Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Tara's Custom Creations

    5.0 (3 reviews)
    Closed 9:00 am - 4:00 pm

    Tara's Custom Creations Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Tara's Custom Creations

    Recommended Reviews - Tara's Custom Creations

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    I had a Reese's cup cake. It was very good and not expensive. I'll definitely go back.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Tara's Custom Creations

    The Sweet Elephant Bake Shop - Scones, brownies, bars, whoopie pie, croissants, cinnamon roll, and crumbles.

    The Sweet Elephant Bake Shop

    4.4(26 reviews)
    23.1 mi

    A small bakery with a warm homey feel. The variety of products was surprisingly large for a small…read moreshop. 28 different items in the display cases and 8 varieties of prepackaged cookies on the shelves. This is a family business that started in the home kitchen. It is run by a woman who has a love for baking. With that in mind, I expected homestyle pastries, and that's what they provided. My wife and I tried 4 pastries. 1) Walnut Toffee Bar It had moderate sweetness, a light toffee flavor, and moderate walnut flavor. The bottom layer was a slightly sweet cookie type base that was moist and slightly chewy. It was topped with walnuts and toffee. More toffee flavor was needed, but this is great for lovers of walnuts. 2) Gooey Chewie Bar This was definitely gooey from lots of caramel in a chewy fudge like bar. It wasn't overly sweet. It had some pieces of nuts in it. The crisp crust on top was slightly sweet and had great texture. It was a simple dessert that was made well. 3) Blueberry Crumble It had a flaky croissant like pastry shell filled on top with blueberry jam and cream cheese. It looked like a danish. The cream cheese was smooth and light with a natural flavor. It was not sweet. Sweetness came from the blueberry jam. It had a good sweet fruit flavor that contrasted nicely with the slightly tangy cream cheese. The pastry shell was well-made. The exterior was flaky and crisp while the interior was light, airy, and slightly chewy. This dessert doesn't look pretty, but the flavors were well-matched and satisfying. 4) Cinnamon Roll with spiced cream cheese frosting The spices in the cream cheese were cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg. The spices were subtle tasting, but there was enough to give the frosting flavor a hint of spiciness. The roll was soft, moist, and slightly tacky between the layers where the cinnamon was located. The spicy cinnamon was balanced with sweetness from the frosting and roll. Overall, the taste and texture were excellent. The service was helpful, polite, and quick. The store was very clean. They don't have restrooms, tables, or chairs for customers. They have cakes, slices of cake, cupcakes, muffins, quiches, brownies, scones, cookies, coffee, tea, and bottled water. Everything was reasonably priced. The pastries and cookies were not fancy or unique. There was no pastry chef level of presentations here. Everything looked homemade. The food here brings warm feelings of home cooking. They're a good place for comfort food.

    Always amazing treats with the most helpful friendly staff. Creative, artistic, out of this world…read moreflavor. What more can you ask for?

    Photos
    The Sweet Elephant Bake Shop
    The Sweet Elephant Bake Shop - Mocha toffee cake. Wow!

    Mocha toffee cake. Wow!

    The Sweet Elephant Bake Shop - The view from across the street.

    See all

    The view from across the street.

    Cakes By Ashton

    Cakes By Ashton

    5.0(3 reviews)
    0.3 mi

    I have been following Cakes by Ashton on FB but never made it there until today. The bakery is…read moresuper clean and cute decor. I even bought a blouse there! I have been eyeing the Banana Cream Pie with Banana Buttercream. The gentleman in front of me in line ordered what I thought was the last one and apparently Ashton noticed my shoulders slump . When it was my turn, I ordered half dozen cupcakes. She had one more Banana Cream Pie! I was estatic! Got that, Boston Cream Pie, Cookies and Cream, Red Velvet, and Dark Chocolate with Vanilla Buttercream. Ashton is very friendly and knows her cupcakes! Fortunately, I have no food allergies and neither do my children. However, if we did, I'd definitely get our cakes there. They taste out of this world! Moist and delicious flavors! It took me everything to not sit in my vehicle on the side of the road to devour the cupcakes. I drove an hour one way. Yes, I will drive for good food. I apologize for taking a huge bite of my Banana Cream Pie cupcake before realizing I forgot to take a pic .

    After getting my hair done at Salon 214 (which is practically next door) I noticed the lights were…read moreon at Ashton's. I have been wanting to try these cupcakes for a while now so perfect timing! When I went up to the door it was locked. Thankfully Ashton promptly opened it up for me. Since it was closed due to prepping for an event there were no cupcakes in the cases. I said I was hoping to try her cupcakes and she said she did have some in the refrigerator case. Just a day old. They did not taste a day old! My family and I ate them when I got home. They were very moist and delicious. Could not tell they were vegan at all! We will definitely be back. To top off the great cupcakes, Ashton is a very sweet person herself. She thought I was there to pick up an order of gorgeous looking chocolate covered strawberries and when I tried to pay for the 3 cupcakes I chose, she said they were on the house. Even after I told her I had not ordered the strawberries, she did not have me pay for the cupcakes! She has made a loyal customer with her generous act. I will be making my hair appts when she is open so I can take treats home to my family. Thank you Ashton!

    Photos
    Cakes By Ashton
    Cakes By Ashton - Banana Cream Pie with Banana Buttercream

    Banana Cream Pie with Banana Buttercream

    Cakes By Ashton

    See all

    The Sweet Tooth Bakery - looks like my kid did it.This cake wasn't worth $26 wasn't winning points with flavor.

    The Sweet Tooth Bakery

    3.1(61 reviews)
    14.1 mi
    $$

    I'm very disappointed! Im a previous customer who will not EVER return…read more Last year, they missed the ombre mark on a two-tier cake. I let that pass. Photos attached. I paid $250 for a two-tier cake UNDECORATED. I added all of the items on the cake myself. You can clearly see they missed the ombre color scheme. This year, I ordered a 3 layer cake with a colored photo provided by my granddaughter. I requested pink, purple, pink inside with strawberry filling. They missed the color of the cake inside and outside completely. Pink vs neon pink. The cake tasted awful. The icing was slopped on the cake without care. It melted 45 minutes into transport. There was not enough support inside the cake as the top layer slid off during transport. They made an entirely different cake! A $10 refund was offered. It's such a joke. I wasn't able to pick up cake due to my father passing away. So my son picked up the cake. He couldn't refuse the cake bc it was going directly to the party. He had no time to change or complain. My granddaughter was so upset she didn't get the cake SHE picked out. Look at the photos, and YOU choose if YOU want to do business with them. The first picture was the cake my granddaughter chose. The rest of the photos are the cake we received. The girl answering the phone said the owner sits home and does paperwork. She does not come in the bakery to do any baking or decorating. That in itself allows you to make your decision if you want to do business with them. If you are looking for quality and specifics, try another bakery. Joyce, the former owner, is no longer here who took pride in everything that went out the door.  I am disputing the $72 charge with my bank.

    Don't waste your money- Attended a party and this cake not only looked like a kindergartener did…read morethe work, it tasted awful!!! Shawn was Not friendly- poor customer service!!! ZeroStars!!

    Photos
    The Sweet Tooth Bakery
    The Sweet Tooth Bakery
    The Sweet Tooth Bakery

    See all

    Sweet Joys Cakes and Desserts - Party Barbie - Happy 21st Birthday Cake

    Sweet Joys Cakes and Desserts

    5.0(22 reviews)
    46.9 mi

    I saw a post last month about a Valentine's Day promotion from Sweet Joy's Cakes and Desserts that…read morecould be delivered to JMU. Being the mom of a freshman who is 3hrs away learning how to navigate special days where you can't be present is new and can be a challenge. Of course I sent a care package full of treats, but I wanted her to also have something fresh. I ordered a box that came with six cupcakes, two cookies and half a dozen chocolate covered strawberries. This was a large enough box for her to share with her friends (highly doubt this happened. My girl loves sweets lol) or to keep her satisfied all weekend lol. Ordering was easy and delivery was a breeze. They checked in with me the day before to confirm the delivery time and even snapped a really cute picture of her holding her surprise. I definitely plan on visiting them in person on my next visit to the Burg. If you're looking for a few sweet treats, I'd highly recommend Sweet Joy's.

    2 giant thumbs up for Sweet Joy's Cakes and Desserts! I ordered a bday cake for my student at JMU…read more Not only is the cake gorgeous and just as I requested (actually better), but is delicious (according to my kid, cuz I won't get any lol). Their communication with me the customer, and my Duke, the recipient, via email and text, was exceptional. Not only received a confirmation text that she received it, but got a picture of Duke and her surprise cake.

    Photos
    Sweet Joys Cakes and Desserts - Basketball cake with jersey on top

    Basketball cake with jersey on top

    Sweet Joys Cakes and Desserts - Birthday cake

    Birthday cake

    Sweet Joys Cakes and Desserts - Chocolate covered strawberries

    See all

    Chocolate covered strawberries

    Tara's Custom Creations - desserts - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...