Taylor street pizza by the slice is always hot, delicious & slices are enormous I get 2 slices & can only get 1 1/2 slices down & I'm a big eater. Slices are always ready when I stop for lunch on a weekday. I'm in & out in 1min. read more

Really don't get it. Taylor Street in Geneva has been around for many years and it's still in business? Gave them another try after many years and it hasn't improved. Think I figured it out....the sauce. It's really lacking in any flavor and the sausage isn't helping, hoping the sausage would boost the flavor but not. Crust is chewy too. Oh well, if you like a bland pizza, this is the place. read more

Honestly been the best slices available we've found in the tri-cities! Granted, ALL WE'VE HAD IS THE PIE, ITS A SMALL PIZZA PLACE it has quality pie, and our favorite is the to-go slices. Service at the desk has always been with a smile the last 2 years we've come, and it has the small corner shop look and feel - only seating is one table outside for 4 - don't expect a waiter Like any REAL mom n' pop shop, there will be small changes, little ups and downs, not-so-good pies and some AMAZING ones - you should try a slice read more

Taylor Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

See all

I placed an order online and paid what was owed. Then after I picked up the pizza and my transaction was finalized, they hit me with another 3 dollar phantom charge. I won't be going back to that establishment ever again. I refuse to do business with companies that are are not honest and charge everything up front. read more

Complete trash. The food is a joke. Ordered an Italian beef sandwich and a bottle of water. The total was $11.29. Smallest beef on the planet. What a rip off. I will never go back to this place. Portillo's would have been so much better. read more

Taylor Street Pizza - A joke of a sandwich. Italian beef - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

Messed up my order in July. Talked with a manager and he said he'd credit my account to make up for their mistake. Called to order tonight and to no surprise the credit isn't there and they wanted me to remember the name of the manager I talked to when the error was made 3 months ago. Canceled my order and went elsewhere. Never going back read more

I decided to try this place because I had a deal from Uber Eats. The family requested deep dish and stumbled upon this restaurant. We decided to get an extra large cheese deep dish and it was great. Lots of tomatoes in the sauce which was nice. The crust was slightly burnt which was the reason for loss of a star. But plenty left for leftovers which is always a win! Due to needing to spend a certain dollar amount to use the Uber eats voucher, I also added the cheesecake. It came in a nice size container. Very flavorful, I was happy about that from a pizza place! Since I ordered through Uber eats and not the restaurant directly, I already knew to add extra time for a delivery order. I would recommend the pizza! (And the cheesecake if you have a sweet tooth!) read more

Worked here for a little while now and they are great, lovely staff who are all friendly and I'm always happy to see them. Food has always been amazing, recommend the double dough or thin crust, I haven't tried the others but I'm sure they are great! And it feels very homey in there to me from the brick walls to the amazing smell inside. read more

Food delivered hot and excellent. Highly recommend. The pizza was exactly what we ordered but exceeded our expectations. Would use them again! read more

I should have looked to my Yelpers before ordering here. Not the worst pizza I have ever had, not the best either. I decided to go for it because I got a coupon in the mail for them. Sorry to say that I would choose a full price pizza over theirs any day. read more

Ordered a pizza and an italian beef, cost about 30 bucks, and they were decent. I went becauuse the Upside App was offering a 20% discount with proof of receipt...problem is, after I'd already paid, the employee informed me that "yeah, its a common problem; our receipts don't show the last 4- digits of the card" because we bill "in house" or something like that... he seemed kind of annoyed by me. Ive never had this problem with other establishments, but he gave me and a number to call. Which couldnt fix the issue. Takeaway: the food isnt bad, they seem to be cheaper than Rosati's, but DON'T use the Upside App with this place. read more

Total joke. Ordered throught Uber Eats. Had a problem with the order. Called Taylor Street to see if I could cancel and reorder when the problem was sorted out. They told me know. The order was started, and since the issue was on the Uber end, I would have to sort it out with them. No big deal. Try to work things out with Uber, a total waste of time, and five minutes before my expected delivery for the pizza, the guy I talked to before calls me and asks if I want my order. I'm like yeah. So now a 45 min. order takes 1.5+ hours to get to my house. In the interim, Uber tells me the issue has been resolved and the correct total should show on my receipt. Pizza comes and there's no receipt, despite one clearly being stapled at some point. They told me it was Ubers fault but I noticed right away, and she emptied out her bag in front of me. I called to get the receipt, and got a bunch of run around from a kid now claiming to be the guy in charge. He told me I couldn't get a receipt which I told him was ridicoulous, and then he said he would send one out. Half hour later, they have the Uber driver show back up with a receipt for the wrong total. For average, at best, pizza, the extra order of poor customer experience I received was completely unacceptable. Spend your money somewhere! read more

I recently rediscovered this place after some time and I'm glad I did! The pizza is much better than I remember and the staff goes out of their way to be friendly and helpful. These two factors add up to making it my go to place for pizza. I recommend giving it a try or another try if it's been a while for you! read more

Shaun answred the phone with "what do you want" and acted very annoyed through the call. needs to work on his customer service voice.

So disappointed . Flavorless pizza. Where was the seasoning? Very tough crust. Way too much sauce. Ended up throwing away most of the pie.

The food is okay but I wouldn't eat there. I worked there for a few months and was harassed.

Purchased a Chicago style deep dish pizza that was not good. the dough was not cooked and the sauce was a low quality marineira sauce. Diced tomato sauce would have been better. This location better get their act together soon as there are other choices in the Tri-Cities. Too much standing around. More attention needs to be given to quality. read more

Ordered the cheesy beef pizza multiple times over the past few months for delivery and we really liked it!

Ordered their large party package for a birthday party and it was awesome. Good food and good value.

Decided to drop in due to a deal with GetUpside app. Got two slices of pizza, paid with card so I could upload the receipt. However, guy behind the counter didn't even offer to give me a receipt. So I asked him for a receipt, and he printed one. Unfortunately I didn't look at it right there...or I would have seen he gave me a cash receipt, and it wasn't even for the right amount!!! Not only was the pizza terribly doughy and chewy and lukewarm, but the service was HORRIBLE. Don't eat here. It's as bad as it looks. read more

I ordered online today a veggie wrap at 11AM to be Picked up at 12PM and when I got there @ 12:10 it was not done and the cook seen me ask for my order and then just started making it. I only have a half hour lunch so I was really pissed. Everyone else's order was ready but mine. A veggie wrap is so simple to make. I guess they forgot about my online order. I will not order from there again because they are not to dependable !! read more

I love the Great White Pizza! I add Canadian Bacon and Tomatoes. It is my very favorite!

If you want to spend a couple days with food poisoning and the chills , this is the place to go. I wish the health dept would close this place down. Worst pizza in Illinois - manager is clueless too. One star is actually too much credit !!! Do they have negative stars for reviews? read more

great pizza and great staff!! they truly care about their food and their customers :) their dough and sauce is made from scratch every day and you can truly tell the difference in quality between taylor street and other pizza places where everything comes frozen. they take the extra time and it pays off! read more

Sean and his crew deliver the best pizza and barbecue chicken wings! We love Taylor Street Pizza! read more

Taylor Street Pizza - Taylor Street Pizza in Geneva besides the pizza has the absolute best barbecue chicken wings! - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

Picked up pizza, no one is wearing masks in the place. Order was wrong. Jennifer who answered the phone had zero customer service when we called to tell them our order was incorrect. Marinara sauce was burnt. Place has gone completely downhill. Plenty of other good pizza places in Geneva. We will not be returning. read more

New ownership. Quality has gone down. This was a weekly favorite for the family until new ownership recently took over. Same great employees so leads me to believe the new owner went to cheaper ingredients. Doesn't taste the same. Its a shame but now going to Rosattis. read more

Taylor Street has become a staple pizza stop for me since moving to Geneva. After work, it's a great place to grab a quick slice and know that what you are getting his hot, tasty, and worth every penny. The staff have always been kind and courteous, and give a sense that they care about their customer's satisfaction. The only drawback is that they aren't open past 9:30 PM, which does mean after a night shift, they are usually closed. Other than that, quality pizza and quality service makes for a high quality experience that is quick and affordable. read more

Terrible service. Jennifer is so rude. They messed up on every part of my order to blame Grubhub and did nothing when I called for help. Take your money somewhere else. They seriously don't care about their customers. read more

Favorite place to get a slice. When the have cheesy beef slice go with that, is essentially a beef sandwich and slice of pizza combined. Giardaniera, or however the heck you spell it, really adds a lot to pizza. Can't go wrong with sausage either and younger ones dig cheese and pepperoni. read more

Typical pizzeria. Quick service, fair prices and average pizza. We usually get delivery and often times get steak sandwiches with our pizzas. The pizzeria has 2 tables I think, maybe 4 people can be seated. On a summer day you are better off eating outdoors on the park bench where it is cooler. Oh yea, they also serve pizza by the slice. We recommend. Cheers! read more

Our family loves Taylor Street pizza! Always comes hot and fresh! The rest of the menu is pretty good, too! Menu consists of typical pizza joint foods - pizza, pasta, salad, etc. read more

I had a horrible experience with them when using them with EXCEL gymnastics. I called the night before and they told me to wait until Sunday because they opened at 9am. I called all morning and finally got a hold of them at 11am, even drove past it and they were clearly closed. We ordered the pizzas and hung up. Then I checked my phone and realized they had called me and they forgot the time to deliver the pizzas. I called them at the time I wanted the pizza and they said soon and said they would give me a discount. In the end the pizza was 30 minutes late, I got zero discount, and the kids had to eat super hot pizza right from the oven. NEVER AGAIN read more

I have been eating at this location for several years now. They use to be a great place to get a slice from that was always a great quality. It has gone extremely south in the past few years. I had a slice at 11:20 today and it looked like the pizzas had been sitting out since yesterday. I have eaten at just about every pizza place in an hour radius and they have hit the bottom of this list. Which is sad because they are the closest to work. Hopefully they can pull it together. read more

Service was kind and the atmosphere was darling, but the food truly suffered. Even fresh, it tasted like cheap, public school cafeteria. Beside the pizza, it's not a bad place. Poor pizza at a pizzeria, though, is quite a deal-breaker. read more

Bbq chicken pineapple pizza is delicious, however we got the wrong salad in our delivery order and the delivery man complained about having to drive to St Charles from Geneva, implying that he wanted an additional tip for the distance...? If it's too far, then tell the customer that you don't deliver to that area on the phone. read more

First time customer. Out of meat for Italian Sub. Out of meat for Italian Grinder. Out of Fried Zucchini. Fried mushrooms were greasy. Turkey sub and egg plant sandwich were not worth the price. Go elsewhere. read more

I started working near Taylor street and ordered pizza for work. The pizza looked good but started eating and this pizza is extremely salty. I don't know if the cook made a mistake but asked other workers and they agreed too much salt. read more

Great old style fresh hot pieces by the slice at a very reasonable price. Try it...you will be wanting to come back again very soon!!!

My favorite pizza ever! Great customer service. Would give it a 5 but they don't always have fresh pizza slices.