Let me tell you - this place is fantastic!! We made a last minute decision to invite 40 people to…read morethe house for cake and champagne. The mistake we made was it was for Jan 2nd. We had no idea it was pretty much impossible to get a custom cake following the holidays on short notice. Well--- it was no problem for A Slice of Heaven. We decided on three gorgeous and delicious cakes from their online options. They were ready in three hours. Our guests raved about the cakes and all wanted to know where we got them. We will certainly be picking up cakes from Slice of Heaven for future parties with zero concerns. THANK YOU Slice of Heaven.

I had the best cake I've ever eaten. It was the first time using Slice of Heaven/Sarasota Cakes…read morebut it won't be the last. The price was right, the German Chocolate Cake was truly amazing. Thank you Slice of Heaven!

I ordered a cake for my mom's 80th birthday. I live in New York and took a chance based on the…read morereviews and the wonderful photos on Eli's website. I decided on the Rose Cake, with a chocolate, gluten free cake. The results were spectacular and delicious. Eli and her staff were wonderful to work with. I can't recommend this bakery enough. Thank you for helping to make this special birthday so memorable.

Eli never disappoints! Each cake I've ordered is absolutely gorgeous! Here's one I picked up the…read moreother week for my son's first birthday!

Stephanie was so easy to work with from the very beginning. When we met her at our wedding cake…read moretasting we knew right away that the flavors and styles she offered was exactly what we were looking for. We ended up getting a 4-tiered cake as well as our groomscake with Sugarpaste. I didn't know exactly what I wanted for the groomscake and showed her several pinterest ideas, and she proposed the perfect cake. The guests absolutely loved our cakes! We are looking forward to our anniversary cake and will be returning customers in the future for other events. Thank you for everything Stephanie!!!

Poor service and does not keep commitment. Lack of communication. I arranged to order a custom cake…read morefrom this company for my daughter's birthday. Once we agreed on the design and price I never heard back. I reach out several time's to finalize the agreement but never got a response. I ended up ordering from another vendor.

Amazing sourdough Bread. We had a cinnamon bun, keylime pie and slice of Blueberry lemon cake all…read morevery very good. Owner very friendly pleasure to talk with. When i walked in first thing I saw a beautiful blooming cherry tree. Love this place.

Ivona was extremely friendly and very professional. I was all the way in California and I was…read morehaving my destination wedding in the beautiful Anna Maria. With this being said Ivona was very communicative through the distance and was able to accommodate my dream cake! Not only was the cake beautiful and match my wedding colors, it was EXTREMELY Delicious!!! Fluffy chocolate cake, fresh bananas, with Carmel drizzle, oh my goodness! It was perfect! Thank you so much Ivona, you are an amazing baker! My family is still raving about your cake!

Mrs. Catherine did outstanding! she matched the pictures exactly and understood the vibe we were…read moregoing for and expecting. she followed up before making them all and had them ready for us early when we asked to change the time. They taste amazing, and all out guests complimented them!

Don't go in the cottage. Owner is rude and frazzled, there are no cookies to be purchased. She…read moreshould keep the door locked.

Being a lover of GREAT coffee and not tons of syrup... we found this little gem. A wonderful iced…read morelatte every day. And it was perfection. And don't get me started on their key lime coconut cake! Wow. Friendly barista!

We got this cake last minute for our son's 16th birthday in Anna Maria Island. The cake flavor was…read moregood. Frosting was a little on the sweet side. It's a cute and welcoming bakery on the island. The service was good.

If your looking for a great cheesecake this is the place to go in Sarasota. They also sell their…read morecakes at the Sarasota Farmers Market on Saturday. Ordered a 9" Strawberry cheesecake and 3" Raspberry,chocolate,blueberry and mocha. They were the hit of my wife's birthday party. Her cakes rival the ones made in NYC.

Cami made the cheesecake for Boston's bridal shower and they are incredible. My favorite one is the…read moremango topped cheesecake bites. All of them are actually crazy good and that makes is real difficult to choose which one is my second favorite. Thank you Cami for the wonderful dessert!!!

5 Star experience! Natasha got back to me quickly, and was able to make the two very specific…read morecakes I needed for my father-in-law's 90th birthday. They were very tasty and just perfect! Two Thumbs Up for this business! I will definitely patronize again when I'm in the area.

This was a beautiful cake that tasted even better than it looked. We ordered Chocolate Cake with…read moreChocolate Buttercream with a Strawberry filling. Everyone loved every single bite!