This business checks all boxes in quality of work, customer service and delivering on schedule. Every employee i interacted with was extremely helpful & gave clear information, something i find to not be the norm today. Such an amazing team here that provides a seamless customer experience. read more

Aaron and company do fantastic work and are very straight forward about what your car really needs. And they are so nice! Very professional and extremely experienced. I had cars in there about 10 times in 20 years! read more

they worked with me in communicating with my instance company. did exce work, and went out of thier way to ensure I was completely satisfied. In short, they were exceptional! read more

The best of the best. Talented people that make your damaged car look like new. The highest rating and recommendation. Fixed the destroyed trunk panel on my Honda CR-V. Damage was awful, the work excellent. read more

I would never hesitate to recommend them to a friend. Did a great job and also fixed the front air dam thing under the front bumper.

They do very good work and communicate throughout the process. "No surprises". With 2 young drivers, we have unfortunately visited Stillwater more than we'd like, but the team is very professional and thorough. Ownership is straight-talking and works with you. read more

I had extensive damage to both doors of my car. After coordinating with the insurance company and car rental company my experience was terrific. The work done was exceptional. I am so happy my car was restored to its beauty. What a terrific job! I highly recommend Stillwater... read more

Got into an accident and the guys and girls at Stillwater made it so simple. From dealing with insurance to keep me posted every step of the way. They even had the dealer check codes and clear all codes. Top notch and such a pleasure to deal with. Thank you. read more

My leased RAV 4 was hit in the rear a few years ago. When the lease was up, I needed to get it fixed with the insurance money I received. A friend recommended Howie at Stillwater Auto Body in Mahopac. He was GREAT!!!!! They were great. They took care of everything. And even though my car was hurt in 2011, the insurance still paid for my car rental in 2013. In NY, I think you get like 3 years to fix. Howie said it would take a week, but I got a call 4 days later to come and get Baby. They did an awesome job. I am so pleased to have found this honest and reliable auto body shop. Thank you Howie. read more

They are great guys did a great job Thank you I would definitely recommend Stillwater Jerry Plunkett read more

It's never good to get to know the people at an auto body shop because it means you are there too often , but the people at Stillwater Auto Body makes the experience so much better. They are reliable and do an amazing job to make your vehicle look good as new. And they are a pleasure to work with. Highly recommend. read more

I highly recommend Stillwater! They provide amazing service and they made my car look brand new again. I honestly couldn't be happier with the results. They have gained a forever customer in me and I will being referring all of my family and friends to them. read more

Stillwater restored my car to perfect condition after a pretty complicated hit. The turnover time was incredible and the job is impeccable. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly. Highly recommend. read more

Could not be more satisfied with the work done on my car! Ask for Aaron, he was excellent. The women in the office were also very sweet, which is always a plus! You will not be disappointed if you take your car here. read more

This the my first yelp review. I'm taking the time to write it because of the excellent service and repairs I experienced after my car was in an accident. Stillwater was recommended to me by a family member. I usually go into these types of shops very untrusting, especially since mechanics are notorious for overcharging, especially when a woman who knows nothing about cars and repairs walks in. Howie, one of the owners, was extremely professional and kind. He took the time to help me unload car seats, explained the timeline for repairs and gave me a place to wait for the rental company to pick me up. When the person from my car rental company arrived in an unmarked car with no ID, I naively got in the car. Howie burst out of the shop, cell phone in hand, and would not let me leave with the driver until he had verified his identity and made sure I was going to be safe. I learned a lesson in safety while truly appreciating Howie's care and concern for a customer that he had just met. My car was finished a week earlier than expected. Rather than overcharging, charges were actually less than the estimate (yay!). And, most importantly, after almost $7000 worth of damage my car looks and drives like new. While I hope I never need to have autobody work done again, I will definitely bring my business here if I do! read more

they are amazing! I have used Stillwater for almost 4 years now and they are professional, fair and expert at what they do. Would never go anywhere else! Kudos to Aaron and Howie! read more

My family and I have been using stillwater for years. They always do a great job and definately take care of their customers! I just got my car fixed last week and it looks great, never would have known anything happened to it. read more

We trust Stillwater with all of our auto repairs. We can always count on the professionalism and expertise.