Was in town for work and this restaurant was recommended by the woman at the hotel front desk (I had of course already been checking out Yelp but it's nice to get a recommendation from someone local!). I was disappointed that they were out of the cornbread which sounded great. When I asked what yum yum sauce was the delightful waitress brought me a sample to try. They named it well! Yum yum! Since they were out of the cornbread she recommended the half and half potato which had yum yum sauce on it. It was delicious! The owner was there and he promised me there would be cornbread if I came back today for lunch they would have some. I did - they didn't! :-( I will have to try again when I am back in August. The restaurant is cute and you feel like a guest in someone's home. I will definitely be back. read more

In the never ending search for somewhere to eat comes some gems. Stephen's Heads or Tails came up today. Let me tell you this is some fine food! It's clean, a little small but it's homey. Service was right there, super friendly!! The other customers sitting near us chatted with us, talked about what there is to do in Marksville. We had the Crawfish Etoufee and it was crazy good!! Best I've ever had! Came with a salad and bread. We both brought the salad to go because it's pretty big, fresh mixed greens tomato slices cheese cucumbers and croutons. That's an impressive side salad. Talked with Stephens the younger who cooks. Our waitress was friendly attentive and busy! This is another place we are going back to, another place that rates more than five stars! We really had fun, couldn't have had a better time!! read more

This place had the best fish and gumbo I've ever had. Very nice waitstaff. Great pricing. Sadly I think they recently closed.

The waiters were friendly and there are a lot of options on the menu, but the food was not as great as most of these reviews are saying. I had the pasta-lavista and would not get it again. It was just ok although the portion size was good. My son's burger and waffle fries was solid choice (cheddar jalapeño bun). Unfortunately, they only do the bread pudding on Friday and Saturday (and I say unfortunately assuming that it is as good as the reviews say). If I'm ever back in town and at this restaurant, I think the fried food might be the way to go. But I am a little skeptical that this deserves five stars because my first experience was not close to that. read more

Wowza!! This unassuming little place won't get your attention from the road but my God the food is good! Coming from a real Cajun cook, I approve this menu. We were hungry and ordered seafood balls and two entrees to share. We could have split one entree and still had leftovers. You get a ton of food for your money and omg do not forget the bread pudding. We read reviews and waited for it to get cooked. Oh wow...so glad we waited. I've never had bread pudding this good. The ends were crisp like fresh French bread toast and the texture was perfect with white chocolate sauce. Next time we need to sneak in some rum to daub over it. Can't wait to come back and try everything else on the menu! Do yourself a favor and stop at the little brown building. read more

See all

We just finished an amazing late lunch here after leaving Paragon Casino. It's a small very home-like place. The wait staff is really friendly and we enjoyed the casual environment. We started the meal out with a generous helping of fried okra. Honey had the Rico Burger and I had the lunch Top Hat plate. We were both starving and inhaled nearly everything and it was so so good. We will definitely be back when we are in town again. It was amazing! Highly Highly recommend. read more

Delicious food!! We have loved everything we have tried. Well worth the drive to Marksville.

Great food services. Amazing. Very nice and quiet and restaurant. They serve some of the best étouffée.

Wowzer! This place puts out some great tasting food with huge portions. I called in an order and was very impressed with what I received. I ordered the bowl of gumbo, tacos and a dozen fried shrimp. The gumbo had so much meat in it - for sure a 1/2 of a chicken breast and a link of smoked sausage. Then I came across a different sausage, possibly pork. The gumbo was so good I didn't touch the shrimp bc I couldn't pull away from the gumbo; a dark roux. The lady who took my order made me almost fall when she asked "do you want a sweet potato with that gumbo"? I didn't even think to ask for it so I was thrilled when she mentioned it! "Yes I want a sweet potato." My mother had the tacos and she said they were delicious. The tortillas were definitely hand made tortillas and that's something you don't see every day! No one ate the shrimp! We were overly impressed in the food, had enough for lunch the next day! I would've given 5 star but a to go order with no utensils or napkins? I'll blame it on to many young, inexperienced girls by the register. read more

Mr. Stephens continues to go above and beyond to establish himself as a unique restaurant in the Marksville area. The styles he incorporates in his menu items are from his soul and you can tell he takes great care in each one he makes. Take the short drive to visit this place from wherever you live to taste his southern and unique flair he puts in his food. read more

I don't usually write reviews unless something is outstanding! The food here at Stephens Heads or Tails is amazing. I got the Pasta La Vista and it had this sauce mixture that has lump crab, crawfish, and all things yummy. My family had the catfish and country fried steak. The ettoufe' is award-winning! please stop here and grab a bit to eat! Great staff and the chef is so personable!! read more

We were in Marksville again this weekend and decided to go and try the Yum Yum Sauce.....actually we went TWICE. The first time we had the Yum Yum dip with chips. Have I said this stuff is to die for?? Oh.Em.Gee! We went again on Saturday night, and we both got the Catfish Yum Yum, but asked for it grilled, which they graciously did. It was so good, I forgot to take a picture. lol. Thankfully, they provided a roll so we didn't have to lick the plates. I'm telling you the stuff is that good. The first night I got the crab burger and my husband got the grilled shrimp Poboy which were okay, though I must say it's Yum Yum all the way from now on. If in Marksville, you MUST try this place. I have shared their new menu. Reasonable prices, friendly people and Yum Yum Sauce!! Seriously, you have to try it!! This our MUST go to place in Marksville. We brought my son's mother-in-law from New Orleans with us last time. She has not stopped talking about that Yum Yum Sauce since! Awesome!! read more

See all

Awesome food and service. Super friendly owner that mingles and talks to everyone. Definitely have the bread pudding, only available on the weekends. read more

This place is so good! It's a nice, calm environment and the staff is great. I felt like I was eating in the comfort of my own home. I would highly suggest visiting! read more

Great food and service!! Highly recommend "The Trilogy" and the Crawfish cornbread with the yum yum sauce on top, everything was very good!

We recently moved here to Louisiana from California and have never had crawfish. We went to Stephens Heads or Tails to try them out for the first time and let me tell y'all they were so friendly and they even showed us how to eat em! The portion was generous and the flavor was delicious! They had a perfect amount of spice! Looking forward to visiting Stephens again soon! read more

worst service I've ever had. Owner was arrogant, condescending and extremely rude. I won't go there again.

Everything we had was very enjoyable. The fried shrimp was fresh. The seasoned fries complimented the excellent coleslaw. Loved the hush puppies and the fried catfish. The yum-yum sauce should be illegal! SO GOOD! The white chocolate bread pudding topped off the meal and will bring us back. While the service was somewhat slow, it was extremely friendly and the menu was explained thoroughly. This is a great place for Cajun seafood. read more

Can't say enough great things about this place! I will start with the customer service, we came in a bit skeptical primarily because we were traveling for the holidays and had never been to the area before. However, as soon as we entered our concerns were put to rest with exceptional service, knowledgeable staff and MY GOD! Some of the best food I have ever had. Try the BREAD PUDDING!!! The food came out quick and tasted great... TRY THE BREAD PUDDING!! And the owners came and made sure everyone was enjoying their food and service. I highly recommend this place, and oh yea ... TRY THE BREAD PUDDING! read more

you are making a mistake if you do not eat here when in or passing through town. sadly they were sold out of cornbread but the yum yum sauce topping the pistolotte more than sufficed. my girlfriend got the half and half baked potato and wow, best baked potato she ever had in her life. just her exact words. great service, will definitely be back when passing through town. looks a little sketchy from the outside but extremely comfy and welcoming once inside. all in all, a+ stuff truly. little bit of a wait, but i mean its food thats cooked to order, not a drive thru. read more

Wow!! So glad I found this on Yelp. This place has awesome food! We tried the yum yum dip and it was delicious. I had the fried pistolette with yum yum sauce and 2 large fried shrimp. We will definitely go back to this place. The owner came to our table and he was so very friendly and told us about his crepes for dessert which we ate as well. It was heavenly. Had a great waitress. You will not be disappointed with the food here read more

Delicious food - especially the cornbread. Husband had the Trilogy and loved it. Owner is incredibly nice.

The food here is actually really, really good and the beer is cold but I can only give two stars due to service, wait time and total disorganization. This is the second weekend to go there. The first of which we never even got waited on and left. read more

Great food great service and fantastic people. If you enjoy great seafood this is your place

Been here twice and will come back. Nice selection of food and great service. Po-boys were loaded. Grilled catfish yummy. We had boiled shrimp and it was cooked just right. Spicy but not over seasoned. The owner Brian came over to greet and gave a short welcome. read more

Husband and I came to Marksville and was recommended this place. What a hidden gem in Marksville! We had the Gator Balls, Pasta La Vista, chicken& sausage gumbo, and the bread pudding. Everything was well seasoned and such a great portion with reasonable price. We were so stuffed that I wasn't thinking of dessert then Stephen, the owner, recommended bread pudding for dessert. I was sold when he said it just came out of the oven. Boy, was I glad he recommended it! The bread pudding was piping hot and moist. The sauce was creamy and perfectly sweetened. Definitely a winner in our book! The place, the food, staff and owner made a small trip into a pleasant one for us. We love homey places like these that serves authentic southern food! read more

See all

This was my second time in Marksville, but my first time here at Stephens Head or Tails. I have to say, the food is awesome and the people are nice. I highly recommend this place. read more

Stephens Heads Or Tails - The bread pudding was super delicious and these crawfish are the bomb! I highly recommend this place if you are ever in Marksville, LA. - Seafood Near Me - Marksville, Louisiana

Very good food a must try The Philly cheesesteak is the best it's a must have for seafood is awesome

The trilogy was awesome. The sauce is to die for. My husband said the fried catfish is the best he's ever had.

Food was excellent! Owner and staff very friendly. We will be stopping here again. You will want to save room for dessert if you can the fried crepes are to die for. Seafood was fresh and cooked to order. read more

By far the best place in Marksville. You cant go wrong with anything on the menu. My favorite is Midler B cornbread. Its good portion of crawfish cornbread smothered in yum yum sauce. Not to mention the owner is cocerned about his guest experience. Definitely a must try!!!!!!! read more

We were in town from Houston, TX because my band was playing for a convention at the Paragon Casino. Just had lunch and food was excellent and service was great. I had fried shrimp and they were fresh and my wife had fried catfish. The batter on both was tasty and not salty at all. Hush puppies were great. Also had an appetizer of crawfish corn bread and that was amazing!!! read more

Really really really good fresh food. Yum yum sauce was amazing. Can't wait to go back again. Friendly and excellent service. Outside and inside seating. read more

The owner takes pride in his restaurant and every element of the food he serves. He takes the time to get to know his customers. We had an amazing lunch and would highly recommend. Do not judge this book by its cover!! read more

This is my new spot to eat in Avoyelles Parish. The food is outstanding, and the service is just as good. I'm a huge fan of the taco salad, as their shrimp had just the right kick to them. read more

The reviews are correct! Great place! A lot bigger than it looks from the outside. This is the kind of place where you get the feeling that the owners are hard working people. The burger with sour dough bread is great! I love it when I find a home town place like this. We had lunch. The sign says crawfish tonight. Might have to come back for that read more

Excellent service and the food is delicious. The prices are very reasonable for the quality and amount of food. Be sure to try the Yum Yum sauce! read more

Stephens Heads Or Tails - Seafood Near Me - Marksville, Louisiana

Great salads!!! In Marksville for work and the healthy food options are bleak. You'd never think a little seafood shamal would have the freshest salad in town! read more

Best burger I've ever had! Also their cat fish yum yum is delicious! Fried (or grilled) catfish with this amazing white based yum yum sauce on top. read more

Excellent food and great service. The owner, Brian Stephens, takes time to visit with customers and always aims to please. As others have said, the yum yum sauce is delicious. Don't miss this place when in Marksville. In fact, make a special trip just to go there. You won't regret it! read more