The broasted chicken was absolutely fabulous. Place was packed and waitress was absolutely incredible. The cheese on the pizza was plentiful and the crust was crispy and delicious. Must go again. We were starving. I forgot to take pictures . read more

Finally got a seat at the bar. This place is legendary and it lives up to the legend. I got the broasted potatoes. Big wedges of tater cooked to perfection and served with sour cream, butter, and Heinz ketchup. Next time it's going to be chicken or pizza although I'm going to want potatoes with them. read more

The Elmton - Broasted potatoes. - Pizza Near Me - Struthers, Ohio

I've been in the area for weeks and all the locals have raved about elmton. I picked up a pie for lunch carry out and it was awesome. They use four cheese blend that includes Swiss and they put green peppers on every pizza. I was a bit apprehensive but elmton delivers flavor in a big way. I loved it!! read more

The Elmton - Large pizza - half pepperoni and half mushroom and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Struthers, Ohio

Pizza special on Tuesday/'16 and Thursday'12 on one of the best pizzas in the area. Saturday open roast beef sandwich special with mashed potatoes and brown gravy is delicious, along with the broasted chili dogs at a great price. Eat in or take home, well worth the trip. read more

I am not gonna say I don't recommend them, but the pizza wasnt as good as everyone hyped it to be. It was good pizza don't get me wrong but I'll leave it there. I have had commercial pizza taste just as good if not better for half the price. Maybe I caught them on a off day? The people working were super nice and respectful. read more

This was a while ago but one of the chefs went to our church and never took a shower. Him and his whole family had such stale B.O. that it was hard to be around them. They lived in a home with a shower, just didn't use it. Their pizza might be the best tasting ever, but I wouldn't eat anything that came close to him. No way that guy is washing his hands or caring if the food is clean. Folks there had to know he never showered. read more

The Elmton - Pizza Near Me - Struthers, Ohio

Food is great and so is service their pizza is amazing and chicken is delicious need to get some of their ice cold beer also

Hometown favorite. My family has been coming here forever. It is our heart restaurant. Maryann, the owner has always treated us like family and we love her. We love the pizza, chicken and broasted potatoes. An ice cold glass of classic cherry soda is essential! I recommend a side of the garlic sauce to dip your chicken and potatoes in. This place is so special, I pray it continues on forever read more

This place has been here forever and there's a reason: IT'S PHENOMENAL. great beer, the best pizza I have ever had (and I've had a lot ). Boasted chicken, pierogis, etc. Service is always good. No problem with our order, waitress was friendly. This restaurant/bar is a nostalgic nod to the steel mill era that the area was known for. Get that Pizza, ! read more

This place is a local restaurant icon that is great at everything they do..! Elli is our favorite waitress..! From chicken to pizza, they are a great place for a quick lunch or a relaxing dinner. But, Please don't tell anybody!!! This is our hideaway, where it's always peaceful and fun.. read more

This is the best pizza and broasted chicken anywhere!! The owners, Jack and Marianne are wonderful and Elena and the rest of the staff are too! 100% recommend! read more

Came here to try the pizza since it always pops up in talks of favorite pizza joints in Youngstown. Like the old school historical vibe but service was awful, I think we got the rudest waitress there. The other younger waitresses seemed nicer. Pizza wasn't bad but definitely not in the ranks with the bests like Wedgewood, Uptown and Cornersburg so will not be back. read more

amazing roasted chicken n veg basket.. pizza is great as cheese pizza with no toppings!!

A local legendary restaurant that never disappoints! Best chicken around. Awesome vintage atmosphere. One of the Yo's treasures...and one of the unique pizzas in the area. read more

I have literally been coming here my whole life! My parents took me here after I was born, I'm 36 now. Hands down the best pizza and chicken in the city or more. That's saying alot because we have good pizza here. If anyone doesn't like this pizza, they are nuts!! read more

Food is outstanding. Service great and timely with family atmosphere. A tradition in our family for almost 70 years!!!

What could be better then a old style bar and pizza shop. Great pizza and a chicken dinner. Sat at the bar had the a great hostess which made you feel that you were a regular. Thank you Maggie. read more

I was looking for someplace new to eat at. This place came up on my newsfeed so I thought I'd give it a try when I pulled up to it, I was really reconsidering. From the outside, it was dated as a bar from the 60s. But then I thought, I'm here, I'll go in and check it out and look at the menu. I'm so glad I did ! We ordered several different things. All the food was delicious and the service was excellent ! I can't wait to go back ! read more

Absolutely the best white pizza ever, the red with sausage great too But I love the white with banana peppers

The best "Real Pizza " in the Youngstown area. Definitely a great place to go for truly authentic pizza. read more

The Elmton - The Best "Real Pizza" in the Youngstown area ! - Pizza Near Me - Struthers, Ohio

Recently we spent the night in Youngstown on our way to Michigan. A good friend grew up in the area and when I asked him where we should eat, he told me that The Elmton in Struthers had "the best pizza ever." Of course your favorite pizza is always the one you grew up eating, so I knew he was biased. But we gave it a try. I called ahead and was waiting to pick up, wishing we had decided to eat in. The vibe is great and classic feeling, and the staff and fellow patrons were sweet. We got the large plain pizza and tried eating it out in the parking lot, but found it was too hot and too sloppy. Someone came out of the restaurant and told us that we had to wait a little bit to eat an Elmton pie. While I usually object to that sort of waiting game prerequisite I have to say it was worth the wait. The pizza was pretty delicious and we couldn't stop eating it. Oddly the plain comes with spicy green peppers mixed in the cheese, but I can see why. The heat gives a really nice kick off the thickness of the brick cheese. I'm really glad we stopped through here. Maybe one day we will again. read more

This is a neighborhood dive bar, but there's a reason it's been around for as long as it has. The service is always attentive, the food is on point, and the pizza specifically is worth waiting for. Definitely worth the stop if you're in the area. read more

The waitstaff is great! The pizza is terrible! People say the owner is hard to get along with. Bellaria has much,much better pizza. read more

The broasted chicken & pizza are still delicious ‼ they have a convenient takeout area located on the side of the restaurant. read more

The Elmton - Pizza Near Me - Struthers, Ohio

Been coming here since high school in the late 60's Lived out of the area and recently returned. Went in yesterday with a group of 3. Our waitress got the order wrong, then forgot to bring an item, not once but twice. The pizza was not the same, very dry and we ordered extra cheese. We got jammed in the bar area with a large group and it was just a mess. The bill was 65.00 not counting tip for a pizza, hamburger and a hoagie {at least it was good). The Cole slaw was great but the pizza was terrible. Oh well I won't be back just sorry to see what has happened to this great place of my youth. As they say you can never go home again ! read more

Stopped there this afternoon got a 16inch pizza to go for dinner.Pizza was excellent, cooked perfect, couldn't been any better, always have gotten great pizza here for years. read more

I have been a lifetime Struthers resident and a lifelong Elmton customer and fan. Until today. I called to get a couple of chicken dinners. The staff called back with some confusion (again, it's only two dinners). No problem, I clarified what we ordered. They called back again about two minutes later because they were confused again. (Really?!? - it seriously was only two dinners). I canceled the order due to a lack of intelligence on their part. I asked to talk to the owner, and when he got on, he hung up on me mid sentence as I was explaining the problem. It would have been nice if he had made an attempt to diffuse the situation. I have heard from multiple people how much of an a$$hat Jack can be. I got to experience it firsthand today. I will make sure I let everyone I know how he values his customers. read more

Great food! Loved the thick-crust pizza & the sweet sauce. The broasted potato wedges were wonderful, too!

Food is always good. Been going there for over 50 years. Went there a year ago and service was terrible forget what the excuses were. Went to try it again after about a year a couple weeks ago. Once again terrible service excuse this time "mix up in the kitchen ". Will try again next year just because of memories. Don't know if I have any friends left that will be willing to join us though. read more

I love the pizza and broasted potatoes. My husband loves the chicken too. It's a true gem and glad it's still around.

I have been a lifelong customer of elmton pizza ! i recently purchased a 12-inch pizza, a grilled chicken salad, & broasted chicken dinner ! the order was on-time & correct, the food was incredible, & carry -out staff friendly & personable! i would rate elmton pizza as one of the best pizza & food restaurants in the area! read more

I can't believe I never reviewed this place. Ok, Monday they open at 4pm. 12" pizza is $7.00 on Monday. And chili dogs are 1.20 on Monday. If you aren't used to it, pizza is topped with a Swiss cheese blend, which is really good. But strong tasting if you weren't expecting it. The pizza is great. And I got my first chili dog from this place today. From now on, I am getting it whenever I stop in. It is on a toasted bun. Hot dog is hot. And chili sauce is homemade. That spicy Greek tasting chili, no beans in it. As good as any dog w/chili I have gotten anywhere. They have other stuff. Broasted chicken, which is actually deep fried in a pressure fryer. Everything is great. I have been eating here for years and years, but last couple years the food and wait staff have really great. Little update. I got the Broasted chicken yesterday, the seasoning is great! And crispy on the outside juicy inside. I got the mashed and chicken gravy. Extra side of gravy. And a glass of gravy. Kidding. But I do love gravy. Back again today for the Broasted fish. You can get (just like the chicken) fish only, or fish dinner. Add two sides. And the Broasted fries are the BEST! The seasoning blend is outstanding. And they are large pieces, bigger than steak fries. And crispy on the outside, tender on the inside. I really like this place. If you get a bad meal (which I never have) it is a rare error. There is a reason that in this city of Struthers ohio, with a LOT of really good places to eat, The Elmton is consistently busy. read more

The Elmton - 12" pizza with crumbled sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Struthers, Ohio

This hurts the soul to have a bad experience at a great old school pizza and chicken place. The pizza order was all wrong asked for half plain got whole thing covered , the potatoes were undercooked nowhere near crisp, the broasted chicken was so salty we could not eat it .The order of bbq wings were slimy and undercooked. They failed to give us the salad , bread, and coleslaw that I paid extra for. It was so bad I don't know if I'll ever try again read more

Their pizza is unique and has no happy medium; you'll either love it or you'll hate it. Broasted potatoes are great, especially if you ask for them well done. Also recommend the chili dogs. It's not something they're known for but probably the best in the area as well as one of the best kept secrets. read more

Our favorite family restaurant in Mahoning County 4 generations have gathered here for all our birthday celebrations read more

Best Pizza in Youngstown! Always a must for when family or friends come in town! Never disappointed!

Raw, uncooked pizza dough, no pepperoni, sweet peppers when I ordered banana peppers, just thrown in a blob on pizza; definitely not a good pizza. read more

The dining room experience is just as good as the pizza. I had a chicken parm that was great. The sauce is sweet and the chicken was done just right. The ambiance is classic 60's/70's decor meets family gatherings. Conversations around you will range from talk of the old country to the old-timers filling in the youngsters on what it was like 50 years ago in the area. Our waitress was excellent. read more

To the native Wildcats of Strudders this is an absolute must-see! My mother is a Struthers native and insisted we make a stop here as I was home (Youngstown) for a couple days over the weekend. The Elmton was packed to the gill at 7:30 on a Friday night. This place is tight quarters all around with basically no waiting area. The hostess informed us that it would take 20-25 minutes to get seated, but it only took ten. I was thankful for this as I felt like I was standing right next to a booth of people enjoying their dinner --- because I was! Once seated, there was a nice view to several TV's and I was able to watch the beloved Bearcats off the Orange in the Big East Tourney (hells yes)! I tried both the pizza and the Cavatelli as I was informed that pasta, pizza, and chicken were the to-do's at the Elmton. Cavatellis were exactly what I'd expect from the Youngstown area: pasta and sauce deliciousness. The pizza was much better than most anything in Cincinnati, but I thought the sauce could have been sweeter. Drinks were dirt cheap as is everything in the Yo. Domestic draft beers were a buck seventy-five, I need not say anymore. Next stop: Ripps! read more

Great tasting pizza... The crust is excellent, the sauce is very good, and the combination of cheeses they use is fantastic. You know you've got great pizza when you can order it plain and it still tastes awesome. You can make any pizza great by adding a lot of toppings, but when you can order a pizza with none of that and still find it very tasty and satisfying, you've got great pizza. Their pizza comes with lots of cheese and you get green peppers free without ordering that as a topping. read more

The Elmton - This is the plain pizza... It comes with lots of cheese and green peppers without having ordered a topping. - Pizza Near Me - Struthers, Ohio