Great place. Not fancy. Not pretentious. Have lived in Nazareth for 25 years and picked up treats at different merchants but finally stopped in at the real location today and left with a happy assortment of gluten free treats for my wife and some other things for the rest of the family. The (owner?) was super friendly and helpful. I look forward to stopping back. read more

I went to my local farmers market in Cape Coral Florida and came upon Shehly's table. The variety pack on little turnovers were amazing. The owner said he was in the process of moving to our area. This will be a great addition to our city. read more

The worst carrot cake I ever had. Super greasy and frosting was gross. Didn't finish eating it. Got a stomach ache and nausea. Stay clear.

Fabulous and friendly. In case you don't know, kiffles are a Hungarian pastry kinda like a cannoli but with fruit inside. They were yummy and the shoe fly pie was excellent! read more

wow...This place is a local, top notch, authentic bake shop for homemade kiffles, pasties, and breakfast sandies. If you dont know what a 'pasty' is, I highly recommend you try one of their varieties. This place is also very dog friendly so bring your furry friend. I did not try the coffee this time but I will return. read more

Stehly's Bakery and Eatery - Stehly's Bakery and Eatery in Nazareth, PA - Bakeries Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Finally, a decent quality sandwich shop. Homemade meats and locally sourced bread. I appreciated the time put into the sandwiches. The tastes of the meats were delightful. Only complaint was choices of beverages and seating area. Had the Anthony with a sprightly dressing and tasty home cooked meats. I would defiantly stop here again for a meal. read more

Love the new opening where it's a little more accessible compared the establishment before. They still sell the same pies and pastries which is great because we are fans of their blueberry and apple pie. We tried their sandwiches as well and have to say they are delicious! We ordered the grilled cheese and jake sandwich. Huge portions which is enough to share with another person. Will be coming back and maybe eating here. read more

A total hidden gem of the Lehigh Valley! We had amazing sandwiches and their fantastic homemade tomato soup today and were blown away. Their coleslaw happened to be the best I may have ever had! Now that I know it exists, I'll be in Nazareth a lot more! read more

Kiffles! I have been enlightened! NEVER even dreamed these existed. A small pastry/cookie/fruit stuffed/baked roll up! What a yummy sweet treat. But I get ahead of myself. We all had the same roasted/smoked pork sandwich with pickles and a serving of cole slaw. Everything was perfect. The roll was toasted and the sandwich served with mayo mustard and pickles. Every bite a delight. Oh. . . And we had cheese and potato pirogies, freshly made. And NOW to the kiffles . . . Of which I had never heard of before. The owner was so kind and did his best to educate me on these delightful baked bites. He gave us plenty before we decided which kinds to purchase. And believe me I wanted a box of each kind. To sum it up, GO ! There is obviously live music, great food and fresh coffee. On my list of favorite places to be sure! read more

Had a breakfast sandwich and was pretty happy with it. The kaiser roll was very good. Would like to see an assortment of more breakfast items, bagels, and sandwiches though since Nazareth has nothing like that right now. Just diners and pizza shops. Update: went there again. Had dinner. Soup and sandwich. Tremendous soup and owner suggested a jalapeño Cheese on my grilled cheese...it was tremendous. Also, my wife "built" her own sandwich since the owner said he can make her anything. It was also tremendous. I can't stress the importance of going to local food joints in town. This town needs more places like this with more foot traffic. read more

Stopped by cause I heard it was a new place by the former owner of the pie shop. I was not disappointed. The food was really good has great atmosphere friendly workers and of course great baked goods. I recommend that everyone give this place a try if you are in the Nazareth area. read more

To be fair, we went there after a storm hit the area but even though the owner/manager - not sure which, apologized profusely about the food coming out slow, that was not nearly the start of their issues. Their waitress took forever to come take our order and she was just not someone that you would want touching your food. The food was average at best, we were there around 11ish. The place is dirty and although interesting with all of the wall hangings and full stage in the middle of the place, I would not eat here again nor would I come back for late night entertainment. read more

Love how they make you feel like family and open mic night is great! Recommend the Justin. Love that sandwich ! Also they have some great local acts! read more

Stopped by on Sunday 5/28/17 for the first time and it won't be my last. I heard this place had the best pies and I love fruit pie but can never find one that isn't a canned, gooey, sugary mess. I bought the mixed berry pie and it was absolutely delicious. Berries were fresh and not too sweet just perfect. Can't wait to go back again and try a sandwich next time. This is my new happy place!!!! read more

Was getting my car serviced down the street early in the morning, this was one of the only places open. Wonderful atmosphere, friendly staff, solid food. The instruments hung throughout the establishment really make the place unique. I highly recommend swinging by if you get the chance. read more

While we did not sample the pies and things this place seems to specialize in, we did however, decide to try the breakfast/brunch type menu, keeping it very simple within the limited menu: egg bacon and cheese sandwich and toasted bagel with cream cheese, and coffee. The Dark Roast coffee was called "Punch in the Face" and was anything but; it was totally watery and gross, stored in thermoses usually demarcated for special or flavored coffee. Not fresh at all, and gave my wife an acidy stomach. The bagels were from a supplier obviously, and not a very good one, plastic-sealed bagels which tasted disgusting as hell, not even exaggerating here! The cream chese was in a prefab plastic container but tasted either out of date/sour or was maybe not even actually cream cheese? I am NOT exaggerating! I threw my entire bagel away, it was not edible. My wife ate half and got sick from it :( The Egg sandwich was not horrible, but not great either. I did ask for scrambled, got fried, asked for salt and pepper, didn't get it, and the swiss cheese was unmelted. I feel bad saying this but this place is a disaster. :( read more