Without a doubt our favorite restaurant in Montauk. Always great service and food…read more Amazing place to eat with incredible sunsets!. Our fav's the calamari sushi roll, cauliflower side and the traditional lobster roll! In the summer the wait may be long but if plan it correctly, you can enjoy the musical entertainment first and then dinner! A two for 1 deal!

UPDATED Base my…read morereviews off what you pay: *Place was jammed at 5:00 on a Friday. Price - ~$100+ (appetizer, entree, drinks, tip) Food - 3/5 - mixed bag, some great some ok. Service - 2/5 - place was jammed, but still very slow. Ambiance - 5/5 - nice location with live music. Overall - 3/5 - stand by my original 3 star review. This place is a bit overhyped and you pretty much pay for the experience of eating there. Food was a mixed bag, some dishes really good, others are whatever. The Tuna with lentils was by far the best. Service was very slow, you cannot make a reservation so you are playing Russian roulette walking into the door. Even the place being busy, still took way too much time get things moving. You pay for the location, nice spot on the water, live music, modern inside, that is where you pay. All things considered, probably would not return. Best Dish - Tuna with lentils Would Return - Not likely

Love Gin Beach! Gorgeous view and really good food. We went with a party of 11 and sat "inside" by…read morethe bar. Service was also excellent!

Gin Beach Cafe in Montauk is a really nice spot by the water with a great view of the docks. I had…read morethe Lobster Roll BLT, a watermelon martini, and fresh oysters. Everything tasted fresh, especially the oysters, and the martini was perfect for a Summer day. The service was okay but the food was better. It is a little overpriced, but the food and the setting make it worth visiting.

Lovely place with beautiful cozy decor, great service and amazing food. I had the broiled flounder…read morew brown rice and Cole slaw and yes it's pricey at $40 but was a generous portion. Simply cooked, not fancy but the fish was like butter. Amazing!

So glad we decided to try this place for dinner tonight. We wanted to be near a great area to view…read morethe sunset and The Dock was close by. ( sunset was just around the corner on Mermaid Beach). Our server was very friendly and had great advice on food choices. I had the chicken quesadillas- delicious. My husband had New England scallop chowder ( delicious) and fried coconut shrimp ( tender & tasty). And the peanut butter pie is yummy. Quirky, fun decor too!

The property and restaurant are decorated beautifully - that and being on the water/the view is the…read morestar of the show. Can eat dinner then walk down on the grass or to the water and have another drink (bar on the grass and near the water). The food was very good! No complaints at all, but the menu is a little limited. I'm sure they'd substitute things for you, but very picky eaters might have trouble here. Walk ins only, show up early for no wait. Expensive but expected.

The ambiance and beach bar were breathtaking , literally feels like you're in Europe. The food was…read moredelicious, that I will give. we got the peppers with halloumi , tartare, lobster pasta and swordfish Kebob. The drinks were EH. The Muddah Freqqin wait of 2 hours and 45 minutes to be seated, is absolutely, positively not worth it, leave. It was a one and done for me dawg. ** upset me the most ** waited almost three hours to be seated inside by the bar , could've ate quicker at the bar hours ago

UPDATED Base my…read morereviews off what you pay: *Place was 75% full at 6PM on a Friday. Price - N/A Food - 4/5 - food was good with family style portions. Service - 4/5 - very personable and friendly. Ambiance - 4/5 - nice spot on the pond. Overall - 4/5 - as always, Harvest makes it case for the best spot in Montauk. Food is always great, a little pricey but delicious and family style. Did not dine-in, did takeout but service was still top tier. Shout out to Caroline the bar tender, she was sweet, went above and beyond and made great drinks. Place is located at a beautiful spot, does have a classy vibe. As always, does not disappoint. Best Dish - Hard to say Would Return - Definitely

This WAS our annual goto spot for more than 10 consecutive years. Time to find a new one. This…read moreplace turned into a time limit factory with inattentive service. The burger did not live up to its large price tag as it tasted pre frozen. Also, a beverage was accidentally spilled with most of it in the table. The server cleaned it up and disappeared for 30 minutes without a new drink or ask if we wanted a new one? No just an assumption that this guest that stayed up til midnight on the dot 7 days prior to make the reservation will stay thirsty for the entirety of the meal. Don't get me wrong everything else was delicious as usual but it felt like they were doing us a favor for being there.

While in Montauk last weekend, I stopped by Topside for lunch, and it ended up being one of my…read morefavorite meals of the trip. Both the food and the overall experience were outstanding. Everything tasted incredibly fresh. I started with the fluke sushi, which I'd never tried before, and it was delicious. (I wish I could accurately describe sushi/fish in better detail, but I can't so just trust me on this one!) For my main course, I ordered the hot lobster roll, and as an avid lobster roll-lover, it did not disappoint. The lobster was served in generous, chunky pieces with just the right amount of butter. It came with fries that were perfectly crispy, though I do wish they had been seasoned a bit more. The restaurant overlooks the inlet, making it the perfect spot to relax and watch the boats come and go. The staff was welcoming, and the service was excellent from start to finish. They also played great music -- that particular day they were playing country music (a southerner's dream!). Last but not least, another bonus is the location. There are several charming little shops just steps away, making it easy to browse before or after your meal. My biggest fear is it's going to be super crowded the next time I'm back in Montauk and I won't get a table. With that being said, I absolutely cannot wait to eat another amazing lobster roll with that lovely view! 5 stars for the lobster roll, 5 stars for the view, 5 stars for the hospitality!

My husband and I have been coming here for 40+ years and have always been happy with the food. Not…read moreso this time! I ordered the mermaid roll , which was supposed to be tempura shrimp and Crab. The shrimp wasn't even a full size shrimp, but rather shrimp cut in half lengthwise. More disappointing than that was the fact that it did not have real crabmeat, but rather the fake crab :(. My husband had the mahi mahi taco and it hardly gad any fish, but mostly vegetables Come on Gossmans- you can do better than this!

Exactly what you are looking for. No need to shop anywhere else for your standard, classic lobster…read moreroll. Great services and ambiance.

It is literally a shack behind her house. Best part is not how delish or affordable it is but that…read moreshe is open year round!! We came early spring and most restaurants are still closed but she's open. Lobster rolls 2 for $38!! Cash only. And she is just absolutely lovely!! We will definitely be back

This place is a true gem! Feels like you're in the Mediterranean! Come for the gorgeous sunsets…read morestay for the fantastic food, vibe and super awesome staff. Everyone is so friendly and I honestly look forward to seeing them every season. My favourites to order are the lobster Cobb at lunch , the addictive insane fries, superb calamari and if I am there for dinner the whole fish is amazing! You can't go wrong with the raw bar either. Duryeas is the top of my list!

We had a great experience here for breakfast on our recent girls weekend to celebrate a friends…read morebirthday. The manager Kara at the Duryeas Market was so helpful and accommodating and we were so happy with the service and friendly nature of the entire staff. The store is beautifully curated and has amazing inventory for the summer! Definitely check it out if you are in Montauk this season!

Take this review with a grain of salt because we didn't actually get into Hideaway, as they were…read moreover capacity at 10pm. I was with my clout friend and knew it was bad when the bouncer denied his platinum clout card. I never seen it decline in my life....... They said we could order a drink and hang out on the patio, but couldn't actually get inside or order food as the kitchen closed at 9:30. The group of 10 I was with began to deliberate if we should head back to NYC or hang out on the patio for awhile and wait in quiet desperation. I didn't really care so I just lit up one of the little cigars I had and chilled in the parking lot, which was essentially an active construction zone. There were cranes, piles of lumber, shipping crates, etc. all on top of a gravel parking lot. I felt like I was on a movie set. I had a clear view of the stars too which was so humbling. Like damn I'm just here on this floating rock in the middle of the universe. None of this really matters so I'm just gonna have a good time. Moving from LA to NYC, the 2 most light polluted cities in the US, I never get to see the true night sky. It always gets me existential. We ended up dipping like 20 minutes later, but highly recommend coming here and smoking a cigar in the parking lot and pondering your existence if nothing else. Ig @jnov_ Tiktok @jnov_reviews

My friend took us to Hideaway as he used to come to the waterfront area with his family for years…read more It's a fun vibe with live music and a great outdoor covered patio, but the food is overpriced for what it is. Two tacos for $18 is outrageous, but that's Montauk for you. $9 for elote and creamy corn each, we passed on the $17 guac. Food was flavorful enough, wouldn't say it was particularly authentic. Overall good vibes/experience but would probably opt for dinner elsewhere.

Recently attended a wedding here that was truly magical. The cocktail hour was delicious. All of…read morethe past apps were amazing. Cocktails and dinner were amazing. You can't beat the view at sunset. An amazing venue overall!!

Beautiful location (views), quaint atmosphere inside, excellent food, very mediocre service (Leo…read morehad no sense of urgency, we had to ask for our server at the beginning after waiting for awhile (& it was NOT busy!), then later remind him I had another glass of wine waiting at the bar). The asst server (female) was amazing and much more attentive. We shared several dishes: salmon tartare, Shishito peppers, buttermilk chicken, and Parm fries.... all excellent