Excellent burger and fries. Good mashed potatoes. Coleslaw unique, vinegar based, very fresh. Service okay.

The service was quick and friendly! The food was excellent and was served very quickly! Great place to eat!

Very good place. We were just driving through and found this quant place. Lots of local very friendly. Great food we got the Wolf burger and it was great topped it off with the best fries in town. I highly recommend this place. If I ever pass through again I would definitely come back. read more

Nice place. Great service! Friendly atmosphere. The buffalo sandwich was Amazing! I would definitely recommend this place for drinks and dinner too. read more

We visited this great place June 12 and had a great meal. They have a varied menu with excellent bread pudding. My wife had a Wylye (local fish) po-boy with home-made chips. Raved about the secret recipe tartar sauce. Everything they served was great and reasonably priced. Go there if your in the Black Hills and hungry. read more

Great little casual, family-friendly. I had the bacon burger jalapeño, which was just hot enough to release the flavor of the beef. My companion had fish and chips which rivaled fish and chips ANYWHERE! read more

Surprisingly varied menu for a bar/restaurant. Partner had pasta I had fish and chips (risky in S Dakota I thought). Pasta portion was generous but not outrageous. Fresh veggies and penne were good and satisfying. Two large beer battered pieces of cod along with seasoned fries were hot and crisp. Tartar sauce was a nice blend. Not too heavy on the mayo. Service friendly and attentive. 10% off our bill when we showed our hotel key read more

Order the Green Beans appetizer. Yum!!! Very spicy and enough for 2-4 people. The buffalo sandwich was yummy and the shepherd's pie delicious. We had leftovers for lunch the next day. Service was spectacular. read more

The Custer Wolf did not disappoint. On our first night in Custer, we arrived late and almost everything was closed. We had two hungry kids on our hands and the team here welcomed us in with open arms (even though it was past closing time). Everyone was very friendly and the food was delicious. It was hot, fresh and obviously made with a lot of care. No one rushed us. In fact, several of the people working made small talk. We felt very welcomed. Three days later we decided to eat at the Custer Wolf again on our way out of town. Still delicious and still friendly. The restaurant is clean, the food is made to order and everyone seems to enjoy their work. If I could give them 10 stars, I would. read more

Random stop after dinner was rained out food and the beer was good.. but the service was awesome only two guys working the bar and they were great. Also the bread pudding was a big hit for dessert too read more

The food was delicious and came out very quickly. This place was very clean. My wife likes the little quirky touches the restaurant has. Great place for people who like micro brews. Also they are kid friendly. read more

Great food, great service and a large selection of above average micro brews. Very friendly.

On vacation and this restaurant was close to where we were staying, so happy to have tried it. I had a delicious grilled Buffalo filet and my friend had Walleye. The servers were attentive and polite and the ambiance was very Black Hills. I will definitely return! read more

Finding vegan food on the road is always a challenge. The vegan dish was by far one of the best I've ever had. It had a sweet potato purée with almond milk sauce over rice, mushrooms, kale, and fresh tomato on top. Wow!!!! The rest of my party had the burger, the Reuben and the fish and chips. Everyone loved their dish. I highly recommend trying this place a try. read more

We stopped in for our first visit on a busy St Patrick's day and were very pleased with our experience. Our server Sam was attentive and pleasant. Both of our dinners were excellent in taste and quality. Good beer selection. read more

Excellent food. Reasonable prices. Really happy with my choice. Hope it moves up to the top of the list for Custer restaurants.

The ranchers pie and meatless lasagne were tasty and filling. The squash in the lasagne added flavor and enhanced the texture The food had that home cooked taste and feel. The onion rings were hand breaded and flavorful. The service was exceptional. Our server was attentive and very welcoming. The wait for our food was short. Friday night the place was filled with local people enjoying an evening meal together. That enhanced our dining experience. We would highly recommend this restaurant! read more

Great place with friendly helpful staff. I had the cold plate appetizer as a meal. Delicious & more than enough food for one. The buffalo salami was so good and was paired with cheddar. The Brie spread with thin apple slices and a generous portion of spiced toasted walnuts was to die for. My hubbie had their version of a Reuben which he loved. Would definitely return. read more

We took a gamble on this place, and let me just say. It was beyond amazing! I had the buffalo brisket sandwich, and it was so good. All of the flavors worked together into a masterpiece! Everyone's food was awesome - even the kids Mac and cheese was gourmet level! And don't skip the bread pudding. Trust me. We had a great experience! read more

Visited here during the recent 2018 Buffalo Roundup. So glad we did. I cannot say enough good about this restaurant. It is not at all fancy, very rustic and a little worn, in fact, but everyone who worked there was just so nice and friendly my wife and I felt like we belonged. My wife had the shredded buffalo and I had the reuben. Both were excellent!!! The buffalo was tasty and not tough or stringy. Very flavorful. The reuben was a little different because it was served on a marble rye roll! How unique. Also quite good. Our server, Megan, was just delightful. She made us feel so welcome. Other staffers brought our food and filled our tea and water glasses and were equally delightful. One touch I thoroughly enjoyed was how the check was presented - in a child's book!! How clever is that!! Apparently, this space was once a book store. The restaurant must have inherited the old books and now use them to bring your check to your table. Each book is signed throughout by previous visitors. This was, indeed, unique. We wanted to return for another meal but just didn't make it during our short visit. However, if we are ever in Custer again and this restaurant is still there, we're making a bee line for it, for sure. I'm sure you'll enjoy just as much as we did. read more

Service was very slow and were served by three different waitresses. Daughter ordered coffee and was told that they would have to make a fresh pot .Daughter said that would be fine . Our waitress then said it would take quite a while to make . She was right . It took over 30 minutes for the coffee and 45 minutes for food . Food was ok but will not be back. Waitstaff changed so often that no one actually knew who ordered what. Asked for straws and never got . Different girl brought appetizer and she was asked for straws which was brought about five minutes later. Reviews were misleading. read more

Stopped after reading previous reviews. What a great little restaurant. I had the chili dog and it was not your routine chili dog. Delicious! It was a cool day so my wife had a bowl of the chili and said it was excellent. And she doesn't eat much chili. Would definitely come here again. read more

Great dinner. I even tried the Pineapple Cider (ACE) terrific! Food just as good as Sage Creek Grill a few doors away, but I thought overall a better value. read more

Great food, great service and reasonable prices. Highly recommended. The onion rings are as big as your face and the ranchers pie is to die for. read more

This place has great food. Several of us had the pulled pork sandwich with cranberry coleslaw. Another had the chicken fingers and another had the jalapeño burger. Everything was delicious. We are glad we ate here. read more

The reviews were positive and now I know why. This place rocks. I would give it more stars if possible. My wife had the chicken salad and I had the bison pulled sandwich both were outstanding and the rings were fantastic as well. Service was good and the price was not bad considering they have a captive audience. read more

Great food and service! Spicy green beans were delicious! We also had the fish and chips which were equally tasty! Highly recommend this place- you won't be disappointed! read more

Great option in Custer! Friendly and quick service. Food was great. I had the chicken salad with cilantro lime dressing. Yum! Fresh greens and veggies and just the right size and the chicken was moist and cooked perfectly. Price very reasonable. A unique personal touch to share customer feedback with classic books. read more

Wow!! What a great atmosphere and great food! The Pub Club and the "Father-in-Lager" were excellent together. Our server, Crag Master, was exceptional...so personable and willing to go above and beyond. read more

Really good find in Custer. Great food and service even during the height of bike week. We are a family of 4 and everyone enjoyed it. The Rancher's Pie and Shredded Buffalo Sandwich were two highlights. read more

If you have made it this far, go eat and or drink here. Mix of local tappers with some others, but more in the bottle or can. Menu is limited but everything was good. Things are laid back, there are board games on the shelf near the bathroom if you plan to stick around drinking. If you just drove hundreds of miles and are ready to chill out after a stop at Rushmore or Crazy Horse, stop here to reset for the coming day(s). Affordable grub, cold beer, friendly folks all around. read more