A hidden gem and so glad it popped up as a recommendation! Their sashimi was some of the windy and…read morebiggest pieces we've ever had! We went twice on our trip we liked it so much there

5 + location and view…read more 4 minus overall No reservations, so depending on time of year you may have to wait for a table. We have been here a number of times and usually enjoy our meal and experience. They have Good sushi selections and usually have nice fresh seafood selections. We had Tile fish prepared with escarole, white beans, and crispy leaks. Quite good! We also had wild Alaskan salmon that was somewhat disappointing. Id skip that! Was kind of dry and a bit fishy. Not terrible, but not really exceptionally enjoyable either. Service was good! They definitely work hard! They were washing down the table next to us as we sat down which is fine. Unfortunately, they were using some kind of solution that smelled like dirty or rotten damp rags. Unfortunately the smell took a while to dissipate and impacted our party's experience. It also probably reduced our ordering of pre-meal apps and drinks, not intentionally, but because it wasnt appetizing. We will probably return, because our experience might have been off a bit because they are not in full season yet.

Gin Beach Cafe in Montauk is a really nice spot by the water with a great view of the docks. I had…read morethe Lobster Roll BLT, a watermelon martini, and fresh oysters. Everything tasted fresh, especially the oysters, and the martini was perfect for a Summer day. The service was okay but the food was better. It is a little overpriced, but the food and the setting make it worth visiting.

Excellent view, excellent service, excellent company and excellent food! Decent prices, Clean…read morebathrooms and a huge parking lot

Talk about a hidden gem. One of the best little finds in Montauk. Crab corn chowder was delish and…read moreso were the fish and chips. Get a painkiller too!

My brother and I were on a nostalgia tour of Montauk, and ended up here after walking around…read moreGosman's Dock. We had wanted to go to what's now Mary Lou's but used to be a restaurant we went to all the time on family vacations. The security guards and swarms of influencers in sparkly dresses and cowboy boots made us quickly realize this wouldn't be an option for dinner. We started walking back toward Gosman's and noticed The Dock tucked away on a side street. We decided to grab a drink at the bar and regroup on next steps. The ambiance here is very casual, its a busy spot with a large indoor bar and a handful of indoor and outdoor tables. Our bartender was a master at tending to the rush and took care of us quickly. While we were deciding what to do next, we made conversation with a local Gosman's fish monger who let us know the food here was worth staying for, and even went as far as to ask one of the staff members for the name of what the restaurant next door used to be for us as we were trying hard to remember. I'm so glad we stayed, because the food was really on point here. Clam chowder was hearty and had plenty of clams. Their steamed clams were incredible, fresh and packed with lots of chopped garlic in a broth that you'll want to drink. The star of the show here is the tuna melt: a giant fresh tuna steak served on an English muffin with cheese and some of the best fries I've had at a restaurant in ages. Glad to have made another core memory here in Montauk at The Dock.

The ambiance and beach bar were breathtaking , literally feels like you're in Europe. The food was…read moredelicious, that I will give. we got the peppers with halloumi , tartare, lobster pasta and swordfish Kebob. The drinks were EH. The Muddah Freqqin wait of 2 hours and 45 minutes to be seated, is absolutely, positively not worth it, leave. It was a one and done for me dawg. ** upset me the most ** waited almost three hours to be seated inside by the bar , could've ate quicker at the bar hours ago

Super pretty restaurant in Montauk with lovely outdoor seating overlooking the beach…read more Need to come early since they don't accept reservations and it gets pretty packed especially on weekends. The food was overall pretty damn great. The fresh oysters were amazing. Very fresh. The scallop crudo had great balance. Loved the chili oil drizzle on top. The lobster tagliatelle was rich and buttery. The snapper was also perfectly cooked. Spiced tomato sauce. Overall, definitely a must try restaurant when in Montauk. On the pricier end. But when in Montauk...

Amazing food and great service! We love this restaurant! The restaurant is beautiful inside and…read moregreat views outside. Kim and Rich McGuire

Beautiful restaurant with an amazing sunset view over the pond. We had a reservation and were sat…read morein a cute booth right on time for dinner in the off season. They give you bread and shredded Parmesan cheese to start (although delicious I have no clue how you were supposed to eat that without looking crazy lol). I ordered the artichoke pizza to start but ended up having that as my meal since it was giant. Overall pretty good but no wow factor on flavor. My bf ordered the Montauk fish of the day (fluke) and loved his meal, the lemon risotto and charred veggies made the dish and brightened the fish right up. Overall amazing spot with the view and ambience, limited vegetarian options, but pretty good food.

Are at the inlet cafe along the water (unsure if the menu is the same for topside) but we expected…read morean average meal with a beautiful setting. What we got were GREAT meals, and cold wine with a beautiful setting. -Ahi Tuna: 5/5, seasoned and seared perfectly. If I'm being totally honest this may have been the best I've ever had anywhere. -Fish Tacos: 4/5, great flavor but lacking fish. Seemed to be overstuffed with filler but still delicious. -Calamari: 5/5, all rings which is always a plus for us. Seasoned great. Overall we were very surprised with the quality of the food and left very satisfied. Considering the view, location, and quality I'd consider this a great value for what you're paying. Definitely coming back

Topside is our first stop on vacation to Montauk. Yesterday afternoon was perfect !! Matt, the…read morehost, is so personable and really on his game. It was a beautiful day, we started with Prosecco and margarita and enjoyed the boats going in and out of the inlet. Starters were raw clams (so tiny- yum) and shrimp cocktail - big and fresh. Everything is artfully plated. As my favorite watermelon feta salad wasn't on the menu - actually a blessing - I tried the Lobster caprese salad and it was a miracle. I took a picture. My husband's fish and chips was hot, crunchy, and not greasy at all. Plenty of fries. A couple cocktails, beautiful scenery and a fantastic meal is the way that we jump start our Montauk trip. Highly recommend it. Note- there's a lot of talk about Gosmans just being sold blah, blah, blah. No worries the Topside hasn't changed a bit. No kids allowed- probably too dangerous. Not the worst idea for my serenity fix either. Cheers ! To the folks complaining about the price- you're in the wrong town. Topside is a treat for us, worth every penny !!

It is literally a shack behind her house. Best part is not how delish or affordable it is but that…read moreshe is open year round!! We came early spring and most restaurants are still closed but she's open. Lobster rolls 2 for $38!! Cash only. And she is just absolutely lovely!! We will definitely be back

Finally had the chance to give Bennett Shellfish a try after seeing it all over social media. As…read moreothers have said here and on the Gram, this is run out of a couple's actual home and as such, there are (understandably) rules to follow. You'll pull into their driveway and ring the bell as indicated. Once we did, there were signs all over about not eating here which, again, understandable, we're in your home. Ambiance is very much to-go counter. We entered to a stressed out lady behind the counter who yelled out "it's cash only!" which I'm guessing has been an issue despite all the very clear signage. Her husband was having some breakfast at the counter and immediately told us that he knew he was breaking "the rules" (dude it's your literal home do what you want). We ordered two lobster rolls as well as clams on the half shell - the total came to $49 which is a steal here compared to other spots. The clams were extremely fresh (just shucked, to the point where there was juice everywhere in this paper container with no top which is great if you can eat it sitting down at a table somewhere...not great if you know you need to GTFO and drive somewhere in your car with it). I saw another couple take their lobster rolls to go and even though the buns were packaged separately, the lobster salad was piled into the same flimsy paper container with no lid. If you don't want people to eat in your house (or driveway), serve these things in actual to-go containers. If you're coming here I would honestly bring your own Tupperware because now my car smells like clam juice. But I guess that's the price you pay for quality seafood and an affordable price out in Montauk.

This place is so good! But I'm taking the dust off for the confusing ordering system where you must…read morepay and order at the counter before receiving your food and drinks and any changes/additions to the order. Besides that, it's a complete delight and is very accommodating to heir guests. This place overlooks orient point and is a beautiful sight! I love people watching here and seeing the boats roll in. Some of them are impressive. The food is great- a must here is the lobster cob salad if you're splitting. So delicious! We also tried other platters and lobster rolls. It's a great place!

Got to sit outside and experience the real draw here. Sunset dining on the water with good food,…read moredrinks and company. I think the whole ordering system is chaotic but it's a small price to pay I guess. Ended up with part of a seafood tower delivered first but subsequently rectified. Calamari is crazy good, especially with the light eel sauce. Roasted whole fish was a crowd pleaser and came with veggies to make a very decent centerpiece. Seafood tower was acceptable. Went with a double magnum of rosé that was comically large and extremely drinkable. I sat inside for lunch the last time I was here and it was middling experience. Sitting outside on the water as the sunset is something else. If you're going to dine here then that's what you should be doing.

Take this review with a grain of salt because we didn't actually get into Hideaway, as they were…read moreover capacity at 10pm. I was with my clout friend and knew it was bad when the bouncer denied his platinum clout card. I never seen it decline in my life....... They said we could order a drink and hang out on the patio, but couldn't actually get inside or order food as the kitchen closed at 9:30. The group of 10 I was with began to deliberate if we should head back to NYC or hang out on the patio for awhile and wait in quiet desperation. I didn't really care so I just lit up one of the little cigars I had and chilled in the parking lot, which was essentially an active construction zone. There were cranes, piles of lumber, shipping crates, etc. all on top of a gravel parking lot. I felt like I was on a movie set. I had a clear view of the stars too which was so humbling. Like damn I'm just here on this floating rock in the middle of the universe. None of this really matters so I'm just gonna have a good time. Moving from LA to NYC, the 2 most light polluted cities in the US, I never get to see the true night sky. It always gets me existential. We ended up dipping like 20 minutes later, but highly recommend coming here and smoking a cigar in the parking lot and pondering your existence if nothing else. Ig @jnov_ Tiktok @jnov_reviews

My friend took us to Hideaway as he used to come to the waterfront area with his family for years…read more It's a fun vibe with live music and a great outdoor covered patio, but the food is overpriced for what it is. Two tacos for $18 is outrageous, but that's Montauk for you. $9 for elote and creamy corn each, we passed on the $17 guac. Food was flavorful enough, wouldn't say it was particularly authentic. Overall good vibes/experience but would probably opt for dinner elsewhere.

Came here to have one drink outside. I did not try the food…read more It's at a beautiful location with ample outdoor seating. The restaurant itself is beautifully decorated. The outdoor space though is why you come here, especially during an evening sunset. It will get crowded. The bartender was very friendly and pleasant. My cocktail was ok. What makes this place nice is the location!

Easily some of the worst food/drinks I've ever had. Cannot say this strongly enough. Do not go here…read moreunless you want to waste a night. Yes, the food was that bad. Service was ok. Management was nice. Never again.