Was craving an Italian sub, so I ordered one from this place on Uber Eats and had it delivered…read more This sandwich did not disappoint. Ham, cappicola, salami, prosciuttini, provolone piled high with lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar, and oregano. Wow, this sandwich was huge and it was just a half. I will be ordering from here in the future without a doubt. I think I just found my new favorite sandwich shop.

Got the Larry David (pastrami), was a bit suspicious that a pastrami sandwich came with cheese…read more... Full hero for$24+tax tip (inflation and tariffs suck), sliced cold then warmed pastrami over cheese in hero. Not what I was expecting, will go to a real pastrami place next time. Otherwise a standard hero place, looked like they had decent hero/sandwich choices. Maybe I got the wrong sandwich, but it was just ok.

John's Deli is a solid neighborhood staple since the early 80's. Great sandwiches and delicious off…read moresite catering.

I always tried to like this place. Moving from Brooklyn to Jersey I appreciated having a deli close…read moreby. I didn't mind paying for their overpriced items due to it being a family business and for the convenience. However today I ordered a sausage egg and cheese and my sausage is as hard as a rock and dry like beef jerky. Not sure how it even got past the chefs as it is noticeably hard to cut through. Would recommend just going somewhere else.

Totally boggled by the one star reviews on this place!! No meat on the sandwich? Thick cut cold…read morecuts?? Bologna!! My mortadella sandwich was packed with meat sliced to paper thin perfection. The ricotta on the sandwich was creamy and plentiful. The oil and oregano were perfect compliments. And I got a hunk of pizza gaina in honor of the upcoming holiday and it was better than my grandma's!! So sad I don't live closer to here. I follow them on Instagram and all their posts are drool worthy. But I'm back up north enough to make sure this will be a stop I make before heading back to the shore.

It's really expensive for what is basically Italian catering. I will say my rice balls were…read moredelightfully cheesy and chewy. It's a conflicting reality because I didn't agree with the prices of the food. But the quality in taste does show!!

This is a great local place. They are really creative with their food, which is inexpensive as…read morewell. Today I had the double Italian hot dog - two fried hot dogs with potatoes, onions and peppers, and mustard all stuffed into a giant bread pocket they call pizza bread. It was delicious and only $6 - I used to work in Livingston, where a lunch like this would be $10. Also I get breakfast sandwiches a couple times a week. They are friendly and when I call in an order, it's always ready on time.

This is a local spot around the corner from my house. I go there for lunch all the Time food is…read morealways fresh and exactly what I ordered The owner is always friendly and knows everyone prices are cheap food is not

Overall the food is fairly good which is why we come back but sometimes the servers can be hit or…read moremiss. The pricing is fair and the decor is a typical diner. I think the biggest pet peeve is they don't just automatically bring you water unless you ask for it and they also won't refill your water unless you ask for it.

Well, this was my first visit to this particular diner. What started out as a good dining…read moreexperience at first, turned horrible at in the end. But let's talk about what went well before the drama. I ordered the hungry man breakfast special with coffee and water, with lemon on the side. Service was great and the food was good and served timely and hot. Seems like a normal dining experience. Finished my breakfast and I had a refill on my coffee while reading a couple of articles on my IG feed. Asked for the check and a to go cup for my coffee. The server brings me a coffee in a to go cup and I tip her and gather my things and leave. Not a moment after walking out side, I'm being yelled out at, "hey you didn't pay for your coffee". Excuse me, what? I'll spare you all the details because I was pissed and unhappy at this point. To the owner and the waitress: it will behoove you to inform your guest that there's an additional cost for coffees to go before hand (a friendly reminder never hurts). But also take note that I didn't ask for a to go coffee, I asked for a to go cup for my existing coffee. For this reason, this establishment will only receive two stars; because the entire experience was not bad. However, it was horrible enough to leave a sour taste afterwards. I'll recommend this place because you may not have the same experience that I had. I make it my personal business to be honest and transparent when it comes to my reviews, and there's no exception for this diner.

The people who work here are very nice. I got veal cutlets sliced by the but her and some of their…read morein-house sausage. Took it home, cooked it, ate it, and it was great!

I was up in Nutley visiting and bought a very old and stale cheese strudel for 14.95…read more Unfortunately I didn't find this out until I got back to Toms River. I did call them and let them know they should give their stale crap to their families and not sell it!

The food was amazing. My daughter and I were there and loved it. We had sandwiches and anisette…read morecookies!! Jodie was so sweet and made us feel at home. The deli was clean and cute and really made you feel like family.

Sooo good. We go here every chance we get. Have yet to find a menu item that we dont like…read more Extra special sandwiches. Great prices generous sandwichea and extremely tasty. I always make a point to leave a review for stand out food. Very good place. Doesn't diassapoint.

Here for lunch this place is great always outstanding service and always good food we ordered the…read morevegetable wrap. It was delicious. And a Denver omelette, Very, very good. The place is always warm and welcoming and clean.

From the moment we pulled into the ample parking lot, we knew we were in for a treat. This was our…read morefirst time visiting All Star Diner, and the experience was nothing short of wonderful. We were greeted immediately upon entering and made to feel incredibly welcome in such a comfortable and inviting atmosphere. The menu is impressive, offering a beautiful selection of everything from breakfast to dinner. I personally loved the blueberry pancakes, and the scrambled eggs were cooked to absolute perfection. My loved one thoroughly enjoyed the chicken scampi; the ingredients were clearly fresh and high-quality. Our only small note for next time would be to request a little extra spice to kick it up a notch, but the flavors were already spot on. A few other highlights: * Cream of Turkey Soup: Absolutely delicious and a must-try! * Reese's Pieces Cheesecake: We ended our Sunday evening with this, and it was the perfect finale. The plate was even decorated in such a festive way - it truly felt special. What really made the night, however, was our server, Alexandra. She was a total professional and an absolute gem. You can tell she is an asset to the team and well-loved by the regulars. Thank you so much for your warm hospitality. We already can't wait to return! God bless you all!