten the steak. I got the pork medallions. They don't have much flavor much than the sauce you use. So make sure you use that sauce! The place outside and indoors reminds of some type of pub like a Simpson Moe's Tavern. Really nice looking and the servers were really attentive. If I go again I'll assure to get the steak and those delicious garlic mashed potatoes! Those were my favorite! read more

The Melrose Grill - Pork medallions - Steakhouses Near Me - Renton, Washington

I have been here several time. I always get the seafood linguine pasta. This time it came with a a whole plate of sausages. I don't even eat pork. The waiter said it always comes with it. Not true. I have also posted a review before here. Be careful when ordering and I am posting what's in it cause it does not say pork. Waiter was great but didn't offer to remake or take off. read more

See all

Having not been to the Melrose for some time, we were thankfully able to get a table this past Friday evening. Service was quick, very pleasant and drinks arrived quickly. For dinner, my favorite Pork Medallions in a peppercorn sauce did not disappoint! Incredible! JB had the brochette and prawns which were equally delicious. Our experience was a reminder not to wait so long to return. Next visit will be the beef stroganoff which is another favorite. Melrose is definitely a favorite in Renton for anyone wanting a delicious meal. If you haven't already, check it out-you won't be disappointed. read more

Tough steak - so tough it wouldn't cut! Rushed out for table Brochettes cold Shrimp overcooked Been there dozens of times and this was not up to standards. read more

The interior felt dark, outdated, and uninviting. Staff were distant and carried an odd sense of being discouraged from interacting. No one checked on us throughout the meal. The tomato‑and‑cheese salad arrived with a frozen, pale tomato that had no flavor. The steak was fatty, tough, and not worth the price. Overall, it was the worst dining experience I've had. The restaurant seems to be surviving solely on an old reputation that matches its tired décor. It's time to stop overcharging guests and consider closing the doors. read more

Melrose Grill is my absolute favorite steakhouse in the greater-Seattle area. My family has been coming here for years, and we have a great experience every time. Steaks here are seasoned generously and cooked to perfection. Each entree comes with bread service, a house salad, vegetables, and a side of your choice. This visit, we ordered a ribeye and filet, both of which were excellent. The restaurant is small and dimly lit, always bustling, and has the greatest staff. May has been our server multiple times, and is always very kind and welcoming. I would definitely recommend putting The Melrose Grill on your list of places to check out in Renton, and highly suggest making a reservation. read more

See all

Best steakhouse in south king county. Always fresh and top of the line cuts. Can be noisey but always fun. The servers are very personable and informative. The food is wonderfully seasoned and the wine list is varied. You can't go wrong with a meal here. read more

I've been coming here for birthdays, anniversaries, and special events for the last couple of years. The service and food has always been great! When you order a steak you get a salad and 2 sides. I always get the garlic mash and crispy parm potatoes as my sides. I've sometimes opted for the loaded baked potato which is +$1. The steaks are super affordable and come with great sides! I always look forward to coming back. read more

The Melrose Grill - Ribeye with garlic mashed potatoes and crispy parmesan potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - Renton, Washington

Great food. For the price, really amazing food. This place is a hidden gem. Ribeye steaks were good. Salads and desserts were good. Beef stroganoff was good. Feels homey and comfortable. Our server was excellent. Would come back! read more

See all

Had a late dinner last night. Service and food was excellent! Ambiance- pretty dark and outdated but twas not an issue for us. We would come back if/when we visit WA again. read more

The Melrose Grill - House salad w/blue cheese, crisp and fresh greens - Steakhouses Near Me - Renton, Washington

See all

Incredible food incredible people the consistency the second to none. Five star. The best steakhouse in the State Of Washington by far.

PROS: Steak was PERFECTLY cooked - we were that annoying table that ordered 3 of the same cuts and asked for it to be cooked differently and low and behold all steaks were cooked to perfection from rare to medium rare to well done I- The mashed potatoes were also SO good - it was smooth but also they leave the skin in so there's some texture to it too. The FLAVOR was immaculate - dare I say the best mash I've ever had. CONS: Not sure the side lobster was worth but def nothing wrong with it - just a lil steep desserts were also just ok but no complaints IG: Spillingthe.beans read more

See all

We arrived 10 min before our reservation time all of our party was there and we had to wait to be seated one hour and 15 min latter we are regular customers there and that was a little long tried to stay positive but that was not acceptable,our server and the staff were great other than that unusual wait time and there was no consideration or compensation to our group. read more

You know what's better than Melrose? Nothing I love the atmosphere. I love the food. I love the staff awesome place. read more

See all

Went for date night! Such good food!! Service was great too! It was a busy night our lady forgot a couple things but she was the sweetest!

We always enjoy our food, drinks, and time at the Melrose Grill. Our last visit I enjoy a wonderful Lobster tail and ribeye steak. It was all cooked perfectly. My leftovers made for two lovely lunches. You are always going to get more than you can eat. The service is always attentive and pleasant. Parking can be a challenge so leave extra time for that. read more

Disappointing. Filet Mignon and the brochette both ordered Medium. Both arrived Rare and heavy pepper. Potatoes were good though. read more

Always great food and service! Best place in Renton, the ambiance is always great too. This place has been here for many years, hoping it stays for many more. read more

Paper napkins is not a good start. The water was put on the table without even a welcome - the server just walked by and put them on the table without a word - didn't ask if I wanted bottled water. The waiter was not very warm - we tried to compensate with lots of appreciation, and he seemed to warm up (a little). It actually seemed like there was some discontent going on in the kitchen. The steak had a nice sear but the tomato and blue cheese salad, whereas it was good, the tomato was not at peak flavor- maybe better for a seasonal salad. Ok overall. read more

This place has always been 5 stars for us! Love the classic steakhouse atmosphere, excellent service & amazing food. This time we ordered Chardonnay while we decided what to order. We got filet mignon with extra veggies, prawns & extra veggies & salmon, veggies & garlic mash. We got a Caesar & a house salad with them. They do give you a yummy bread bowl to start as well. Everything was just so over the top delicious, from the bread bowl & butter to the salad's & entrees. Highly recommend this place as it's always amazing & consistent. They do have a great selection on their specials board too. We'll be back soon! read more

See all

This place is a hidden gem. The food was phenomenal! We got steaks, lobster and king crab (we went all out for a birthday). Steaks were seasoned well and cooked correctly. I've never seen a Maine lobster until tonight- they are huge! Our waitress May was a sweetheart and took really good care of our table- thank you May! read more

See all

The service was great but the food did not live up to the expectations. It was over cooked and no flavor.