I love going to Tacos Nicole it's by far the most authentic and best tasting Mexican restaurant in Middletown. The flavors are big and bold and everything is fresh and handmade. The service is fast and reliable with the staff always being friendly and welcoming. Seems like everyone in the restaurant is just there for a family dinner. The restaurant itself has a truly authentic Mexican vibe not all the fake stuff that most Americanized Mexican restaurants have. If you what true Mexican food and flavors Tacos Nicole is definitely the place to go. read more

Tacos Nicole - Steak quesadilla with handmade corn tortilla, carnitas taco - Tacos Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

The food was greaaat! The service just as good! Also the horchata is spot on! There's this other drink we tasted it's pink and has different fruits. It was amazing as well! read more

Tacos Nicole - Pastor Huarache Soooo good!! 10 out of 10 recommend. - Tacos Near Me - Middletown, New York

Tacos Nicole - 5 Stars Amazing food and refreshing natural fruity drinks! The service was great and everything tasted fresh. Definitely a spot I'd come back to. Highly recommend! I bought a quessabirria & agua de fresa I recommend!!! I got to give credit to the Mexican cookers ! Arriva MIS MEXICANOS ! Somos la mera verdura para Tu caldooo !! read more

Tacos Nicole - Horchata de Fresa ! - Tacos Near Me - Middletown, New York

Was in town for work and was craving tacos. It was great! Fresh and authentic. The side salsas were spicy and delicious! read more

Tacos Nicole - Tacos - chicken, steak, and sweet pork - Tacos Near Me - Middletown, New York

I'm local but not that local. About 30 minutes away. Anytime that I come to this side of town, I make sure I make a stop here. The tacos are always the best. They are fresh, delicious with the fresh ingredients. Definitely authentic. read more

Let's start with the Milanesa de Pollo / Breaded Chicken Torta. My husband said it was awful. The chicken taste was off. He wasn't even sure it was chicken. Sandwich got tossed. Guacamole & Chips was average, nothing to get excited about and definitely not worth $12 for the small container. Horchata / Rice Drink it was okay, way to much cinnamon. You had to keep stirring the drink to keep the cinnamon mixed. It did get better when some rum was added. Bistec / Steak Tacos, they were awful. The was no flavor in the meat at all, salt couldn't even rescue them. I ordered from this place from the reviews on TikTok. I'm not sure about how they review but this is a honest review. Rate: 2/5 - I'm being generous with my score. read more

The tacos were delicious. The Al pastor were my favorite. I also tried the homemade hibiscus drink which was super refreshing. The staff was so welcoming and friendly, gave us a tour of their menu and a sample of the homemade drinks so we could decide what we wanted. It's a very nice, fun atmosphere and I'll definitely be back! read more

Very friendly staff as soon I came in the door and very fast service, as soon as I placed my to go order I saw them preparing it. So on to the tacos, the quesobirria tacos, the braised beef was very tender and moist from the broth, plus very well seasoned. The broth itself to dip in, was flavorful but not a salt bomb. Only thing I can say was I really could not taste the cheese since it was very buried in between the tortillas, would been better if it was under the beef filling instead. For the flank steak taco, just a really good tender steak taco, plenty of beef and overall worked well, particularly with their hot salsa which was spicy but not overwhelming so you feel your sinuses clearing. Hah. Glad I made the trip there to try it. read more

Tacos Nicole - Quesabirria and flank steak tacos - Tacos Near Me - Middletown, New York

A little local spot on the outskirts of Middletown on Dolsontown Road is a true authentic taste of Mexico. Our waiter Jose' ( I am truly sorry I forgot how to spell his name) educated us on which direction to go for authentic true flavor. I had the Pollo tacos and hubby had the Campechano Absolutely delicious. We had a tasting of the Pastor ( spicy pork) out of this world. Friendly and spot on clean. I have to give a shout out to the tables and chairs and decorations of this establishment. The beautiful and colorful tiles made me feel welcome. Thank you read more

Here for work and we visited this place and it's probably the best tacos I've had in a long time, the food came out quick fresh and hot the service was incredible , not to mention if you do karaoke you get a free shot. Definitely coming back before I leave. read more

The food is good truly the best Tacos in town. I'm so full I have to sit here and let my food digest before I leave here. Very hospitable waitresses here and I thank them for their service. Warm Mexican scenery here if I come back to Middletown, NY again I would be here again and I highly recommend this place to people that like real tacos. read more

See all

Best steak quesadillas and tacos in town!!! this staff is always nice and pleasant. Also had a steak sandwich forgot what it was called on the menu, but it was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend. read more

The food was beyond delicious. The meals were reasonably priced and came out very quickly. They were loaded with ingredients and proteins as well as an amazing flavor. When we arrived an older gentlemen greeted us and thanked us for coming, he was sweet and endearing. The service itself went to crap. The waitress brought the food as it was cooked so our meals did not come out together. There was not any ambient noise and every worker not working was on their phone so there were multiple songs, tik toks and conversations going at once. There is a young girl, aptly named Nicole who was loud, cursed and really added a bad taste to the meal. She was yelling at her friend who was sitting counter with her "why the hell don't you have instagram?!" over and over. She kept getting louder as the meal progressed. She then randomly served a table with her phone in hand, purse over her shoulder while having a conversation with someone in the phone. She was loud and really needed to be taught etiquette. She later walked out the restaurant yelling everyone's order to wherever she was going. Take out is your better option. read more

Food was great, and staff was very nice and welcoming, food was fresh and good portions too

The place is an absolute gem. My girlfriend and love coming here. The food is delicious, and the prices are great. Love the service. The staff are super friendly and welcoming, always smiling. The owner is super friendly as well, I forgot his name but he always comes to say hello and check in on you. It's a fun place to grab a bite to eat. It's very clean, great music, fun decor. Desserts are awesome. Again it's a gem of a place. We'll give them all the business we can! read more

This use to be our go to spot but there has been a serious decline from the food, the freshness, the quantity, the service and everything about it has gone downhill. As someone who use to order at least once a week to now I'm never going there again. I noticed the quality went downhill and the quantity was constantly getting smaller and smaller. The guacamole we would order went from a filled container, to something only filled 3/4 or 1/2 way. When I asked, I was told prices had increased for them. Then they started putting in less and less meat, less and less cheese. It's just been getting worse and worse!!! Then while ordering they had a female who didn't speak English take orders. Every order something was wrong, sometimes 2 or 3 things were wrong. I think that they have double the credit card usage fee, while other do what they get charged by the cards Nicole's seems to takes advantage. I believe I got charged 10% either way when I got charged for everything the lady calculated it in her head and a $55 calculation from the menu somehow turned into a $78 charge. I still went after that just paid with cash and the bill never matched the menu prices even after I calculated the tax myself. No consistency with many things. What sealed the deal was the other night my family who ate the chicken all got very sick. 2 people had chicken tacos and also a quesadilla.... All of us sick. I'm done with this place. Its awful. I started going to Bira on Dolson in the ShopRite strip mall. Taste way better and they have been consistent. Middletown and the area has so many Mexican places... why such a decline when there is so much competition? read more

Food was awesome at the little gem Great place for a quick bite or full dinner. Seating open and fully lit with full service bar. read more

I went to Tacos Nicole to order food for home for me and another to share. I decided to get those two dishes to go. The tacos were bery good topped off with alot of cilatro on each tacos (chicken, pork, and mexican sausage). All the meat on each tacos were in little pieces diced. The quesadilla was very good as well, very cheesy tasted the meat, pepper lettuce and onion. My personal preference would be me adding sour cream plus the orage hot spicy sauce or use the pungent green sauce. Wish i knew what the names were. Overall it was good definitely want to come back again in case i needed late night snacking. read more

Tacos Nicole - Chicken quesadillas and 3 Tacos Chicken, Pork and Mexican sausage. - Tacos Near Me - Middletown, New York

Great place fresh homemade corn tortillas and great food highly recommend. Authentic Mexican food read more

Tacos Nicole - Pastor spicy beef authentic - Tacos Near Me - Middletown, New York

Friendly staffs, good food, very authentic and reasonable price perfect for a quick lunch. read more

See all

Great service. Ordered food for pick up and it was ready once I got there. Ambiance was great definitely an authentic place.

Stopped by today with my family and am glad we did. I had fish tacos. My wife had shrimp and my daughter had steak. All absolutely delicious. The restaurant is nice and clean and the staff were friendly and accommodating. Will definitely go back!!! read more

I stopped this place after picking up my son from school. I had never been there before but I knew they had not been in business too long. I got a spicy sopas meal and it was excellent. There is plenty of seating and the staff was very nice and helpful. If you are in the area..check this place out if you like authentic Mexican snacks!! read more

Tacos Nicole - Spicy sopas - Tacos Near Me - Middletown, New York

The tacos are decent. I feel like the meat and caldo could have way more flavor. That's just be comparing it to some really great ones I got in Philly and can't find that beautiful taste anywhere else. But they are good. On the bright side 3 fill me up because they packed them up really good ! read more

Excellent food. I highly recommend the shrimp burrito and Jamaica to drink. This place is always busy. They even expanded their space. read more

Do not go there. My wife placed an order. When she got there they didn't understand English well. The order was not ready. When she got the order it was not what she ordered. No beans on the dish she ordered. no respect. Food of bad quality. Go to a good Mexican restaurant. Never again!!! read more

I'm visiting family here in Middletown NY I'm from LA Ca, and they recommended Tacos Nicole. This is truly authentic Mexican Food. We had steak, pork and chicken tacos and an order of chicken nachos. Good portions of meat also ordered guacamole freshly made and aqua de Jamaica everything was delicious. Green and red salsas each had a very good flavor spicy. Andres the owner even stopped by to check on us. Fast friendly service with a good atmosphere and music playing in the background. Will definitely be coming back and I highly recommend Tacos Nicole. read more

The people that work there are nice. The tacos they serve are dry and cold. The horchata is bussin and I'll get juice from them, but the tacos are not worth $3.50 each. Ruben's Jr Tacos are 100% better than theirs. read more

Tacos are fantastic, authentic Al Pastor, not the fake slices up pork cooked in a pan like most places. Family recipe, solid place.

Moved from Phoenix a year ago to finally escape the heat. Was not prepared for the absolute abysmal dining options for Mexican food. Tacos Nicole stands head and shoulders above the rest. Everything tasted made from scratch with fresh ingredients and was fantastic. The margarita.. again, from scratch- no sweet and sour mix, just fresh fruit juices and tequila. The hot sauce, also from scratch and fantastic. The owners were very gracious as well. Bear in mind though, this is primarily tacos, chips and guacamole, and margaritas- but boy do they really do that right. read more

The food was served nice and Hot! The staff was very friendly and attentive. The Ambiance is family friendly diner, and dinner hours are pretty busy but the food comes through. I recommend not only their tacos but their quesabirria! It was very savory and probably their best thing in the menu. read more

Tacos Nicole - Tacos de Pastor y Carnita & a Huarache - Tacos Near Me - Middletown, New York

Staff are rude and disrespectful. I attempted to place an order at Taco Nicole. While in the process of giving my order to the waitress she ignored me to take the order of another customer who eventually received their order before my order was even placed. I reported this incident to the manager who did not care to do anything to attempt to rectify the matter except try to argue that my order was in the process of being made, ignoring the principle that the waitress who was taking my order was disrespectful. As a resident of Middletown, I love to support local business and I am very disappointed at the way I was treated and made to feel in my own community. I will not be patronizing this business any more. read more

Great food, specially the birria tacos and aguas frescas. The ambience is always great!!

Servicio muy malo por parte de las meseras la comida buena muy mala atención y actitud pesima

Food here is good the service is nice. Everyone is kind and the ambience is lovely. Reminds me of the years I spent in Arizona. I would recommend a food a list of allergies that their food could possibly contain. read more

Pleasant, clean and efficient. Five or six small tables available; most of the business seems to be take-out. I asked for 6 tacos: 3 chicken and 3 el pastor. The 3 el pastor were delicious; the 3 chicken were very well done and dry. The wait time was minimal despite their being busy. Tacos were nicely packaged and included sliced cucumber. Unfortunately, the lime slices were also dry and, squeeze as you might, they yielded little juice. Small space in a strip mall. read more

Amazing Huaraches!!! Very upbeat happy place, service was excellent. Tacos Nicole has a community feel. I WILL be back!