Friday night and the restaurant is busy, however Brenda provided exceptional friendly service. Running to other table but still attentive to us. The restaurant has bar seating, table and booth seating and a separate room, for parties etc. Food always fantastic. They custom make each meal, so changes and substitution can be made. Italian Home Fries special. Long hots, onions their amazing potatoes in a garlic oil sauce substituted meatballs. Oh so good. Chicken Rosa, over pasta with Artichokes, spinach etc. In a white sauce. Great dish. Seafood Carmen over Hats with Extra Sauce by request. Clams, fish, and shrimp in a delicious vodka sauce. Oh may. Excellent dish. Portions are large, of course leftovers. Soup New England was very good. Make reservations. read more

See all

My mom has been raving about this place for years and we finally ended up trying it. It was phenomenal in every way! The calamari is perfectly crispy, the linguini with clam sauce was the tastiest version i've ever had!, and the crispy chicken sandwich was one of my husbands favorite sandwiches. We have gone here twice in the last month. The service has been great, the waitresses have been friendly. Hands down one of our new favorite restaurants. read more

Excellent food! Outstanding service (thank you Carolynn)! Great atmosphere! We had walleye with basmati rice/asparagus and mixed seafood special. The fig and honey martini was best cocktail I have had in a while. read more

All I can say is wow. The special seafood Alfredo was out of this world and the riggies were fantastic as well. The greens were very good as well. Place never disappoints. Ever. Staff and ambience are comfortable and this will be our go to date night. Great job black stallion staff, you knocked it out of the park. read more

A first trip to a restaurant I have been wanting to try (one of the friends who went with me called it my "white whale") for some time, and well worth the 30 minute drive! Let's start with our server Brenda, who also handled my call to make a reservation earlier in the day. Claiming to have worked at the restaurant for 35 years-- I wondered if she started as an elementary student, she got our table started with water, drinks, and bread before going through the specials and sharing comments about her favorites. She was attentive throughout dinner, and I'd be happy to have her work my table when I return. Our party of three opted for the three Friday night specials, a thick cut pork chop, wahoo, and haddock Francaise. All of us started with salads. New England clam chowder was also an option. The greens were fresh and I liked the Italian house dressing. My choice was the haddock Francaise, sweet and tender and definitely enhanced by the lemon and capers in the sauce. It was topped with spinach and Brenda recommended the angel hair as a side. I loved the entire dish, although the ample main portion meant I barely touched my side of pasta, which was enough to have been an entree itself. My friends said their dinners were good. The wahoo was served over rice, and none was left to be boxed. The pork chop looked great, but the star of that order was the side of mashed potatoes which all three of us tasted and agreed were excellent and definitely homemade. There were a variety of desserts, and we were told that all were made in-house by three different bakers. Given the ample portions, dessert was not a priority but the choices sounded tasty. It's not a fancy place, and the vibe was casual and quite friendly. Plenty of regulars. The restaurant was busy and reservations seem a must given the line of people waiting for tables. Our reservation was for 7pm, and we waited less than five minutes to be seated after arriving to a full restaurant. I have already said I would return, and there were many dishes on the menu that looked interesting. Pricing was reasonable, with the three entrees, a bottle of wine ($32), and one cocktail costing around $45 per person. Recommended! read more

Riggies are pretty good. The chicken was very tender. I like the taste of the water here as well. Please see the attached photo. read more

The Black Stallion Restaurant - New American Near Me - Vernon, New York

The food here is very good prices are reasonable and very friendly and efficient. Staff ...had a nice time here

Only the best food and incredible service for many many years. Always consistently amazing The place is quaint and i love the atmosphere

I've been to this restaurant twice. Each time , I have had a wonderful meal. The first time, I had a stuffed pork chop. The second time pasta with steak and peppers. Both were delicious. Since portions are big, you can expect to take some home. read more

Food was delicious. Pork chops are fantastic. French onion soup was awesome. Service was wonderful and great atmosphere. We went last night read more

2 years in a row during Antiques at MB we tried to dine here. NOT OPEN ON SUNDAY. 3 others had pulled in. . Change your hours please! Very disappointed. read more

Absolutely a fantastic experience. Food was delicious. So many options to choose from. The service was excellent. Our waitress was friendly and efficient. Definitely worth the trip. Wholeheartedly recommend!! read more

I had spotted this place when doing the Oneida Cheese Trail. After checking on Yelp I found the reviews and the menu to be excellent. Celebrating a birthday with a steak lover and since we were at Turning Stone Casino I called on a Saturday about 6:15 to see if we could get a table for two. Although it sounded busy when they answered the phone we were told 7:15. We arrived 10 minutes early were greeted right away and seated within minutes. Very busy place plenty of tables including a large round one raised slightly in one corner seats about 10, and a room off the main with more tables. Bar is good sized and seats about 14 with a separate entrance in the front. Horse pictures and oil paintings bring a cozy area themed feel since it is located a short distance past the turn to Vernon Downs Racetrack and Casino. Birthday guy ordered steak, salad, and originally mashed potatoes then decided to go with the angel hair pasta side. Not a fan of veal, I ordered the Rocco with a chicken cutlet which our sweet waitress accommodated immediately. I chose the New England Clam Chowder and we ordered the calamari with marinara as an appetizer. Yes we knew there would be leftovers. Steak was cooked perfectly as ordered although he said some seasoning would have improved the flavor even salt and pepper. Mashed were thick and creamy very good and the salad was perfect size. Small loaf of warm garlicky buttered bread was superb. Calamari was cooked tender with a panko breading sprinkled with some parm cheese and parsley and piled high with a cup of homemade marinara. The New England Clam has carrots and potatoes and plenty of clam and flavor. My Rocco was large with plenty of greens on top, a large eggplant medallion breaded and tender, same for the chicken cutlet and topped with melted mozzarella cheese. Food for days and so very good. Our waitress checked on us frequently, bringing drink refills before the first were empty. Service was 5 star! We will be back to try other menu items. No room for dessert but they had at least 7 homemade ones. read more

See all

Food was great! Brenda, our waitress, was incredible! Her recommendations were spot on. Will go back as soon as we are back in town.

This restaurant is for someone that is looking for huge portion sizes. The high prices to me reflect food that would be of a higher quality, but in reality I believe it is just pricey due to very large portions. We barely made a dent in our dishes. The food was okay. Nothing particularly stood out. I went for a birthday dinner with family for my mom. We were disappointed with slow service. Also, my husband ordered a beer and again, for a restaurant that is a bit pricy, we thought it was strange that they served him a bottle of beer with no glass to pour it in. Ambiance is fine. I don't think this place was for me overall. read more

See all

Delightful! Atmosphere is warm and welcoming. Service top notch. Food is amazing! The calamari alone is incredible! Thankfully we live close by! read more

This is one of my brothers favorite restaurants. He kept insisting that I go so after a day of shopping with my Mom we decided to check it out. First off, it's actually very cute and comfortable inside! They decorate very nicely so you get a cozy homey feel. (Full bar which is always a plus). They are able to accommodate large parties as well. The waitress we had (I forgot her name I suck) was FREAKIN OUTSTANDING. Very personable and bomb personality. She explained the menu to a T. ****(Everything is made to order so it might take longer than expected. This ain't no fast food people so don't be going in there and getting mad because your food is taking awhile to cook)....***** you have been warned. So mom and I obviously ordered the scallops for an App. Holy wowza they were possibly some of the best scallops I've ever eaten. Hands down. I would go back just for this dish. Mom ordered the eggplant parm with greens and veal I believe? She wasn't entirely impressed. We are also used to my gram making delicious eggplant though so you go in with an expectation to start. Mom commented that the eggplant was too thick. I ordered the chicken franchise because my brother said it was the best he's ever had. I would give it a 3.5/5 stars, not bad but it isn't the best I've ever had. I was between giving 3 and 4 stars for this restaurant but I decided on a very generous 4 stars, mainly because our waitress was amazing and the scallops were tooooo diiieeee for. I would definitely come back but I'll have to try other things on the menu. Cheers mates! read more

See all

Good food good service A pleasant atmosphere very busy make a reservation But if you don't have one they will accommodate you best they can. read more

Black Stallion was great! Good food, attentive service and nice atmosphere. Onion soup was good with crunchy onions on top and my wife had a pork chop special that was nice and juicy and flavorful. It was super busy but it didn't affect the quality of the food or the service. Would definitely recommend! read more

The Black Stallion Restaurant - Asian style pork chop with shiitake mushrooms and a zesty glaze. - New American Near Me - Vernon, New York

See all

Brenda is amazing. Best chicken franchise I have had in 20 years. Great place watch the driveway though I didn't see it ! Can't say enough about the food and service. read more

We've been here twice and had excellent service and great food each time. We plan to put this on our regular rotation of places to visit.

Definitely a busy place. It is packed full of locals (we were visiting from NJ, but welcomed just the same ) Portions are huge, so almost everyone leaves with leftovers. Service was warm and friendly, waitress was amusing and kept up with the busy pace. We were never rushed. Too loud for an intimate date, but a fun night out if with family and friends. read more

The Black Stallion never disappoints! If you are in the mood for a steak cooked to perfection, then this is the place to visit. I always order the filet. It comes with three filets, and the filets are topped with crab meat. I always have leftovers because they give you quite a bit of steak! My second favorite dish is the homemade hats pasta. The pasta is amazing, and their Alfredo sauce is creamy and rich. I would call ahead for a reservation, especially during the weekend. read more

See all

Very good food even better waitress... First of came up to the area for weekend getaway and was recommended to this place by one of the locals enjoy it did not disappoint bread at the table. I had one of the specials which was the chicken. Luna which had great flavor had a reasonable price. and my wife ordered the haddock which she liked very much as well... as good as the food was the waitress Brenda was absolutely spectacular. Very kind very tentative help with my special diet requirements and we ended the meal even giving her a hug. That's how amazing to us. Let's not forget the marbles!!! if we ever come back to the area will be stopping at this place again... God bless you, Brenda!!! read more

This place is unbelievable. The food was delicious. The waitress was amazing. The atmosphere was so nice and relaxing. My first time there and I can't wait to go back. I had fish and it was delicious. read more

A few years back this was my favorite place to eat. Now the food is mediocre and is not worth the price.

Great meal but it was so loud it was difficult to carry-on conversations otherwise it was nice

Great selection, great tasting food, and great staff! Friendly patrons too, we struck up an informative conversation about the area with the folks at the next table. read more

Amazing food, cooked perfectly. The staff is very nice and attentive. The prices are higher. But, the food is worth the price. I recommend the spinach, asparagus Alfredo pasta. It's delicious and the sauce is homemade read more

The Black Stallion adds a touch of class to Vernon, with attractive plating and excellent dishes. We had a special appetizer, which was a shrimp and pork belly poutine. Hands down the best poutine I've ever had, though you'll have to like onion to enjoy it. The Chicken Milano is divine- have it on a bed of angelhair pasta, where all that lovely alfredo sauce will soak in. Their alfredo is excellent, by the way, as is their hollandaise, which is also a part of this seafood-stuffed chicken dish. The breading adds some really nice texture. The Veal Francaise was the one element we weren't so big on, only because the only thing you can taste is lemon. If you really really really want lemon, this is the dish for you, though. Everything was cooked well, but the lemon overpowered all other flavors. The green salads we got on the side were excellent- fresh, with high-quality greens. No iceburg lettuce. I tried both of the dessert martinis, and they were excellent! I prefer the one with chambord, but would happily order either again. For dessert, we shared a key lime creme brulee, and the tartness of the lime was perfectly balanced with the sweet, creamy custard. The torched sugar crust was perfect. Our waitperson was attentive, friendly, and professional. Also, don't worry about dressing up here- we did, but nobody else in the restaurant did, and that was fine, too. The food is fancy and tasty, but you don't have to get all gussied up if you don't want to! We will for sure be back. read more

In town to see family. Wanted to grab a bite after traveling all day. Asked the motel owner and she said we'd be happy with The Black Stallion. She was right! It's an unassuming place, reminding me of many old bar-and-grill places I knew growing up. I was just hoping to get a decent burger. The menu suggests folks who have a little more than average appreciation for food. Mostly, it included steaks, Italian, and seafood. Oh, and they did have sandwiches too but after looking over the menu, I wasn't going that route. Dinners came with soup or salad to start. I had the days special soup, a Cajun influenced New England clam chowder. I'd drink it by the quart. Lots of clam bits and nicely cooked veggies. Creamy, but happily a little thinner than usual NECC. SO went with the salad, which was simple but nice with cherry tomatoes, onion and olives. Their house bread was super too. Fresh out of the oven with a garlic drizzle. I went with eggplant parmigiana, a long time favorite. I got it on angel hair pasta, but could have chosen several other types of pasta, which was unexpected. It's hard to describe what makes parm good for me but a few high points were the browned and crisp edges of the eggplant slices, the sauce balancing spices, and, of course, healthy (?) amounts of mozzarella melted all over the top. SO had chicken parm on angel hair. She proclaimed it to be the best she ever had. In both cases, either offering could have easily fed both of us. So I did not finish my parm, uncharacteristically, because there was a lot there. Plus I'd seen several desserts floating to other tables and needed to investigate further. Among the choices including several crème brûlée options, cheesecake, lava cake and others, I got coconut custard pie and next door went with vanilla lemon curd cake. My pie was awesome. It had a great filling with a ton of coconut in it and whipped cream on the side. The master stroke was the sprinkle of nutmeg which gave it a little more character. The cake was good but for my taste it needed more lemon curd and a little lighter buttercream. Not sure when we'll have occasion to get to Verona again but when we do, we will definitely ride The Stallion again! read more

My wife and I were in the area, yelped this place, and decided to give it a try based on reviews. I'm sure glad we went! From the hot fresh bread to the main entrees, it was all fresh, hot, and tasty. The lobster Mac and cheese appetizer was delicious. Just the right amount of cheese, and plenty of lobster. Prime rib was juicy and tender. Came out just as ordered medium rare. Even the side of veggies that came with it was tasty. The shrimp and Veal Mornay was superb. Served mixed with linguini in a very tasty Asiago Alfredo sauce. Service was excellent even though the place was packed. ( At 6pm ! ) I would recommend this place to everyone. read more

See all

We had a rehearsal dinner there last night it was awesome!! Decently priced great food and exceptional service!! The owner Sal was very accommodating and our severs were attentive and wonderful!! I know ones name to be Jenny sorry didn't catch the other but she was fantastic as well!. This place is a must! read more

Great little place! Looks like a local institution. Very good menu, diverse selections. I had Tehran steak sandwich, bread was awesome, steak was tender. Loved it. Excellent service. I totally recommend coming here for lunch or diner. read more

See all

Never fails. Go there every chance I get. Super staff, delicious food. I have my favs but today went off the grid,,,,....steak sandwich....omg...awesome Very friendly and comfortable. read more

Had a late meal here on Saturday evening at 8:00. We were a party of 6. Our service and food was outstanding!

Went here with my family the other night for a nice dinner and We were not disappointed. Our waitress was extremely friendly made our experience terrific. I had a chicken and scallop filled bread bowl that was full of flavor as was the rest of my families meal. Will definitely be coming back read more

The Black Stallion Restaurant - Daily special - chicken and scallop filled bread bowl - New American Near Me - Vernon, New York

Seriously? I can't believe I'm the first one writing a review for this place. It's such a popular local Italian restaurant, and my friends living Upstate are regulars to it! Decor is country style, and staff are friendly. Food was awesome, especially the calamari, the soup and the daily special Hawaiian white tuna! The calamari was very crunchy, yet the squid didn't get coated by a thick layer of batter. Just thinly coated, and it was perfect! The Hawaiian white tuna, I think, was pan seared, and accompanied by some sweet-and-sour squash chunks and balsamic vinegar. The texture of the fish was so smooth, and the dressing was very appetizing. The veal dish, the steaks, and the chicken & scallop combo dish were pretty good too. read more

See all

Ohhhhhhh Myyyyy Gooooood!!!!!! I'm on the job with a group of ladies taking classes nearby who were given vouchers to eat. Me being the driver of said trip I received one as well. We come in and were greeted very warmly by a wonderful waitress named Kelly. She was very nice and very attentive. I ordered a chicken parm that was made exactly how I ordered it. I gotta say my plate went back clean. The garlic bread given to us in the beginning was good, Kelly brought me some more. All the ladies enjoyed their food. Portions were humongous. I gotta say if you are ever in the area check this place out. You will leave stuffed or you will need to be carried out.... That's how I feel right now. Unfortunately I gotta drive back to the hotel. read more

See all

A bit disappointing visit today as we were happy last time. We arrived at 4 and it was not that busy. However, my clam chowder was left forgotten and I had to ask about it and no apology... I decided to go without it. Ordered the seafood mix on linguine, Frutti de marre. Seafood cooked well, texture wise is very good. However, again I feel this week is just not a week for me. The seasoning is off and I have to add salt... I promise I am not with extreme taste on salt. Anyway, 3 stars this time. Won't say I'm not going back but I will have to think twice now. #italianrestaurant #fruttidemarre #thisisutica #vernonrestaurants read more

The Black Stallion Restaurant - New American Near Me - Vernon, New York

See all