Amazing experience! Hit something in the road without seeing anything, just heard the change in tire noise. Stopped when I could and called these folks. They told me to bring it right in. We arrived within 5 minutes and they took us right in as the tire was deflating. They were very busy, but have two dedicated people for such issues, or so it appeared. Incredibly friendly staff that was very outgoing. We were on our way back to our planned day within minutes. We now have a tire place to call when we need to replace tires and we were awarded with the attached souvenir that nobody wants. read more

Sumter Tire & Auto - Our souvenir - Tires Near Me - Wildwood, Florida

Excellent service, repair was completed quickly. Only reason for four instead of five stars tire was installed with impact, had to ask for it to be torqued. Friendly staff also. read more

The best tire and automotive shop I've ever been to! If you want to support a locally owned and super high quality tire shop, give them a call! They provide super fast, efficient and professional service at affordable prices, what more can you ask for? Also, it's local owned and operated and they care about their employees and community instead of goin to a large national chain, support this local business and get great quality service and great pricing at the same time, you will be happy you took your car here read more

Excellent service and personnel Outstanding!!! I would not go anywhere else! Check them out first all the services that are provided! read more

Came by today for a rear brake and rotor job on my ford edge. I had all the parts new just needed them to be installed. Asked at the bay for a quote and the guy told me $250. I said really that's your quote? I said be careful because I was just at the Sumter Tire south and they game me a quote also. He asked what they quoted and I said $187.50 and he said fine I will do it for $187.50 if you shut your mouth. I told him no you obviously are trying to get over on me and I will be leaving a bad review and I drove off. read more

This is my kind of establishment and I would highly recommend to anyone. My tire exploded on the highway, I gave them a call while waiting on a tow truck. They said bring it in, when I got there everything was smooth sailing. Repaired my rim and got a new tire and back on the road in a timely manner. Just call ahead and you'll be solid! read more

I've come to these folks on several occasions since moving to Florida in late 2025 and so far I am very impressed. They have done a great job on everything they have done for me so far, and they have even recommended other companies for services that my two high cost cars need that they don't provide. They are friendly and efficient. I would recommend them. read more

Dropped by this morning with a slow tire leak in my Tesla model Y. They pulled me immediately into the facility and we're plugging the tire within minutes. Only charged me $20. I was amazed at how friendly and nice everyone in the store was. I even talked to the owner for a few minutes. I believe his name is Larry. My wife found the recommendation on The Villages Tesla club Facebook page. So glad she did, best experience I've ever had at an auto tire store. read more

I've done business with Sumter Tire & Auto 3 times, and each time I visit I am greeted immediately, nearly before my car comes to a full stop. Then I am immediately directed to pull in for service. No wait at all. They are friendly and no nonsense. The establishment seems to have a dozen middle aged men each working their trades. True mechanics no blue hair and nose rings. Fast and efficient. Stopped in today with a slow leaky tire and got an oil change also, home within an hour. The national shop I stopped at first told me that they couldn't plug any tire 5 years old. I asked is that a corporate policy? Yep. Ok they lose. Sumter got the work and $$. I told the gentleman running the show, and he said "isn't that the way it's supposed to be?" Yes, but so rarely found today. Same great experience when I was shopping tires, plus they had the best price. Maybe it's because they are efficient? read more

Handled my issue expeditiously. Price was right. Will return. Easy in easy out. Excellent work.

So glad I found this car repair shop close to The Villages. Service was quick and economical Great customer service!!! read more

Better service. $1500 later and my car is still broke Total ripoff. I wouldn't bring my golf cart to these clowns let alone my car read more

Nice to know honest people still exist! I was told after oil change at a chain location that my brakes and shocks were bad and needed new tires. I went to Sumter Tire in Wildwood at 810 N Main. They told me they were not that bad, I could go some time before needing replaced. I will definitely go back to them for all repairs. oil changes ect.! Very honest people! read more

Sumter Tire & Auto is the only repair shop I bring my car. They were able to diagnose the problem within 30 minutes, and I had my car by the end of the day. Very honest, friendly, and professional. read more

Very honest, but expensive for the services they provide. I value honesty in this industry, so I must give Sumter Tire & Auto some credit!

Sumter Tire & Auto is the best. They are very competent and courteous. No trying to sell you unnecessary services.

The best tire shop I have ever been to. They work quickly and efficiently, and not expensive.

I just had new Toyo tires put on my car. The tires were recommended by Bob. He saved me $70.00 per tire vs the Continental that were previously on the car. The new tires ride better than the old tires. Everyone was very courteous and professional. Excellent job. Thank you read more

A bunch of super nice and helpful folks work at Sumter Tire & Auto. They got right on my leaking tire, found and removed the offending nail and then patched it all up correctly. I particularly liked checking out the 4H Farm Animal Awards on the wall in the office area. Old time Southern Style service is alive and well at Sumter Tire & Auto in Wildwood. read more

Charged me extra for oil change because it's a VW later I found I had a leak around the drain

Needed an oil change, have seen many recommendations for Sumter Tire. I tried them out, Great people, everyone I came in contact with was very pleasant and helpful. Got my car done quickly and at a very competitive price. I will continue to use and recommend this fine business. Thank you so much. read more

Don is a concerned and friendly service advisor and highly recommended by many friends. Thanks for your help Don

Cannot give higher praise. Had a flat in my right rear tire and I called this morning on a Saturday! The kind lady said come over and they would take a look. I arrived and within 5 minutes a guy removed my tire to the garage. In less than 15 min I was called to the office, was informed there was indeed a nail, they patched it up and I am good to go. $28!! I highly recommend using these guys! Honest, fast, courteous. read more

This auto shop is amazing: Sumter Tire & Auto Service. Mechanics and space enough to work on more than a dozen vehicles at a time. Wide range of repair equipment and tire inventory. And they go overboard on courtesy and explanations. No appointments--first come, first served. Open at 8 a.m. I got my vehicle in line by one of the service doors at 7:30 and I was #2. At 8:00 there must have been a dozen vehicles in line. read more

Sumter Tire & Auto - Counter - Tires Near Me - Wildwood, Florida

This place has never let me down in 6 years. Great service, price and quick. I believe it's due to the superb employees & owner. Highly recommended for any auto repairs or tires you need. read more

They always are swift and provide great service. I have them check the air in my tires every month. No charge

This is the place to take your car. Honest, hard working, great people. They get the job done by doing all the right things. Want the best for your car? This is it. read more

Van was broken down on i-75. Got it towed to Sumter. Turned out to be the battery & alternator. They said 4.5 hours, but worked their tails off & finished it in less time. We got back on the highway on headed home safely. Thank you! read more

They sold me the wrong size tires, i drove on them for about a year while I kept going back to them because the tires would not stay balanced. Not one person noticed I had the wrong size tires. A woman at another tire store told me I had the wrong size tires. I went back to Sumter tire to to see they would make it right. They were horrible to me. They made me buy the new tires telling me they are giving me the tires at cost. Then I find out the new tires they sold me was the regular price. They are not trust worthy and they are arrogant because they are one of the few places in Wildwood. Beware! read more

COME HERE BEFORE YOU GO ANYWHERE ELSE!!! THIS PLACE IS FANTASTIC DENNIS IS AWESOME AND HE IS FROM NEW JERSEY WHICH MAKES HIM EVEN MORE AWESOME!!!!! My wife and I have a 2016 Hyundai Tucson Sport. About 8 months ago we had a check engine light come on. Took it to Jenkins Hyundai. Told us it was the turbo Wastegate relay. $1100. Left the shop got home check engine light came back on. Called Jenkins Hyundai. Took car back to shop. Charged me another diagnostic charge for the same code. Now they said the Wastegate had to be replaced. $2200 later for a total of $3300 plus a new $1500 water pump it needed. Several days and a total of $4800 later the check engine light came back on. Took it back to the shop at Jenkins Hyundai and was told the turbocharger needed to be replaced. Another $4687. I was beside myself. The service advisor told me that they have to replace parts first to see if it fixes the issue. The mechanic said try changing the oil every 3000 miles to see if it helps. We did this for several months and the light would go on and off by itself. Finally the light stayed on. Our neighbor said take to Sumter Tire they are honest and friendly and don't need to rip people off to stay in business. We took it there and one of the service guys came out in less than 5 minutes and said it needs a turbocharger. I told him the Jenkins Hyundai story and he said they had to know the first time that the turbocharger was bad. Well Jenkins Hyundai is redoing their building so we paid over $8,000 towards their new building. The mechanic Dennis and Sumter Tire and the girls in the office are fantastic. Love this place and will never buy a car from a Jenkins owned business or take it there for service. read more

This business was amazing! My boyfriend and I were traveling to move from Tampa to Illinois and pulled over for a flat tire. The business was high quality, they were willing to help in a heartbeat. We waited 30 mins for assistance and the man who changed our tire had it done in 5 minutes. Very friendly business! read more

As soon as I showed up somebody came out, took my car immediately and checked my brakes. Waited 10 minutes very truthful found out did not need brakes for at least another 40,000 miles as I was waiting at least another six people showed up people came out and took their vehicles Place to go to have your vehicle needs checked And there was no charge read more

I managed to embed a screw into my 4month old tires recently at an unknown location during errands. So I started my day at Sumter Tire & Auto in Wildwood, FL arriving just as they opened at 8 am. WHAT A REMARKABLE find this business is with its courteous, efficient, skilled, & professional team. ERIC, an excellent part of that team understood what I needed done, explained how it would be repaired, ushered me into the waiting area and returned much quicker than I expected to let me know it was done. The check out process was handled by another outstanding team member, DANIEL. In summary, if you need unexpected automotive care or scheduled vehicle work from an honest shop THIS is the one. Thank you SUMTER AUTO &TIRE! read more

Sumter tire and Auto fixed my Hyundai in less than two hours after I bought it in for a engine light and misfiring. The problem ended up being a coil and spark plugs. They also topped off my oil and recommended an oil change and I was out the door for $512. I am totally happy with the work performed and professionalism of the company. I would definitely recommend this auto repair shop to anyone who needs their services. read more

We were preparing for a trip to our daughter's home in Clearwater. I decided to have the oil changed and Rotate the tires. They showed me the steel showing through the tires.I purchased a set of Toyo tires which were installed in a matter of minutes! The tires were very smooth and quiet And gave us a sense of security on I-75 Thanks Sumter! read more

Great customer service. Very friendly and fair prices. They don't try to sell you things that you don't need.

Sumter Tire & Auto has dealt with me on two occasions, so far. In both occasions, I have been pleased with their work and the speed to get me in and out of their facility! I am pleased. read more

Sumter Tire and Auto provides honest and reliable service. They don't try to up-sell with things you don't need.

Too expensive the reviews on here recently are from loyal customers. The work was done but I was charge way more than the quote.

Another driver warned me: "Something is dragging under your car". Sumpter Tire & Auto was nearby -- teaming with mechanics, cars on racks ...obviously a very busy day. My first surprise: The woman in charge greeted me with a friendly "hello" "how can I help"!! Really, in 2023!! "We have an open rack -- let's take a look" -- really, in 2023!! I watched a mechanic looking up at my car retrieve tools, work a short time and lower the car. He then came into the waiting room and explained the problem. This was an experience out of the 1950's when the mechanic and my dad knew each other's names. Friendly, efficient, professional and at 1950's prices! read more