The ice cream is delicious, the staff is friendly, the portions are super generous and it's…read morereasonably priced. I love this place, because I always see someone I know - and nobody is unhappy at an ice cream place!! Minus one star because the picnic tables structural integrity is suspect. Just make sure you strategically seat your party and you should be ok! Cash only!

Best service I have received EVER! We were up in the Freehold area on vacation so we had no clue…read morethat the ice cream place closed at 8 - silly us show up at 8:45 but we still got friendly service even though the girl had to reopen and turn on all the machines! Would never get service like that down in NJ. The ice cream was delicious and came with huge portions and the prices were great! $2 for a cup is unheard of. I would love to return when it is actually opened and try some of the different flavors they have because they have a huge variety and lots of toppings to choose from.

Best ice cream selection & best service in the region. Great for kids & adults. Can't wait to go…read moreback!

Perfectly sized for an ice cream stop or snack refill. My 8 year old liked the selection of candy.read more

Over the summer on vacation in the area my son of course wants his nightly ice cream and this place…read moredid not disappoint lol.

Holy Cow indeed! The best soft serve ice cream. Simple done right. Light and creamy…read more My go to is a chocolate dipped vanilla cone in store, and usually get a pint or two to bring home. There is no indoor seating. There are plenty of picnic benches outside, but minimal shade. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Note: This is a CASH ONLY establishment.

Are you in the mood for a delectable tasty treat!? Well let me tell you. Snowman has it. The ice…read morecream they are creating is delicious. Had the 3 scoop sundae with hot fudge. I couldn't finish it but it was delicious! Service and Ambiance were great. Highly recommend!

Best ice cream in town! Black cherry, Cookie Monster and pistachio are so good!!! Also the peanut…read morebutter cup sundae with Reese's crunches , peanut butter sauce and marshmallow sauce , whipped cream and a cherry on top was the best!! Nice service, the girls are really friendly, fast and efficient! The most importantly, they are generous with their scoops! Totally worth the trip for the ice cream!!! Parking lot can be busy at times! But street parking is also available.

Obsessed with Boice Bros. Dairy I stop every time I'm in Kingston for work--cold or hot, it hits…read moreevery time. The $1 "oopsie cups" are elite (literally can't beat that), and my go-to is a vanilla Reese's milkshake Always busy, always good vibes. A must.

Came here after a long day of work, and it was the kind of treat that made the wait worth it. A…read morecoworker had raved about it, and like with most hyped-up food, I assumed it would be overrated. But I was wrong! We walked up, and I ordered a dairy-free Dole Whip in pomegranate flavor with rainbow sprinkles in a cup. I wasn't sure what to expect--I'm usually not a huge pomegranate fan--but from the first taste, I was sold! It was sweet with just the right amount of tartness, and the sprinkles added a fun pop of color. It was the perfect cold treat to make an 8-hour workday feel worth it. Now that I've found this place, I'll definitely be back--there's so much more I want to try! 5/5 stars.

Delicious unique flavors. Happened to come on a night with live music and it was great to hang…read morearound and enjoy that with others. Friendly staff that were very knowledgeable about all their offerings. Will be back soon!

They always have a great selection of candy, chocolates, baked items and ice cream. They seem to…read morealways have live music too. There's tables, couch, chairs and board games. Parking is on the street.

Always a great shake with some soft serve to top it off!…read moreGirl was sweet and on me like sprinkles on a cone! Clean and well maintained property. Thank for a March 18th treat, had to drive 30 miles for this.

Guptill's is not the closest ice cream parlor to me, but I'd certainly go out of my way to stop in…read morefor some. It's a reason to drive on US 9 instead of I-87, for example. I'm really impressed by the large number of flavors of both hard and soft ice cream. Members of my family prefer Guptill's because gluten-free cones are available. The quality and texture of their hard ice creams are always consistently good. They are one of my favorite places to get strawberry cheesecake ice cream. It's cash only here, but tax is conveniently included, barring the need for small change, and there's a convenient ATM if necessary.

We have been going there for the past 2 years. NEVER experienced this. 3 weeks ago my husband went…read morethere...no soft serve. Last Sunday we go there for soft serve. Sign in window says No soft serve chocolate. That was ok....since we were wanting Hot Fudge sundaes with vanilla. Oh...we don't have hot fudge. Hmm...ok. Then the girl proceeded to say, the vanilla has to be in a cup because it is not hardening like it's supposed to. But it's ok. We get the cup with flavor burst. I literally could drink it....so soupy... should just have said, no vanilla either. I could understand if it's a one time issue but going on 3 weeks. Best part....being charged $14 just to throw away. Will not go back again.

Ive been coming to this place for like 15 years. This place is legendary. It shines in terms of…read morecustomization. The most important feature is all the flavors of soft serve. They mix flavors into a vanilla base using a syrup. The biggest issue is that they've changed management twice. They used to be Tom's ice cream. The new management hasnt quite figured out how to generate all the flavors. The new management is still pretty good though. The vanilla base is still some of the best soft serve I've had. My favorite flavors are peanut butter, cappuccino. To be fair, Tom was a dairy jedi. He set the bar really high. In terms of toppings, their sauce game is also strong. They have hardening, chocolate dips, etc. The peanut butter sauce is homemade and my personal favorite. They also have crush ins for the soft serve like reeses pieces and oreos and hard ice cream. These are good, but definitely not the star of the show.

So me and my Poop n Scoop group had to pivot and said lets go to Happy Clown. Ppl rave about this…read moreplace. It was so so too me. I was expecting more flavors then chocolate or vanilla. Soft serve at that. I got the special Black Raspberry twist. It was good. I don't see myself coming back. But if you like soft serve and you are in Athens, NY then go see yourself.

a treat! Orange and vanilla soft serve. Yum! Friendly service…read more I'm getting weary of Yelp nagging me, so here's my review. Yes of course I would return whenever I am nearby and recommend that ice cream lovers stop by!

I love Stewart's. They have everything you need…read more I stopped in yesterday and they put ice cream in my coffee. Do you know how good blueberry coffee with vanilla ice cream in it is? It's really good

If you pay by credit card, keep an eye on your monthly bills. I was billed twice for a fill-up --…read more$50.24 x 2. Ouch! This for a Subaru Impreza with fuel capacity of 13 gals! I complained to Stewarts. They said they would investigate and adjust the bill. Next's month's credit card invoice reflected a correction. However, this month's credit card bill showed an "adjustment" of an additional $50.24! The large print giveth and the small print taketh away. If you use your card a Stewarts, watch your monthly credit card invoices.