An olive oil heaven where you can sample and try all different kinds of oils and find a variation of vinegars and gourmet products like salts, pasta and more! This family owned oil and vinegar tasting room is one of a kind. They aim to provide the best of the best and it's a one stop shop for fused and infused olive oils. These guys provide from the press to the bottle, the way it should be. What you purchase is what you're getting - 100% extra virgin olive oil, 18 year aged balsamic vinegars and gourmet salt to complement and elevate your dishes. read more

Everything is awesome at the blue olive!! Gorgeous store, really helpful and enthusiastic staff. The only thing that exceeds all that, are the products they sell. The experience is entirely addictive! Every olive oil and vinegar is delicious. There are additional products like salts and other accompaniments. Need a gift? The blue olive has it, want shower, party or wedding favors? The blue olive has it! Just go and check it out! You'll be glad you did! I promise! read more

A lot of bugs and roaches inside I don't recommend this to nobody. Please be careful.

No plans of buying anything but this store made it easy to spend money. Who doesn't need a delicious balsamic vinaigrette and olive oil? The tasting part is the best part. Most of what I picked to taste is delicious. Too bad they ran out of truffle olive oil otherwise that could have been in my basket too. I'm sure there are quite a lot of stores in manhattan like this one but being in a small quaint town and finding a store like this is quite lovely. I got the white vinaigrette Ginger Honey and Lemongrass Mint, balsamic vinaigrette blackberry ginger and extra virgin olive oil Koroneiki. Spouts and Himalayan sea salt. If you purchase 10 times you get 25% off on your next purchase. I haven't checked online but I'm sure you can order online as well. I can't wait to try all my purchase. read more

See all

Fantastic place, one of my favorites! The store features an amazing selection of oils and vinegars, infused with flavors that will satisfy any palate. The white balsamic vinegars are absolutely amazing! Friendly and helpful staff- also a wonderful place to grab a classy gift for anyone for any occasion. Special place. read more

This is my go-to place for holiday gifts, as well as for the year long. Sometimes bringing a bottle of wine isn't the best hostess gift- but olive oil and vinegars are a win-win!! Not only are their products delicious and fun, but the customer service is outstanding. If you like to support small businesses, this one will not disappoint. Both the Pawling and Cold Spring locations are wonderful! Try some of their recipes as well! read more

I was just strolling down the avenue when I saw this store for the first time. I decided to go in because it looked so inviting. There are so many different varieties of oils and vinegars. They carry both dark and white balsamic vinegar varieties and many different flavors of oils from different countries. The store set up is very organized, neat and looks very appealing too. I sampled a few different oils and tried some interesting combinations with small samples of bread. All of these oils are excellent quality and taste so fresh. They also carry different salts, spices and rubs. Love the free suggested recipes that are available. Very creative! I purposely cooked a homemade pasta this evening and served it with a side of Italian bread and the Rosemary infused olive oil. Delish! read more

Stopping in because I needed a quick gift, I assumed it was just like other oil/vinegar shops I'd been to. I assumed wrong. The quality of the vinegar and oil here was by FAR the best I've sampled. Not only that, but the owner and his son were extremely helpful in answering how to best use the products in recipes. You can tell how passionate they are about sourcing the oil and bringing out its quality. They helped steer me towards the right choice for my mother's present, and I liked the samples so much I ended up bringing some home for my kitchen as well. I ended up with Lavender and Apple Balsamic and Tuscan Herb olive oil, which have complemented salads and spring veggie dishes so nicely. What set this shop apart besides the quality was the warm hospitality from John and his son. My fiance and I had never been to Cold Spring before, and they engaged us in a great conversation full of advice. We could have stayed there chatting for hours! Really a special experience. I can't recommend this store highly enough, whether you are new to the foodie thing or you think you've seen it all! This review is for the new location in Cold Spring. read more

This place is amazing. They have excellent products. I was in this weekend and John the owner and his son Jack couldn't have been friendlier. Everyone should be going here!! read more

Finally was able to stop by for a visit. The shop is beautiful and impeccable. It was so nice to taste the flavors and mix the vinegars with the oils to get various flavor combinations. The staff was so helpful. We went home with several bottles of vinegar and oil and a few new recipes to try. We will be back. read more

The Blue Olive - Specialty Food Near Me - Pawling, New York

This place is great! There are so many different kind of oil I had no idea even exsisted. They also have many balsamic Vinager types. I didn't even know white balsamic exsisted. The staff is very knowledgeable and can even tell you what oils and balsamic goes good with what types of foods. They also have flavored salts (I bought the onion salt). The oil prices are very reasonable considering you are getting top notch olive oil. Not the second class oil you buy in stores. read more

Love here the balsamic vinegar so much. My favorite is Pomegranate and fig taste. It's very tasty and you can use for salad, yogurt and any cooking. It's very much with Asian cooking recipe also. When I stop by in this neighborhood, I always stop by in this store. read more

What a wonderful little store. Full of interesting and unique olive oils and balsamic vinegars, and you can try all of them, which is the best part because they are all pretty incredible! We had a very hard time deciding what to actually buy. Definitely worth a visit. read more

Great selection of olive oils and vinegars, the staff is very helpful and friendly. Worth a visit!

Broad selection of wonderful oils and vinegars. The best part is that you are able to sample them. Since I the aroma impacts the flavor for me, it's a big help for me to be able to sample! Great, friendly, patient owners who take the time to talk. Lovely. read more

The Blue Olive is where I go for all special occasions to buy for family, friends and coworkers. The oils and vinegars are superb, and with so much to choose from you can spend hours trying them. I love the hot oils! Best of all are the little treasures I find everytime I visit--new soaps, natural body scrubs, pastas, exotic salts--so much fun to discover and beautifully made. The store is exactly right--elegant, warm, and inviting--with the feel of a good wine bar. The expertise of the owners and staff--and the welcoming, friendly atmosphere as you enter, make such a difference in our too-fast world. The Blue Olive is a Pawling treasure. Come see! Colleen S. read more

Just when you thought you were picky about everything there was to be picky about, along comes olive oil. Blue Olive is a beautiful shop stocked with helpful, friendly, knowledgable staff, a lovely selection of regional and infused oils and vinegars, and a wonderful collection of recipe cards you can bring home to experiment with. What a wonderful find, I really appreciated how well the staff helps guide you on a tour of the shop's offerings, what I thought was my favorite (robust/Greek) actually came in behind what I chose as my favorite - a lighter oil from Portugal. Really fabulous selection, especially if you like infused oils and vinegars. I didn't think I did, but Blue Olive won me over big time. Very reasonably priced, and if you're not ready to commit to a full size bottle, you can put together an assortment of mini bottles of oils and vinegars to bring home and try out. Can't wait to go back! read more

Love the selection. Each thing we buy adds a nice surprise to the foods we pair them with!

We love this store! Everyone is very knowledgeable about their products and always so helpful. You often get a recipe with your purchase. I won't buy olive oil and balsamic vinegar anywhere else. It's a great place to grab a hostess gift on your way to a friend's house for dinner too. What a perfect addition to the town! read more

This store is a gem nestled in the quaint village of Pawling, NY's main street. Inside there is a variety of oils, vinegars, spices and here's the best secret: truffle salt. You will want to use it on your popcorn, roasted potatoes, roasted veggies...you name it, add a touch and it will wake up whatever veggie you're cooking. The ladies and gents working there are so kind and helpful, always ready to help and recommend. We needed this store and I'm so happy I can support them. read more

We actually wandered into the new location in Millerton, NY and were offered a delicious bruschetta with trumpet mushrooms, arugula and Gorgonzola with a glass of wine. Yum! We then tried a few vinegars and were directed by a very knowledgable and patient individual to Balsamic Fig, the best I have ever tasted. My husband jokingly asked about something that would improve his legendary Vodka and Tonics. We were astonished to be shown a White Balsamic Lemongrass and Mint vinegar. He adds a couple of drops and a drink that we thought was perfect rose to a new level. We will be back. Can't wait to lay my hands on the truffle salt mentioned in another review. Great place, great people, great products. read more

This place is amazing. Their products are top quality and shopping around the store is an experience. One can find special vinegar, olive oils, soaps, salts, and gluten free snacks. There is something for EVERYONE. One stop shop for gifts. read more