Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sully and Vanilla

    5.0 (19 reviews)

    Sully and Vanilla Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sully and Vanilla

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Both cakes for nurses week. On the left is the chocolate cake with vanilla icing and the decorated one is vanilla and funfetti.
    Lauren B.

    Thank you Paula for the beautiful cakes. I found by chance via Yielp. My mother's home care company was in need of a cake for nurses week. I did a general search in Yielp and "Sully & Vanilla" came up. I ordered a vanilla cake with funfetti and chocolate but the cake assembler made a mistake so we got two quarantine cakes, one chocolate and a vanilla (decorated). All the staff appreciated and plan on using Paula for their special events.

    Christine L.

    I was looking for a custom cake for a 30th birthday and Sully & Vanilla came up on yelp. Another plus was that it's close to my work place. Ordering the cake was easy and Paula is so nice. Best of all, the cake was delicious! I would order from her again. However, I would inquire about the serving size before ordering. I overestimated the size of the cake because of the height.

    Rachel F.

    I don't often leave yelp reviews, but my experience with Paula was so awesome that I felt I had to! After searching high and low for a bakery that could make a reasonably priced custom cake for my boyfriends 30th birthday, I came across Sully and Vanilla. Paulas cakes were priced right, and she didn't bat an eye when I told her my event was only a week away. She was excited about my cake theme (Gizmo from the gremlins!). And worked with me throughout the process to make sure I had the little personalized touches on the cake that I wanted. My favorite part about Paula's cake was that, honestly, it was as delicious as it was beautiful. I was glad to have not dropped hundreds of dollars on a cake made out of fondant that looked pretty but tasted just ok. This cake is so good (and was so big!!) that we're still enjoying it a week later. Will absolutely be ordering from Sully and Vanilla again!

    Beautiful highlight to the party!!

    The cake was beautiful and delicious!! After our first bakery cancelled at the last minute, I went to Sully & Vanilla website added the cake to my basket just a day before the party. I asked for some customization and Paula, the owner was right on it. The cake was delivered right on time and the whole process was so easy, I thought how could the cake be good too? And it was out of this world. It was for my son's First Birthday and it was a total hit! Everyone asked where we got it. It was perfect!! Couldn't have been happier with our choice to use Sully & Vanilla.

    Ombré cake

    Paula at Sully and Vanilla is amazing! I ordered a cake from her on February 2nd for my husband's 30th birthday on the 5th. We chose the funfetti blue ombré cake and it was absolutely delicious! Everybody made a comment about how good the cake was. Thank you so much Paula!!

    Paula baked the cookies, cake pops and cakes for my twins second birthday and they were wonderful! Everyone was asking where I got them as they wanted to order for their next event. Kids and adults enjoyed them. Paula is also super nice and accommodating! I will definitely be ordering from her again. Addendum: I ordered cookies for a baby shower and she custom made bee themed cookies for it! They were so delicious and adorable!

    Jennifer T.

    was initially overwhelmed trying to find the right bakery to design my 25th birthday cake in a city as large as manhattan, but i'm very glad i chose sully and vanilla. paula was very sweet and paid a lot of attention to detail. she was great at accommodating my requests and was very responsive. the cake speaks for itself... it exceeded my expectations both in creativity and taste and was quite the hit with my friends. would highly recommend paula for your custom cake needs!

    See all

    Photo of Jodi F.
    1435
    522
    2717

    5 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Lauren B.
    197
    19
    17

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    The cupcakes were DELICIOUS and Paula was so nice and helpful. Great choice for my daughters birthday party. Highly recommend!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of T H.
    0
    38
    0

    6 years ago

    Asked them to do a Gender Reveal cake during the pandemic for my friends and it was amazing! Highly recommend.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jill A.
    272
    8
    0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Sully and Vanilla

    Review Highlights - Sully and Vanilla

    Paula was super accommodating when I needed a cake with a specific writing on it for just a couple of days later.

    Mentioned in 13 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 52,916 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Amavi - Mid Course - included in Prix Fixe (~$140)

    Amavi

    3.8(58 reviews)
    3.1 kmMidtown East

    Service could've been a little quicker. This is an upscale Mediterranean restaurant that is…read moreintimate perfect for celebrations. We celebrated a birthday here and everything felt elevated. Standouts: branzino cooked to perfection, dangerously good pita (we ordered extra), and the shrimp skewer. The hanger steak and lobster arrabbiata (could've been spicier) were also hits. Chicken skewer? Just okay. We had thLychee martinis & Dreams of Amalfi Hazelnut bar, crème brûlée (we topped itwith melted chocolate from the cheesecake), and Dubai chocolate cheesecake On the pricier side, but worth it for the ambiance, service, and flavors. Perfect spot for date nights, birthdays & special moments.

    We came here to celebrate a birthday... after perusing their website and IG we decided this was a…read moregreat place to celebrate a birthday.... Well we were kinda right. Amavi is a great place to celebrate a birthday if you like a loud, DJ spinning, hookah smoking, over priced Mediterranean restaurant, this is the place for you. Now, this isn't to say this isn't a good place but be prepared. The food is decent, nothing to run and tell anyone about, except their Bronzino was absolutely delish! I wish everything else was at the level of this dish. Here is a run down of everything we ordered and ranked.... 1= fire the chef, 10 = Michelin Star Grilled Octopus :6 Caramelized onion Hummus :7 Sautéed Tiger Prawns :7 Tuna Crudo: 10 Bronzino: 10 Salmon: 8 Lamb Chops: 7 Mashed Potato: 8 Asparagus : 7 Lobster Aribbatta: 5 Hazelnut bar: 0 Dubai Chocolate Cheesecake: 0 Whatever you do, don't order desert. They are not worth it. So if you're looking for a lively and loud space with decent food.... Walk on over! Enjoy

    Photos
    Amavi - Dining

    Dining

    Amavi - Mid Course - included in Prix Fixe (~$140)

    Mid Course - included in Prix Fixe (~$140)

    Amavi - Main Course - included in Prix Fixe (~$140)

    See all

    Main Course - included in Prix Fixe (~$140)

    Keki Modern Cakes - Bouncy cheesecake

    Keki Modern Cakes

    4.4(560 reviews)
    3.4 kmMidtown East
    $$

    Wow, this little shop is unassuming, it definitely catches the eye, especially for someone like me…read morewho loves Asian pastries. I've never tried a Japanese cheesecake before and was extremely excited to be able to pick up some treats for my coworkers as well as my partner's birthday cake from Keki. Ordering is fairly straightforward and done with a simple machine outfront. Once your order is ready one of the staff members hands it to you through a window; there is no inside area accessible to customers but our food came quickly and we took it back to the office. The cheesecake was fantastic. I read a bit about the background of the shop online and how the owner really cares about using high-quality ingredients, specifically dairy. It was justas described, light and bouncy. I enjoyed how it was not overly sweet and found that it was all too easy to devour the entire cake over the course of two days. Despite it not having much weight to it, it traveled surprisingly well as I took it home on my three train commute! Similar to what others have said, the real highlight of the shop, in my opinion, are their cream puffs. I'm not sure what I was expecting, but the outer layer was thin yet had a nice little crunch to it. We tried the classic milk, cookies & cream pistachio and ube flavors. Our favorite was the pistachio by far, which had such a unique yet decadent flavor and our second favorite was the milk cream puff. There's not much else I can say other than you really have to go here and try the desserts yourself. If you're a fan of Japanese desserts that are rich yet not too sweet, you'll be a fan of Keki.

    Just got some tarts here so my review isn't reflecting what they're known for or typically have. I…read moreliked these ok because it was creamy and light, not too sweet either, but it may be the crust part that I wasn't as much of a fan of. There are lots of other tart places that do something sinilar and didn't really think these were that memorable. But read this keeping in mind I didn't try to cake items so that product may be better if all you're looking for is a light fluffy dessert that's not too sweet. Try something else here! Just did take out option here so not much to ambiance or service from my experience to speak on.

    Photos
    Keki Modern Cakes - Bouncy cheesecake

    Bouncy cheesecake

    Keki Modern Cakes
    Keki Modern Cakes

    See all

    Prince Tea House

    Prince Tea House

    4.2(228 reviews)
    3.4 kmKoreatown, Midtown West
    $$

    I am a frequent Prince Tea House goer, but I've never been to the KTown location which has always…read morebeen on my bucket list because of the nice wall decors! And I commonly see the upstairs for private events like baby showers, bridal showers, or birthday parties on social media. After dinner with my friends, I was looking for dessert and I was glad to see this location closes relatively late on a weekday night at 11 pm. Upon walking in, I was greeted by a waiter who led us to one of the purple velvet chair booths that was perfect for two people and another waiter brought us a pitcher of water almost immediately. The menu is on a QR code already on the table and we were given ample of time to decide. My friend and I both already knew what we wanted to order. I got the purple Yam Souffle which takes 25 minutes to make and my friend got the fried squid tails. We also got a signature Rose Green Milk Tea to share. The waitress who took our order has great memory and recalled all of our items without writing it down. She also reminded me that I could adjust the ice and sugar levels of my drink which I had completely forgotten and would have got annoyed if my drink came out 100% sweetness. Another thing is that my drink order frequently comes out wrong at other locations so I was glad she got it right! Green tea instead of black tea and with milk instead of without milk. The purple Yam Souffle is just like the other locations. Hot, soft cakey texture balanced with an ice cold red bean Ice-Cream. So delicious! The squid tails on the other hand was not what we expected. It came out burnt and hard. The outer batter was not crispy either. We informed one of the waiters and he brought it back to inform the kitchen staff. We received a new batch that was not as burnt and had more flavoring this time around. However, the squid was still hard and not like the ones we get from other locations with smaller crispier pieces. Overall, it was still a good experience and I love the decorations at this location! This might be my second favorite location after the Flushing one. Would love to come back for brunch or hi-tea. Or regular food options when I have not already eaten dinner. My usual go-tos are the twister fries, Santa Fe chicken rolls, fried salted crispy chicken, and the trio dessert combo. However, this location has a lot more variety! FYI - there are two unisex restrooms in the rear for customers to use with really cute wallpapers too.

    This is always my favorite spot to go for desserts and hangout. The interior decor is very modern,…read moresophisticated and stylish. We ordered potted rose milk tea to share, Dubai affogato and Brown Sugar Boba Mille Crêpes Cake. We came on a Friday around 4pm. Originally I wanted to try the strawberry matchamisu, however, was told that it sold out. What a bummer. The rose milk tea came with a themed pot and cups which is really cute. The rose fragrant smelled so good and the milk tea also tasted good and has a hint of rose taste. The cake was good, the boba was well cooked, chewy and flavorful! This time there was an unpleasant experience. At first when the Dubai affogato was served, we did not realize that the amount of the coffee was little until we saw another customer's dish that the volume of their coffee looked significantly more than ours. My friend brought it to the waitress attention but the waitress brushed it off and did not acknowledge our concern. When we finished and were about to leave, the same waitress came over and showed us that the container of the coffee was different and hence the volume of the coffee looked different. At this point, we did not care for it anymore. We would have been fine if the staff acknowledged our concern. We thought that maybe using standardized containers for the coffee would avoid this problem. Other than that, the food and drinks were good.

    Photos
    Prince Tea House - Inside

    Inside

    Prince Tea House - Mango Mille Crpes Cake

    Mango Mille Crpes Cake

    Prince Tea House - Too

    See all

    Too

    Sully and Vanilla - desserts - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...