We got the meatball parm and the ba da bing. Both were gas. Quality fresh ingredients and big portions. The owner is also the man.

This spot is a staple for all of our visits. There's a ton of spices and condiments to choose from as well as some unique cocktail mixes. The big draw for us was the VAST selection of hot sauces. We also love picking up sandwiches here (the bada-bing is to die for. You won't be disappointed). The cashiers are always friendly and if they have a certain type of hot sauce already open, they'll let you sample! read more

Hands down..... THE Best meatball panini on the planet! Friendly, courteous folks. Excellent service. Highly recommend. read more

Spice It Up - Spice It Up - Grocery Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Amazing sandwiches The shop sells all types of hot sauces and spices but the hidden secret is their amazing sandwiches The creativity of these sandwiches will have your tastebuds begging for another bite Don't skip this experience while visiting the island read more

Spice It Up - Even the pickiest eater will enjoy the fresh bread and delicious ingredients - Grocery Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

Fast service and great taste. Small grab-and-go shop, so you can find seating in different locations outside the store. Deli meat is sliced super thin which is very important in a good sandwich. Lots of menu options, but they will make you a build-your-own if you ask for it. Went twice during my vacation in LBI and I will be coming back for their food again next summer! read more

Spice It Up - Beached sandwich and 2 country kettle sandwiches - Grocery Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

I stopped by here earlier today with my wife and twins for our lunch. Specifically my wife and I were looking for a place for our twins to eat and Spice It Up fit the bill having both a grilled cheese and a PB&J. Spice it up is a combination food store as well as a deli. So in addition to their hot foods, they have other things like hot sauces and gourmet foods. For lunch on this day my wife and I decided to split the prosciutto quesadilla and then I decided on the PB&J for the kids. The menu described our prosciutto quesadilla as prosciutto, fig spread, arugula and grated truffle cheese. Throughout the whole order process the lady working the counter was super friendly and after it was rang in, she told me that it would be ready in about 10 minutes. With that I left with my son to waste some time as there was no way he was lasting ten minutes in that store without breaking anything. Whenever I came back about 10 minutes later, the food was just coming out of the back and I was on my way. The quesadilla itself was cut into 3 different pieces and was quite good. It was toasted nicely on the outside while the prosciutto had a nice saltiness to it, the fig added sweetness and the arugula a bit of pepperiness. Then the cheese itself was nice enough but i don't think I could have you told you it was a grated truffle cheese. My kids PB&J came cut in half and with a bag of chips. It was loaded with both peanut butter and jelly and both of my kids ate a large portion of their half. The bottom line for me is that I would come back here again in the future. Our sandwich was good and I would certainly be open to trying more of their food, especially the blackened mahi Reuben or ship bottom brewery. read more

Spice It Up - Menu - Grocery Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

The sandwich are always good this is my favorite restaurant in Long Beach island!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Love the sandwiches here! Especially the Dani's. When the craving for a sandwich hits me this is the place I think of.

A+ food & A+ service 10/10 recommend The panini I had was toasted perfectly and the cold cuts were fresh and delicious. Will definitely be a sandwich spot when headed to the brewery next door read more

this was such a great find! we picked up sandwiches before the beach and they were all phenomenal. i got the smokin hot turkey panini, which was perfect, and the rest of the group got subs they loved. boars head turkey is a must for me and that's what they use, and there's a cute little shop with novelty sauces etc. to browse while you wait. 10/10 recommend; great value, great service, and great options! read more

Spice It Up - Smokin Hot Turkey - Grocery Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Every year I come to LBI, I make sure that I visit Spice It Up. It's the next sandwich I ever had in my life.

Got an Italian sub here it was really good. The meat was sliced thin and the sandwich overall was a good size. read more

Spice It Up - Italian sub - Grocery Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

After coming to buy spices, pickles, and sauces for many summers, we finally tried the sandwiches! The menu is well thought out with great homages to Bay Village favorites. The sandwiches were absolutely fantastic. Flavorful, big, and worth the price. After ordering on the phone they were ready within 10-15 minutes! A fantastic new favorite. I recommend the pitcraft! The pepper jelly was the perfect touch. read more

Sandwiches could have been hotter, but they are darn good! Smells amazing too, and decent prices. I'll be returning.

This is a great little deli and market. They have a lot of great sandwiches and a lot of gluten free options. They also do a brunch thing with Ship Bottom Brewing on Sundays at 9 and music at 10am. We went to it with my daughter and the clam burger was amazing. I really hope this place does well. We go there almost every day while we are down on LBI. read more

Always great. Dan the owner is a great guy and is always on site and even making great sandwiches in the back part of the store. Had the bada Bing yesterday and it was awesome. My friend had the pork roll breakfast sandwich and said it's the best he ever had. I visit every time I'm in LBI (which is often). Best sandwiches read more

This shop is a true hidden gem! Our uncle recommended it to us while we were visiting the brewery, and it blew our minds. Sandwiches were extremely fresh and full of flavor!! We enjoyed the "Original Dan" and the "Ship Bottom Brewery". I cannot rave enough about the Bella Vidalia spread on the Original Dan, OUT OF THIS World!! Meats were of a very good quality (mom thought the pastrami was very lean, thinly sliced, and delicious), bread was super fresh (I believe a rosemary olive oil), proportions were excellent (we split them with some pretzels as an afternoon snack, but would definitely be filling for one). Shopkeepers were extremely welcoming, friendly, and knowledgeable. We will be back. Thank you Spice It Up!! read more

Spice It Up - The Original Dan Sandwich - Grocery Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

So good, miss the French dip panini!!! Get a panini, they r great and a large variety.

Totally agree with others - this place really is a hidden gem! Despite coming to LBI for the past 20 years this is the first time I'd heard of Spice It Up and it did not disappoint! The paninis aka daninis are excellent - highly recommend! read more

The nicest people ever! Their subs are so good and I loved the strawberry vinegar!!!! So fresh and yummy!!!

Excellent hidden gem and as others have said, easily the best sandwiches on the island!

Absolutely delicious sandwiches. Went 2 days in a row without hesitation. Ingredients taste so fresh and staff is very friendly. read more

Best sandwich on LBI- and they offer gluten free bread. Also love the vast selection of spices, sauces and dry rubs.

Best sandwiches on the island! Love their menu, sandwiches are a great size, awesome hot sauces just great all around!!!

I recently had ordered sandwiches and a cheese and charcuterie platter from Dan here at spice it up. It was for my boyfriends 40th birthday party. The sandwiches were fresh, the bread was perfect and the sandwich itself was so creative and tasty! The various spreads and toppings combined were truly unique and delicious! The cheese. And charcuterie platter was also absolutely delicious! The cheeses were labeled so it made it easier for picking, also the spreads and jams with the cheese and crackers were perfect! My boyfriend and I often go to spice it up, the boutique is great!! There are so many different marinades, spices, hot sauces,etc....truly a great store and excellent Service! Definitely will be using them again for another party! A must see when LBI! read more

If you want an awesome freshly made experience try this deli !! Dan and John truly cater and care about your order. Gluten free wrap is amazing and they always have specials and and vegetarian options . Our family and friends are all amazed as well. From satisfied customers read more

Amazing sandwiches and super friendly owner. We ordered through grub hub for delivery and there were no drivers so the owner called and offered to deliver it herself. Will definitely be back! read more

Spice It Up - Grocery Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Best Deli on the island. Not only do they have the best sandwhiches and hot sauces but they are also great people. This is a must try before leaving the island. I would normally recommend something on the menu but to be honest you cant go wrong with anything you pick. read more

Wild experience, ordered 4 meatball paninis and 1 original Dan. They ran out of meatballs and made 3 Meatball Hoogies instead and 1 Turkey sandwich. Only thing that did not go wrong was the original Dan. I am furious, and upset. The customer service was dogshit and they did not respect our order. This place is a big no go! Save your time and go to Jersey mikes. read more

Haven't tried their sandwiches yet but love the store. Great variety of hot sauces & spices. I stop in & grab something new every time I'm in LBI. read more

Had the London broil cheesesteak, phenomenal! Very flavorful and fresh! Big portion. Service was quick and very courteous. Definitely worth stopping in. read more

Looking for a quick bite my son and I decided to give the deli at Spice it Up a try. We bought some of the retail items in the past and since we liked them we thought we would give the made to order sandwiches a go. Man were we glad we did! I had the Morro Castle which was a cross between a spicy Cuban and NC BBQ, It was fantastic and well balanced. My son had the song of the sea which uses tomato focaccia and prosciutto that was tender and flavorful unlike the cheap tough stuff you find and most pizza joints. It's hard to find high quality in an area tourist frequent but Spice it Up delivers and even uses Hudson Bread which is a top bakery in norther NJ. We will be back to try the rest of the menu and sing the praises to our family and friends they mooch on our shore house, you know who you are! read more

Went here two days in a row. Got a different panini each time and they were both excellent. Super friendly staff and they have a great selection of hot sauces, pickles, etc. highly recommend! read more

Great place! Planned to get some sandwiches from the deli and go up to the brewery. We placed the order and they offered to bring the order up to us while we found a seat upstairs. Very nice people and the sandwiches were amazing. I got the Smoking Hot Turkey special and my fiancé got the Parlor Squakin Chicken special. They were very good - great amount of meat and sauce. Bread was perfect. Definitely recommend it! read more

Today we ordered the Original Dan and it was amazing! The meat, cheese and delicious spread and bread just melt in you mouth! It's the perfect place to take out from while grabbing a beer at the brewery! We are definitely going to be ordering again multiple times this week! read more

This place needs to be on everyone's "to do" list while in LBI. Great selection of spices and cocktail mixers! Recently had a party catered by Dan. He hooked me up and had everyone speaking about the awesome sandwiches were. There are many unique rubs and sauces that you can't find anywhere else. His recommendations are worth listening to especially if you want to spice up your next dinner party. Keep it up Dan and Regina! read more

The original dan sandwich is out of control. Amazing flavor, just the right amount of meat and the bread is grilled to perfection. This is a GEM in the neighborhood! read more

Their sandwiches are the best. So full of unique flavors. The owner is a great guy, friendly and outgoing. I recommend the pulled pork, or Ship Bottom brewery sandwich. read more

We used Spice it up to cater my wedding day lunch for my family and bridal party. Wow, what a spread! Not only were the great to work with and fairly priced, but the quality was amazing! We had assorted sandwiches and salads. My Dad said the pasta salad was simply the best he ever had. I specifically loved the strawberry salad. They have options for picky eaters too! I would highly recommend Spice it up for your catering needs! read more

Great little sub shop. Or hoagies, heroes, sandwiches - whatever you call them. Customer service was great. My 6-year-old ordered a sub and it was huge! Pulled pork on a brioche bun was delicious, even without the signature cole slaw and the added cheddar cheese. The "cool beans" panini - well let's just say my husband devoured it. We had been at the water park all morning and grabbed lunch when we were done. Sat outside and enjoyed. Highly recommend. read more