One of the young men working there with the broccoli haircut threw the pizza at me when I walked up and asked for it. It took over 30 minutes. It was very disrespectful. First time there, I came up asking for the pie, and he shoved it at me. I will never come back. My parents said the same thing as well read more

Little girl with shaved head at register was very rude , service was slow, food wasn't the best, overall bad experience wouldn't go back if it was the only food establishment open within the next 50 miles read more

Extremely slow service. Ordered on the website 7:00PM, received email says pick up at 7:29 PM. Showed up 7:30, had to stand there for 20+ minutes, got pizza at 7:52 PM. That's almost 1 hour to wait on a large basic pizza. Do better! read more

Pizza was very good. Service was also good (however you do order at the counter and go sit down and go back to pick up your pizza when they call you). read more

Tries to place an order online- it said they were not taking online orders at this time. I then tried to call- rang for two minutes and phone was never picked up. Called again 20 minutes later and they picked up but placed me on hold. After two minutes, I hung up. Why bother. I guess this place does not want business. A bunch of kids running the place. Go somewhere else is my suggestion read more

Spitony's Pizza - Spitony's - Pizza Near Me - New Baltimore, Virginia

Service here is always awesome--friendly and efficient, never have to wait for long. The wings here is a must! Definitely get it breaded! I have never been a huge fan of breaded wings but the way they do it here just adds that nice crunchy texture on the wings. Always cooked perfect! read more

Spitony's Pizza - Buffalo Wings--breaded - Pizza Near Me - New Baltimore, Virginia

See all

got a steak and cheese, in house. had wrong ingredients and was falling apart. had them remake it and asked for toasted bread. they remade it. was so soggy and lacked flavor. ate 3 bites and threw it away. used to love this place. but unfortunately will not be coming back. waste of $23 for sand which meal and beer. read more

5/5, 2022-present, multiple visits. One of our favorite stops in the area. Spitony's is an old school pizzeria of the kind that used to be common before chain franchise model decimated them. The food is excellent without being overpriced or pretentious. The service is always friendly as you would expect in a neighborhood shop. But the star is that the place feels like a throw back to the better parts of our past without any of the drawbacks. Definitely recommend stopping here if you're anywhere near. read more

Would have been 5 stars if they had the entire takeout order ready on time. Noone likes seeing their pizza, spaghetti, and calzone get cold as they begin to make garlic bread... read more

Always great! Best place around! People are always nice, food is always great, its a constant for me!!

Great little pizza and sub shop will continue to grab both from this place. Friendly staff, decent prices, good food

Wow! Great pizza! Thin crust pizza with tasty sauce at a reasonable price. This is an old-school place but the crew was friendly, fun and efficient. We will be back!! read more

Too expensive and pizza wasn't even that good. Seems like a place riding the coat tails of the past.

Man, the rib eye steak and cheese was fenomenal. Both staff members i encountered were polite, professional and helpful. It's small joint and that's usually where food hits best. read more

Very small dining area. Better for takeout. Pizza was good but maybe a little bland. I might want to try it with different toppings.

Pizza and wings are the best in the area. Has been our go to for 40 years. Service is always friendly.

Always a pleasure to come here and get pizza for the family. Love their pizzas and the staff is terrific. A must place to stop and eat.

Incredibly good pizza at wonderful prices. Love the service i receive every time I visit this establishment! Great people and great environment. 10 out of 10 I definitely recommend and always take my guests to this establishment any time i have friends come in from out of town! Great work guys! read more

Yummy! One of my top 3 pizzas places. Definitely recommend trying the pizza, subs and naked wings.

Good steak and cheese subs. Fried foods sometimes aren't drained enough. Service has always been good getting your food. The people behind the counter weren't over friendly. read more

My wife and I gave it another try and it was better. The pizza, chicken parm sandwich and fried mushrooms were pretty good. Friendly and courteous staff, and most tables were occupied. read more

Amazing!!! We were traveling back home and wanted to grab something (local) that wasn't fast food. We ordered the cheese steak, the meat lovers pizza, fries and wedges. The food was great, but I would definitely recommend trying the pizza if you cant be a frequent diner. It is made from scratch (crust and all). The staff was extremely friendly, knowledgeable, respectful and worked well together. We sat outside because the weather was perfect. We will definitely revisit if the opportunity presents itself. read more

You can't beat the pizza or the prices here. Everyone is so friendly. Only drawback is getting to the restaurant off of 29. Nice homey at my. read more

Their food is pretty good. I can't say it's the best, but it's pretty good. When we went to pickup our food, the restaurant smelled a little weird, which wasn't the most appetizing sensation. Their pizzas are great, but the appetizers were probably frozen before they were deep fried. That's fine, but I can do that at home. The staff is certainly nice enough! If you're curious, give' em a try! read more

Stopped in for dinner driving through on Friday night. They were slammed and working their tails off, so you know it's good. Inside is a blast from the past, but don't let it deter you! Truly excellent pizza, and we've lived all over the country. read more

I really wanted to like this place, since it's the closest place to our new home. Unfortunately our two experiences have been ok at best. Pizza, salads, subs and fries are all passable, but not great. Baked ziti was just terrible. Two of us ordered it and both threw it out after a few bites. Tasted like a famously bad grocery store brand sauce. Lots of cheese on top but not sure there was any mixed in with the pasta. Also topped with way too much oregano. Dish appeared to have been microwaved in the plastic container in which it was served. Had it been baked, If have expected an aluminum pan. Store is small, felt dirty and smelled awful when we were there. Sister restaurant two doors down has been great. Shocking two places under same ownership could be so different in quality. read more

Pizza was good but could have been a little more pliable. The sauce had a little sweetness to it. Chicken wings were good and the sauce was creamy and a little spicy. read more

Spitony's Pizza - Plain Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Baltimore, Virginia

See all

Pizza is consistently good. Better than all the chain pizzas and not overly priced. Everything I have tried is good so far like the meatball sub, cheesesteaks, jalapeño poppers, fries and got me wanting to try everything else on their menu. I've only done take out and haven't sat down to eat, but the workers are very friendly. read more

Decided to stop by here after struggling to find some place to eat & we're so glad we stumbled upon this place! Ordered a large mushroom pizza for 2 & we devoured in just minutes. Pizza came out piping hot. It was well cooked with a nice crispy crust. Cheese was ooey-gooey & greasy. Tomato sauce was strong on the herbs & oregano which I really enjoyed. Topped off the meal with some delicious icecream just down the street. Will definitely be back again when I'm in the area! read more

Great steak and cheese! My daughter ordered a pizza that was also good. Service was fast and the place was clean. read more

Easy pick up spot next to 7-11 and close to home. Decent dinner options and not a budget breaker

Good gluten-free pizza. Great service. I stopped in on my way home from one of my "memory lane" road trips. Called ahead and when I arrived the pizza was almost ready and came to me piping hot. Very good gluten-free pizza with delicious toppings. The staff was very polite and courteous. I would definitely go back when I'm in the area. read more

Anytime I am in Warrenton I stop in and get their steak n cheese with mushrooms and onions and it is always the best I've ever had. I live in Fairfax with lots of choices but nobody comes close to Spitony's. Keep up the good work. read more

Not from this area and decided to pick up a pie after hiking in Shenandoah national park. Great pizza.

Consistently the Best pizza in the area, great service, and the new gluten free is actually delicious! :)

Still recommend this place. This is a family restaurant owned by the same family for generations. The Chakalos family are absolutely amazing. They're sweet, friendly, and they know how to manage the restaurant well. read more

Went in last night for a pizza. As a previous reviewer has so correctly stated, the dine in area is somewhat small, but the place feels like an authentic dive - in a cozy sort of way. I ordered the large 16" pizza, with onions, bell pepper, mushrooms, black olives, double pepperoni, double sausage, and double cheese, plus a bottle of water and a mug of Spitony's Ale. Total bill: about $33.00. I decided to eat in - so I grabbed a table, sat down and waited for my pizza. As I looked around, I noted some interesting pieces of decor, framed artwork depicting large ocean going vessels traversing the Panama Canal. When my pizza was ready, I realized I had ordered to large of a pizza, it was waaaayyy to much for me to eat in one or even two sittings. Oh well! I grabbed shakers of hot pepper flakes, cheese, and Oregano and sat down to chow. The pizza had a thin crust and the combination of toppings exuded a light level of saltiness in the perfect amount. Everything was hearty, tasty, succulent. Delicious!!! I was stuffed after three slices. I got a to go box for the rest of my pizza. I note there is a cluster of picnic tables outside to the side of the joint, so you could dine outdoors. There was a steady stream of customers coming in to order and or pick up pizzas. I may have just found my new favorite pizza joint! read more

Spitony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Baltimore, Virginia

See all

This place SLAPS! Ordered a large cheese pie, and they nailed it. Been looking for good pizza in Virginia. This place is it. Food came out quickly. It was delicious, and the customer service was great! Drove by it on the way to Skyline drive and I'm glad it caught my eye. Will be back for more! Well done guys! read more

This place is amazing. A perfect ten in every measure. Food, ambiance, service, everything is ideal. It is a perfect time capsule of days gone by. Pizza and beer. Stop here, don't get it to go, stay and eat there and reminisce about how the world used to be like this! Thank you Spitony's for not changing to keep up with whatever the latest trend has been over the fifty years you've been in business! read more

I really enjoyed this pizza...after living in the area for 13 years I am kicking myself that I never tried it sooner. This is one of those no frills place that has stood the test of time and keeps cranking out great food. If you are looking for some classy joint to spoil you with all the fancy modern things we have all come...keep on moving past this place. If you just really love great pizza stop here and have a slice or two or three...I won't judge. This will definitely become the go to pizza joint for the foreseeable future. read more

Spitony's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Baltimore, Virginia