Love this place! Haven't been here in a long time so it was way over due! Stopped in for date night…read morewith girlfriend and I had my absolute favorite "pasta del la Nona". Location is perfect because then after dinner you can hit the brewery just around the corner to continue a date. Perfect date night scenario. Service is awesome, ambience is perfect and I love this place. Give me pasta or give me death!

After a long stretch on the road between Acadia and Blackwater Falls, we landed in Middletown, NY…read morewith the energy level of two tired turtles. Going out was not in the cards -- pajamas and take-out were the vibe -- so we ordered from Cosimo's, hoping for comfort food without fuss. Success. The crème penne was creamy, soothing, and exactly what travel-weary souls need, and the light pear salad brought a fresh, bright balance that made us feel like we were still making respectable life choices. Portions were generous enough to stretch into a second meal (a road-trip blessing), and everything arrived well-packaged and warm. Simple, satisfying, and perfect for tired travelers who just want to eat well and crawl into bed.

This is my go to celebration spot for special occasions. Stopped in to celebrate a milestone and…read morethe food and service were exactly as I expected! Food is absolutely superb and staff is amazing. Ambience is always one of a business or romantic setting but it looks and feels upscale so it's perfect for either occasion. My occasion was a romantic celebration. God continues to bless me beyond measure.

After years of being begged to try this place, I finally relented this year. It didn't disappoint…read more Everything is delicious. Service is attentive. The ambiance is great. The only issue I had was that my bread was rock hard on my first visit. I just assumed I'm uncultured. I didn't realize it wasn't supposed to be until I asked for seconds. I can't think of any other negatives. Everything has been great.

four stars. slice was fine , low 7s,(see below) but the…read morechicken parm made up for it, I enjoyed both for a split meal. service was nice, no issues overall. would put them on the options list while in town. this review is like the pizzaslice : fine, gets the job done, pointy

After scanning through Pecorinos food photos I knew their pizza was going to be great. We only had…read moretime for a couple slices and they did not disappoint. There's personally nothing worse than overly saucy pizza with the cheese falling off. This was equal part cheese and sauce. Can't wait to go back and try their pasta.

when we arrived for dinner ... the place was empty! However our NY friends highly recommended…read moretheir meals! In Texas if the line isn't out around the corner .. we find another place to eat!. "Frankie" was funny and a jokester! the food ... spaghetti and sausage, egg plant parm .. muscles and shrimp white wine linguini...superb! the walnut shrimp cranberry salad was delicious and fresh- Diana's Mediterranean - yummy! Ever in Middletown again we will enjoy!!!

The location was not as accessible as I thought. It is very hit or miss with the next-door,…read morelaundromat and market. The actual restaurant has a beautiful aesthetic however, the hall that they used to cater is very bland. In comparison the food was good, very basic Italian. With the ziti offered nothing spectacular. The chicken and broccoli was semi-salty, the meatballs were generic Italian with red sauce, the chicken and eggplant were good. Everything was tasty and the service was good. I would definitely give it another try. I am more curious to how the pizza tastes.

Every plate is served with a side of pride... MEXICAN PRIDE…read more Food is well seasoned, prepared and plated. The food is also well portioned from salsa and chips to dessert. Don't forget to visit the dessert and cafe station located at the entrance or the well stocked bar at the rear of the restaurant. Front staff functions like a well oiled machine... front staff is welcoming, friendly, accommodating and menu knowledgeable. They also are very attentive to the tables and simultaneously maintain the appearance of the restaurant and their work stations. The entire establishment expresses their MEXICAN PRIDE. The decor and vibe of this restaurant is extremely inviting and makes you want to stay and enjoy with your friends, family or that special person. There is an abundance of seating and there is also an area to accommodate medium/large groups for special occasions or company events. No outdoor seating is available. Street parking is your only option. Middletown is lucky to have this little gem of a place. Yummy Tummy!

Stopped in this place one day after work to meet up with some friends and I'm so glad I did. This…read morewas the first time at this establishment and I have to say the food was absolutely delicious. The service was great as well. Parking could be a pain in the butt, but I managed to find a parking area around the corner if you're in this area, definitely stop by, because you won't regret it.

My wife and I have made Cugino's our go-to spot in Middletown, and even though it's a bit of a…read moredrive for us, it is consistently worth every mile. It's a cozy, intimate pizza shop with just a few tables, which creates a great local vibe where the focus is clearly on the quality of the food and the people. We started with the Vodka Knots and Pepperoni Knots, both of which were delicious, but the main courses really stole the show. We ordered the Meat Lovers Pizza and the Chicken Parmesan, which we paired with the Sachetti pasta. The highlight of the entire meal was definitely that pasta. I've never had Sachetti before, but they are like these perfect little "purses" stuffed with creamy ricotta cheese. The texture and flavor were incredible--a must-order if you visit. What really makes Cugino's feel special, though, is the service. Our waitress, Adrienne, always welcomes us back with such a friendly and genuine attitude. It's rare to find a place that hits the mark on both the food and the hospitality every single time. If you're looking for authentic food in a warm, small-town setting, "know before you go" that this place is a gem!

I've heard about this spot for a while, and I've had their stuffed pizza a few times before but…read morealways after it had cooled down or sat in the fridge. This was my first time actually eating at Cugino's, and spoiler alert: this is great pizza. We came as a family and decided to do it right. We started with vodka garlic knots, fried calamari, and fried mozzarella. The garlic knots with vodka sauce were a huge hit, perfect pairing. The calamari was well seasoned and fried just right, and the mozzarella was hot, crispy, and exactly what you want. For my main, I went with the meat lovers pizza and was not disappointed. It came out loaded with bacon, sausage, pepperoni, and ham, and every bite was packed with flavor. Everyone else ordered their own personal pies, and each one was a win. The biggest thing we all noticed was that everything came out fresh from the oven, and you could really taste the quality in the food. Service was friendly, helpful, and welcoming, which made the whole experience even better. This turned into a great Saturday lunch, and I'm already looking forward to coming back to try more of their specialty pies. 5/5 stars.

What a pleasant surprise!!! First time visiting and it will not be my last. The ambiance was quaint…read moreand our meals were delicious. The portions are huge and you can get several meals out of one. Our waitress was attentive and friendly. The bathrooms though need to be monitored more for cleanliness and they require updating

As always amazing , fresh and so much food I highly recommend this restaurant atmosphere is very…read moreromantic

Pretty good food but…read more.. Do we really need to have BOTH music and TVs blaring at the same time? I said something and they chose... TV. I should have been more specific: Get rid of the TV! It's not an airport! We don't need to have CNN yelling at us all the time in every public place. I realize your restaurant isn't a library, but the TVs create a terrible atmosphere. It makes me want to leave. I might have stayed longer and ordered more food except for that.

absolutely love their chicken cilantro pizza. it's my favorite from there. can't find anywhere that…read moremakes it but them. the guy who checked us out was great. even gave us free cookies.

Hands down the best pizzeria I have ever gone to. Amazing services, food is beyond amazing and at a…read moregreat price as well.

Food is amazing, my go to pizza store. The staff is always so nice and welcoming, the only thing I…read morehave to complain about is the ice cream. I understand in today's economy it's tuff out there but 2.50 for one scoop of ice cream and almost 4 for 2 scoops is a little crazy. The milkshakes are $6 a cup and it's not different size cups it's one medium size cup for $6! And they aren't thick or anything like how a milks shake should be it's like drinking flavored milks. Would only recommend the prices but overall love the place and the food they have