Perfectly whimsical selection of antiques, salvaged treasures, books, vinyl and odds and ends…read moretucked in corners. Despite multiple laps around the store I still didn't get it all in. Owners are charming and I enjoyed wandering around on an overcast day. Found a couple little sparkles to warm up my home and remind me of how much I love the Cape.

Amazing antiques and such friendly and helpful people! Lots of variety and more space than it looks…read morelike from the outside.

I recently got into collecting vinyl after picking up a new turntable, and while I had some extra…read moretime in Natick, I decided on a whim to see if there was a local record store nearby. The first time I stopped by, it was closed, but I called anyway. Eleni answered, and she couldn't have been kinder. She's hard of hearing, but she was incredibly warm, enthusiastic, and genuinely excited to open up and help me find the kinds of records I was looking for. I'm really glad I went back. The selection was great, and what stood out even more was the atmosphere. A couple of other people were there chatting, helping her out, and digging through records of their own. It felt like a true neighborhood record store where people gather because they love music. That's getting harder to find these days. If you're in the area and enjoy vinyl, it's absolutely worth a visit. Just remember to bring cash, because it's cash only. Small businesses like this deserve the support.

Very cool variety, Very cheap and the lady who runs the shop is quite nice. you really should visit…read morethis hidden gem of a shop!

Great antique store... with a lot of wonderful Knick-knacks, stuff, and needful things…read more Multi-sellers vie for a space to sell their wares. A big building, a good layout, and there is a barn next door too. Walking through was nice as I did not feel as though I'd bump into something. Been there in September '25, and January '26 nice and reasonably priced. Very nice staff.

Obviously, everything on Cape Cod during the summer is going to be pricey. This place is no…read moreexception ... you'd do much better on a lot of the stuff on EBay or at a garage sale, for sure. But, its fun to look ... especially since it's rained almost every @%!& day in July and what else does one do in the rain on Cape Cod than browse and shop? First of all ... the used records pulled me in. The selection was pretty picked over. Barely any classic rock of note ... lots of jazz and eclectic stuff. However, HUGELY overpriced and the condition of many records was a bit rough. Some pricing examples ... The Doors, Soft Parade original in VG+ condition was $45. Owch. Lots of Beatles records for $30 - $100. Edith Piaf album I paid $2.50 for on EBay was over $12. You have to bring the copies of the over $15+ albums to the counter to inspect the condition. The vinyl section was crowded but honestly, not many bargains to be had. They have LOTS of stuff ... the store is a long barn and filled to the brim. There was a wall of 'vintage' Nautical paintings of sailors for $150 - $350, depending on the size. To me, they looked like they were painted recently. While cool, in a retro-kitchy fashion, the price was steep for a faux vintage Sea Captain painting. There were cases of old toys, costume jewelery and other antique stuff. I saw a couple authentic British Pub signs for $500 which were cool. They had some vintage cameras but many were untested and the same price as the tested ones online. The vintage typewriters had keys which were stuck and were priced the same as tested working ones online. I walked out empty-handed but I give 4 stars because it was a good way to spend an hour browsing on a rainy day. The only thing I was considering buying was a jazz record I wanted to listen to that night but it had a pretty scuffed surface, so I passed. Three people in front of me bought records ... maybe they were luckier or less picky. You may find something cool here but don't plan on finding inexpensive treasure. At the very least its fun to look.

I spent about an hour and a half here today. Small but awesome store. The stuff he has on hand is…read moreall quality, with a lot of great specialty and limited edition stuff. The owner is a super nice guy and a wealth of knowledge. He has been in the record store business for almost 40 years. If you ever find yourself on Cape Cod, check him out. Also, Bad Brains and Blood Swear and Tears will be coming hole with me!

The records here are super over priced, if the record is brand new you're spending 5-20 dollars…read moreover market value, guaranteed. I'm very familiar with the typical prices of vinyl records and I didn't see a single normally priced new record, and I'm not exaggerating. The used records here a quite pricey as well, especially any record that's particularly popular. They'll charge you 50 dollars for a Led Zeppelin used record that's not a particularly note worthy pressing. I took a look at 45s they have as well because usually you can find some cool stuff for only a few bucks at most record stores but there was nothing cheaper than $5 here, I'm less familiar with the market value of 45s but every single one felt double what it should be. The only reason is I'm not giving this store a 1/5 is that the walls have a bunch of cool music memorabilia. They also have some cool signed records like a zombies record that's was signed by the whole band for $400, which for the right person is totally worth it. Unless you're looking for something that is exceptionally rare or signed I wouldn't recommend this place for any casual customers.

This place is awesome!!! So many things to look at. Many different kinds of music, t shirts,…read moreposters and more! Definitely a good spot to hit if you're visiting Cape Cod, such as myself

This place is not your typical Cape Cod souvenir store. Instead, you'll walk into a haven of used…read morevinyl, racks of band T-shirts, enamel pins, and patches. The kind of vibe that makes you want to hang out for way too long. The record selection is surprisingly deep. You can tell the person curating it actually loves music. It's the kind of place that feels like a secret, even if it's right on Main Street. If you're into music, style, or just trying to avoid another overpriced hoodie that smells like sunscreen, this store is a must.

A little bit of this... and a little bit of that! My head was weaving and bobbing like a kid in a…read morerecord store! Great new and used vinyl. Speakers, components, turntables, and accessories. Very good prices. Wicked friendly staff. Will most certainly come back and get more vinyl - thanks!

Bought some great stuff and had fun talking to the owner. Went back a second day and bought a…read moreslabbed book. Cracked it open and cleaned and pressed it.

Excellent visit for vacation "souvenirs" :-) On the surface PSR seems to focus on the heavier side…read morebut in fact has a well curated plentiful selection of mainstream classic rock, metal, glam, pop, prog etc vinyl from the 60s to the present. Both sealed new and good condition used LPs are fairly priced and clearly organized. Great store branded merch. Shirts for the whole family! In-store music is played at a pleasant level. Best of all owner and All Sinners drummer Roger is friendly, knowledgeable about his stock and the industry. We get some of his background and he is equally engaged with his regular customers and tourist customers and was interested in where we came from and our experience. The family was perfectly comfortable browsing and chatting with Roger while I hunted in the bins. Was glad to see PSR has a discogs store for me to bookmark and browse. Thanks Roger! From Andy and Family from NJ.

Great shop, great customer service. Roger is the best. Such a cool place to poke around in.read more

Great store with a wide variety of titles/topics. Clean and very organized. Owner is very…read moreknowledgeable and helpful. Convenient parking.

Once I walked through the door I was greeted by a strong smell of incense. Walking down the narrow…read morestairs to the shop are retro 80's movie posters on the walls. The store is a bit small but it is fully stocked with used books, board games, retro video games and figurines. Friendly staff. Fair prices!

Call it Vintage, Retro, Throwback, whatever you want, but if you live/love kitsch this place is it…read morefor Cape Cod! Movie posters, comics, clothing, memorabilia, vinyl records, pretty much anything and everything you either lost or missed from your childhood is here! Generation gaps be damned! The owner Rick is a hands-on lover of the old school whose knowledge far outstrips any normal mortal. He is a compendium of the rare and treasured. Casual browsers or hardcore buyers, this is one spot not to be overlooked.

Well curated vintage shop specializing in weird and unique old toys, records, movie posters,…read morekitchenware, etc. The owner Rick knows his stuff and it seems that everything in the store has an interesting story behind it. They buy and sell and always have new things every time I visit. I'd recommend this place over the other used toy shops simply for his honesty and quality and uniqueness of merchandise.

DO NOT go here!!! I, a paying customer, and loyal tourist of 10 years, was at this store and this…read moreguy Doug was crazy and screaming at young girls in the store, don't know if he's the owner or what but please don't go here. I am trying to reach out to others to have this man removed from his job because of how horrid that was.

I love Newberry comics so much. The service here is always incredible. All of the people working…read morehere are so nice and very helpful. They have a large selection of Funko pops record, CDs, comic books, etc.. All of their products are good value and fairly priced. They often have good deals and sales making everything more affordable.