Square Peg is the perfect blend of Italian comfort food with modern day aesthetic. It still gives that warm and cozy family feel while also bringing in a classic bar, variety of seating, and large windows to bring in a lot of natural light. Their menu is amazing. They offer all of the typical Italian dishes, but what really gets me is their happy hour. They offer an entire personal pizza for $6! It was more than enough for two people to share. It was served fresh out of the oven and was absolutely amazing. Unfortunately, I was in so excited to eat it that I forgot to take a photo!!!! You will have to take my word that it was perfect. I also ordered a margarita, which didn't have the best tequila but did the job. It was very bitter, but I was just happy they offered cocktails since many places only serve wine. Overall, after coming here with a group of about 15, I loved it. The servers were super friendly and asked if we wanted to split the bill prior to serving, were accommodating with seating, and had excellent food. This was a great experience and I recommend for people looking to meet up with a large group. read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

The food is usually pretty consistent and the vibe is always great but today I am reviewing the service and my recent experience. Service was extremely slow. I had to ask for water 3 times before receiving it. I asked for extra napkins that never arrived. I had to get up and retrieve them myself from the bar. Our pizza came but we were never given the red pepper, cheese, and oregano - and since our waitress (who was also subbing as the hostess) was MIA - I had to go up to the food prep area and ask for those items myself. After being a 'regular' and showing up weekly for their Bingo event for the past 5 months, we were pushed out of the Bar after someone reserved 9 seats (which is almost the entire bar area). This was the 1st time we have ever seen 'reserved' signs. When I questioned this their only response was: well, you can make a reservation too. I would have thought that some loyalty would have applied. I'm hoping that corporate is aware that even if your food is good - if you're rude to the customers - word does get out. I made my reservation for next week - so we will see how that goes! read more

See all

Served its purpose. Pizza Thin crust and sauce not too sweet. We had a quick lunch. Serve was a Little off even though the Place Was Empty. read more

I'll start off with, I'll give them another chance soon. Seeing as this was my first visit, it had hiccups. The drinks were served the fastest, and then the salad (which was delicious). But everything there after went down hill. We waited 30-40 mins on the pizza, and when we did receive it, the pepperoni was burned, and the dough was quite hard. Service could have been way more attentive seeing as it wasn't busy. With that being said, I did enjoy the tvs and March Madness on all of them, and did find it impressive that they offer free pizza making classes for kids (my son will attend soon). So, as much of a rocky first impression it was, I'm still going to come back and try again. read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

Manager vaping at the food counter. This is unacceptable in my book. We have went there quite often since it opened. The service has become mediocre but the food was good. After this I will be looking for somewhere else to eat. read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - Manager vaping - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

We came here for lunch and it was fairly quiet. We got the margarita pizza and it was delicious especially the sauce. I recommend it when stopping by. Overall it was clean and service was wonderful! read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

See all

This is a very traditional fun type pizza place that serves other Italian classics but it's the pizza that you go make for. Crispy crust is my favorite. Great happy hour and bingo on Sundays. Great for couples. Staff is pleasant and efficient read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

This place I really hadn't noticed, but it's in a great location, right off Atlantic in the mall with Publix, Chick Fil-a, Carvel, etc. It's a large place, a great corner spot. Never heard of it, but it is part of an expanding small chain that's based in Connecticut, with a few locations. The owner happened to be in the house, so was interesting to talk to. He has the right idea, interested in providing a great experience for the guest, would like to make this into a large national chain. Pretty ambitious... so we'll see. I thought their Pepperoni Pizza was very good, fresh and good crust. I just picked one up to try, so no comments on dining in... but the staff was very accommodating. RECOMMENDED read more

See all

Got pizza to go from here. Was a decent slice for a decent prize. Will have to go back to try some more of their items read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

Wow! What a great pizza! Super clean, excellent service and great food. Absolutely nothing to complain about. Go there!!!

Upon arriving at the Delray Beach Amtrak Station, to visit a dear friend of mine for the weekend, my friend took me to Square Peg Pizzeria. We were greeted with smiles. The place was bright and lively with a DJ offering dance tunes. My friend & I opted to sit at the bar. The bartender was very attentive & friendly. We ordered specialty cocktails- Negroni & The Burbs Martini. Both were refreshing and tasty. We shared a Small Truffle Boscaiola Pizza which was presented with just the right amount of toppings and included six slices. The bartender also supplied garlic powder & parmesan cheese. My friend & I each ordered a glass of wine afterwards. The bathrooms are clean and there is plenty of parking in the open lot. Several people sat at the bar as well as large groups in the dining area. I recommend Square Peg Pizzeria and look forward to a return visit. read more

See all

Came here for a kids pizza making event and of course mama had to eat too!!! Cool thing is, they have a happy hour everyday, so I waited until 2 and ordered my food which included a side Caesar, mozzarella sticks and a one topper pizza. Pizza is wood fired so it's very good. Mozzarella sticks were pretty good as well and so was the Caesar. Service was a bit slow because despite there being 4-5 ppl here, there was only 1 woman serving tables. My daughter's free pizza came out piping hot where as mine felt like they let it sit for a few minutes before being delivered.Overall, it was a good experience and I would come back for the happy hour. No frills kinda chill family place with games and you can watch the games on their TVs. Good food for the value. read more

Came here for dinner with friends. Did not eat inside due to a loud Bingo game going on So we sat outside. Service was ok. Ordered Ceaser salad which was decent. Boneless chicken wings were actually fried chicken tenders. They were ok. The Detroit Pizza for $29 was really bad and I rate a lot of restaurants. There was no sauce or cheese on the pizza just burnt bread. I told the waitress and she just shrugged it off. We paid the bill and left. Just because my experience was 2 stars does mean yours will be. read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - Detroit style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

I like Square Peg Pizza. The crust is puffed and doughy, they slightly over cheese, and they use a tangy tomato sauce. Each slice had very little flop but big on flavor. I especially like their cupped pepperoni. Once cooked, they are a little greasy in a good way and crispy. I had their hot-honey chicken wings. I'd skip them next go around. Square Peg has a pretty decent happy hour that ends at 7. A side salad, 2 small 12" pizzas, 2 Chianti's and a dessert ran us about $60 including tip. I hope Square Peg makes it. It's a large place, with not enough customers. The shopping center where it is located is on the corner of Military and Atlantic. There's terrible signage and very little visibility from the street. I've been there twice and unfortunately the help, while super nice, are kinda clueless. read more

See all

Came here with our church youth (a group of about 25 people) on a Thursday evening and we were greeted with the kindest hostess. We are a big group so we always expect it to be chaotic when we go anywhere. We were immediately seated and given water and plates. We ordered a variety of pizzas and wings for the whole table. The wings were 10/10- they were absolutely phenomenal. Extra crispy with the right amount of sauce!! The pizza was also amazingggg!! I had a slice of the prosciutto and arugula and was obsessed. The rest of the table also enjoyed the buffalo chicken and pepperoni. I will definitely be back here again (and maybe our whole group again lol)!! Side note- I apologize for the poor pictures as the food was so good that I began eating before I took a picture! read more

See all

It's new used to be Zima! This is wayyyyy better! O M G I had the meatballs and Itilian olives and it was damn near organismic! The meat balls are HUGE and the olives will make you slap your Itilian grandmother! So zesty and good! BUT wait, there's MORE! Happy hour Friday and Saturday 8:30 - 11:00pm! This is most def on the rotation! This is new and awesome! read more

Tried this place the other night and was genuinely impressed. I do want to start with a caveat though, the underside of my pizza was ever so slightly beyond the char and crossing over into the burnt territory but I ate most of it anyway and it was phenomenal. I just wish 75% of the pizza wasn't burned on the underside. I did take out so I couldn't bring it to their attention without calling and complaining and I'm not that type. The cheese they use feels different than what you're used to on a pizza but tasted and presented amazing. My wife got a pasta dish and was raving about how great it was. We will definitely try this place again, I'll admit my expectations were medium but I was truly surprised and happy with what we received. read more

I have eaten a lot of pizza since we located here eight years ago, but never, ever have I had this horrendous pizza at this place. The crust doesn't even taste like pizza dough, the cheese is bland and tasteless and the pizza sauce what little there was of it, was hardly edible. Is no wonder the place was empty considering the quality of the food. Do yourself a favor go to a real pizza restaurant. read more

New Favorite Alert! Just discovered The Square Peg Pizzeria, and WOW, what a gem! Fabulous food at fabulous prices. Great friendly service & beautiful ambiance. We couldn't get enough of their giant meatball during Happy Hour for only $6 (yes, you read that right!). We danced the night away thanks to the sensational Jammin' Jimmy Carillo, who kept the energy sky-high with crowd-favorite hits. This place truly has something for everyone: Dinner & Dancing, Game Nights, Bingo & Trivia, Pizza-making classes for kids & adults & Community fundraisers. It's more than a restaurant . it's an experience. We're already planning our return. Best of luck to the entire team at The Square Peg. You've got something really special! read more

See all

Delicious food! The gluten free pizza in particular was amazing. The wings were good too. We ordered delivery, so I didn't get to go inside. But, I've heard it's great. The delivery was quick and arrived BEFORE scheduled to. I love the buffalo chicken pizza with the creepy pieces on it. read more

See all

Some of our friends had been to Square Peg Pizzeria's Happy Hour and recommended it to us so we decided to give it a try today. When we arrived at the time HH started which was 2PM, we were greeted by their very welcoming waitress, Jasmine who told us that we could choose any table we wanted. The restaurant is large and they have tables for 4 or more, some were high tops and they also have a bar where you can also sit. The tables around the perimeter also had padded bench seats... my fav! They also have a few xl TV screens around the restaurant. We told Jasmine that our friends recommended their Happy Hour so she gave us that menu. We asked Jasmine for her recommendations based on our tastes. Her input was so awesome!! Our wings were seasoned with Square Peg seasoning and now I am highly recommending it! We got both the blue cheese and the ranch dip. YUM!! The 2 mozzarella sticks were the size of eggrolls! No kidding! And then the pizza came out. Hot, cheesy, crispy and just right. Definitely New Haven style and an excellent version of that! Before we finished, Matt, the manager of Square Peg, came over to our table and introduced himself and wanted to know how we liked the food and restaurant. We both told him we were ultra impressed with everything... the restaurant, the food, Jasmine, the service. Matt told us about all the nighttime activities they have - Karaoke, Bingo, ... the parties they've made, the parties that people have made there! And what's coming!! Oh boy!! This is A PLACE TO WATCH WHAT'S HAPPENING!!! There's a lot going on here so keep up with their doings!!!! I didn't know what I've been missing! Oh, and soon... outdoor dining, for those of us with doggos, we can bring them with us!! Thank you Jasmine and Matt for a great Happy Hour today!!! We loved Square Peg Pizzeria and will be back for Happy Hour and a delicious dinner soon! Soooo goood! read more

See all

Edit: After some frustration the volume was increased, apologies were made, and free desert offered. We will return, the food was phenomenal. Very frustrated. I am writing this review as we are sitting in the restaurant. We came here to watch the Super Bowl and we're told that the sound would be on and all we are hearing is CNC music factory and watching the game on a couple of TVs . They are promoting the game they have balloons, but the fun of the game is the sound. Doubt we will come back even if the food is phenomenal so disappointed. read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - Promting the super bowl but no sound? - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

Yelpers please ease up on the 4-5 stars. Maybe you have only eaten little Caesar's your whole life. This place is ok, they are definitely trying to grow into what they really want to be. The comparison to New Haven pizza is way off. The pizza is ok nothing great, I would suggest that if they want to stay open to quickly elevate the quality of the pizza and ingredients. I'm not a fan of precooked boxed sausage crumbles on my pizza. A $30 pizza requires the best quality ingredients. Also New Haven pizza doesn't flop this pizza is very is very floppy. The salads are great very fresh and I like that the owner/managers come around. I think one probably needs to work the oven until the pizza gets better. read more

Food is great, atmosphere is a vibe. A little pricy, but they do have some good specials.

Lots of parking easy to find! Missed the amazing happy hour prices but will be back!! I had the margherita pizza and house salad and it all came out very quickly. Both were sooo good. read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - happy hour - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

I only write Yelp reviews when a place is really good or really bad. Judging by my 1 star I think you can take a guess of why I'm here. I ordered a Cheese Detroit Style pizza which was $27 for the smallest and most unappetizing pizza i've had in town and i've lived here for 18 years. You're better off getting a frozen Digorno pizza at Publix. I was so disappointed by the size and quality of the pizza I immediately went to the Mcdonald's drive thru down the road. I can't speak for the wood fire pizzas but I can't imagine they're a redeeming menu item. Also my caesar salad that was lettuce and 4 stale croutons? I'm all set. First and last time here. read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - Detroit Pizza and Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

It was Wednesday and we Went here for happy hour and trivia with a party of 5.. ordered most of happy hour menu.. mozzarella bread, which was yummy , pork meatballs and fried mozzarella were very good.. also had a house and Caesar salad which was ok.. my friends said pizza was good..my only bad critique.. were the metal chairs with bars that press you in your butt hips... they are cool looking but, I couldn't sit in them.. they were the most uncomfortable chairs I've ever sat in.. thank god for the cushioned slide in booth.. Trivia was fun it started at 7:00 lasted until After 8:00.. overall food was good and it was a fun place, but I won't be back because of those metal chairs with the bars... sorry, comfort is the key! read more

See all

How could this place get a four star rating? I just had a pizza delivered just plain cheese. It was terrible. It was half cooked just about raw after the first bite so I put it in the oven for 400° for about 1520 minutes. Still was terrible Caesar salad. I ordered was a joke a little thing of Caesar dressing so just to let you know I did call and tell them this was not good and I did not want anything in return but I will not go back. read more

We ordered some food including Detroit pizza, which was I'm sorry...disgusting! Raw dough and too sweet. The salads were small for the price and the vodka sauce was too bland. This was a one and done for us, wishing them success, but it's not for us at all. read more

Excellent pizza! Wood-fired and cooked to perfection. The crust is awesome, the sauce and toppings are delicious! We had a large pepperoni and a small Oh Honey (prosciutto, honey, fontina cheese, figs, Gorgonzola & Parmesan)....loved it!! Service was great, gave us great recommendations and made sure we were all good, start to finish! Definitely rather there again! read more

See all

Big place with a big menu. Lots of interesting pizzas and specials. We should definitely check it out.

They have a really great happy hour 12"inch pizza with pepperoni for$7 bucks, mozzarella sticks for $5 and da delicious salad for $6! The pizza was good not my favorite but I'm kind of picky when it comes to pizza' had a Sauv Blanc for $6. Our server was great although very busy. They all seemed to help each other which was nice to see. read more

See all

Service 0 out of 10 Food 5 out of 10 Ambiance 2 out of 10 First time here and will not be back. Get it together. Poor service, no soap in bathrooms dirty silverware and dishes on clean tables, 2 hours for two pizzas and a dessert, paid for it after 30 minutes and still no dessert, waitress MIA we walked out without receiving it. Ordered margaritas, waitress couldn't even tell us the tequila they serve even though it was only two brands. Never came back to ask if we wanted a second drink. Sad they won't last here. read more

Square Peg wasn't good with below average food at prices that do not reflect its location or the cafeteria like dismal and basic dining room. The seats are hard, much like a fast food outlet and are designed to be uncomfortable and discourage a relaxing dinner and that is not a good look for a restaurant. Also the napkins are paper and who wants that? There are a few random vintage video games adding to the mediocrity of the dining room design. We tried three pizzas and none were even average. A basic cheese pizza was forgettable and the best compliment I can offer is that I've had worse but it's really the Sicilian/square pies that are strange. They seem to be mostly bread and it's like the pizza maker forgot to fill up the pie with ingredients and it's not like they are using high quality ingredients to begin with. Did they run out of sauce and cheese or are they just thrifty. The Sicilian/Detroit pies are priced at $30 and more and the price is fine if it offered more than bread, you know like a pizza. A Chicken Parm which seemed reasonably priced at $28 was a large portion until I realized it was mainly pasta. There was one chicken cutlet and it was okay but would have been better if it were a fair portion. All is not bad at Square Peg as service is excellent with a nice waiter and caring manager and I know this is a small chain and there is nothing the local management can do to elevate the restaurant. Happy Hour seems okay though but I wouldn't go out of my way for this place. read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - Detroit style. - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

See all

i had an event at the Square Peg located at 4957 W Atlantic Ave, Delray Beach, FL 33445 on Friday, June 15th. I ordered wine and when I went home, I began coughing up the wine. It was very bitter tasting. I was also very upset with the way that I was treated by the management. I would never have another event at that venue. It was a very upsetting situation for me. read more

Came for the happy hour menu which is an excellent value if you get the pizza and Cesar salad. Cesar was average, but you can't beat it for $4 if you come between the hours of 2pm-6pm. Pizza was the best $7 pizza I've had (also happy hour price). Food is probably 4 stars but bumped it up to 5 stars because of the service from Keileigh (spelling might be off). She treated us as if we were her highest paying customer, and gave us excellent service. Hope you get her if you come. Mozzarella sticks were pretty good (you get 2 for $5). But getting the 12 inch napolitan coal-fired pizza with pork-only meatballs for $7 is a great deal. Hope they keep it read more

I love their motto! "Be Nice" Square Peg Pizzeria moved into the former Zimi location within the Publix plaza on the corner of Military Trail and Atlantic in Delray Beach! If you are in the area, give them a try. Great pizza-- Both round traditional pies and Detroit Square thick pizza! Also delicious. They have an extensive menu with something for everyone to find and enjoy. Can't wait to go back and try the wings and pasta. This plaza so needed something like this- The manager and staff were all so nice. read more

Square Peg Pizzeria - I love their motto! "Be Nice" Square Peg Pizzeria - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Delray Beach, Florida

See all

I get pizza here almost every week and it is my favorite spot in the area. Fast, tasty and consistent.

Had gotten a gift card and decided to use it for late lunch. 1:30'arrival found only one other couple in the place. We were told to sit anywhere. The server came and brought menus and asked for ant beverages. Just wanted water to start. We got two glasses of room temperature water from a pitcher with no ice. We ended up ordering an order of fried calamari to share and a chicken parm sandwich for each of us. The calamari was brought first and although tasty enough it seemed overpriced for the portion, which was smaller than most Italian restaurants. The sandwich came and although tasty, was not up to the standards of most other comparable places. The chicken seemed to be coated similar to fried chicken fingers and did not fill the whole roll. The ends were just bread. Average amount of cheese and sauce. The "toasted roll" as mentioned on the menu was NOT toasted and was soft unlike what an Italian bread sandwich should be. It was also served with a bag of potato chips for some reason. Unfortunately for the server, a few more people came in and she was the only one, plus she was covering the bar as well. The check with just one diet soda added came to over $50 which is on the high side. My thought is that although not the worst place I've gotten Italian food, there are many other places in the area to try that offer better value if you want Italian food and this one does not stand out.. read more

Quick visit. Easy to order online. Still working out the new kinks so it took quite awhile for the order to be ready. Pizza was excellent. Note - they offer vegan cheese! read more