My mom lives out here and this is quite literally the only "nice" restaurant in town. I really…read morewasn't expecting much out of Watseka but the service and food ended up being incredible! I ordered the filet mignon with asparagus. The steak was cooked perfectly and well seasoned. The asparagus was fresh and had great flavor. My mom was craving the fried shrimp, mashed potatoes, and mac. She loved it all and I was even stealing her mashed potatoes it was so good! Service and food was 5 stars. Giving 4 stars because the inside could use a little more ambience or aesthetic.

We were happy to see Prime Rib on the menu but were VERY disappointed. The texture was not that of…read morea slow roasted prime rib. It had grill marks which told me it was not a fresh roast. Mine was so salty I could not eat it. We had to wave our server down multiple times. The price was high for the quality. When we mentioned the issues all we got was a "I'm sorry". We noted that the salad bar alone was popular if you just want salad. I doubt we will go back.

Whistle Stop has new management as of several months ago. It was previously O's Place. Food at…read moreWhistle Stop is very good. I have had fried chicken, finger steak sandwich. wings, meat loaf lunch special, shrimp basket, pizza, burgers and prime rib a couple times when it was a weekend dinner special. All the food is very good. I would recommend that if you are going for dinner, get a reservation. My favorite sandwich is the finger steak. It is a ground steak patty on a hoagie bun with grilled green pepper, onion, mushrooms, cheese and garlic butter. I don't like cheese that well so I have them leave that off my sandwich. They know how to make fries. They are nice and crispy, Service is normally good but if they get hit with a big group all at once, it might take a little longer. The ambiance is typical of a small town cafe. It is not a fancy place, but is clean and friendly. If you have a drink at the bar before eating, people are friendly and like to strike up a conversation which I think is typical of small town places.

Found them on yelp while visiting the area and wanted pizza. Missed the pizza window as I got there…read moreright before they closed after lunch. Got a breaded tenderloin and it was good.

The ribs on Sat night are fantastic. A small place. It may be a bit out-of-the-way for some, but…read morethe food was excellent and the service could not have been better waitress had her hands full but did an amazing job. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone.

I had a great experience at New York City Deli. I ordered a turkey sandwich, and it was excellent…read more They make it really easy to fully customize your sandwich, which I appreciate, and they use high-quality Boar's Head meats--you can definitely taste the difference. My wife got the Italian which is her staple lunch selection. She really enjoyed her sandwich and a 1/2 was plenty for her. Portion-wise, it was perfect for me. I'm not someone who needs huge servings, and the sandwich was just the right size--honestly, it worked well as a half sandwich for lunch across two days. For a couple bucks more, you can get extra meat Which we did not do. Great quality, flexible options, and a practical portion size. I'll definitely be back.

Nice, clean, independent little spot, next to a gas station. Great variety of sandwiches & fresh…read more(no fries) available. Service was friendly & fast & the food was hot (optional). I recommend stopping g for the winning soup & 1/2 sandwich.

What a great place. Very nice outdoor seating. Excellent selection on menu. Burgers are thick and…read morejuicy. Onion rings are very good. Fish sandwich also very good. And great service.

Smoked kielbasa as an appetizer on the menu? Heck yeah, I'm here for it. And you know what? The…read moresmoked kielbasa was even better than I was hoping it would be. It came with three different sauces: beer-infused mustard, tangy barbecue and creamy horseradish. I could have just sat here and ate charred pork and drank beer and I would have been happy. We also got a Caesar salad, which was OK but would have been a bit better if it came dressed -- the dressing came on the side. The wedge salad was good but was less of a wedge and more of a regular salad. Fenwick Farms has a kids menu, which features things like cheeseburgers, buttered noodles, chicken strips and other kid-friendly foods. Each kids meal comes with a side and a dessert (ice cream sundae), although we didn't get our ice cream, but it was fine because my kids didn't need anymore sugar that day. Speaking of kids: They have free arcade games to play! My kids played Pac-Man and NBA Jam while we waited for our food. The Fenwick Farms Brewing Co. beer is made right here at the brewery, and this is the first and only craft brewery in Rensselaer. They have 30 different beers on tap (most their own, some guest beers), and they offer flights. Indiana knows how to do craft beer, and FFBC is another great example of great beer.

This was our first stop at the Sandwich Shop. We were planning to go next door but upon exiting…read morethe car, we saw their sign "Dinner for 2" in honor of Valentines Day. 2 double bacon cheeseburgers, fries and 2 drinks for $22. SOLD! What a cute place! I don't know if they always hac the red and white checked table cloths and candles or if that was special for Valentines Day but it was adorable and made our Valentines meal a little more special. Our waitress was super sweet and attentive. Our cheeseburgers were some of the best we have ever had. We even considered driving back up there the next day for more! And the fries! By far the best fries! We couldn't stop eating them! We are sold. We will definitely be coming back here. There were other sandwiches I wanted to try but that cheeseburger will be hard to beat!

I went here while on a work site visit! It's super cute! They have a classic lunch counter. We sat…read moreat the counter since it was super busy and seating was limited. Service was super fast. The food was mouthwatering! The fries alone were amazing! They were golden crispy perfection! I got the double cheeseburger with tomato, lettuce, and pickles on top. The bun was perfectly buttered and browned from the grill too! I'd come back if I ever go out that direction again!

Hands down the best Italian Beef in region. Staff is the best and new spot always has seating…read more Sandwiches aren't cheap but huge. Very happy this place is around. Miss their pizza.

Meat sandos make me happy!…read more Glad we stopped by to try this spot! Literally everything was so delish! We were greeted upon entry and although I briefly looked at the menu online, there's so much other randomness that's available! Be sure to follow their socials for specials and limited menu items that aren't on the paper menus at the counter. We ordered the Baldarotta, Italian Beef, and Turkey Pesto-Hot. Also got an order of fries and the Sicilian Potato Salad. Then ran away with 2 pistachio cannolis! There are quite a few tables in the dining area. I really enjoyed that each table was different with a different set of chairs for each table. There are restrooms available...which was great because I definitely got messy! The namesake Baldarotta had a combination of the porketta and sausage and it made me smile from ear to ear! Such a comforting sandwich. The Italian Beef came with a a whole wide container of au jus for optimal dipping and was so flavorful! The Turkey pesto ordered hot (vs. cold) is a game changer! The pesto Mayo was DELISH! Fries were well seasoned. The potato salad had olives in it and I enjoyed that as well! The cannolis we took to go and enjoyed them later that evening! I loved how it wasn't too sweet at all! Parking was easy as there are spaces in the back. They are next to a brewery so could see pairing these tasty eats with a drink or two next door. Will definitely be back!

Great sandwiches with generous portions of meat and cheese, very reasonably priced. Plus you can…read moreget interesting imported foods to go with it. I've had the Houston, the Indy and their special Pastrami on rye. They're a way better deal than any chain sandwich place and the quality is much higher as well.

One of the best Italian subs I've ever had. We're from outta town so wanted to grab something. The…read moreservice was super sweet and friendly. Cute little deli with lots of Italy supplies I could spend a lot of time in there.

This place is amazing. Love the food. I loved the salad bar. Was very good. Loved the desert on the…read moresalad bar. Ate here on way back to Columbia City, IN from Bloomington, Illinois. Definitely will have to stop here again.

Unfortunately, The Homestead is no longer at this location. It has moved to West Lafayette, IN. The…read morefood was excellent and it is sorely missed in the community.

These new locations are so shiny! Glad this classic diner found its way, in a fan of the juvenile…read moreatmosphere and easy going music. I remember midnight runs with friends, sticky floors, weird late night customers dropping in, the staff confused why college kids were getting royal and jalapeno crunch burgers in the wee morning hours, and sadly the late hours are gone! But I'm real excited for the evolution including beef Tallow replacing the awful seed oils. This was my first time trying the new fries. Extremely crispy and fresh, the manager and staff very friendly, noticed this well thought out location has it all going for it. Can highly recommend the app, rewards program, and might milkshake!

Food came out fast and was great, one of the bests I've been to in a long time. Restaurant was…read moresuper clean as well!