Love this spot! I was in the area and was looking for fresh food. I passed this market a few times and decided to check it out. I'm so glad that I did! They have so much different food here- they have convenience foods, a pizza counter, sandwiches, snacks, freshly prepared food, a cheese section, and more! I was glad to find this place and stopped in a few times to load up on charcuterie boards, snacks, and drinks for the weekend. I'd recommend stopping here if you're in the area and want to grab essentials or snacks for the road. read more

See all

Excellent Market in the heart of town, you can find anything you may need from breakfast and lunch specials to toilet paper and toothpicks.... read more

Hickory Hill Market - Convenience Stores Near Me - Windham, New York

Ridiculously expensive. A bar of cream cheese was 8$, pasta sauce 13$, and 4 oz of lox 15$ for reference. These are 2x standard prices. Drove another 20 minutes and found normally priced groceries at a larger store. read more

I was very disappointed with my experience. My son and I ordered a pizza, and the employee told me it would be ready in about three minutes, so I stepped outside to wait. At the time, I was the only Hispanic customer I noticed in the restaurant. While I was outside, another couple arrived and went inside. When I came back in, I saw that the only pizza that had been prepared--our order--had been given to the customers who arrived after us. When I asked what had happened to my pizza, the employee smiled and apologized, saying it was a mistake. We had to wait even longer for a new order. I cannot say why this happened, but the experience left both my son and me feeling embarrassed, unwelcome, and uncomfortable. Everyone deserves to be treated with fairness, respect, and equal attention. Because of how this experience made us feel, I chose not to purchase anything else from the business during the rest of our stay. Unfortunately, this experience has also made me decide not to return in the future. I sincerely hope the business reviews its customer service practices so that every customer is treated with the same respect and consideration. read more

Wow what a lovely treat this place is!! We're visiting for a few days and this has been our go-to spot for lunch. Every sandwich and wrap we've had here has been HITTERS. Everyone here is so sweet and welcoming. I got a grilled cheese with chicken noodle soup yesterday, and today I tried the crispy chicken cutlet sandwich and everything was so good. I wish I had a market like this near me back in LA. High quality, great prices, great portions, awesome service, endless options. Really cannot ask for more read more

Hickory Hill Market - Crispy Chicken Cutlet Sandwich - Convenience Stores Near Me - Windham, New York

Love their Italian subs and sausage and pepper heroes! Always filled with plenty of meat and veggies. Still have to try the pizza. You can find anything you want there such as pickles, salad fixings, ice cream, beer, breads, cold cuts, etc. read more

Great market in town to grab some snacks, food, and essential products you may have forgotten to pack. They also sell alcohol here. Some things can be a bit overpriced which is the only downside. read more

This place is a must go to It's got decent gas prices And very good food along with beer and other other stuff you might need The deli counter out some food and the potato salad and macaroni salad are dead on. read more

Excellent find in Windham area. Good selection, friendly staff. Convenient hours Good parking read more

Hickory Hill is Super clean with a wide selection of staples and specialty items; kind staff, decent prices - this is a terrific local store. read more

My favorite market. Love visiting and getting everything I need. Would highly recommend

Very clean and diverse little market which is nice especially since it's basically the only option within miles to shop for basic grocery needs. Staff is friendly. The only two gripes I have is that their prices are definitely marked up and the fresh food counter operates pretty slowly and inefficiently. Had to pay $10.99 for 24 poland spring water case, which is pretty expensive compared to what you would normally get it for. Aside from that, it's a very convenient local place to go to for your basic needs. read more

The deli food seems very fresh and the prices are reasonable for a convenience market in a tourist area. However, I took 2 stars off because the staff could be friendlier. We arrived hoping to get a quick dinner around 6 and we're told that the deli counter had closed at 3, even though the website clearly said 9. There was no real hot food as suggested by the website other than pizza. read more

Good variety. Breakfast lunch dinner. High high prices. Only game in town. Great craft beer selection local

We were staying in the hotel next door and stopped by the Hickory Hill market to get a few things and we're pleasantly surprised. They had a wide selection of groceries, drinks, and snacks. I personally loved that they had decaf iced coffee available, as that is sometimes hard to find. My fiancé had a breakfast burrito with chorizo that was so good he went back for it again the next day! My only caution is the pizza- our friends had one that smelled very garlicky, and they did say the flavor was overwhelming. Overall, this store is a great and very convenient place to grab a few groceries or a nice breakfast on the go! read more

Upscale convenience store located in the heart of Windham. Just minutes from the mountain. They offer a nice selection of deli items and do in fact make a pretty decent sandwich. Bagels are good as is the coffee. Definitely one of the better markets in the area. A little on the pricey side but you are getting a good product. read more

Excellent market. They have everything from home made desserts to beautiful ribeyes. The deli prepares the best sandwiches in the Catskills. A true NY sandwich that won't empty your wallet. This is a must stop. Clean accommodations with smiles and service. Visit once and stopping in will become routine. read more

Nothing here has prices it's crazy. I ask at the register if I'm missing something and just not looking in the right places. the lady says right we don't display prices. It's a joke! read more

Price displayed on board at pizza/deli counter is supposed to match what customers are charged at register per law. Telling me you cannot do anything about it is total BS. This was a 5.5% difference in the price of a pizza. Jim: you need to do better! read more

Great gas station and deli/pizza restaurant A bit pricey on the groceries. Excellent food. read more

Can I give no stars for the huge piece of plastic in my wife's veggie wrap?!? Absolutely unacceptable and disgusting. read more

Hickory Hill Market - a meal in a styrofoam container - Convenience Stores Near Me - Windham, New York

See all

Solid local market and gas station. Has a little of everything and sides on the higher end of quality. They have saved many meals having just what I needed. Solid cheese selection, produce, dairy, beer, snacks and coffee!!! Prepared food is available at certain times and Bomb pizza with a small seating area to enjoy it! read more

I LOVE THIS PLACE!!!!!!!!! SO MUCH! I will say...that this is the best gluten free pizza I have had and it made my heart so happy to know that they have gluten free to-go options. The market has just about everything you could think of, gluten free soy sauce, gluten free bread rolls, chips, dips, household supplies, tons of cheeses and meats (deli aside). Everything is reasonably priced considering that it's in the ski town. They do have a refrigerator room that has tons of beer, seltzers and one or two gluten-free beers (that sell quickly). I go to this place whenever I'm skiing because everyone is so nice (the night shift more than the day shift which are so easily overwhelmed it's painfully obvious). If you're in Windham don't dismiss this for food options, I almost did and I'm glad I didn't. read more

This place is fantastic! Employees, food, service, all Excellent. Highly recommend the handmade pizzas, made to order. read more

More than a gas station convenience store. Great breakfast lunch and dinner meals. Quick and well made. Good quality food and customer satisfaction. Highly recommend. read more

A great little market, right on the edge of town, perfect one stop shop for everything you might need for a weekend getaway. The pizza was delicious, made to order, thin crust and cooked perfectly! Also the New York style cheesecake was a big hit! read more

Wow! This is a great local market that we found during our recent stay in Windham. The pizzas were excellent as well as the deli sandwiches. The breakfast sandwiches were also delicious. Everything was so fresh. The chocolate chip cookies by the register were to die for. The best we have ever had! Our kids loved this store and I'm sure will be taking about it for months to come. I wish we had such a great market where we live in suburban Philadelphia. read more

We were staying next door at the Winwood inn and initially thought that this was a typical gas station convenience store. Boy, we're we pleasantly surprised! They have a fabulous pizza restaurant in the back and really good grocery options. We picked up two pizzas from here for dinner and they were top notch. Really. The deli and grill closes after lunch, but they had pre made sandwiches which we snagged for a mid-hike picnic lunch. Also stocked up on breakfast goods, water and Gatorade. We didn't know this, so we stopped at the hanne Ford market in Cairo. That is a nice store but it was not necessary as this place was right next door. Did I mention that they have cold beer and soft serve? read more

This place is amazing. Part deli / convenience store with your every day grocery needs. The employees were all amazing and the place was very clean. We ordered sandwiches and they were delicious. They also have a wide range of drinks. A must visit if you're here to visit the slopes. read more

Having travelled extensively this is a decent place to go grab a bite to eat, love the fact that it is run by local individuals and not big corporate companies. I think that the most disgusting and honestly humiliating part of this place is the fact that the management, overall and deli management have not only called out their employees in front of their customers, but belittled and made them cry in front of customers as well. I highly recommend that to improve this establishment to turn over overall management, and deli management to individuals that actually care about the well being of there seemingly very young staff. The experience and atmosphere of this place can be overall improved I think with these changes. I think the management treating their employees like that in front of customers made a huge impression on me. No one should be talked to or treated that way, especially in front of strangers, and that is why this place got only a 2 star review. read more