Quick response and appropriate questions about the project. Do not seem to be pressuring me for…read moreinfo just to make a sale.

Can't frankly say how good they are at the job - because they failed at the sales cycle…read more For four windows in a base configuration, they were north of $14k. To put in perspective: Home Depot installed the highest end Simonton windows possible with the specs requested and came in at around $7k installed. Which means that HomeSealed has excessive profits padded in. So...if you don't care about the money side, they might be perfectly fine to work with as a local outfit. EDIT: laminated was requested as a cost compare option, not a requirement. Even if laminated were a requirement, Home Depot's was still cheaper by over $3k. Fact is - as we said - HomeSealed is just priced higher because they don't use every manufacturer, they only use the ones they use, which tend to lean the higher cost. That's what we said: they might be fine at their job and you might want the best of whatever, maybe they're fine. BUT...if you're like 95% of homeowners who feel that significant pricing differences for basic things like colors is illogical, HomeSealed isn't for you.

We had Siding Unlimited replace all the siding on our 30 yr old house with LP SmartSide and also…read morehad them replace the soffit, fascia, gutters and downspouts. We were very happy with their quality of work, the responsiveness of our service rep, and the courtesy and responsiveness of the work crew. Victoria W

Forces phone calls that are not necessary (all they're doing is typing it into a scheduling…read morecomputer so they can spam email you anyway and send unsolicited text messages). The ideal stage: - Reach out via Yelp (to get Yelp Guaranteed) - They schedule via Yelp - They collect all information either via email or via Yelp - They send someone out - We decide if want to use them based on what they're talking about - THEN we provide additional contact data That's not the way Siding Unlimited works. And unfortunately, it means we can't really work with them, because we will not talk to "girl at the front desk" overpromising only to have the real tech show up and say they can't do it.

We love our new roof!! It looks great! The entire crew was…read morevery kind and respectful of us as well as of the items that were in the garden beds that were in their way. They did such a great job!! Plus their clean up was magnificent! You cannot even tell there was a crew here. Everything is spotless!! Please pass on our praise and give those gentleman all a raise!!

They don't even deserve one star because I never saw them. Salesman never showed when my wife and…read moreI took time out of our busy schedules to get an estimate. Apparently his time was more important that ours...news flash, EVERYONE IS BUSY! I was willing to hand them the job, they must not need my business. Never again, very disrespectful and inconsiderate.

Sent a request for quote through Yelp's chat, no response (at all)…read more It's unprofessional to not reply at bare minimum.

Honest. Great description of work that was needed. Met the lowest of two other estimates. Dan was…read moreexcellent to work with.

High Quality products and installation at a reasonable price. The sales and installers are easy to…read morework with.

I received a call from Mark O'Neill after spending time talking with Adam at the 200th Milwaukee…read moreHome and Garden showy. I had not heard of Malarkey shingles, and prior to the home show had received eight estimates from roofing companies. I showed Adam the estimate that I received from the roofing company I was going to use. I pulled up files with the names of the other companies that's sent representatives to give me estimates. Adam felt strong that Mark would be able to beat the price. I made it clear what my budget was and it wouldn't include shingles, gutters, and replacement of any facia boards that needed to be replace replace replaced. I also emphasize. I do not want a hard self. Mark O'Neill called me the following evening Anne Wood only push an emphasize the malarkey brand. I had chosen Owen's Corning Duration. What I thought was rude and unprofessional was his attitude about other companies. He also mentioned that he contracts the work out. He delivers the materials, but usually is not on site for the job. He explained to me that his jobs are, 'Fillers' for a group he has worked with for ten plus years. If he has worked with this group of guys for ten years, why has his company only been incorporated since 1-2-2024. What was the name of previous company and why are reviews from 2024-25 only? If he speaks so highly of them, why contract? They have other jobs. I made it clear I want to work with a company that employs their crew. He did not respect my opinions. What happened to respecting the customer and allowing the customer to have an opinion?

I needed a very small siding repair. I was NOT interested in a two step process with an estimate…read morefrom a salseperson followed by a visit from the actual workers. I made that very clear to the scheduler. The scheduler confirmed that that could be done. I subsequently received an email confirming the appointment. I replied, repeating my insistence that I simply wanted the repair made in a single visit without a separate visit from an estimator. Sure enough, an estimator arrived 20 minutes late without any equipment. He was downright rude when I complained, saying "no one does business that way." I told him that Guardian was put on notice at least twice that I was not interested in a two step process. I would not have bothered taking time off from work had they simply told me they required a two step process. At my request, the manager called me, and I explained the situation. She was pleasant on the phone and said that she would she she could find someone in the organization to address the issue. I forwarded the earlier email for her records. She promptly acknowledged receipt. That was all two weeks ago. I never heard from her again. She did not respond to three follow-up emails of increasing urgency. The repair still have not been made, and I am back to square one. I DID receive a robotext asking me to rate my experience. (eyeroll). Stay away from these people. They are arrogant and beyond worthless unless you have a major project, and even then you have to worry about how they respond to a problem. Dear Guardian: am sorry I am not worth your precious time. It will not happen again.

Have had a LOT of communication with Guardian over the past few years. They did a sealant on our…read moreroof, but due to the age of the roof that plan did not hold up - they did explain to us that we really should have a new roof, which we agreed with and they subsequently gave us a credit off of the original quote. Workers were very diligent and hard-working. The project managers had to deal with extra problems that were uncovered when the old roof was taken off - many layers and uneven spots, for which we did pay extra. Our problem is with the follow up. While our manager/site boss - not exactly sure what his title is -was communicative during the process and did come back to follow up with some debris that was left in the gutter, etc. we told him that our large front bush got damaged. He assured us that they have a company that they work with, and that he would have them get in touch with us. That was three months ago, and I have sent him five texts, none of which were answered. While the roof itself seems fine, the lack of follow-up communication does not bode well for potential future problems.

Very happy with the roofing work. The team explained the process clearly, answered all of our…read morequestions, and completed the job efficiently. The workmanship and cleanup were excellent.

So Yelp is suppressing negative reviews for this company; there may be some payments, not sure…read more What was requested? Just a quote for roof repair work. Basic stuff. Quality? Can't answer that because they never responded. Value? Since they didn't respond, can't answer that either. It's not worth anything of value (because you can't pay anything) if you get no response to the quote request for service. The bottom line is two-part. 1: Yelp needs to stop suppressing valid reviews. Please make sure you open "not recommended" - chances are the majority are valid and the positive ones are paid or fake somehow. 2: If a quote request comes, be a decent business and respond, even if it's to respectfully decline to serve.

This team is solid. They called after I contacted them through HomeAdvisor. They came out to…read moreprovide a fair quote when compared with other bids. They scheduled the job and showed up on time. The installers were very professional with my wife as I was not home. They called me to let me know they had some recommendations on how they could run the gutters better than what was originally installed. As discussed this knowledge proved very beneficial as the final product provided a more efficient way of getting water away from the house. Thank you very much for a job well done.

Overall, excellent experience. There was a fairly substantial (3 week) delay in getting the work…read moreunderway, but this is not unheard of in the home /repair contractor business. Also, the dumpster that was needed to be dropped measured 8X 20 ----a good peice of info to have. The quote I received to do the work was fair--this is a smaller, and, in my experience, honest local company that is not out to gouge you. Once they were able to show up and do the work, they were fast, professional, courteous and efficient. A crew of 3 guys tore my rotten clay tile roof off, and replaced it with asphalt shingle in just 1 day----- on a 25 x 25 ft Greendale original home with a pyramid hip roof, plus a small adjacent, 10 X 8 ft utility room roof, plus a cleaned up the yard fairly decently as well, before leaving that day. (The dumpster remained till the following day though--but it was also removed quickly at jobs end) The company has been professional during every step of the process. The crew cleaned up fairly well, but there were a few things --some tile chips and debris here and there, 2 or 3 roofing nails left in the driveway, some tile and debris on the front porch overhang, and some scrapes on the siding where tile had scraped when it was pushed off the roof--(which were easily removed with mineral spirits) , and a piece of scaffold equipment still up on the roof near the chimney which was possibly left for inspection purposes. I can't complain though --considering the monumental mess with piles of debris this job created. Owner Keith sent a follow-up guy to clean up these things to my satisfaction and the guy made sure I was happy with everything was A-OK before he left. The cleaner that was used to remove the scrape marks worked like a charm--with no marks visible after. The house looks exactly as it did before the job began except now it has a new roof! This company prides itself on doing a good job and getting Angie's List rewards, it means a lot to them. I thought the price for the job was fair. Also, they provide a 10-year warranty on their work, and the shingles themselves have a 50-year warranty on them, in case there are unforeseen issues ahead. They deserve the solid reviews they get. I would hire them again. And may do so for an attic insulation job, which they also specialize in.

AVOID INFINITY EXTERIORS AT ALL COSTS…read more They did not fulfill multiple aspects of the contract, our roof has been leaking all week just shortly after installation, and the company has failed to acknowledge or remedy this. They also chipped paint all over the exterior of the house and damaged our brand new windows. In addition, they reused extremely rusted materials despite the contract specifying they would be replaced. When told of these, the quality manager came out -- he papered over some issues, said he would get back to me on others (and didn't), and told me the area with ripped metal where water was getting in was "fine" (that night, we had even more water coming in). Our package also included a "50 point inspection" afterwards to ensure everything was installed properly. Not only did this not happen, but when the Quality Manager came out in response to my complaints he admitted multiple things were missed on initial installation. These were only caught by me having to go up on my roof and check, instead of the 50 point inspection. I am more than happy to update this review should the company decide to fulfill the contract and fix the failing roof. For now, I am forced to spend my time and energy calling, consulting lawyers, and contacting NARI.

My family noticed that a group of shingles on the attached garage facing the front porch raised up…read morecoming out of the previous winter of 2025. Again this shows the quality of installation or the lack of isn't a standard this company advertises. The consumer needs to feel that a roof is installed correctly and will get at least 20 years. Again, be aware before a purchase.

Excellent job, hard working people, top quality products, beautiful roof and gutters. 1600 square…read morefoot home completely stripped off and new roof installed in 8.5 hours. Total clean up not a single piece of scrap left around our home. They added value to our home. Fair and honest price. Would recommend them to anyone. Come see our home for reference and example.

From the owner: Miltown Exterior is a local and affordable roofing company that will help you with any of your…read moreexterior work, we are located in Dousman Wi,