We came in as first timers and ordered take out. Everything was ok until we got the bag and we could not believe how small the bag was. Ordered two regular haddock sandwiches and after that very disappointed. Sandwiches were on a regular bun. I buy those buns myself at Dollar General for $1.50 for 8 but was really upsetting was $4.00 for a baked potato. Went home and did our own potatoes. $20.00 for 2 little sandwiches for 2 people. Will not be back. read more

The man that owns it is rude and the bathrooms aren't kept up with. We were gonna eat there but the man said we can't use the bathrooms without eating when we were about to eat. He was really rude and I won't be back. He needs to extend his hours too if he wants people to eat there. read more

If you like to eat cat food in a dirty cafeteria The Fish Boat is for you! Actually, I wouldn't feed it to my cat. I thought I caught a glimpse of a large rodent but I may have been mistaken. Also, no smiles allowed as the proprietor has a penchant for dour looks and rude belligerence. Fortunately there are plenty of trash cans to dump your plate after the first yummy bite of thawed and refrozen (repeat) seafood delights! Don't know what happens to it after that but if it still looks good maybe he can make money on it twice! Enjoy! read more

I've known about this place for at least 5 years now but never went in here. What a surprise, I ordered a meal and said to I think his name was Dave, I'll probably won't eat all of this. I started eating and everything was so good. I finished all of it. I think this is going to be one of my new favorite spots. My goal is to try everything on the menu. If I could give it a 10 I would but it only takes five stars. Thank you Dave for having such a great place. read more

Been coming here for over 15 years and am constantly impressed with the quality, portion size, variety and pleasant staff. When I visit my hometown I always have to stop in for the clams, haddock or a combination platter...the sides are also amazing... secret Yugoslavian family recipe pierogies (come just for these sometimes)...now I want to go back and I just ate there last evening. lol read more

Had them deliver my food to my house, it was nothing but dog. I called to get the food rectified owner was very belligerent and told us it was perfectly good food and we should just eat it! He told us they had a new oil so it will not brown and he was not saying out his driver again cuz it was too hot!!! He also yelled at my elderly mother that it was not his fault so he shouldn't have anything to do about it. One star will never go here again stay away like the plague or in this case the coronavirus! read more

See all

I stopped in Monday because a client suggested we meet there. I came in an hour early and had lunch before the client arrived. I always do this as a way of "paying" for my booth space when I am meeting someone primarily for business. I need not have worried about taking up the space, I was the only one in the restaurant. The lunch I had was mediocre at best and totally overpriced, it was the fish dinner. My client arrived, I bought him a drink and we talked for about an hour. When we were done, I was there for a few minutes getting my stuff together. Dave (the owner?) then shouted over that he should charge me rent for office space. He didn't have time to come over while I was eating to see if everything was ok, but he had time to make a sarcastic remark! It was not done in a humorous manner, it was mean spirited. On Wednesday I stopped in with a business partner of mine. Dave was in the middle of a conversation when an employee asked what she could do for us. I asked to speak with Dave. The employee told him I wanted to speak with him. He immediately turned his back to us and continued the conversation. After he was done talking he walked off into the back room, never acknowledging that we were there even though he knew we were patiently waiting to speak with him. I don't know if he is just rude or if it is something else. This may not be important, I am white, but the client and business partner are both black. No matter what the reason, I will never step foot in the place again and I will encourage everyone I meet to never go there! Dave's behavior is totally unacceptable! read more

The Fish Boat has been a family owned seafood restaurant since 1957. It is also a seafood market where they specialize in selling fresh fish and shellfish by the pound. How in the world they get their selection of fresh fish in Johnstown is a mystery to me, however it looks fresh and firm and I would be willing to try it as I watched quite a few folks walk in and go straight to their fish on ice and order beautiful filet's of fish and shellfish to take home and prepare. I for one have become a yelp whore and I am anxious to check out places just to review them, there I admitted it, I am a glutton for spreading the word and being rewarded by comps and ufc's. I no longer cook, I eat out seven days per week and the family and friends get to share in my adventures. Seriously, I was so hungry for a good fried haddock hoagie and I was not disappointed! The haddock was dipped and fried until crunchy but moist and delicious, it was a huge thick piece that was then laid on a soft six inch roll lathered with tartar sauce, topped with cheese, lettuce, pickles, onions and tomatoes. This happened to be the special of the day so I got cole slaw and fries with it. They serve sandwiches or Ala carte items, boats or dinners of a variety of fresh fish, plus crab cakes, salmon cakes, fried flounder, perch, oysters, fish cakes, tuna on toast, soft shell crabs, shrimp, scallops, clam strips or you can opt out of the sea and pluck a chicken breast, tenders or wings. They have a nice variety of sides, cole slaw was okay, they slice and batter their own fried zucchini which was okay, the have frozen french fries, baked potatoes, but I opted for their homemade pierogies and these were very good. The also offer noodles and cabbage which was basic, I kick my own up a few notches with bacon, Swiss and parmesan cheese and sauteed onions. The mac & cheese is not much different than you would find at KFC or Popeyes. They have both NE and Manhattan clam chowder as well as Maryland crab soup, I ordered a half pint of the white chowder, the diced potatoes were still raw and swimming in a thin bland milky broth, with not many clams, onions or celery. I would not order it again. Their salmon cake and crab cake are very minced meat, no chunks and the crab was deviled. Both were deep fried and tasty, but not what I was expecting, for the low price, I should have known better. They also go under the name of H&H Caterers, so therefore you can order party platters here of steamed shrimp in bulk or anything else you see on the menu for that matter. They are a restaurant, retail and wholesale for a complete line of seafood. I would go back again for the haddock hoagie and the homemade pierogies and the original nostalgia of the restaurant with the cool murals and spin on a stool at the very long counter or grab a table just to people watch. It's a pretty cool scene. read more

See all

Every time I come to the city I make a stop here. I love this place. Food is great. Prices are good.

After a craving for fish I found The Fish Boat on yelp, and decided to load up the car and head to Johnstown to give it a try. The fish boat has been around in Johnstown since the 50's so figured they must be doing something right. The fish boat is an interesting place. It reminds me of a Seafood Diner lost in time on the lonely streets of downtown Johnstown. As soon as you walk in you immediately get that feel of a nostalgic piece of history with a "fish shop" in the city touch. Upon arriving the place was empty and no workers could be found either. I went to the "Fresh Fish" area and sadly no fish was to be found.... So I was a tad skeptical that we may have some mediocre fish...or maybe they had it in the back room? I ordered the Fish Sandwich.. and my wife some shrimp. Upon ordering I couldn't help but notice that the woman behind the counter was not very pleasant and gave that feeling that she didn't want to be there, and didn't really want you to be there either.. I asked her a few questions that were answered with one word responses. This normally sets the mood to an ultimate low ,and you immediately start questioning your dining decision.... Then again working Saturdays at a fish shop isn't the best thing I can think of doing either. Once the food arrived it was actually pretty good. The fish had a really good taste and the fries and hush-puppies where good as well. I think that batter was really flavorful and the sandwich hit the spot. The coleslaw is nothing to write home about according to my wife (I personally don't touch the stuff). Overall I really want to give this place a go again. I like the feel, and thought the food was pretty good. Times are hard for traditional family owned places, and sometimes they need the support to prove what they really can be. And I want to believe this place could be great. read more

So I'm in town visiting my sister. I decide to take my nephew for lunch and being from outta town I did a quick google search and came across @The Fish Boat". A family owned restaurant that had been here for decades. I figured if it had been here this long, it must be pretty good, right? Well, I was NOT disappointed. Very good fresh fish and sides. The owner was behind the counter and he and his staff were very friendly and the customer service was superb! Highly recommend and I'll definitely stop in next time I'm in from California. read more

I'd definitely get takeout from here more than once during lent if the prices were reasonable.

Lived in Johnstown before, every time I come to visit the fish boat is a must! I love this place and the food. Best fish in Johnstown. If for looking for a great meal or trying a new restaurant go here, you won't be disappointed. Great hometown food. read more

I have been wanting to visit this family restaurant for a long time. Although I really didn't want to go anywhere, I decided to help out our local businesses during COVID-19 and ordered the crab cake, fish sandwich, hush puppies and cole slaw for pickup. The man who took my phone order was abrupt and almost rude. But considering the current state of our country, I realize tensions are high and nerves are raw. When I went in, I was the only one there but not one of the 4 people working acknowledged me for a good 10 min. Not a hello, smile, NOTHING. Like I was rude for ordering food. The workers seemed irritated with each other too. It was downright unpleasant. Then the food. I have to say it's painful for me to give a local establishment bad ratings but the food and service are awful. I may be laid off due to COVID and this is my hard earned 30 bucks for an absolutely awful lunch. The slaw for the Cole slaw was mushy like it was made in a blender. The hush puppies tasted old. Fish- tasteless and also mush. Crabcake had one noticeable piece of crab in it. Also mushy. Sorry but we will never return. read more

Was skeptical because of all the bad reviews but not disappointed at all. As soon as me and my two children walked in we were greeted by a male immediately and asked if we were ready to order. He was very patient with us and also let us know he would be getting the fryers on. The server was cleaning and also tried to make us feel comfortable while they got started for the day. The male put cartoons on for my kids so I truly appreciate that. Food was good. No complaints here! Will return! read more

We stopped by right before closing and they rustled to get our orders. The owner Dave was extremely kind. Our fish and shrimp was really really good. This is a little off the wall place definitely worth going to. I know we will return read more

I drive almost an hour for this fish! The people are friendly, the food is excellent, prices are appropriate, and it's not greasy like Long John Silvers. Every town needs a Fish Boat! read more

One of the few things I miss about Johnstown. I worked almost six years downtown for one of Uncle Jack's defense contractor friends and The Fishboat was a frequent go-to stop for lunch. The prices were very reasonable and the staff was always friendly. read more