I was using a coupon and it's was 13.99 for 2 foot longs and I asked for one more meat and they charged me 7 bucks for the one meat so do not come here if you want good food and for a reasonable price read more

Avoid this location. I just received two paper thin sandwiches that I ordered on the app. Both of them were made incorrectly, despite the fact that it was all written down. I worked in a deli for years, making sandwiches isn't exactly rocket science. read more

Subway - Sandwiches Near Me - Shirley, New York

Wish I could give 0 stars. Went to this location with my hungry kids and was denied the use of my BOGO coupon even though it WAS NOT expired and clearly indicated for use "in-store or online." The owner said that his store does not accept BOGO coupons in-store and that I would have to order online to get the BOGO deal. He gave no explicit reason why despite us not ordering any crazy customizations on our sandwiches. Even other customers in the store couldn't believe it. Ultimately, since my kids were hungry I paid double the price I anticipated otherwise I would have said "thanks, but no thanks, I arbitrarily don't want the sandwiches anymore." I will not be visiting that Subway location anymore and the local Jersey Mike's Subs near that Subway location will get my business moving forward. read more

Sign and online clearly says they close at midnight on Thursdays, went in to eat and sit down at 9:35 and was asked to leave once I sat down because they said they were closing. Either update the sign or stay open, false advertisement plus the food is overpriced for what you get, eat at any other of the numerous sandwich shops and you'll spend less money and get better food read more

$20 for a sandwich with no chips or drink lol subway isn't the same. Just a rip off with bad workers

Gross. First sandwich blt had raw fatty bacon and I asked for Mayo and got none. They made me a new sandwich and it had 2 hairs in it. read more

Subway - Nasty bacon - Sandwiches Near Me - Shirley, New York

See all

omg that subways is awful like I said if you want a bread sandwich just go there or if you want a sandwich with air in between it just go there !! we have to stop going where Indian owned businesses are they are super cheap !!! read more

I went to Subway on Montauk hwy in Shirley yesterday 4/20/23 I had two GC's and a points card to use. One of my GC'S had a balance of 2.67 so when I went to pay for my food the employee swiped my 1st GC and said that it had a 0 balance but had 200 points on it I said ok then gave her my second GC which originally had a balance of $25 now had a balance of $10.14 she then swiped it then I gave her my points card she swiped that then there seemed to be a problem she called the manager to "help" which he did not. He swiped my 2nd GC again and told me it had a 0 balance no kidding the girl swiped it a minute ago an she even told him that so he mentioned that he voided the sale and said I still had a 0 balance so instead of paying $4 and change it would be $14 we went back and forth for a few minutes he became rude I was so aggregate I left without my food. I'm very disappointed in the way I was treated. I've been going there for a long time but will not be going back I'll wait until Jersey Mike's opens up and take my business there. read more

BANNED FROM SUBWAY- long time customer prob 12 years since moving here, go weekly, went to subway in Shirly by Wing Stop, had a coupon 3 for 17.99, expired 3/28, they could not scan it at check out for some reason. I politely explained that's not my issue, the coupon is valid, and just cut it out from the coupons delivered on Thursday and here it is, enter it manually or something. They refused, so I said if you don't honor the coupon I am not paying for full price nor taking the order, the two employees got belligerent, nasty and banned me. Rather than honor the coupon the they ban a customer and throw out food freshly made (I would assume, unless they are keeping to give someone else). Would be nice if fellow people had the same experience share or local people ban the shop in my defense read more

I have never seen people so unhappy at their jobs. Their misery seeped in2 my food. No one smiles, no one chats, just cold. My sandwich was a bread sandwich. Not much on the inside. They get 2 stars because the bread was warm and soft. read more

haven't had worse service in my life ... stood in the store for 15 minutes while it was empty..... no problem with smoke breaks but damn .... nobody in the store at all? I love subway so it sucks that every time I come here there is a problem with the employees damn .... it's unfortunate and problematic read more

Subway - Empty Store - Sandwiches Near Me - Shirley, New York

See all

Terrible customer service, they look at you with a face of disgust and get irritated when you tell them to put one thing but they mistake it and you have to correct them. Also they were putting the cheese on the sandwich very rough and they couldn't get a strip of bacon off of the others so they just put a whole strip of bacon bunched up together onto my sandwich. read more

Been to quite a few Subways over the years and this has got to be the Inept Prize Winning Champion -- Subway was running the latest new thing, the Turkey, Guac on the Basil Wrap. Went in and asked for it and the girl starts making it and leaving everything off of it -- I tell her she's making it wrong and she says "Well, what else do you want on it ?" There's a full size advertisement photo hanging on the wall behind her. This particular special has been out for at least a month and she wants to know what I want on it ? Seriously, WTF ??? That was the end of it -- don't need to have someone ruin my appetite -- on another note -- the Subway shop on Rte 25 in Middle Island makes Subway sandwiches properly and the place appears to be a lot cleaner. read more

Avi an employee at this establishment was the worst service I've ever experience. first off he told us they were close at ten when it was 10:30 and site said 11 and the chairs were down and clearly open. and then I got a cold cut combo and gave me 2 pieces of every meat and then I got a 6inch combo which is the same price as a footlong and didn't bother to say anything. if this employee Avi is working the counter the next time I come I will walk out immediately. And doesn't even talk English if u come to this country you should speak fluent English so people can understand u. I recommend never getting food here if he's behind the counter. read more

They don't know what they are doing they are very rude. They don't listen to you and they are very messy. Hands aren't washed and gloves aren't changed between sandwiches. They don't know how to use there system and they skip over people who have come before other people. Very unprofessional and would never give them any of my money again. They don't even deserve the star that I had to give them to post this review read more

The old woman, that looks anorexic is extremely rude & needs to take lessons from the extremely nice, younger woman that makes sandwiches.

Typical subway food. This place is hit or miss. Sometimes you get a sandwich impaired space cadet making your food and other times not...

Jenn is the absolute best employee ever and I always enjoy going to get my food. She's is the sweetest and very humorous person. Me and my boyfriend go there all the time and she always jokes around with us, always knows how to perfect our sandwiches and always puts a smile on our faces. The store is always very clean and the service is always great. read more

Good food and staff but need to make new and more deals and need to update the interior of the store but otherwise this is good and i love the tuna read more

I hate this subway ever since they ruined my sandwich, promised me a free sandwich next time, and then when next time came, would only give me 10% off, and then the little s***head cashier didn't even give me 10% off. The girl is cracked out, but she at least loaded the sandwiches up when they were made right... I got the veggie patty sandwich and they microwaved the patty until it was hard as a rock. Didn't realize until I got home, 15 minutes away. Manager and employees there kinda suck. read more

Hate Hate Hate this store. Everyone is trying to be smartest than other. I wan my sandwich the way I want. Unfortunately, there was a warning for my future reference how to say the item as a consecutive number. how do I know I have to say Tomato then onion thereafter black olive so on. Behave was so bad so bad ....I hate this subway. I used to go often but from now on , not at all read more

Came in with my little sister, took about 2 minutes to figure out what she wanted, mind you she's 7 years old, so she's a little picky & kept asking me for help. No one in the store besides the customer behind me & what Irritated me the most is that the employee was trying to rush my sister & I to finish, not only that Criticizing my little sister to the customer behind me saying "mom's should teach their kids to speak up a little louder & not look at them for help" first of all instead of fucking criticizing my SHY little sister learn how to make a sandwich & secondly be customer friendly! Def lost a customer now. read more

I must say I am extremely picky where I eat and with whom deals with making my food, but Joe today made my sandwich he was an excellent listener made my sandwich extactly the way I wanted, he was quick, clean and professional by far one of the best subway employees I have yet to meet! Thank you! You are truly appreciated read more