Favorite hang and attached to the Buckeye Lake Brewery. Always the best service and great food.read more

Pros: Good location with parking at Buckeye Lake…read more3 room set up - bar, seating, food varied menu friendly staff Cons: Wings were dry, though I did ask for sauce on side burger was average order and pick up at counter rather than table service Pro tip: Worth a visit if you are in town walking around lake. There's not much in the area, but this place is ok.

The donut maker starts her day at 1:00 am to make their wonderful selection of colorful and tasty…read moredonuts. They offer coffee, donuts and several breakfast items. Prices are unbelievably reasonable. My husband had the house favorite, Chocolate Pontoon (Long John) donut. He said the donut was super fresh and delicious. I had a cup of regular coffee (which I devoured quickly and a Key Lime Parfait. The Parfait was delicious and made me feel on vacation. The shop is downright cute with an upscale lakeside vibe. There is a small bit of inside seating and several tables outside, where we sat with our trusty canine. The service is super friendly, accommodating and quick. The staff is engaging and welcoming. There is a drive thru if you are in a hurry. Dockside Donuts will be a regular stop on my trips through Ohio! Hands down 5 stars!

Best donuts in Buckeye Lake . I also tried the chocolate peanut butter protein shake- very deliciousread more

Damn good Italian sandwich! The best I've ever had! Visiting from out of town! Great service and…read morefood!

Island House updated their food menu. The food is good and the crowd is great. Easy to come by boat.read more

A great small business that cares for their customers! Every front staff person came by to check on…read moreus, bring us food, irrespective and bring refills etc. Our party ordered burgers, gripped cheese, and a hot dog. The person whobhad the gilles cheese added bacon. They said the bacon was perfectly crisp, not floppy, not burnt. The Hot Dog was a Costco style 1/4lb dog, nuff said. The burgers came out on a soft hamburger bun, topped with a generous portion of lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. The patty was a well seasoned 70/30 patty that hit all the notes. Just right, not overly seasoned with GSP or fillers. Salt pepper Beef that's all. Finally, the star... the hand cut fries! This was a bonus for us as we didn't know thet had them. When the server suggested them, we all said yes! They were that rich brown that fresh fair fries get...ya know?! Summary: If you're in the area and are looking for a place to eat, check out the restaurant masquerading as a house in the center of Buckeye Lake.

We both ordered breakfast and it was decent. I wish that my potatoes were cooked a little more with…read moresome color on them. The eggs and toast were spot on. This is the best diner on Route 79 at Buckeye Lake. Service was quick. Ambiance was perfect for conversation. We will be back.

We went to grab coffee, but decided we should get breakfast while we were here. We were very…read moredisappointed in the food. The coffee was actually pretty good, but the breakfast was not. One order was avocado toast, but the avocado was already brown and covered with random seasoning, plus bacon and egg on top. The other was just an egg and cheese sandwich with a tomato slice -- plain and unappealing. We ended up not eating the food at all and went to Hometown Hotdogs instead, where breakfast was fresh and delicious.

Tried this coffee shop out while out doing a jeep convention and so glad I did. The coffee was…read moreperfect! I got the white chocolate cinnamon ice coffee, beautiful carmel color. I hate coffee shops that put more milk than coffee, coffee should blhav3 a carmel color not a white color. They serve food here, which did look good from spying on others food orders. The place was clean and pretty cool looking. The girls working this Saturday were very friendly. Will definitely come back!

We just got Stromboli delivered for a work meeting. Super good flavor, we got meat lovers,…read morepepperon, and a veggie one with mushrooms and peppers. All were good.

The food just not the same. Soup was warm and I ask for little cheese in potatoe soup and she had…read morethe whole top of the bowl. covered. The Stromboli was serviced with cold pizza sauce although we asked for garlic butter. She was not pleased when reminded of it. She brought it out cold as well. When asked to warm again not happy and barely warm. The waitress acted as though we were bother to wait on. The other waitress kept going gout the door beside our table and the air would blow the napkins off the table.

Tonight was my 1st visit. It won't be my last. I ordered wings they were very good…read more People were friendly and appreciated my business.

This is our favorite local pizza spot! They deliver to Baltimore, Millersport, and more. Our…read moreabsolute favorite thing to order is their pizza flight. You get 4 personal sized pizzas - our favorite has been the cheeseburger and margherita The owners are fabulous people and service is amazing. They are quick and genuinely care about their customers. I highly recommend giving them a try if you are in the area :) Oh - and ask if they have any special desserts- those are a must!

I had a great time. A simple, elevated dining experience marked by professionalism and consistency…read more The staff handled special requests effortlessly, and every course...from a fresh starter to a perfectly executed ribeye and dessert was on point. Clean, elegant, inviting, and worth returning.

Sorry people, but since reopening, your food has sucked. I've been three times, and ALL the meals…read morewe've had were awful. I don't know who is advising you on your new business model, but changing your menu was the worst thing you did. You had a good menu, you just needed to be consistent with preparing it. And the prices were a bit high for Buckeye Lake. I don't mind paying for good food, but when the quality went down, that's when we stopped coming back. You were offering specials from time to time, which were good!! And the live music was awesome. You also got rid of the best person working there. Nate the bartender. You people just don't know a good thing when you've got it. But, at our last visit, I see you saw the error of your ways. Sorry, I really hate to leave this kind of review, but you need to know. You took a nice "upper scale" restaurant and ruined it with that awful food. It's not the actual offerings, it's the quality of the food. Kinda reminds me of the food you get at a stand in an amusement park. My family owned a restaurant for many years, so this review isn't from just one unhappy customer.

We picked up my aunt and went to Mill Dam Corner Grille for a late lunch. Two things to mention…read moreright off the bat, their amazing patio and incredible menu. We ordered pretzel bites and deep fried pepperoni, both of which came out lightning fast. There were four of us and we all ordered four different burgers, again coming out fast. Everything was so delicious and the servers working made us feel welcome and took care of everything. I collect gift cards and they gave me a blank one for my collection and I loved the place so much I got a t-shirt. We're definitely coming back and I already know what I'm getting next!

The ambiance was good. Very nice place to stop for food. The service was average and the food was…read moreaverage. Nothing very special. I was impressed with the activities they had and the different nights that they had for bikers. Great stop for bikers. Overall the ambiance and atmosphere outweighed the service and the food.

We came for my birthday today and it was lovely. They were down one chef but that didn't stop them…read morefrom making a delicious meal! 10/10 on the Arancini, Fried Green Tomatoes, A1 butter steak, carrots, baked potato, and the steakhouse burger. We learned that this restaurant is under new management and has a new menu. Yall knocked it out of the park. Cool vibe. Excellent drinks as well! We will be back!

Don't you just love stumbling upon hidden gems? Hereinafter is a magical place that I found while…read moredriving around Millersport. It's located in what feels like the middle of nowhere near Buckeye Lake. It's almost like I summoned it from my imagination, because I saw it on the side of the road right around the end of the day when I just needed some place to get a drink and a dessert. I sat at the bar, and the owner, Ben, served me himself! They have a full bar with lots of creative cocktail options, but I opted for wine. Ben happens to have a deep love of wine, and he gave me a couple of sample tastes of some of the special ones he had at the bar. We talked wine for a bit (he personally sources the wine he offers at Hereinafter from all over the world). It was such a nice visit -- just chatting about wine while drinking wine -- and definitely made my night. I like my wine dry, but I like my desserts sweet, so I got the warm peach cobbler. It was served bubbling hot in a little cast iron skillet, topped with a dollop of sweet cream. It was delicious, and it felt ultra decadent to eat while drinking wine. The atmosphere at Hereinafter is classy and cool and modern with a nod to mid-century decor (there's a plastic pink flamingo at the entrance). If you don't want to sit at the bar like I did, there are also booths and tables, so lots of places to sit and enjoy a drink and a meal with friends.