Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sugar Mill Sweets

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    InexpensiveDesserts

    Sugar Mill Sweets Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sugar Mill Sweets

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of J B.
    2
    32
    0

    17 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 609 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Thick Cookie Co - Seating for THICK Cookie Co.

    Thick Cookie Co

    4.8(23 reviews)
    3.8 mi

    Everyone is nice. The cookies are really good! I tried the carrot cake this time and the icing was…read moreamazing! Super chill vibe. Reminds me of a more original insomnia cookies!

    3.5 Counting my blessings at the beach this week includes…read morelots of good food. "The kids" brought a box of these home today and we anxiously gathered around the table (after a delightful dinner) and shared a family tasting of six of today's offerings from The Thick Cookie Co. Our consensus on these thick blobs of delectable sweets was mixed. (So, no true consensus except on aroma. That was out of the box amazing!) No one cookie came out on top for all 6 of our crew. We all had our own faves with Toffee garnering most top votes. Making/baking a cookie this thick with thin edges is a true skill and Thick Cookie Co did this well for most of the assortment. However, two fell a little "gooey" short when the centers simply were very akin to raw dough. Flavors of all cookies were much like the aromas - big, bold, and enticing. (My personal favorite was the wedding cake with an abundance of almond ... very reminiscent of marzipan.) Snickerdoodle was a big hit (our baking family goes back generations with this style treat.) Toffee also came in strong at or near the top as mentioned above. Chocolate chip was a bit of a mess....but a generous abundance of chocolate in the center will do that. Least favorite was the cherry cheese cake....it just bitterly missed the mark. So....head in for your sugar overload...these will help you get there in a most "spoonful of sugar" delicious, delightful way.

    Photos
    Thick Cookie Co
    Thick Cookie Co - Ice cream menu

    Ice cream menu

    Thick Cookie Co - Peanut butter cookie (with a bit missing), 2 chocolate chips on the left & Oreo cookie pieces cookie to the right

    See all

    Peanut butter cookie (with a bit missing), 2 chocolate chips on the left & Oreo cookie pieces cookie to the right

    Sugar Mill Sweets

    Sugar Mill Sweets

    4.4(54 reviews)
    0.0 mi
    $

    I found this little place by accident! I took home several items. They said they make everything…read more My haul included a slice of German Chocolate Cake. I can make this and found their cake to be too dense. I sampled carrot bread and tasted carrots, but immediately needed a glass of milk!! It was dry. The best thing I ever tasted was the chocolate walnut pie!! Hello!!! It was 5.95 a slice and I was in Heaven; I love, love fudge! This was sooo fudgy my heart was melting with joy!! Reminded me of the fudge I make around the holidays. Other reviews mentioned various foods, I have no idea about those. They are only open for a few hours; it takes time to bake all the goodies they have. I would definitely go back!! In a strip mall, easy to park in front, just limited hours.

    Not sure what has happened to our wonderful Sugarmill Sweets. There is a decline in food quality,…read moreambiance, and service. They have switched to disposable dinner ware. This happened some time after Covid and never went back to regular service. Last two visits they were short of staff leaving one waitress who worked so hard to make everyone happy but this also left me very uncomfortable. The food has changed and tastes like something is missing. So sad . Hopefully this is temporary. I love this place and the people that own it.

    Photos
    Sugar Mill Sweets
    Sugar Mill Sweets - Pina Colada Cheesecake

    Pina Colada Cheesecake

    Sugar Mill Sweets - YOU HAVE TO HAVE THE ROCKY ROAD BROWNIE!!! Great news is you get to pick a free brownie on your first visit! Soup is great!

    See all

    YOU HAVE TO HAVE THE ROCKY ROAD BROWNIE!!! Great news is you get to pick a free brownie on your first visit! Soup is great!

    Think Poke - Well, at least it's not a "hidden" charge.

    Think Poke

    4.3(275 reviews)
    3.0 mi
    $$

    This has been a 4-star experience every time I've visited here since 2018. This week has been a…read moreslight exception. In fact, Why? I found an even easier way to enjoy it. Worried about lines? (Yes, they work quickly but are often very very crowded.) No problem -- this week, I ordered on line. And it was a great experience. Customize your order item by item...pick all the goodies you want; set a time for you. order to be ready. (You can pick it up, as I did...or order Door Dash, etc to deliver it to you at work or home). Simply put: Chose my items, clicked on "order"...and received a text almost immediately. And, when my order was ready (within the estimated time...) I got another text informing me thusly. Very, very convenient...no hemming or hawing over a large menu board trying to decide while being jostled by other hungry patrons. Definitely will order on line again....especially when I'm pressed for time. 5 star experience indeed!

    This place was highly recommended because I'm military, and everybody loves Poké bowls! I walked in…read moreand there was about seven people already ahead of me so I knew this place was going to be very good. I walked up to the front and ordered my Poké bowl which was salmon and tuna. I got an extra scoop of salmon that came with it or I could've gotten a third protein. You can get it with rice, brown rice greens and I think there was a couple other options. Their menu is very easy and very clear to understand and read which made a very helpful and not overwhelming. Everything was labeled perfectly and very quick and fast efficient service I got my Poké bowl on a bed of greens. As you can see, I added a few extra toppings and that was extra like the avocado, seaweed salad and mango, but the mango was actually not ready and crunchy and hard. It did not taste very good at all! I also got a passionfruit Boba tea with lychee. This cost me $25 for both . Everything was packaged very perfectly and my drink looks phenomenal and tasted great.. The staff, they were very kind very quick. The environment was very clean and very kept. It's a very tiny shop. They were out of napkins, so you just had to use a paper towel roll. That was kind of inconvenient since everyone else is grabbing to rip a piece off . I happily enjoyed my visit overall ! Will be back thank You for making it a good experience!

    Photos
    Think Poke - Inside

    Inside

    Think Poke - Create Build Your Own Bowl

    Create Build Your Own Bowl

    Think Poke - Delectable

    See all

    Delectable

    Sugar Mill Sweets - desserts - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...