This place located inside Kalahari Resort surprised me! First the place is huge, they have a big bar on one side a huge dining room on the other side, open kitchen. Don't get scared by the wax statue as you walk in like I did! When you see a place like this in a resort you don't think it's going to be much.. but it actually was really good. The hundred layer lasagna was piping hot and super tasty. The fettuccine Bolognese was loaded with meat and the fettuccine was cooked perfectly. Penne pasta, the salads, the appetizers of calamari and burrata and the Italian wedding soup all delicious. Be careful of the meatballs not sure if they just didn't mix it well or if it's supposed to have hot pepper flake in it to give it a little kick.. but I've been into a chunk of meatball that had so much hot pepper in it I couldn't eat it. The pieces that didn't have all that hot pepper we're very good! Their drinks were delicious, old fashioned and other things.. expensive but delicious. The free bread that you get was very good as well with the oil and parmesan to dip it in. Service was very good. read more

See all

This place must throw away SO much food. Took an hour after ordering to get the food (and orders weren't even taken until we had been there 30 minutes) - even drinks took 45 minutes to show up after ordering. Kids got their food 30 minutes before the adults, so they were finished by the time the adults' food arrived. Inaccuracies, even after taking so long. Way too salty, some things pre-prepared/reheated (chicken parm especially egregious) but still arrived cold. "100 layer lasagna bolognese" was literally a generic mountain of basic salty meat sauce with a little linguine. It's garbage. They know it. They think that giving you a bucket of it will make up for it. It does not. At least it was hot, which is apparently a bar they typically are unable to reach. Waiter was MIA. Food service was wandering with dishes, unaware of what table they were going to. Especially frustrating when you've been waiting an hour for your order. Our large group was promised a full table in a room. They sat us at two awkward, separate tables in the middle of the restaurant. This is while we can clearly see multiple, empty rooms during our entire 2 1/2 hour time there. They claim the food is authentic Italian. It was so bad all around, that if I was Italian, I'd be offended. Overpriced slop. read more

While I did not eat the mozzarella garlic bread, everyone said it was so good. I celebrated my birthday dinner here and was very pleased. While the food was a little too salty for me, I still really enjoy my penne vodka. Our server was super friendly abd not overly attentative. I was slightly embarrassed when they sang Happy Birthday but I did really love it. It was such a good experience overall. read more

See all

Just went last night with a party of 12 people. Abby was our server and was phenomenal! So happy we chose to go here for our last night of vaca with friends. Drinks and food were delicious. Service - amazing. Highly recommend! Moscato wine was perfect and get the calamari! read more

Sortino's Italian Kitchen - Shrimp scampi - Italian Near Me - Pocono Summit, Pennsylvania

See all

It's become a holiday tradition for my aunt and I to eat here on Christmas. It's always busy with the families staying at the resort but we grab seats at the bar no problem. THE FOOD -some of the food can be hit or miss. We've shared a few things over the years that were meh and some were delicious. -this year we found they no longer give you the complimentary garlic loaf of bread (it's now an app to purchase) but instead tomato rosemary focaccia. I enjoyed the new focaccia though the old bread was missed! -my aunt had the pizza and really liked it. I felt the crust left much to be desired. Considering it's labeled as brick oven pizza I was expecting a thinner crispy but chewy edge / more hand tossed taste to it. -I tried the chicken parm and enjoyed it! Not the best vodka sauce I've ever had but tasty nonetheless! Big portion as well. -we shared the broccoli and I was pleasantly surprised. Very flavorful and cooked well. Nice size portion too. THE DRINKS -we always get espresso martinis and they are absolutely delicious -since we sat at the bar we notice a lot of what they're making and the cocktails all look good -the bartenders always are whipping up drinks and seem very knowledgeable THE STAFF -the bartenders are always very friendly and accommodating! Always able to answer our questions when we have them. THE ATMOSPHERE -cool place! They do some dishes tableside (maybe the salads and dessert?) it's decorated in a cute way Overall, I wouldn't necessarily drive out of my way to eat this Italian , but since we don't have many options on Christmas this is our tradition and we really love it. I'd say my favorite part is always the bread and the alcohol I could be satisfied with that. read more

Sortino's Italian Kitchen - Chicken parm, side of broccoli, margherita pizza - Italian Near Me - Pocono Summit, Pennsylvania

See all

If we didn't almost wait 1 hr for our entrees to come, I would've given more than a 2 star review. When our entrees did come out, it was cold and lackluster. I would hardly call this authentic Italian food. I've had better spaghetti at a local diner. read more

Got 2 Tiramisu, 1 Cannoli, 6 Rainbow cookies and an Affogato to go. Got to my room and first thing I noticed was no spoon or fork given. Let me break this all down because each thing was very disappointing except the service the server by the bar was very nice, not his fault everything I bought was bad. Tiramisu- tasted old, If there was any real mascarpone cream in it, it was not good at all. Cannoli - was not horrible just not good. Rainbow cookies had this odd flavor like cheese not good. Affogato I had high hopes for but alas the espresso was ran too long so it tasted burnt. SMH. Spent with tip over 60 dollar. Very disappointed but I shouldn't be surprised, many people might not notice the difference if it's not deserts they eat often, but growing up on Italian deserts and espresso I feel like I can honestly cretic what I ate or let's say took a few bites and through out the rest. SMH. read more

Sortino's Italian Kitchen - Affogato - Italian Near Me - Pocono Summit, Pennsylvania

See all

Superb service! My group of 7 friends went to Kalahari to celebrate a bachelorette. They gave us each a glass of complementary champagne and cannoli for the bride! We really appreciated it. The food was delicious and great portion sizes. The food came out quickly and we were all pleased with our meals. Although the ambience is formal feeling, families were all dressed casually which was comfortable for us too. Great place! read more

Service was great - our server was friendly, fun, and patient. A family environment. Their gelatos are always a hit (especially their pistachio 10/10). The seafood fra diovolo which, forewarning is very spicy - but if you're ok with that, this is a hit 9/10. Chicken penne vodka pizza 7/10. Alfredo 8/10 with broccoli and steak medallions 8/10. read more

See all

I've eaten here four times. I like the atmosphere- big windows, lots of natural light. I've had the full run of their menu from a lunch time Italian buffet or a plated meal for business meetings- service in both cases was exceptional. We had a social gathering of alumni several times - once for a sit-down meal, once appetizers. Such a nice evening in both cases with quality food and service. Definitely recommend for groups or a private dinner. read more

Came here again, probably the best food I have had here. They have a salmon on the menu that is delicious. It's a little pricey at $32 but it's a big portion. Cooked perfectly, moist on the inside and crispy on the outside. The fennel salad is lightly dressed and has very thinly sliced fennel that is crunchy and delicious. My husband's meatballs and spaghetti has the biggest meatballs ever. Everyone loved their meals, including the bolenegse, risotto, chicken Marsala and shrimp scampi. Besides the salmon the homemade mozzarella app was my favorite. Came with huge slices of thick bread baked with garlic. And a huge hunk of Mozzarella. I wish I had a bigger appetite it was so delicious. The bread it came with was better than the free bread they bring over, which is still good. The calamari app is also very good. 6 people split it and we each got 4-6 pieces. There is banana peppers in there too or maybe it's picketed jalapeño, either way it added a nice zing to complement the fried ness. The service was attentive and friendly. It was our nephews birthday and they brought over a cannoli! Though they didn't end up singing their signature birthday song. Ambiance is cozy and warm, we like to sit at the high tops by the bar. Def would come back again! read more

See all

Our family of 10 was seated quickly and service was great. Everything we tried was delicious! Family friendly and clean!

Most food was very good...a chef should know to never allow unopened shellfish to be sent out, received many in one order!! Otherwise service was good, place was quiet but it was a Sunday night. read more

Food was kinda salty. Steak was tender Service was decent Focaccia bread was not good read more

We decided to try Sortino's Italian Kitchen at Kalahari Resort in the Poconos this evening. The food was decent. We ordered the Caesar salad which was a large portion enough to share for our party of four. Then my husband ordered the pasta diavolo, which said was a bit spicy, then I ordered the chicken Parmesan. I thought the chicken and the pasta were good. My son and daughter shared the kids pepperoni, which was a good size for both of them. Justin, our server, was quick, friendly and attentive. The ambiance is casual but still a nice touch of class, which was surprising for being at the largest water park. It's definitely a bit on the pricy side but very convenient if you're staying on the property. read more

See all

I rarely leave bad reviews, but this one was warranted. From the moment we walked in, the experience went downhill. The restaurant felt completely disorganized--no clear system, long wait times despite empty tables, and overall chaos. The host who seated us was shockingly rude. She didn't greet us or say a word--just tossed the menus on the table and walked off like we were an inconvenience. Unfortunately, the food didn't redeem the experience either. It was bland, lukewarm, and clearly not fresh. Nothing we ordered was memorable--in fact, most of it was left on the plate. With so many great places to eat, I definitely won't be returning here. read more

A bit disappointed with this establishment. Ordered a chicken and shrimp pasta dish in a garlic & wine butter sauce. Food tasted fresh but it lacked flavor. Very rarely do I need to add salt to a dish like that, but found myself shaking on quite a bit bite after bite. The table shared an order of steamed mussels in a lobster bisque style sauce and they were good, but also lacked some flavor. Salads were not dressed and had little to no flavor even after dousing with olive oil and vinegar. We had a table of 10 and a few of our orders got mixed up a didn't arrive until others were almost done with their entrees. It was a bit busy, so I'll give the wait staff a bit of a pass on that. I seriously did not like that they did not put bread on the table, and upon requesting it, was informed that it was not provided and there was an additional charge for it. OK, I get it, it's a water park / resort ...... not specifically an Italian restaurant.....but the hotel staff really talked this place up quite a bit like it was going to be a special dining experience. Not so much. Certainly edible, but nothing that's going to make you want to return anytime soon. read more

The good-food was above average, atmosphere is lovely The bad-service a little slow and our waitress seemed overwhelmed, way to expensive for pasta read more

Service was amazing, ambiance again was amazing. The food on the other hand was mediocre at best. I got the veal parm and it came out looking like chicken fingers. They were tiny portions 2 little chicken finger like pieces. The pasta was ok but lacked sauce. You can get better Italian at a local mom and pop place. read more

We are from Canada and only come here once a year. I have been dying to try this palace out for a few years now and everything was amazing! Right from the wonderful interactions with our front host with a spunky fun attitude (in a VERY good way) to our server just being so informative and delightful, we were all very happy with our experience. We were a large group of 10! Our server made great recommendations based on his own personal choice OR what was popular right now. The music... atmosphere ... just wonderful. I ordered the eggplant parm. The pasta was okay but it was not the main Center of the meal. For sure the BEST eggplant parm I have ever had I will for sure be back next year ~ read more

See all

Large Italian restaurant with not a ton of ambiance, but the food was surprisingly very good. We ordered calamari and garlic cheese bread to start but should have passed in the cheese bread since the complimentary Asiago rosemary bread was very good. Wife's sangria was excellent. The Chicken Bambino, Seafood Avialo, kids chicken Alfredo and kids cheese pizza all were enjoyed. The Bambino & Avialo were standouts. The waiter was pleasant and made up for fairly slow service. Would definitely recommend over chain Italian restaurants and given its attached to an amusement park, we were surprised as it was in par with many good Italian restaurants in Philadelphia & South Jersey. If you're accustomed to the very best Italian, then maybe it's not for you. read more

My volleyball team went in Saturday night, we had the greatest time. Our waitress was Abby who provided great service, made great conversation and was very patient with the check. We had quick water refills and we loved the pizza there. Although the food was fancy, it was appetizing. The warm, soft, lighting set the mood and the atmosphere and the ambiance was so calm and collected and we had a great dinner. -Xtreme read more

Excellent service which is willing to go above and beyond. The food was also fresh and delicious. Thank you Sebastian and the Chef!

We had a reservation for a group of 10. Unfortunately, we had to wait ~30 min for our table which ended up being two smaller tables slid together to comfortably fit just 6 persons. The more disturbing items were the lack of genuine courtesy and professionalism in letting us know that they either overbooked and/or couldn't manage the restaurant effectively. It's one thing to be slammed by clientele but another thing when the two managers are unapologetic and somewhat rude when two families with young children are waiting 30 min. The food was fine (pasta a bit cold) and the service individual (although polite, nice) made several mistakes and took far too long to retrieve drinks on two separate requests/reminders. Obviously it's one of ~5 restaurants onsite to choose from but thought I would share my poor experience. I think this experience is important for other customers and the management to see for informed choices and improving their customer service, respectively. read more

Outstanding Italian food especially considering it's in a water park resort. Agree with one of previous reviews that food was a little salty but other than that it was terrific. Portions were huge and the service was amazing with our waiter Joustin making our evening a truly enjoyable one. read more

With not many choices to pick from, I decided to make a reservation a day prior to guarantee a table, Same day reservations doesn't seem feasible when the park is busy. The staff was very accommodating and our server, Lawrence had a great personality that made the dining out experience more pleasant. First out was the bread... the bread was stale and tasted like undercooked dough. Lol... and the nerve of them to serve it with olive oil and Parmesan cheese as if it was supposed to compliment the bread. My wife and I both ordered the chicken parmesan which came out in decent timing. The serving size was decent and it actually looked and tasted pretty good. Maybe a little more sauce but other than that, I was pleased with the meal. I'd try it again but after I tried the steak house that's located right beside it first. read more

Sortino's Italian Kitchen - Chicken Parm - Italian Near Me - Pocono Summit, Pennsylvania

This plays is amazing and has great service, I recommend, the food tastes amazing. It is cooked perfectly. Their pasta is so good. The workers are nice and I recommend birthdays, where they sing a great birthday song. This place looks and plays the part which makes it amazing. If you go here you have to make a reservation because it is usually packed. But I see the reason why. read more

Mediocre at best. Places on resorts may not have the best track record with food and this restaurant fell victim to this as well. The food was under seasoned and just not flavorful. If you know me, you know i love italian food, so I was thoroughly disappointed by this. There were so many better food options at Kalahari, so I wouldn't recommend eating here unless you're sick of everything else. read more

There was one uncomfortable situation that happened during our dinner at Sortinos on Friday(12/13) around 7pm et. My daughter(6 year old girl) really liked the waxed statue inside the restaurant and was curious and was touching and feeling it. All of a sudden and I am guessing the manager at that time( tall white male) approached her and my wife at yelled at her. It was very uncomfortable and unprofessional of him and I hope someone talks to him about this. Instead of being rude and raising his voice and telling her that it cost $20k for the statue he could have been a bit more Sensitive about this. read more

Sortino's Italian Kitchen - Italian Near Me - Pocono Summit, Pennsylvania

Happy that they were able to squeeze us in for a last minute dinner reservations however not happy at all about the food. I chose to only order some appetizers and glad that I did but ended up not eating any of it. Calamari was over cooked. Mussels dish on the menu states that it's in a white wine sauce and when it got to the table it was in a marinara sauce and when we questioned our server Justin about it, he stated that it was a typo in the menu.... Ooooohhhh a typo that you failed to inform me about when I ordered it. The kids enjoyed it so kept it but I didn't like it. The veal parmigiana didn't taste right. Meat smelled funny. I had to spit it out. I just tasted some of my daughters plate. The baked ziti surprised us all when it came out looking like Mac n cheese. Wth?? Didn't taste bad after some salt and pepper. The best thing I consumed was my aperol spritz. Big disappointment. I guess I have high expectations as an elite yelper. Maybe if you come here just keep it basic. Maybe you will have a better experience read more

See all

Nice decor, but Sortino's really fell flat with their food. We went two days in a row during our stay at Kalahari, and this place definitely wasn't my choice either time. Almost everything we had during dinner was average or a letdown. The wings were dry. The Caesar salad was boring and the breadsticks were rocks. The mussels marinara were flavorless and definitely not fresh. My linguine with white clam sauce was on the better side, but it lacked proper seasoning. I had to add a healthy portion of red chili pepper flakes. I will say that we enjoyed the garlic bread, and the kids really liked their personal pizzas. Breakfast was even worse. We came for Kenya's Birthday Party, a kids' breakfast buffet event featuring fully costumed and presumably miserable employees. The scrambled eggs were blocks, the sausage was dry, and the fruit wasn't that fresh. The best part was probably the cereal. Makes sense since it wasn't something they made or prepared firsthand. read more

See all

We've been to kalahari at least 10x over the last 5 years and one thing that stays pretty darn consistently good is Sortino's. We've eaten there each time and never had a bad meal. Most of the time, the servers are great and the food is solid. My favorite is the pasta baronessa, usually order that w the arugula salad. Kids always like their meals. Last visit over Labor Day weekend was exceptional, we had the joy of Lawrence as our server. He was so warm and funny, and made us feel like nothing we asked for was a bother at all. He even heard us talk about an engagement and brought cannoli for the newly engaged! Lawrence was phenomenal, we hope to see him there again, thank you for a wonderful dinner. It's great that they allow for reservations, and they're easy to make online. read more

See all

I hope my review will be useful to improve the service at this cafe. The waiter service is bad, we waited a long time for the order. Also, they didn't bring us the children's pizza, because they simply forgot, as a result of which the child was forced to eat the wrong dish that she wanted. The waitress ignored us. As for the dishes we ordered, they are ok, the alcoholic cocktails are ok, the only thing that upset me was that the waiter brought them late, which caused the salt in the margarita to melt... I probably won't visit this establishment again read more

See all

Great Italian food. Treatment of me and my family with my two younger kids 6yr and 8yrs really made them feel special. Food was fantastic and generous portions read more

Sortino's is connected to the Kalahari resort. Convenient location and very family friendly (obviously). The inside of the restaurant is very spacious with beautiful decor, complete with an open kitchen. I was able to nab a last minute reservation on the phone for 4 people at 6:45pm on a Saturday night - I called at 6pm but I highly recommend making a reservation much earlier than that. We got lucky because we saw many people trying to walk in to inquire about reservation and got turned away after that or offered a much later available time. Our server was wonderful. I wish I remember her name... perhaps Natalie? Honestly she made the experience good because she was so friendly and attentive. She was definitely very busy made sure to stop by many times to make sure we were okay. The food it was average. We got a plain brick oven pizza for the kids to share, I had the seafood al diavoli, and my husband had the chicken parmigiana. I thought the pizza looked meh but the kids ate it which is all that matters... the extremely picky toddler loved the ziti that came with the chicken parmigiana so again a win!... He said he wants to eat the ziti for "100 years." LOL. I did like my seafood al diavolo. It was just slightly spicy, plenty of sauce, and a decent amount of seafood. Yum. We did not order the meatballs but saw it at a neighboring table and it was humongous and looked really good - would definitely order that next time. The complimentary warm bread served in the beginning was a nice touch. Sortino's is worth a visit. read more

The atmosphere is nice and service was good, our server was really nice. However the food was very disappointing. The calamari felt really plain. The garlic cheesy bread was good. But my main meal was very disappointing, the broccoli felt just steamed and tossed into my Alfredo and the chicken was literally rubber. It was so inedible I didn't even eat much off my plate. Save your money and try a different location. read more

See all

Lets start with service, our server Justin was absolutely the best. Ambiance - the interior and setup feels very much like a good old school italian restaurant. Very comfortable. Food: We ordered Fried Calamari Meatball and Spaghetti Spaghetti carbonara Chicken Marsala Seafood al Diavolo Shrimp Scampi Steak mediterranean So we got a buncha food going and everything was great. Im not saying its the best italian food I ever had. But it wasnt too bland, wasnt too overseasoned. Everything was on par. And what more can you expect at kalahari... read more

Really nice ambiance, friendly waiters and love dip is to die for! It was our second time here and it didn't disappoint. We'll come here every time we're at Kalahari. read more

I don't have high expectations for restaurants in colossal hotels like Kalahari. However, Sortino's is surprisingly good. Not great; but good. Calamari was crispy, salad fresh and the chicken dishes were tasty. Kids had pizza that was just ok. Decor was nice but the atmosphere can get a bit chaotic as the place is big. I'd be ok if restaurants like this didn't sing for birthdays as there were 4! Service was average. He (James?) started out strong but kind of got lost as the meal progressed. Took a long time to get our wine! Be sure to make a reservation if you are going on a weekend. read more

Went for dinner after enjoying the water park. The pasta was delicious and so was the pizza. The drinks were tasty as well. We went around 6:30 on a Friday evening and they weren't overly crowded. My only complaint is that they close the earliest of all the restaurants, but they're definitely the best. read more

See all