They popped up on Instagram with a rubarg pie, strawberry rhubarb pie, and I had to get it and when I went in, it's a nice cozy shop and the coffee was delicious.The pie was amazing.I'm sure they had many other things but I really recommend them a lot read more

I have never been here, but my coworker always goes when there's a special occasion and I didn't realize after the fact that I should've took a picture of the box of all the good stuff that she got but I will show you two items that I did pick out out of the hole box they make the amazing best whoppi cookie with like two sugar cookies as there's cream filling inside. it is amazing. I'm just thinking about it their donuts every time that box comes in that door in this office it is nothing but sweetness and just good eats. Definitely if you're nearby as one day I will show up there to see what's going on, but in the meantime, please enjoy the pictures. read more

See all

Great pastries and scones, staff is friendly as well as the owner. I don't get to go there often, but i hope to get there soon.

Cute little bakery in Bloomingdale - lots of fresh pastries and cakes here. I had a raspberry and cheese danish that was very fresh and delicious! read more

A really cute and charming little shop. It's easy to miss if you aren't looking for it, located at the end of a strip mall. But once you're there there is plenty of parking and popping in for a treat is easy. I left with a bag of 5 goodies - croissant, cinnamon roll, a to-die-for almond pastry, a fruit swirl bun, and a little cheese and fruit pastry. Everything was delicious and tasted great the next day after a minute in the oven. Very pleased with the experience and will return. Only word of advice is to avoid rush hour as the area can become a little congested and frustrating to navigate. read more

See all

I found Magpie Bakery via a GF search on Yelp, and it definitely lived up to the hype! Loved meeting the owners and hearing their story of how and why they started their bakery. The cakes I had were absolutely delicious! The poptart was not my favorite thing, since I prefer softer desserts, but I enjoyed the flavor of it. I will for sure be back! read more

See all

Very nice locally owned bakery/coffee shop with a nice limited selection of pastries. Requests are happily accepted with notice. Priced a little higher than other bakeries in the area. Ample parking. This is a small, cozy bakery with a few tables for dining in. read more

I stopped in to order a cake for my husband's surprise 50th birthday party - process what super quick and easy, and they were super friendly and able to help me choose what size, flavors, etc. based on party size and preferences. I sent them an inspo photo of a cake I saw online that I liked, and they completely nailed it! I was super impressed. The cake was delicious and everyone enjoyed it. Will for sure be ordering cakes for every occasion from here. Happy to support local businesses with talented staff! Seriously, I can't get over how gorgeous the cake turned out. Thank you so much, ladies! My husband was thrilled. read more

The Magpie Bakery - Custom 2-tier birthday cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomingdale, New Jersey

This is the best bakery around for not only cakes and cookies but breakfast and dinner hand pies and such. The shepherds pie and pumpkin pie tops any other competitor. You will pay more here but you are also getting top quality ingredients so every item is worth a shot. What makes this place that much better is the owner knowing how to run this business , if the owner is reading this don't ever change your business model with how you treat your employees and customers because it's some of the best I've ever seen read more

See all

What a phenomenal bakery! Friendly staff, delicious treats made with the best quality I can find in the area, adorable shop. I ordered a cheesecake for Christmas Eve dinner and it did not disappoint! The chocolate crust has a rich deep chocolate flavor and the cheesecake consistency was perfect- not too dense, with just the right amount of fluffiness. Will continue ordering for special occasions from here. Hint- I also recommend the brownies and personal bread pudding! read more

The Magpie Bakery - Cheesecake with chocolate crust and strawberry topping with Christmas design. Picture doesn't do it justice! - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomingdale, New Jersey

I wanted to share that yesterday we got a cookie and brownie platter from Magpie Bakery in Bloomingdale for a get together, and it was awesome, delicious and a crowd pleaser! It's so nice to have a great bakery in the area again too! I recommend it if you haven't tried it yet. I even enjoyed an amazing cold brew iced coffee and a spinach quiche while I waited!! I'm definitely headed back! read more

The Magpie Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomingdale, New Jersey

The banana cream pie was such a hit at my family gathering, it caused a huge fight on who got to take the leftovers home and my sister in-law is still mad about it. 10/10 would order again read more

Always fresh, everything on the menu is outstanding. This place is a must try, love the cinnamon rolls and pies!

First time at the bakery, found the staff to be very helpful. Everything looked wonderful. Bought several pastries that were delicious.

Been back a few times for cheesecakes and savory pies. Owner is lovely and every time has been great. Today place was packed, people are learning about this great new local business. Highly recommend. Noticed today they have a coffee and tea bar as well. read more

The Magpie Bakery - Presentation is crooked and all mine - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomingdale, New Jersey

Fantastic bakery. I've yet to try something I don't like. My favorites are the donuts, bars (almond cherry), savory pies (Parmesan leek, heated up) and rhubarb pies. But really everything is great. The bakery is modern, clean, welcoming and the staff are super sweet. It's a family business so you can really see the care and thought that they put into everything. So glad to have Magpie in our neighbourhood! read more

Recently moved into the area and discovered this great little coffee shop/bakery. Been there a few times now and have not been disappointed. The fresh made lattes and coffees are absolutely delicious as are their custom flavors. While not someone to eat a lot of sweets, I have treated myself to some of their pastries including their absolutely delicious cinnamon rolls, chocolate chip muffins and most recently an absolutely yummy personal pumpkin pie. Pumpkin Pie is a favorite during this time of year and their pie earned big points from me! Also tried one of their Shepard's Pies for dinner and that was really delicious as well. The place has nice atmosphere, if the weather is nice you can sit on provided tables outside, and the staff are all super helpful and friendly! If you're in this area I highly recommend a stop here for pastries, delicious coffee and some really yummy meat pies for lunch or dinner. Love this little place! read more

The Magpie Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomingdale, New Jersey

Their pies are second to none. They have gone above and beyond in their service as well. I will purchase again.

I have been to this bakery several times since they settled in Bloomingdale. I've had the sweet and the savory and everything has been great. There was a red velvet cupcake in the box but I ate that in about 20 seconds. The cupcakes, brownies, apple turnovers, bread pudding, savory pies. Everything is all great. But what really stands out is the service. I don't know the girls name but every time I go in she is smiling, talking to you, making people feel welcome. I have not gone back to businesses because of attitudes and bad service. If I don't feel welcome or comfortable it's a one and done for me. But she is great and the owner is very sweet too. Will definitely be continue being a customer here. read more

The Magpie Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomingdale, New Jersey

See all

I am not a pie person, but this blueberry pie my friends got me is the best I ever had! The best!!!! Thank you! Keep on baking

Absolutely marvelous bakery--bright and welcoming and charming! The savory scones (maple sausage and spinach) were fluffy and the cinnamon rolls had a pillowy texture, and we enjoyed the small pot pies. The apple/blueberry pie = flaky crust perfection with a bit of crunch from the sugar, and we appreciated that the flavors were so good without being overly sweet. The regular brownie and some bread pudding (yes, I may have gone overboard, but no regrets!) topped off a perfect day. Magpie Bakery really has anything you could possibly be craving. Thank you for the delightful experience and conversation! Can't wait to try more creations!! read more

The Magpie Bakery - Apple/blueberry pie - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomingdale, New Jersey

I read reviews here on Yelp so I decided to check it out myself. First of all It's very well hidden in a tiny strip mall. I went in and noticed it was nice neat and clean but kind of scares for a bakery. I ordered a brownie, and was surprised that it cost $3.75. So I brought the brownie home and eat it. It was very good, nice and solid well worth the price. I would recommend people going there. It's very good. I will definitely tell my friends and family. I will definitely go back!! read more

I finally was able to stop at Magpie Bakery, and what an absolute gem it is. Sparkling clean, the staff is so helpful and kind, and it was so hard to choose what to bring home, each pastry was so perfect. I have not been able to find good carrot cake, and if you are a fan - RUN, do not walk, to Magpie to try the most outstanding carrot cake bar- perfectly moist, creamy decadent, and I couldn't wait - I ate it in my car in the parking lot!- and I shall be back for more. While the carrot cake bar didn't make it home, the treats for my husbands birthday- cupcakes and an chocolate cream pie- did. Once again, all were wonderful. Magpie is tucked in the back of a little strip of stores. Make they trip, you will be glad you did. read more

Showed up just as owner was closing and she stayed open to serve us...thank you! Delicious treats and refreshing iced teas. A terrific break following today's hike. read more

The Magpie Bakery - Holiday Crumb Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomingdale, New Jersey

Much like diners here in New Jersey there are A LOT of bakeries but magpie always seems to take the cake ( sorry couldn't help it). Mel and Cher are always there to greet with a warm smile and fun new recommendations. Thank you Magpie for always saving the day! P.S. I can't recommend the apple turnover enough! read more

This is my 1st review ever so Magpie Bakery really left an impression. I ordered a birthday cake for my best friend's 60th birthday. It was a 1/4 sheet cake with cannoli filling. It had to be by far the best cake I've had in a long time and the 20 guests at the party agreed! Even the cake decorating was beautiful. Thanks so much for the delicious cake and your attention to detail. read more

Fast service and the food was yummy! I definitely recommend the lemon bars and the strawberry rhubarb pie!

Wow! Where can I begin? The strawberry latte was phenomenal! Love the feta and spinach pastry. The chicken pot pie (hand pies) were divine. My two year old loved the cupcake. Love this place. I can't wait to go back! read more

Want to say the customer service was awesome!! Sheri. (sp). I would definitely recommend

Amazing service. High-quality baked goods. We placed a large order for pick-up & it was waiting for us when we arrived. We'll be back!

Food quality is very good (both sweet and savory items) as is the service, but they're a bit off the main highways, don't offer as large a selection as most bakeries I've been to, and they are pricey! I do highly recommend that everybody try them at least once! read more

Magpie is the best It is terrific to finally have a quality bakery in our area And there savory pies are fantastic Give them a try your sweet tooth and taste buds will love you for it read more

Everything about it is great! We like the "savory" pies like chicken pot pie. Delicious and they cook quickly. Very friendly staff as well. read more

Great pie and scones! Too many other great things to choose from. We had a very hard time not buying up the whole bakery.

Best red velvet cupcakes and cakes!! Love this hidden gem! Prices are reasonable too. read more

The Magpie Bakery - One thing better than the next! - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomingdale, New Jersey

Baked goods were just ok. Nothing special, not particularly flavorful. I ordered an assortment of pastries. None were great.

Best pot pie I've ever had! The crust....my favorite part :) The sweet treats were delicious. Very cute bakery, seating inside for a cup of tea/coffee and a cookie/ muffin! The owner is absolute delight. Best of luck! I will be back.... read more

Had a last minute baked goods emergency and Magpie came through . Not only that but our guests all raved it was arguably the best cheesecake they ever had , thank you so much . read more

Delicious pies. I went in to buy a specific pie. I found out that the type of pie was not made that day. The owner insisted I come back in a few hours because she would make that particular pie for me. She went beyond what any other bakery would do. Support this business! read more

Wow the price of a personnel peach pie was way off the chart. Mostly dough....little canned fruit!!!