I drive all the way from Batesville, IN to Colerain to get my Stehlin's fix! It is truly the best around, and worth the drive! I love Stehlin's so much, I featured them on my blog. https://karenpopecannady.blogspot.com/2020/04/feature-friday-stehlins-meat-market.html read more

Everything is always good & fresh . Great selection and sometimes hard to find items. Great helpful knowledgeable personnel.

Always the highest quality meats and great service. A great selection of meats and other fine food. You know what you are getting with Stehlin's. read more

Always a large selection to choose from . Service is always friendly and fast. I always get the salted rye bread they have available to go along with the fresh roast beef. read more

Hands down, the best meat market in Cincinnati. I highly recommend their Goetta, their sausages are incredible too

Believe it or not, finding great ethnic sausage in Cincinnati isn't easy. It's a brats and metts town. We had family down from northern Ohio and struck out at jungle Jim's and Kroger's. LK is at Findlay market but not in a really safe area of town. We found Stehlin's! Super nice and we got a fresh batch of garlic sausage and cheese sausage. They were fabulous! I highly recommend. Worth the drive across town for us lame East siders read more

This used to be one of my favorite places to go. They always had a case full of fresh variety sausages which were my favorite. Their bratwurst are the best in Cincinnati. The last couple of times I've gone in there the varieties about half of what it used to be. Most of it is prepackaged up and he can't get the fresh made stuff anymore. It's kind of a drive for me and if I can't get what I want I'm not going back. Not recommended anymore. Really a shame. read more

Unless you are a regular they don't treat you very kind at this place. I stood in line while 2 people cut in front of me to checkout.. I just let it go. then as soon as I get up to the register.. the guy walks away to talk to a "regular"? another worker comes up to the cash register, looks RIGHT AT ME.. then looks over at another customer that just now finished getting what he needs and waves him over and says "here I'll check you out".. WTF? Lol I laughed and left my stuff sitting there and walked out. I use to be a regular here.. I'd come in once a week but since I moved away I don't get to that area much. they've always been WAY over priced.. specially for stuff like Baked goods and their jarred stuff on the shelves (meats for sure since the quality isn't any better than a grocery store). I paid the prices because they were local and I wanted to support the smaller business. not anymore. There are far better meat markets in the area. read more

You shouldn't get your meat anywhere else. This place is ran by fantastic people with amazing knowledge and passion for the industry. Also very clean and organized I have bought filet from them several times never disappointed in the cut (how can I be?) or the service. Their twice-baked potatoes are also amazing - bake them about 5 minutes longer than instructions say though, trust me - DELICIOUS. We've also got their pulled pork and it was a huge hit I actually enjoy coming to pick up our food and seeing all the different cuts they have. Can't recommend this place enough. read more

They make the most AMAZING smoked sausage I've ever tasted. It's become a legend in my extended family. It's been fondly spoken of at every family event for over 60 years!!!! read more

My family and I go to a different butcher around town ever year to get meat for our 4th of July cookout. Each time they were very nice. This time we wanted to go somewhere close to home. When we got to the market my dad and I walked in to see how many people were in the building. As soon as we stepped foot in the building some guy yelled and screamed at us to get out and wait. He didn't even say please! Very rude! When we were able to get in after 2 people left the store, we went to go look for meat. No one greeted us. Personally the meat was way over priced for the portions they had. My dad and I decided that we could go somewhere better. We left and went somewhere else miles up the rode who were much more polite. read more

This old school butcher shop is the best. They have the best meat, and selection, and the guys are all friendly and fun.

I love Stehlin's. Freshly butchered on a weekly basis, they really take pride in their products. I think their pricing is incredibly reasonable considering they're locally owned and butchering on site. You're not getting some gosh knows how old meat from who knows where. Highly recommend the ham salad. I've gotten my entire family addicted to it - it's literally the best ham salad I've ever had. I also love their customer service and product selection. Since they butcher weekly on-site you can get all of those cuts you can't find anywhere else. Need a 6 lb skin-on pork belly? They'll put it aside for you. Looking for a boneless, fresh ham? They'll put it aside for you, then cut it to your specs and you'll know that the meat is fresh since it was butchered earlier that week. Support local businesses guys - this is a great family owned business. I grew up in Colerain, and now like in KY, but I still make the trek to pick up my special orders (or that ham salad). read more

Metts & goetta (if that's your thing)! A wonderful old-school butcher in Colerain with local meat and specialty items from lamb to seafood to deli. I have asked them for various items (lamb backs, for example) and they always come through. Prices are reasonable. While not "organic", most items are local which is a big plus. The spicy metts are awesome! read more

I just received the second half-cow that I've purchased that has been butchered at Stehlin's. The first time was okay but this second time I'm extremely disappointed. First cow: This was my first time getting a butchered cow. I was pressured to get my steaks cut in such a manner that they basically just ran them through a band saw. I was insistent that I did not want the bones in my steaks. For the most part they did that, although, there were a few. The roasts were cut in such a manner that they did not fit into my pots or crock pots, this was disappointing. On the whole it was a mediocre experience, but I was willing to use them again. Second cow: This time I ordered a half cow from a different rancher. When I called Stehlin's I was pressured to have my cow cut as I previously did. I get that this streamlines the process but I definitely wanted changes in how the cow was cut. When they called me to say they were getting ready to cut my cow they tried to get me to have it cut as I had previously, despite me already having placed my butchering order a few days before. Upon receiving my cow I discovered that it was butchered to about half of my specifications. Again, despite telling them that I wanted the roasts cut smaller, I still cannot fit them into my pots and crock pots. I was also told that double wrapping of butcher paper was not an option. I already knew that they do not vacuum seal. Summation: They have a clean operation. While they are not rude to you on the phone you get the distinct impression that they just want you to take the cow as they want to cut it and get you off the phone. The customer service aspect definitely needs work. I just paid a significant amount of money for the butchering but it was not correct and my order was extremely reasonable. The next time that I order a cow I will definitely go out of my way to order from someone who does not have their butchering done at Stehlin's. read more

Amazing quality and even better customer service. We have been going there for the past 10 years and have never been disappointed.

Bought a 12lb brisket untrimmed from here for 88 dollars. Found the exact same brisket (Excel brand) for 35 dollars at GFS. $7.30 lb compared to $2.89 lb. First and last time I will ever purchase meat at Stehlins. read more

Stehlins is one of the last places in Cincinnati where you can walk a cow in and take it home a week later in small, white packages. The butchering facility is c-l-e-a-n as a pin, the Stehlin brothesr and their team are super nice and helpful. If you are looking for an old-school family butcher, supplier of hogs for a neighborhood hog roast, purveyor of beef tongues or fresh pork cracklins -- this is your place. A+++. read more

Amazing service, incredible quality meats. The perfect place to buy meat. Always a treat to be able to shop there when in Colerain.

Location is great. Staff is super helpful and friendly. Customer service is super here. Take a number is important as they get busy in a moments notice. I have been here several times because the service is so good. The meat is local and that's good. Fresher than any box store of course. Try a sample cheese pack the cost is low and the different flavors is good snack read more

This is the real deal. Butchers that know where your cut of meat comes from, and can answer your questions about cooking or grilling. I'm a regular for the home made chili w/ beans, and the the Ravioli they carry is Russo's brand ravioli. The cheese is the best. Its an easy weekday dinner to make for the kids. Love this place, also try the goetta. read more

Friendly, knowledgable service. I love that everything is local. I have been coming here for years. I just wish they would sell there products in grocery stores, so I could cut down my drive time. read more

I give 2 stars since the meat is decent. However, the service I just received was ridiculous. I called in an order in advance of coming into the store. I stood at the register for about 10 minutes before anyone acknowledged me. Once finally acknowledged, I was told I had to take a number. I explained I was only picking up a call in order, and I was told I needed a number anyway. Mind you, about 5 people had walked in after me and already had numbers since Ive been waiting to be helped. The guy then told me, he knew I had been waiting awhile already, but I still needed to take a number. From this disturbing experience, I will no longer be shopping for my meats at Stehlins. read more

As a special treat for a friend of mine in the Armed Services and his family, I ordered 6 porterhouse steaks cut 1-3/4" thick. Everyone remarked that they were the best steaks they had ever eaten, that they almost melted in their mouths. My mouth is watering just talking about it. read more