Absolute best Buffalo chicken wings around. Scratch sauce with 2 levels of heat -- sure to please. The extra epoxy got me and the regular for the family. Always have packed , could use more music and lightning -- but I get it that lots of bar people like to watch sports. Generally friendly and cordial service with a blarney. Cheers ! read more

Popped in for a quick drink with the neighbor, and this is truly a neighborhood Irish pub. The menu leans on Irish food staples, and while I've had better salmon and toast as a starter, the short rib sandwich had an excellent braised short rib that fell apart in the mouth, delicious, the bread didn't hold up much (maybe could have used a garlic or horseradish aioli?), and the shoestring fries were ok, definitely needed the ketchup. Seating at the bar was a bit crowded. Jimmy the bartender was great in service but busy, but the seat I had was right behind the taps so I didn't have much space for the plate of food -- recommend getting a table next time or watch where you want to sit - plenty of space for a glass of beer, but not for a plate. The half plate of wings - a lot of garlic parm sauce on top, and while not the best wings (lacked any crisp), the sauce was nice and thick and heavy - albeit salty, but that's ok for wings. The sauce there actually did the fries good. Lots of TVs and street parking or muni lot parking (free after 6p weekdays). read more

See all

Place is pretty good, servers are always friendly. Manager was rude. We had something corrected on the check and she comes out, doesnt say anything, looks mad, and when we said thanks have a good night she walks away all mad and says nothing. It was such a minor correction on the check and we were nice about it so like what are you mad about read more

Stopped in for a quick drink with friends at this great neighborhood spot. It's always packed, with friendly bar service, solid cocktails, and fries you should definitely order. read more

Been here from the beginning. Great family business, good people & phenomenal atmosphere. Great place to unwind if you either get off the train, finish a round of golf (Maplewood C.C.) or taking a break from Home Depot. Excellent beer selection, select wines & great food. Oh, great place to catch soccer (or most any sport) read more

Dismal dining experience on Dailey quiet Sunday early evening with 40% capacity. Staff looked and served as if they most certainly didn't want to be there. We've been going for years and have seen a precipitous decline in food - and we focused on pub food which is generally their "bread and butter". All food items were overcooked and simply tasteless. Silverware was slapped down on the table in a mountain for us to distribute. Empty glasses and dishes left on the table well after we finished each and wanted to order more which made for a chaotic and unappetizing scene. Sadly removing this from a dining option and may only join for a quick beer. read more

Had diner here this evening with my wife. Inside has a very typical Irish Pub feel. It was a beautiful evening so we ate outside where they have several tables and it's perfect for people watching. We started off with a couple drinks. Beer was ice cold and refreshing. For dinner we shared a house salad and asked for balsamic vinaigrette on side. We got a side of just balsamic vinegar. Salad was just ok. For mains my wife got the salmon over a bed of spinach and loved it. I got the shepherds pie and honestly it was a major disappointment. It looked good, but really was lacking. Chopped meat filling had zero taste and was dry. Almost no sign of any vegetables except for a few very finely chopped carrots( barely perceptible) . A real fail for a dish that should be featured at an Irish pub. Service was adequate. I gave it 3 stars based on my wife enjoying her meal. If it were based on my dish it would be one star. Must be a reason they were the only place in town with empty tables. Probably won't be returning. read more

St James's Gate Publick House - Shepherds Pie - Pubs Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

The food is somehow decent, but I'm sorry the service is horrendous... Decor ambience is nice but the service definitely doesn't want me to come back read more

Good menu. Tasty burgers & fries. Friendly service & pleasant atmosphere. The fireplace in winter is especially welcoming.

BEFORE I BEGIN MY REVIEW A REMINDER, THEY USE A MICROWAVE TO WARM FOOD THARTS ALREADY COOKED.. THE FOOD IS NOT MADE FRESH........I order bbq chicken wings, first they was ready to quick, they microwave the wings and pour bbq sauce all over. Being that it was the evening they thought I wasn't paying attention. The wings was so hard you can feel it cutting your stomach on the inside taste like wood. I was chewing one wing forever. Wings are supposed to be cooked as order and sauce supposed to be cooked with it not cold bbq sauce on top. read more

Great local pub for a bite and a beer. No frills. Just a cold pint, a whiskey and a solid burger. I've had a few things on the menu and everything I've tried so far has been pretty good. If you are in the area stop in and have a beer. ENJOY!!! read more

See all

We have gone to St. James Gate each time we have traveled to Maplewood. When we walk through the curtain, we are transported to an Irish Pub in Dublin. They have food options for just about every palate. The service is hit-and-miss depending on the timing. read more

Great experience! Came here for brunch and we were pleasantly surprised :) Started off with pub fries and buffalo wings! Great start :) Then we ordered the brunch burger - amazingness! For drinks - mimosas were great! read more

See all

This place is only interested in serving you if you're white. My experience is thus: - told it would be 30 minute wait for table - other groups come in and get seated immediately - after 30 minutes, told to wait 30 more - more tables are seated - servers come to take orders and deliver drinks to other groups seated outside - my group told to order at bar - another 30 minutes passes and nothing There's only one difference I can see between my group and the others - race, and my group was primarily speaking Spanish. I got the distinct impression they would rather my group just leave. So we did! Cheers. read more

Let's start with the goods shall we? Great downtown location; nearby parking; extremely friendly staff. My boyfriend and I ordered LA's Crock of Cheese as an appetizer. Our dining mates went with chicken tenders (which I might add, looked like ready-to-eat tenders that had been microwaved). What arrived was an abomination of my tastebuds. If you had showed me a 6 year old was in the kitchen churning out orders, I wouldn't have been surprised. This excuse for a lunchable was the "crock of cheese"?! I'm not the person to send food back or cause a scene about my order, but this deserved it. Instead, I was shocked into silence. I could not, and STILL can not believe that they were willingly serving this. My entree was Shepherd's Pie. The #1 thing going for it was the tongue searing temperature. I'm known for liking my food HOT, but this was HOT until the very last bite. Perhaps, too hot then? It was edible but nothing to rave about. Overall, this entire experience was disappointing. read more

St James's Gate Publick House - Menu - Pubs Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all

What a lovely place to watch the World Cup. They were insanely busy, duh. But things were pretty held together considering. They didn't have any coffee, which kind of sucked (server said machine was broken). Mussels in cream sauce was yummy, my husband said his Reuben was forgettable. They have a lot of tvs and a nice atmosphere. All in all, a good place to watch a soccer match. read more

St James's Gate Publick House - a crowd of people watching a soccer game - Pubs Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all

Dined here for lunch, one of the only places open on a Monday afternoon. The decor is dark but comfortable. We sat and were greeted quickly. I ordered a cosmo and appetizers. Everything was good, typical bar food. Our waiter was great too. Would come here again. read more

St James's Gate Publick House - Pubs Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

What the hell kind of Irish Pub runs out of fish and chips? Seriously, we were the first ones in the restaurant this evening at 5:30 pm. We waited for the last two people in our party to show up who got here by 5:45 p.m. and we were totally ignored until approximately 6:30. I did not get my replacement meal until everyone else had been able to finish theirs in our party of eight. When I got it, they had not let it rest long enough, it was too hot, and I burned my lip. read more

St James's Gate Publick House - Pubs Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

Great Irish pub! Great vibe and staff! Perfect to go for St Patrick's day or soccer games! Large variety of beer! Good location and easy parking! read more

What's going on NJ? Another 1 star for horrible food, bad service and shabby worn interior. I ordered Fish & Chips and got 2 pieces of burnt wood. It was so burnt yet served. Coleslaw? I've never had marinated chunks before, hope I never do again. Fries too were burnt and tasteless. Changed my hockey-puck to a Corn-beef sandwich. It was little scraps of corn-beef, not sliced. Server Grace was not graceful, more like clueless. Restaurant was very worn and tattered. Oh, and all served with a flat Ginger-ale . Burp read more

We go here constantly. Burgers are always extremely solid. Good beer. Service is super quick. Plus, love watching the soccer games. Love this place. read more

Cute, cozy, in a picturesque downtown. That whole area is a hidden gem in central jersey.

"Excuse me waiter but, I didn't order the BLACKENED FISH N CHIPS. Oh!. Then it's burnt!" Hmmm, who would have thought? (See photo). Hard to believe that the chef/cook would let this out for service and the waiter let it pass as well. The CHIPS tasted as if they had been sitting under a heat lamp for well more than an hour. The SHEPHERD'S PIE had an off after taste and the meat inside had the not-tenderized chew of ground horse meat. Ridiculous, that in order to post the review, one must give it a minimum of 1 star. Why is there no icon of a skeleton with crossbones or better yet, the devil with my option of selecting multiple pitch-forks? IMO, this is one case that the restaurant should be turned over to an owner that has the appropriate skills to make the place into a deserving establishment. read more

St James's Gate Publick House - Burnt Fish n Chips! - Pubs Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

Food and service is great! Employees are friendly. One thing I would change, orderd a burger, medium, the patty was burnt Service and employees were great overall. read more

Great spot!Irish pub right here in NJ!! Get a Guinness and chicken sandwich. The waiters and waitresses and bartenders treat you like family! read more

We visit friends who live in Maplewood from time to time. St James Gate is always a good option. Great beers. Really good pub food. Nice staff. Last time we sat at the bar and had the Sheperd's pie. First of all, it was huge. Second of all it was delicious. Since we could not finish it all, we took it home. It reheated really well and was just as good. The bartender said "We should use mashed potatoes as insulation. That will stay warm for hours" He's got a point! What really surprised us were the fries. We are fans of the crisp and thin french fery. I was expecting a think pub fry - not so fast! These were thin and crispy and HOT and I could have eaten an entire barrel of them. Can't wait for our next visit! read more

Horrible..... Ordered fish and chips. Fish was basically frozen fish sticks. Fries just ok. Grandson had Mac and Cheese that was so dry he didn't eat it. My son had the short rib sandwich which was dry and over cooked. Nice place though but probably won't go back. I hate paying for a terrible meal. read more

Relaxed bar/restaurant right in the middle of Maplewood village. The atmosphere is inviting and laid back. Decent selection of drinks and lots of seating at the bar and in the dining room. Would I return? Sure, sometimes you just need a bar that's just a hangout :) read more

St James's Gate Publick House - Bar area - Pubs Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

Came to dinner at St James's Gate last night after not being here in years. It's a nice but casual Irish pub. We were greeted right away and seated. The service wasn't great, just short and to the point. We ordered the Celtic Wings, Mac N Cheese with short rib, and a burger. The wings were great and a large portion. The burger was was fresh and cooked to perfection and on a soft toasted role. I really enjoyed it and would recommend. It came with a side of shoestring fries which we devoured. My husband's Mac n Cheese was okay. It's flavorful but not super creamy or cheesy. The short rib was tender and good. Not bad but don't expect it to be oozing with cheese. Overall a good experience. We'll be back so I recommend you check it out. read more

St James's Gate Publick House - Pubs Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all

Good food, nice pub atmosphere. Service was great for a busy Friday night. Seems like a popular local place.

A cool pub, had good food for what we ordered. But here's the issue: if I'm going to spend a whopping $32 on 2 casamigo margaritas, I expect to leave with a buzz. They tasted like straight up margarita mix..I was floored when I saw the price on the bill. Not cool! read more

can't imagine maplewood without it. not great when it comes to vegetarian options. my brother used to work there and they definitely need more bussing staff, the people there are overworked. friendly and warm atmosphere, fun decor. read more

Walked in for few drinks. Friendly service. A pub. With pub food and drinks. Exactly what you expect and want. Glad to see this on Main Street. We need more of these. read more

Overall decent experience. Went with a group and were seated outside. Appetizer of cheese/bacon fries was average. I got french onion soup which was pretty good, and a BLT with fries which was also okay. A solid choice for dinner downtown. read more

Absolute terrible Place to watch a game. Foods solid. If you want to watch something go elsewhere.

Service was slow and food wasn't good. We had a pretzel with cheese and the cheese was like the most liquid orange soup I've ever seen and we never saw a cheese like that before. I've given this place three tries now because the ambiance is good but it's finally time to call it due to service and food. read more

This has to be some of the worst service I have ever received from an establishment. There was one, highly inexperienced server taking orders for about 8 tables. Between taking our order and delivering our check (which I had to chase her down for) she never once checked our table. I had to chase down workers for water refills, the check, ketchup, you name it. No managerial staff on site to assist. To top it off, the place advertised $5 bloody Mary's and mimosas, but the check didn't reflect that. When I asked the waitress why my drink wasn't $5, she said I needed to specifically request it. What?! Then don't advertise it to the masses! Decent food for a bar, but otherwise, save your time and money and take your business to one of the many other options in the neighborhood. read more

One of the best meals I've had in NJ in a long time. You can taste the passion of the chefs love and respect for irish fare in every bite. Incredible Fisn N Chips. Perfectly cooked cod fish and beer battering. Many reviews on here seem to think that the breading on the Fish N Chips is burnt, but in fact, it is the flavorful Guinness beer battering that may give it that appearance to the untrained eye. The Pei Mussels are unrivaled in their rich white parmesan cream sauce. You'll want to lick the bowl clean. Their burgers, short rib, and reubens are all great sandwiches that you can't go wrong with. Would recommend this restaurant anyone who likes rich and robust flavors where a pint of Guinness will pair with everything on the menu. Simply put, the closest you'll get to the soul food of ireland without traveling thousands of miles away. read more

I found this place very enjoyable. There was some controversy post-dinner, as my sister (who was the one who selected the restaurant) insisted that the vegetables in her Bubbles and Squeak were insufficiently varied. As long as my dinner is edible, I'll give it five stars. I'm not picky about food. But I'm infuriated by bad service and the service at St. James was excellent. Attentive and friendly. Plus there's a bookstore a few doors away and we strolled in to do some browsing after our meal. Lovely town, Maplewood. read more

Love the hot wings - they are actually hot and tasty! Also a decent Shepard' pie. The service is great, love the vibe!