Had 2 California dragon rolls. Each was huge & had a lot of avocado but they were rather unbalanced, with not enough protein. The crab flavoured stick was also too mild to flavour the roll. The crispy bits were nice though. read more

Sushi Garden - a plate of sushi rolls on a table - Sushi Bars Near Me - Newmarket, Ontario

Was sick 3 hours after ordering. After 15 min of throwing up I was fine. Something was off.

Ordered some take out and their quality was amazing. We ordered some soft shell crabs, dynamite rolls and a bento salmon box, it was so much food for us and we have lots of leftovers for Friday night dinner. The food was absolutely amazing and there was SO MUCH FOOD for so little - it was unbelievable. I definitely will be ordering from here again! Happy eating fellow yelpers! read more

See all

Shout out to Chef Will @ Shushi Garden. Cooking Table! Went for a special occasion! He made it entertaining and very enjoyable! His food was very tasty, as well as his entertainment! I highly recommend trying the cooking tables . read more

We have been coming here for years. They have the best portions, flavours, options and great service. I will always recommend them. Patty Clapperton read more

Ordered the dynamite rolll, deep fried crab/cream cheese roll and salmon skin roll. All rolls were fresh and nicely presented. Got an extra roll, as the order was slightly delayed. Bless Will's heart! Will order from here again read more

Sushi Garden - Bonus roll as order was slightly delayed - Sushi Bars Near Me - Newmarket, Ontario

Amazing sushi! Delicious & yummy. Very great place to bring friends & family. Prices are reasonable and quality is also very good. They have a cooking table and I saw the chef making fire. so fun. Must try soon So recommend to my friends here. Very good! read more

Sushi Garden - Sushi Bars Near Me - Newmarket, Ontario

I called for take out. I was told that the order would take 40 to 45 minutes. I finally received my food 60 minutes later, 20 of which I was just standing there with employees going back and forth not acknowledging my presence. I finally received my order after asking how much longer it's gonna take. I didn't dine in because I was taking food as take out but the place was absolutely a mess and dirty. 1 big table stayed full of dishes for the whole time I was inside . Buckets and food were just scattered near the kitchen. Employees with food on their clothes , and the list continues. I wouldn't order from there again not would I ever want to dine in. read more

Generous workers, and large portions for a good price!

I may try other sushi restaurants around Newmarket, but I keep coming back to the Sushi Garden. The atmosphere is wonderful and the staff are always very welcoming and pleasant. The owner is always there and personally serves his customers alongside his staff. The prices are reasonable and the menu selection is great. They also have two tatami rooms for private gatherings, as well as teppanyaki! They are also licensed and serve several Japanese beers, as well as sake. read more

The all you can eat !!! It's very easy to use words like delicious or tastes so good but this meal was exceptionally well done and served with a lot of care. Price is a little higher than the competition but the taste IS worth it. Our 2 year old son loved it and even mentioned it was very very yummy. (Cost Extra 6$ for him) read more

Sushi Garden - Sushi Bars Near Me - Newmarket, Ontario

Came early on a Saturday. Business hours state 11am opening but nobody was there till 11:50. Ordered a Maki combo with a super spider roll. Sashimi was served partially frozen. Sushi rice tasted off. Not terribly appetizing and wish I hadn't ordered so much. Would have been 1 star but staff was friendly and polite. read more

Good sushi in general if you aren't a traditionalist. Just look at the menu and you will find a variety of dishes I have not seen in any sushi restaurant anywhere. While the do serve the standard sushi selections, a lot of emphasis is on these specialty items. On traditional sushi, it can be a bit hit and miss. I have had red tuna that is quite good, and was a generous cut, but seemed to have a strange texture. The octopus was chewy in contrast. Sushi Garden has one of the only Teppan table sections around, but I don't recall seeing anyone there. With Chitose a few blocks away, I can't see a compelling reason to make Sushi Garden my "go-to", but when invited by someone else, I would not refuse. Great potential, and they seem to be visionary in menu creations, but not in the lead position yet. read more

We called to make a reservation, however it seems that Thursday's are not too busy. We were seated immediately after entering the restaurant by a very pleasant waitress. Three of us ordered from the Teppanyaki menu and my husband ordered from the Sushi menu. The drinks, salads and soups arrived quickly and I must say that we all enjoyed the dressing on the green salad. The Miso soup arrived steaming and flavored perfectly. The boys loved the sushi, making comments like "so much better than AYCE" and "excellent red tuna". We then sat back and watched the show. From the freshly prepared fried rice, seared salmon, shrimp and scallops and the sauteed vegetables, we were entertained. Our chef took the time to season the courses perfectly and wait for our reaction to each dish. If your looking for something a bit different in Newmarket, I would highly recommend trying out Sushi Garden. Be sure to make reservations if coming on a weekend. Tips: the table can hold 12 people, so it makes a perfect group outing. read more

I've been to a few sushi places in the Newmarket and Stouffville areas, but my favorite by far is Sushi Garden. The staff are all very nice people, and the fact that the owner is there on a regular basis and interacts wit customers is a very positive thing to see. Also, when I have called ahead for a pick up order, the owner has consistently remembered my name, which is a nice, personal touch. Their food is great, atmosphere is great, and the staff are lovely people. Highly recommended. read more

I have never taken the time to write a review for any sort of business but I felt I had to for this place. My family had the WORST experience here. Staff was unfriendly, the rice was burnt and oily, and it took two hours from the time we sat down to eat to be served our main course. Out of 16 people, none of us will be back. read more

Unless you want horrible slow service and terrible food I wouldn't go to this place. We ordered an unagi handroll, veggie tempura maki, ton katsu and pork katsu curry. We were not greeted or seated for 5 mins. Then it took another 15 mins to order the food. Handroll and tempura maki was ok. It took more than half an hour for our dinner to arrive. Ton Katsu and pork cats curry were disastrous. I had to send my curry back since it was the WORST I've ever had in my life. The server told me that it was cooks second day, the server himself just told the cook how to make the curry! In my honest opinion, you should not serve food that your cook doesn't know how to make. Lastly, we couldn't get the server on our table for another half an hour to ask for the bill. 1 HOUR and 30 MINUTES later I left the restaurant hungry and disappointed. In conclusion, wouldn't go there again, wouldn't recommend it to anyone. read more

Probably my favourite restaurant in Newmarket! Food and service are always great. We've been coming here since moving from Toronto and we are always given top service. Will is an amazing chef and works his butt off to ensure his customers are satisfied. Thanks again buddy! read more

Great customer service! Great food for a great price! He gave me free Miso soup with 9 California Sushi rolls and Shrimp Tempura for 11.00! - Lunch time. read more

I'll start off by saying they have a great waitress there who always seems to be in a cheerful mood and remembers me and my favourite menu items. When she isn't there, however, the service is often quite inattentive and on the slower side (understaffed?). The service I received on my most recent visit is actually what pushed me to write this review. My friend and I had to wait a minimum of 15 minutes each time before someone came to take our orders with our AYCE menus and no one came to check on us to see how we were doing (despite being the only customers along with one other table in the restaurant). After waiting for the most awkwardly long period of time to place our last round of orders, we looked around to see where the staff members were at, only to see them casually seated at a table watching something on their phones. We decided this time to speak up and let them know we've decided on our order, only to be met with a sigh of annoyance as they reluctantly got up. Geez, sorry for coming to spend our hard-earned money in your restaurant for an enjoyable dinner... On to the food. The food is pretty darn good, hence I keep coming back once every couple months or so. I'd say it's better quality than most other AYCE sushi places I've been to. However, the service is really starting to make me question whether or not the food is worth it. I'll also note that if you plan on booking a reservation for the teppanyaki table, make sure you ask if there have been any other reservations for that night because you'll want to make your reservation for the same time or later. If you request an earlier time, they'll take your reservation but won't actually get started until everyone around your reservation time has arrived and this can mean sitting there waiting for 30 or so minutes for some random people. I found this out the hard way for my birthday dinner. read more

We came in around 3pm for lunch. Granted slow time of day - but targetted this place with its "5 star" review after visiting Sushi Itto and Golden Sushi seeking higher quality. The place is dated, signage out front makes it look out of business. I think we woke them all up cause once we came in they all came from the back and unwrapped the seran wrap off all the food and started preparing...yuck. Still wanting to give it the benefit of the doubt because of the reviews here we ordered. Food was at best standard all you can eat quality. A $30 platter had very litte butterfish or salmon. None of it tasted really fresh. They really skimped out on quality... As well as quantity. For $30 we could have ate all you could eat and probably a better lunch. We just assumed this would be better quality from its reviews. When we started eating they all came out and ate their lunch too. Its more like their house than a restaurant. The only reason we gave it a 2 is because they were super friendly. The habachi table and private rooms looked like this place could be good with a reno and fresher food/menus. But this is NOT a 5 or 4 star in our opinions. read more

Terrible service!! They didn't even give us napkins or soy sauce had to ask for it and then we ordered a roll and they didn't even know their own menu came out with the wrong roll. On top of that we asked for tea and never got it. The place was so empty so there was no excuse for their shitty service. They also never gave us miso soup or salad. Every single sushi place I been to give you those appetizers and here no they don't. They're try to rip you off every penny!!! Never going back here again!!!! read more

The food is delicious which is why I keep going back but unfortunately the place looks very very dirty. When at the teppenyaki table there isn't much of a show, just more of cooking in front of you. Other restaurants definitely do a better job in that area. read more

The best Japanese food in Newmarket by far! Love the spicy tuna maki. Very friendly service, great customer service:)

We enjoy going here often. Best Sushi we have ever eaten and it keeps us coming back. Service is friendly and efficient. Always greeted with a smile and can't wait to go back. read more

My boyfriend and I go here about every 2 weeks for all you can eat sushi. Very friendly staff and the sushi is always fresh and delicious! The only place in Newmarket we go for sushi read more

Good food at very reasonable prices, the service is actually very attentive and polite. Definitely will return.

I'm new moving to Newmarket and first time here, horrible and won't back, forget their sushi.

He got there late and the guy working let us in and gave us a great time free food for the kids free rice chicken and salmon best customer service I've ever had and the food was great he shared story's of people taking him for granted like if your food is 10 mins late you don't get it free also we got free special ice cream read more

Enjoyed an excellent meal off the all you can eat menu last night. Not only were our menu items tasty, fresh and leaving us wanting more, the chef's selections were also delicious. A hidden gem in the Newmarket area, would definitely eat there again. read more

Best sushi restaurant by far in the area. Been going there for 20 years and it's now under new ownership and has been refreshed. Better than ever - you've got to try it. read more

We visited Sushi Garden for the first time. After all the lovely reviews it was disappointing. At 7pm on a Thursday evening, there was one other couple there who left shortly thereafter. I'm guessing it has seen better days. At the cooking table we were given plastic coated, photo copies of a typed up page of available entrees. Each was so dirty and sticky it left one worried. After deciding that we would prefer Sushi, we were escorted to a different table. It was disappointing to hear the background music of Justin Beiber and whatever pop music one can find on a car radio. As a bonus, at least there was music. We were then presented with a 8-10 paper, photo copy of a page of many sushi choices by a server in black top who had a minimum of 4 dried "food"? splatters on her top. Again, not very appetizing with regard to cleanliness. We were not given any directions but were given a pen and so assumed we were to check off the items we wished. As each item arrived, I guess one waits for the next one to be while eating the one just brought out? Awkward as no one had their order together. I am not familiar with Sushi. What I was surprised with was that we were not given plates, other than the dipping containers and so, without the fluidity of chopsticks, it even made sharing difficult. Considering that we were the only table there for the entire evening, the service can only be labeled as bad. Eventually we were given plates after the 3rd sushi choice was brought out. There was never a question of how it was or if we needed anything. Finding where the server was hiding wasn't hard as while they waited for us, (server and cook) they sat at the cooking table watching a movie or something on their phone. Several of our orders just never appeared at all. The ones that did come out were good I might mention. However, after having waited far too long and not willing to stay for our missing orders to eventually be made as they must have been completely forgotten, by interrupting their cell phone entertainment, we "with some effort" got the attention of our server and got the cheque. $90.00!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! For several orders of Sushi and Water. Although I did call the establishment the following day in order to prevent further awkwardness during the outing, they were unwilling to do anything to make me feel better. I am not a Sushi person, but given the surroundings, the music, the completely empty establishment, the tiredness of the surroundings, etc. , ...is 30 or so odd pieces of Sushi typically $90.00???? Further, it was mostly vegetarian so not even expensive items. I will give this place a pass for future. Service, atmosphere, pricing, customer service, all terrible. Perhaps the stack of magazines on the table next to ours should have been a tip off. read more

I cannot believe how much this restaurant has changed since I have been here (approx 5 years ago). The owners must have changed as the quality of service was horrendous! I cannot believe that I went here on Valentines day to be left sitting at the cooking table as the rice and chicken were left to cook and they walked away. They combined our meal with the people sitting down the table from us (who had gotten there much earlier and had already had their salad and MISO soup). They completely forgot to bring us our MISO soup and I had to ask twice to get a glass of wine...they completely forgot?? It was supposed to be a special evening to share with my boyfriend for our first valentines dinner and he had never experienced a japanese dinner at a cooking table before. After dinner was cooked they served us the meat and left then came back and cooked the bean sprouts which had no flavour whatsoever...then left us again. The dirty dishes sat is front of us for another 15 minutes before the waiter finally came over and had the nerve to ask us if we needed anything else! They completely forgot to bring dessert which was part of the meal package. I was furious and could not believe how I was treated and would have to make a spectacle in front of my boyfriend on VALENTINES DAY! The only offer they made was to give my SOUP in a to go box! Completely unacceptable!! They finally only took TEN DOLLARS off the bill! I was not going to make any kind of fool of myself in front of my boyfriend and I paid the bill and left! I will never return again. This was completely disappointing as 5 years ago the same restaurant was incredible to go to...the food and the atmosphere was soo much better. I have never been so upset. I do not recommend going here. read more