I've made a few trips to this thrift store and have to say it is a gem! Prices are very reasonable…read moreand merchandise is always nicely presented. I am growing tired of the "chain" aspect of some of the larger resale shops and the willy-nilly way they price donations. The staff here is helpful and happy to have you as a customer. The clerk who checked me out was more than happy to tell me about about Heritage House & the mission behind the store. I found a few gems @ Second Thought, and i'm sure you will too!

what a wonderful place to shop! Its a charity type store that sells things at great prices. The…read moreladies that work there are a blessing!

Best thrift store in the entire greater Rochester area. Always fresh options. Great prices. Lots of…read moregems to be found. Very friendly.

It's a very nice place and the people are very friendly. We as a family enjoy shopping and getting…read moregreat deals.

Well this place was wild. Overstimulating and overwheming at first but I walked out with a good…read morehaul for $5 and some change. The staff was helpful, courteous, and gave good instructions. Totally different kind of thrifting than i have ever previously experienced. you dig through bins which are periodically switched out.

went 2x last week. same problem. found single sneakers, 11 in all. almost brand new but could not…read morefind the match. this happened twice in 2 weeks. where's the match??? seems a little fishy makes you wonder if the matches for the sneakers are in the back and being held so the employees can take home. sorry. but that's just my feeling being this happened twice in 2 weeks. very sad

Welcome to trinket town! Whatzits and whoozles abound. If you're in need of a microwave plate or…read morereplacement coffee carafe, this is the place! Lots of frames, records, old dishes and estate/garage sale leftovers. The sheer amount of stuff crammed into every corner is both overwhelming and inspiring.

What a fun place! I cannot express fully how expansive it is here though.I've been 3-4 times and I…read morestill don't think I have been through the entire place. You could spend literal hours here just exploring. They have clothes, furniture, books, video/audio entertainment, kitchen goods... the list continues! Staff here is very welcoming helpful and available. If you like thrift stores/flea markets-definitely go!

I'm so sad that the only time I got to visit was on their last day open (1/24/26), but really glad…read morethat at least I got the chance to stop by before they closed! The setup is an array of clothing and accessories from many different local vendors. They had a huge selection of vintage items from 50s, 60s, 70s, etc up to y2k, and they were all labeled very clearly. Everything was reasonably priced for the vintage condition, including a very cool Gunne Sax top. Service was great too! The shop owner was very nice, and the community seemed to truly value this shop. Many people stopped by for one last chance to shop and to say hi.

Cute concept for vintage store. Located near ugly duck coffee on Charlotte Street... This old house…read morehouses quite a few independent vintage vendors on both the first and second floor of the house. Clothing and accessories as well as a few household items were available. Staff was friendly and helpful. The store was very busy on a Sunday afternoon.

I've visited this location a few times to donate and browse. It's not a large store, but like any…read morethrift shop, you either find treasures or not much at all. The prices are fair, and there's plenty of parking. 3.5 outta 5

Ok, so you know how Covid brought back the jigsaw puzzle pastime to the national consciousness?…read more Well, Goodwill now has a plethora of used puzzles that are in GOOD condition. This location in particular had a really good selection of puzzles (500s, 750s and 1000 pieces, and round ones too!) Every puzzle I've done so far has had all the pieces (one of my biggest worries when purchasing) so it's been a great investment. They puzzles are priced right between $2.80 and $4.00. I will definitely be back, because I've scored some good finds here!!!

Unless you are donating brand new furniture, don't bother calling these guys to pick up anything…read more This is the second time I've offered very expensive furniture only to be turned down for picking it up. I thought the Salvation Army was not for profit, but obviously they're only interested in making money on things that they can sell in their stores

Best prices for books..hardcover only $.99 ! Pleasant…read moreemployees very friendly! Wish people would donate more to this store.

Whenever I am in the Pittsford area, I like to pop into NTY's consignment shop for some gently used…read moreworkwear. I made a point to stop by today because the sister Clothes Mentor locations in Greece & Henrietta have closed. I plan on entering the store when I am driving down Monroe Avenue toward the Pittsford Wegmans, so I can make a right hand turn in. Upon exiting the lot, I usually head towards another store towards Pittsford Plaza so I can make a right out of the lot. Trying to make a left and crossing two lanes of traffic is extremely difficult. Lots of the brands they tend to carry are J. Crew, Free People, Lululemon, Loft, Calvin Klein, Old Navy, and some Marshalls/Nordstrom/TJMaxx brands. Designer bags and shoes pop in the store as well and are often featured on their Facebook stories. Currently, they have their racks of summer seasonal wear out, and lots of athletic wear. The owner told me she was going to make a jacket and blazers rack soon this week, after clearing some more space. Some items are priced well, others are a touch higher than I would like to pay but it really depends on the brand and the type of item. Today I left with a cobalt blue Banana Republic skirt ($12), a red Mario Serrani pencil skirt ($10), and a Loft blouse ($14). With the tax and a check-in discount, it was $33. The store is requiring masks to alleviate the discomfort of other shoppers and staff. They are offering 10% off with a Facebook check-in to help promote the business.

Incredible selection of designer brands for unbeatable prices. Everyone who works there is very…read morehelpful. Love this store!

Prices are high for secondhand items, and many aren't in great condition. Anything…read morebroken/cracked/damaged shouldn't cost more than 99 cents (but they do). I did find a reasonably priced flower pot, an overpriced but kind of perfect basket for my bedroom ($8), and a pretty-good-condition summer dress. One other annoyance is that there are no fitting rooms, so I had to hope for the best that the dress would fit once I got it home. They did offer an opportunity to enter an email/phone number at checkout and get a discount off of your total purchase, and I happily did so. There is a rewards program of some kind, but I likely won't go here enough to utilize it. This is a good place to go to satisfy the thrifting thrill in the colder months when there are no garage sales. The staff was friendly and it is an organized store, I just wish the quality of the items was reflected better in the pricing.

Went to Savers for the first time. It's a trip for me cuz I don't live nearby. A big store full of…read morestuff, especially the household items etc. I looked at the summer dress selection. There's a ton of dresses and the condition of items on average looked decent. The starting price is definitely higher than Goodwill and Amvets: 5.99 and above. Some pieces can go over 10 and hit almost 20 bucks when they're just some mall brands like loft, ann klein, etc. Too bad the dressing rooms are closed at this time. So I left even though I found some nice dresses for work. Just learned you can return from another Yelper's review. I suppose it's a 7-day return policy as Goodwill used to have this rule. I didn't see return policy posted at the storefront.

Clothes are sorted by color not size. I'm sure this saves employees all kinds of time, but it's a…read morebad, bad idea. Incredibly difficult and just daunting to try to find anything. Store is dirty, rest room is vile.

This is one of my favorite places to visit whenever I'm thrifting. Selection is a bit haphazard,…read moreand the product there seems to be WELL picked over, probably indicative of the amount of customers that patronize this location. The Salvation Army headquarters is nearby, concrete proof of their mission. One of the better charities out there competing for your tax deductible donations! Other locations worth checking out include their stores on East Ridge Road in Irondequoit and Jefferson Road in Henrietta.