Clean and fun atmosphere. Girl working the bar wasn't very friendly but overall great place.read more

A found this bar on www.putinbayohio.com and www.putinbay.com and had a great. Fun Bar a little…read moreout of downtown. Great place Great Service

Mojito Bay was our very first bar stop on the island. I will say that we were there in late…read moreSeptember, so our experience was much different than it would be in the height of their busy season - it was super quiet on the island and all of the bars we visited were almost completely empty. Honestly it was so nice and relaxing, and I don't think I could handle being at the "Key West of the Midwest" during the summer months! Anyway, Mojito Bay is a cool sandy beach bar with swing seats that specializes in - you guessed it - mojitos. They have a huge menu of different types so I got the "tropical surprise" and Nate got a passionfruit mojito. They load them up with lots of fresh mint and liquor - they were strong and very tasty! The vibe was so beachy and fun, definitely a party spot when it's busier.

Stop 2 on the Put-in-Bay pub crawl. The sand and swings at…read morethe bar were fun but the poor attitudes of the bar staff were not. The drinks were average for paying a premium price. My next visit to the island will not include the Bay. Very disappointed to say the least.

Great swimming pool and bar open to the public. Lots of seating and lounge chairs. Pool also has a…read morehot tub on one end. On Saturday they have music and a club atmosphere. Great group of bartenders and bouncers to keep everyone happy. They even serve food.

Even on a rainy day, this place was great to lounge at as I enjoyed my frozen cocktail (Miami Vice)…read moreand met new friends at the bar with my husband. The service was top notch, and we really enjoyed ourselves during our first evening on the island.

This was our last stop on the island. Loved our bartenders - they were super friendly and chatted…read morewith us about the island and its inhabitants. We were there in late September so it was super quiet. I loved the big "pay it forward" board where you can pay for a drink for someone and they can claim in later (within one year). We just got drinks, but the food menu looked really tasty. Nate got the hot honey Manhattan, which was very good! We loved the kick from the hot honey. I got a 1oz pour of Blanton's which was very reasonably priced. They have a pretty extensive bourbon menu for a sports bar. Lots of sports team memorabilia, would be a fun place to watch a game.

I went with a large party and we were split into two tables. The Bloody Mary was excellent. The…read moretacos not so much.... They were tiny, expensive, and unimpressive. The shrimp taco had 3 little shrimp and was nothing special, the pork belly taco was spicy and lacked any sort of texture. The hand cut fries made up for the taco disappointment.

Get the cherries. They are behind the bar soaking in 151 rum…read more They are horrible, but i had 8 of them! Whew !! Drinks, live music, this is the best place on the island. Rock out !

Definitely a popular spot on the island...you'll always find an enthusiastic crowd and bands…read more Maybe it's because the band wasn't that great on the night I went, but I had a fair time - not bad, but not great. The circus top building adds a fun touch though. Probably worth a try- can't really miss it when you're walking the main drag

Joe's bar has GREAT burgers!! We were pleasantly surprised that everything we got there was really…read moregood! Their cheese curls are the yummiest guilty pleasure, a must try. They have fast service and pleasant employees. There are a few tables inside but since it is a bar and we had the kids, we ate outside at the picnic tables. If you're camping in PIB or in for the day and want to eat GOOD FOOD at decent prices, this is your place.

This was another stop on the middle bass Island pub crawl…read more Joe's is a hopping place. They have a great outdoor space with plenty of seating. The bar is really busy, but you get your drinks quickly from the very friendly and a ton of staff. Of all the places we drank on our trip this one had the best service, best drinks, and best drink prices. On an island teaming with restaurants and bars, that charge A premium and delivers little value. Joe's is The place to go. The drinks were great. They have a great appetizer menu and the burgers are off the hook. I will definitely come back to this place again.

Came up to PIB for the day specifically looking for tacos. After passing Victor's (did not try)…read morewhich is literally a taco food truck without wheels, we kept walking and found Margaritas. Great vibe, clean, with good music but not too loud. We were there around 1pm on a Friday for lunch. The good: Birria tacos were good. Food came out hot and fresh - almost so hot you had to wait. Great consume' as well, especially for what I'll call a "basket lunch spot". The bad: we sat at the bar on the south side. The east side bar gets more attention. My friend and I both just got water - we were immediately ignored by the 4 college girls running the bar. Had to beg for a second glass of water. Even got one bartender's attention and she looked and walked away. Here's the punchline. I like to have a nice cocktail sometimes as much as the next guy. A margarita sounded really good on a sunny Friday. However we flew an airplane in to PIB for the tacos, so zero alcohol for us. Clearly that did affect our service quite a bit. We aren't cheapskates, we are pilots that needed 100% of our faculties to safely come home to our families. Would I come back? Truly I'd probably go to The Keys instead. Equally fun outside- better views, food and service.

Pre mixed margaritas - but decent…read more Nachos were really good Service was ok Ambiance was nice!!

We went here for a dinner for my friend's bachelorette party before a night out. We were looking…read morefor good cocktails and a good, hearty dinner - that is exactly what we found here at The Boardwalk! We all ordered cocktails that came with quick service and were delicious! My friend tried the Crab Cake Sandwich and loved every bit of it. I ordered the Simple Cheeseburger, and although it was a typical cheeseburger (with added bacon), it was cooked perfectly and was as juicy as a cheeseburger could get! The fries on the side were great too. We left there being very happy with our choice. This is a great spot on the Boardwalk if you ever visit Put-in-Bay!!!

We visited this place on a Saturday for lunch. There was golf cart parking out front and it was…read morewithin walking distance of many other stores and bar since it's in the downtown part of the island. When we walked in we were a bit confused as there were multiple bars and food areas. The bathrooms were on the walkway leading to the restaurant. They were small and pretty filthy. One toilet one broken and filled with waste, and the other had toilet paper all over the stall. We were visiting with our dog and discovered, after walking upstairs, that dogs are not allowed on the upper deck. They are allowed on the lower and back portions of the area. We ended up at the seafood bar on the main level. Being from Maryland we're use to seafood with a lot more flavor and seasoning to it. This was very expensive for bland seafood. We also ordered a frozen lobster bisque to-go. (The plastic containers were flimsy and didn't make it back to the mainland before it cracked down the whole side.) If we go to the island again this will be a spot to skip.

Most of the stars are for the fantastic musicians- sunset duo!! During high season, you can…read moreregularly find live music here. Ambience is also nice- right on the water with a large outdoor patio. But beware of where you sit- if you choose to forgo hosted seating, you are stuck on the patio. It would have been nice to have that made obvious before we all roasted in the sun. Food was fine, nothing to scream or smile about. But really thanks to sunset duo for some gorgeous tunes for a perfect summer evening.

My family and I took a trip to Put In Bay and we came here off a recommendation and it did not…read moredisappoint! The food was delicious and perch I had was very fresh and nicely fried. My family cleaned there plates and there were plenty of people having a great time all around! The vibe is very beachy and matches the vibe of the island. The server was very nice and knowledgeable about the menu and drinks! Overall it was great place to stop by on an island trip!

The flavor of the pizza was good, but the crust honestly reminded me of a cardboard insert from a…read morefrozen pizza... there was also so much cheese that every bite the toppings would come off. The breadsticks weren't bad. They were really big but a bit doughy. Needed cooked longer. The staff was friendly and the food came out quick though.

This is a long standing local operation, and it's a breakfast/pizza/bar all in one. We came for…read morebreakfast, which was a nice and peaceful vibe, which was greatly needed after an evening of island shenanigans. Food was great/ I loved the health nut plate, especially the chia pudding. My gals enjoyed the eggs Bennie, and the other said the gravy on her biscuits was the best she's ever had! My liver would not permit any breakfast cocktails, but my friend really liked the frostini! Our servers were all great.