Cornersburg Pizza

First, I looked at the reviews online. They seem good. When I got to the place, the exterior is…read morenothing to write home about. The exterior wood trim is rotted and the sign out front is faded and the place looks like they haven't put any money into it in many years. I was gonna turn around and leave but decided to give it a try. Had wedding soup and a small spaghetti the wedding soup was average no meatballs just small teeny chunks of meat. And the spaghetti was just again average meatball was small spaghetti portion very small all in all I'd say pass on this place. It looks like they're going out of business to me.

Love it. I have been going there for years. Their sauce is…read moredelicious. I like the meatballs too.

Best homemade meatballs with that sauce

See all

Dining room

YOSTERIA

4.5(41 reviews)

4.6 mi

Our server was amazing! She was friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed…read morethroughout our meal. She had a great attitude, checked on us at the right times, and made our dining experience enjoyable. The service was fast and professional. Thank you Jessica for the excellent service--we'll definitely be back!

Second time here as we loved it so much last year! Abby was a great server, very professional and…read moreattentive. And personable... We had the Gnudi with brown butter and sage again as it was so amazing last time. Had a refreshing fennel and orange salad and a delicious eggplant Parmesan too. Dessert was the millefoglio which was very light and yummy... All in all, fabulous meal!!!! And ambiance is casual .great experience.

Dessert millefoglio

See all

Casa Di Canzonetta

3.9(27 reviews)

4.1 mi

One of the most amazing dinners I've had the pleasure of having in Youngstown (which is hard to…read moresay!). The drinks were phenomenal, the appetizers were amazing (especially the star of the show, the sweet ricotta board). The salad was incredible and tasted so fresh. And the pasta was to die for. I had the carbonara, which was so creamy and delicious, with an incredible flavor profile. The spicy rigatoni alla vodka was one of the most amazing sauces I'd ever taste. The slightest spice from the calabrian chilis really made the dish. I loved how perfectly coursed each plate was, I never felt overwhelmed with the amount of food in front of me. Our server was absolutely fantastic, I can't remember his name but he was taller with dark hair and glasses. The hostesses were also so friendly, and they were able to sit us an hour before our reserved time so we didn't have to wait at the bar! This place had the BEST people watching! It wasn't too loud, or too bright, and all of the old photos on the walls were so cool to look at (as well as the vespa above the kitchen)! I would highly, highly recommend this place. One of the best experiences I've had in Youngstown.

Service at the bar was great. The double pork chop from the specials menu was delicious. Wife…read moreenjoyed the pollo parmigiana.

Seating

Crab stuffed mushrooms. Omg... can't go wrong

See all

Shrimp & clams, 2nd time getting this!

Cassese's MVR

4.1(132 reviews)

4.4 mi

Love the MVR ! Great place to go to meet friends for a bite to eat. The food is always tasty, and…read morethe service is great from a friendly staff.

We had dinner this evening at Cassese's Italian restaurant. I'm never in Youngstown but I was there…read morefor Grandsons baseball game. I ordered the spaghetti. & meatballs cause I thought since we r at an Italian Restaurant it would really be great! But I didn't like it at all!! My Prego or classico that I used was better. They even charged for extra sauce. I did ask for a little more. My husband liked his Gigi dinner though! The male server we had was nice. Will not be back !!

Inside

Blackened salmon

See all

Outside

Station Square Ristorante

3.8(261 reviews)

7.0 mi

I stopped one night in the Youngstown area and the hotel manager suggested Station Square for…read moredinner. He described it as an Italian restaurant, but that doesn't do it justice. The menu is big, with all the Italian pasta, veal and chicken favorites you could want, but also with an extensive seafood menu, steaks, chops and salads. Station Square is apparently a Youngstown institution as it was celebrating 40 years! The restaurant is incongruously attached to a Super 8 motel, but don't let that throw you. This place is big, but it is well run. The staff is friendly. I sat down and my server appeared promptly and my food came out quickly, even on a busy Friday night. I had the salad of tomatoes and peppers, which is exactly what it was with a little oil and vinegar. Nothing fancy, but good. I had the chicken Parmesan with angel hair pasta. Very good. I finished with a blueberry cheesecake, which was excellent. I also enjoyed a professionally made old fashioned. It all worked for me!

Very good Italian cuisine. We enjoyed the lasagna, greens and peppers appetizer, bread, and salad…read more The sauce was just right, not sweet or tart! You will enjoy the old world ambience.

Bar area

Tomahawk steak + Seafood Risotto

See all

Michelobe ahhhh

Nicolinni's Chophouse

4.5(62 reviews)

3.1 mi

Best restaurant around. I had the Lasagne Bolognese my wife had the Chicken Marsala, both were…read moreoutstanding. Holly our server was fantastic. I highly recommend this place.

Managed to get a high top in the bar area where service was great. The chicken and greens are…read moreamazing here. So flavorful with just the right amount of heat. Meatballs and ricotta are also very good. The pumpkin Tiramisu is as delightful. Light and full of flavor. We will come back just for this.

Frenched Pork Chop

See all

Exterior

Prima Cucina Italiana

4.2(15 reviews)

3.0 mi

We always stop here on our road trip from Connecticut to Wisconsin...it never disappoints! The food…read moreis outstanding, which we did not expect the first time we stopped in. After all, we were in Youngstown Ohio, not Chicago or New York. What a gem! First of all, the wine. Here is where we learned about Pecorino wine...and we had thought it was just cheese. Delicious! As for appetizers, we always order the artichoke as it is stellar...and now we add the octopus to our list of must haves. Polpo was tender, perfectly cooked. Served with a garnish of potatoes and capers and a divine sauce, beautifully played. After all this, we split the eggplant Parmesan...light, full of flavor, perfect in every way. This restaurant is why we drive through Youngstown. We are excited to try their new spot in Austintown next time we come through. We understand they are moving there but also keeping this location as a more casual concept. We wish them luck. Amanda was a great server!!!!

Loved spring at the bar and having conversation with bartender and manager. We meet some regulars…read morewith standing reservations every Friday night... definitely gives you the first impression of a great restaurant.

Octopus

Lemon sorbet dessert. Refreshing.

See all

8/23

Salvatore's Italian Grille

4.0(235 reviews)

3.1 mi

Excellent!! Everything was absolutely delicious. Can't wait to return! I miss Ytown Italian living…read morein Colombus. Great ambiance and cozy inside. Nice and quick service. The cavatelli and meatballs, Italian greens, stuffed peppers and wedding soup were all perfect.

Came back On a Friday afternoon and got the fish special…read more It was fried Cod with French fries. It came with a basket of warm rolls and pizza bread. Very good! I enjoy the intimate atmosphere of the place. Lots of secluded tables available for seating.

Inside

Cavatelli and meatballs. Sooo delicious

See all

Outside view

Nicolinni's Restaurante

3.9(58 reviews)

1.7 mi

Food is always good, service is good and the ambience is ok! The pesto and oil with bread is great…read morebut don't eat too much. Recommend Chicken Franchise, Chicken & Greens and Chicken Parmesan.

my dad came in from out of town. going out to lunch with family. Asked if we could move 2 tables…read moretogether so we could site with every one. waitress said no owner's rules So we asked the owner he said if we don't like it leave. then he said if we wanna move tables open are own restaurant. Of course I told him to F off but wow just wow. this guy is an a$$. Wouldn't give him water in the dessert Will never spend one cent at this place. Hope he reads this. Hey owner F you.

The greens are worth the trip.

Italian Roasted Potatoes

See all

Italian Greens

Aqua Pazzo

4.1(223 reviews)

5.8 mi

•$$$

Service & food 10 ...had the sea-bass outstanding delicious cooked to…read morePerfection ... manager even came out to greet us...

Service at the bar was good and comfortable. Gina did a great job. The baked eggplant was tasty but…read morea bit soggy for our liking. The hot honey pizza on the thin crust was amazing.

See all

Outside seating

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

D D.

0

4

1

17 years ago

Fantastic. Quality is always excellent. You can't go wrong with this pizza shop. We don't go anywhere else!

Delilah F.

0

1

0

5 months ago

This place really hurt my feelings. They yelled at me and criticized my pp size it hurt my feelings

Mark W.

0

1

0

16 years ago

This is about the best Pizza in Youngstown I've tried so far, always good every time!

Mary Beth S.

0

1

0

9 years ago

Great pizza, just start delivering!!

Cornersburg Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Youngstown, Ohio Restaurants near Cornersburg Pizza

BEST of Youngstown, Ohio Coffee near Cornersburg Pizza

BEST of Youngstown, Ohio Things to Do near Cornersburg Pizza

BEST of Youngstown, Ohio Desserts near Cornersburg Pizza

BEST of Youngstown, Ohio Breakfast near Cornersburg Pizza

BEST of Youngstown, Ohio Dinner near Cornersburg Pizza

BEST of Youngstown, Ohio Burgers near Cornersburg Pizza

BEST of Youngstown, Ohio Shopping near Cornersburg Pizza

BEST of Youngstown, Ohio Movie Theatre near Cornersburg Pizza

People found Cornersburg Pizza by searching for…

Best of Youngstown

Things to do in Youngstown

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Cornersburg Pizza also viewed

Uptown Pizza

4.4

(50 reviews)

austintown, First time ordering here. The sauce is garbage and worse of all the pizza was burnt…read morewhen I got home. Waste of my time and gas to bring it back.....Should have just went to wedgewood pizza across the street, instead of trying something new.... The empty parking lot should have beed the first clue.....

We are new to Boardman but Uptown Pizza has quickly grown to the top of my list as our new…read morefavorite pizza place. We ordered two pizza's both large, one with cheese and one with cheese & pepperoni. The Pizza's were amazing. The people are very friendly & it seems to be a very popular place with the locals. I have to give a shoutout to their staff for their handling & caring of a older lady who came into Uptown Pizza lost & upset. She could have been anyone's Grandma. It was dark out & I felt so bad for her & wanted to help her but I don't know the area well enough to give her any type of direction. The staff at Uptown Pizza sprung into action to help her. Since it was so late & dark they opted to call the Boardman Police to escort her to her destination. That is what you do to foster a good community by being the reason the community is good. Kudos to you Uptown Pizza!!! God bless you guys!!! The Harper's will be ordering our Pizza's from you from now on. Happy Easter!!!

Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza - Austintown

4.0

(127 reviews)

Been loving the pizza for years a must have if you ever in the area please try them .read more

Stopped in on a Sunday evening to try a few different pies. As I'm getting older, perhaps my tastes…read moreand preferences are changing, so I'll share my experience and anyone reading this can take it for what it is. I did not order ahead, I placed my order in store to get the hottest possible pizza, and I ended up ordering 3 small pies to try some different slices. I ordered two small cheese pizzas, one with mozzarella cheese and the other with Romano cheese, and the third pizza was a deluxe. To begin, I really enjoyed the Romano cheese pizza. The Romano cheese has a sharp flavor, but it doesn't over power the sauce in anyway. The sauce was sweet, tangy, and really shined with the Romano. Most important, it wasn't greasy. The mozzarella cheese pizza was good, but the thicker cheese reduced the sauce flavor a bit, still good, and with all of the pies, the crust is a very light and airy crust which is pleasant to eat. Lastly, for the deluxe, I could have done without that. It was greasy, heavy, but my biggest issue, you can tell some of the toppings came right from a can. Overall, 3.5/5 for me at this pizzeria. I'd come back again, however, I'd stick with the cheese Romano pizza.

Risi Pizzeria & Italian Cuisine

4.6

(30 reviews)

when i go the food is normally good. I normally order pizza crispy but keep in mind that u don't…read morewant it too crispy and they burnt the bottom of the pizza and it tasted questionable. The service and atmosphere were very good also.

There is no other review but all stars. This place is like my second home. Where comfort food meets…read moregreat expectations hand in hand. Staff are all super friendly and the food top of thr chain in Desserts see photos and everything else they offer. This place is absolute must try. Awaiting friends pizza in oven .... Another day tried different things everything was Wonderful..

The Elmton

3.9

(124 reviews)

The broasted chicken was absolutely fabulous. Place was packed and waitress was absolutely…read moreincredible. The cheese on the pizza was plentiful and the crust was crispy and delicious. Must go again. We were starving. I forgot to take pictures .

Finally got a seat at the bar. This place is legendary and it lives up to the legend. I got the…read morebroasted potatoes. Big wedges of tater cooked to perfection and served with sour cream, butter, and Heinz ketchup. Next time it's going to be chicken or pizza although I'm going to want potatoes with them.

Ianazone's Homemade Pizza

3.8

(4 reviews)

Love the Veggie pizza and Italian subs!! Can't go wrong with any of their pizzas…read more.. Highly highly recommended.. Staff is very friendly as well!!

Best pizza in town!!! I love the red/regular pizza with cheese and pepperoni. The sauce is out of…read moresight! Also the veggie pizza is spectacular as well as the potato!!! Yum!

Bella Napoli

4.6

(68 reviews)

Bella Napoli in Youngstown is a cozy spot for classic Italian comfort food. The menu offers…read moreflavorful pizzas, hearty pasta dishes, and generous portions that feel homemade. The service is friendly, and the relaxed atmosphere makes it a good choice for a casual dinner, family meal, or takeout. The food is satisfying, well-seasoned, and reasonably priced. If you're craving traditional Italian flavors in the Youngstown area, Bella Napoli is worth checking out.

Bella Napoli's cheese pizza is simple yet satisfying -- crisp crust, rich sauce, and perfectly…read moregooey cheese. Classic flavor done right, definitely worth a taste.

Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza

4.2

(64 reviews)

I have always had an excellent experience at Wedgewood…read more Wedgewood Pizza is always amazing. Every time I have had pizza here, it was fresh, hot, and consistent with my other visits. My favorite pizza here is the White Pizza. I typically add spinach. Wedgewood offers tons of toppings to choose from, which is really nice because there is something for everyone here. In addition, the restaurant is clean, and the staff members are friendly. If you're looking for great pizza in the Youngstown area, I would absolutely recommend Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza!

Ordered takeout for a family get together. Pizza was tasty and reasonably priced. I will see that…read morereconsider purchasing the shrimp pizza. The shrimp was microscopic. lol. The flavor was good though. Everyone ate the pizza without complaint. Service staff took my order over the phone with no problems. It was prepared and ready within less than 30 minutes.

Ianazone's Pizza

3.2

(16 reviews)

This is not good pizza. The bread tastes like cardboard from how hard it was, the cheese was very…read morerubbery, and the sauce tasted like watered down canned tomato sauce. At this point I'd rather eat the Chuck E. Cheese pizza than this again. Crazy when the kids agree with me as well. First and last time I'll order from here.

The pizza is delicious, the staff was friendly, its carry out so no place to sit and eat, but the…read moreinside is about what you'd expect, a cute little pizza spot. The price isn't too bad considering the product they put out.

Franky's Pizza & Delicatessen

4.4

(22 reviews)