Milt and his gang are great. I had a problem with my truck and I thought it may be a transmission…read moreproblem. I took it to Sharp Transmissions because of the reviews and its a transmission shop. I work on my truck as much as I possibly can but dealing with repairing a transmission is out of my wheel house. I dropped off the truck in the morning and I got a call about 2 hours later. Milt told itme he had inspected the car test drove and it was not the tranny it was the power steering pump that had a small not noticeable leak but the fluid resevoir was almost dry and that was the noise I was hearing coming from the truck. He added power sterring fluid and solved the problem but let me know it something that will need attention down the road. I thanked him I picked up my truck later that evening. Drove the truck home ran like a charm. I will certainly take it to him again when I need work done. I appreciated his honesty he could have told me I needed a new transmission instead I got a honest and fair evaluation and fix. Thanks Milt glad to see that there are still good folk out there. Scott S

Oh, the joy of owning an old Jeep (now a quarter century old). Sprung a big transmission fluid…read moreleak when down in New Jersey on New Years Day. The AAA tow truck operator asked me where I wanted it to be towed, and I immediately said "Sharp Transmission." The dropped it off and put the key in the after hours slot. Next day,I called Milt and said, take a look and give me my options. No rush, I said, since I have other cars I can drive. Milt and his crew found some time to not only diagnose the problem (two rubbng hoses put a hole in one), but to repair the problem. Same day! I picked the car up this morning and it is working perfectly. Like I said before, if you are not taking your car to Sharp, you should start doing so. Great service, excellent communication, attention to detail... Highly recommended.

Very poor. They were totally disorganized and didnt do what they were supposed to do. Then they…read morecharged $880 for an oil change + replacing six spark plugs. They charged 1 hour labor to change air and cabin filter (which jiffy lube changes in 3 minutes - literally). They charged a $70 waste-disposal fee so that $119 oil change apparently was $199. They charged for an hour of labor for a "200k checkup" which when pressed entailed "checking brakes and fluid levels". Another scam because the fluid levels were supposed to be part of the oil change - again, Jiffy Lube includes it. Total sham place that sells itself as a 'down home good ole earnest mechanics shop', but in the end it was exactly the sort of place to avoid. Watch out.

The only shop that I'll bring my car to, FOR YEARS. If I can't do the repairs myself, I bring it to…read moreEverett Motors, and just wait for the call that it's ready. Usually hours before expected, which saves money! Great customer service, professional and VERY knowledgeable techs, and the best rates around. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.

I'm now noticing that the reviews for this shop are for the previous owner. Don't make the mistake…read moreI made! Was shouted at over the phone when I called to ask for an update on the car I had dropped off. Was told he wouldn't work on it and to have it towed away to another shop citing that there were "too many cars in line" "people are always calling and interrupting me while I'm working". When picking up the car I tried to explain that I was only calling because of the timeline they gave me and the owner shouted at me threatened to fight me in the office?! Honestly, it seemed like he was having a nervous breakdown, so yeah, wouldn't recommend. Pretty insane way to treat customers.

Update: Bob retired around july/august 2021 so not sure of current quality of service - happy…read moreretirement Bob and thanks for all the help over the years!

Excellent service, Chris was friendly, professional and got the job done quickly. I definitely…read morerecommend J&H!

Mechanics Chris Cuff, Luie, Christopher Gibbs and Gerald are all very well rounded, trained…read moreprofessionals with immense knowledge in the auto mechanics industry with great service and customer care! They have always been a go to for my family for decades! The small shop is a high-volume output shop they do it all and they do it very well! If you need anything done to your car, give them a call. They are very fair priced and worth bringing your vehicles to whether it's for an oil change, gas fill ups, alignments, tire rotations or even new tires, new rotors/brakes, tuneups, suspension/steering work, any type of electrical issues or even for a NYS Inspection they are the shop to go! They are a very well-connected when it comes to part distribution shops in the area so they can easily access parts for your vehicle usually within 20 minutes of calling it in! They do occasionally accept walk-ins from time to time, but it's always better that you call ahead of time and make an appointment. You will always be guaranteed fast, friendly, courteous service from the crew over there! They also have some of the cheapest fuel prices for 87 octane gas, 91 Premium Octane Non-ethanol gasoline, as well as very fair priced diesel, and grill propane cylinder exchanges in the area! They also offer towing services if you get stranded or get into a crash! They only have 4 lifts but the crew usually pumps out over a dozen cars a day! So give them a call at 845-339-5435 to schedule your next appointment! Or just stop in and talk to Chris Cuff! They are always open Monday-Friday from 8am-12pm 1pm-5pm with a 24hr towing service! You can also stop in and pay your heating oil bill with Brittan Graff!

We moved up here (Milan) about 10 years ago and started to have our vehicles serviced there. As…read morementioned in other reviews don't expect to have a lengthy conversation with Joe, but considering their continual backlog due to their great following and service it is understandable. Besides their great service their pricing is also outstanding. Saved a lot of money by using them over the years. The only time I went to someone else was during Covid when RHA was temporarily shut down. The other local and well-respected shop did not correctly locate a minute cooling leak, which was only resolved when RHA re-opened and I brought it in to them.

Joe at Red Hook Auto does great work at an affordable price, and quicky. He's no-nonsense and…read moreprofessional (don't expect long chats... this works to everyone's benefit as time = money). I've been to both chains and mom-and-pop shops in the area, and have often left feeling the job wasn't done well (which later bears out), takes too long, and/or I've been overcharged for the service. This is not the case at Red Hook Auto--Joe's fantastic at his job, honest, and incredibly efficient. He also gives great referrals (body shops and such) if needed. I'm very grateful we found Joe and I highly recommend!

Both of the Robs are good honest guys! Great to work with and cheap oil changes for the area. Would…read moredefinitely recommend!

I went to A& H Automotive and had a great experience. They were professional and polite and most…read moreimportantly honest and straightforward. I will definitely use them again.

terrible. I would give zero stars if possible. my vehicle broke down across the street from this…read moreshop. This shop agreed to fix it for me. every time I called for an update he claimed he was getting to it that day. after 3 weeks of having my car and doing nothing with it I decided to bring it elsewhere. when I arrived he had it buried behind other cars and refused to move the other vehicles and said it wouldn't even happen that day. he told me "I will get to it when I get to it, I don't work on demand". after the police got involved and ordered him to move the vehicles he finally complied. I would not recommend !

Old school family mechanic garage Ralph and his team are fantastic . Reliable, knowledgeable and…read moreprofessional. He works on all my vehicles. A blessing to have in the community we love Family Automotive

M&M is a great local option with very hard-working mechanics and staff. The prices seem fair as…read morewell. I would definitely recommend making an appointment instead of just dropping in as they are extremely busy. Everyone was very helpful while I was there. Parking is limited. You just have to triple park and run into the office if you want to speak to the receptionist. Overall, very good experience and I would recommend.

Mark was incredible. I had car trouble (check engine light came on) and according to an Autozone…read morescanner diagnostics, I needed to replace the Turbo in my car (thousands of dollars fix). Mark -a total stranger to me- returned my call and explained exactly what was happening considering contextual variables that I was able to provide and brought down my anxiety and helped me decide whether to take the car on the family vacation without a Turbo rushed job. Can't thank him enough. He's got all my trust.