Let me 1st start by saying that Ft Collins is a great town and has set the bar pretty high with microbreweries and bars serving up all those great drinks. Unfortunately, I can't recommend Tap and Handle as one of those. We're locals and enjoy inviting our friends out regularly to take advantage of time away from our kids. To be fair, we've gone there several times to give it a fair opportunity although I don't believe we or our friends will be going back.
The service is sub-par in comparison to other bars in the area. Recently, we showed up on a week night and there were only a couple tables inside and a few tables outside with patrons, so it wasn't very busy. Our server was friendly for the few moments that he gave us but I'm wondering if he had just started that night because he acted so frantically busy that he barely had time to take our order while standing there. I understand if he was new or was actually busy but it certainly made us feel like we were interrupting his schedule.
We chose an inside table in the front of the bar however, we were asked to move after a short while because a band was coming soon and would be setting up there. It would have been nice if the server would have told us that in the beginning instead of having to get up and move our food and drinks half way through. By then, most tables were full and it's just frustrating to make a couple trips through the bar carrying your food and drinks outside to the last available table. We could have originally chosen any table other than the only one we eventually had to move from.
There is a great selection of beers to chose from however, during a previous visit, we and our friends were turned down for 5 different beers that were "out." I'm not sure how so many taps could be dry in a bar but we all laughed pretty hard at the irony of most of us having to settle for something other than what we wanted. We still joke about it when we're out.
We each ordered a flight to start out and this is where my frustration really becomes apparent. The server was frantic so it wasn't easy getting 2 flights (8 different beers in total) ordered. My wife had them marked on our menu so it didn't take a lot of time and we didn't ask any questions. The server took our menu to make it easy and returned with 8 shot glasses, each half full of our beers (about 1 ounce each) He set them down with our printed bar ticket and said they should be in order of what is printed on the ticket. Seriously? Our flights weren't separated which created a game of tasting and guessing each other's beers. Since we tried all new beers, preparing for GABF, and the waiter took our menu, we weren't sure what we each ordered and if the beer was actually in the order of what we thought we were reading. Keep in mind, the ticket only had a few letters abbreviating the name of the beer so we weren't even sure what the name was. It wasn't like any experience we've ever had at any other place in town. Since Destihl was visiting prior to GABF, we each went with pints of their delicious Vertex IPA after the flights. They were giving pint glasses away with the purchase of their beers however, we didn't get those either. No biggee because we have tons of pint glasses but it it is fun to support beers you like and it creates conversation because we host a lot of gatherings where people ask about the beers on the glasses we provide them.
We also shared an order of Irish nachos (french fries w/ cheese and bacon bits) with our beers. The appetizer was very good but it was a pretty small portion. Not a big deal either since we ate before going out but it certainly would have been disappointing if we were hungry.
FINALLY, the nail in the coffin was the total cost of the experience. Prices are in line with anywhere else you can go out however, the experience with the staff, coupled with the very short pours on our flights, left us with nothing positive from our time there. I left a ~20% tip, which I shouldn't have, but I hate to short a server for things the management are probably responsible for. In total, our evening cost us $43 for 2 flights of beer (about 4 ounces total per flight), 2 pints of some delicious Vertex IPA, and a small order of Irish nachos. You can easily have this same experience anywhere in town for about half the cost.
If you want to enjoy an evening out, there are a lot of great places around Ft Collins. I can recommend most of them but I'd move Tap and Handle way down the list. read more