Went out of business ! Wish they were still open BEST food…read morein Princess Anne. Owners were very nice. Was 5 stars when they were there

They are closed and have been for over a year now. When you call the phone goes straight to Verizon…read morestating it no longer takes calls.

Great local place. Our favorites are the pizza and the chicken salad sub. Rolls are always fresh…read more The staff is super friendly

Very good foods and service almost every time. Wide variety at decent prices and large menu like…read moreSomset pizza .

Pizza was surprisingly excellent , good sauce, cheese and crispy crust. Ambiance is nothing to gawk…read moreabout, but for take out you can't go wrong. Service was fast!

If you want a scrumptious sandwich, try the tuna sandwich here! I know it seems a bit mundane or…read moresilly, but this place rocks and even has diverse range of sandwiches.

We visited the island last summer for the first time with my family and my wife and I ordered pizza…read morefrom Cosa every single day, on day we ordered twice. This year, we have planned two trips to the island and my wife and I are already planning how many Cosas pizzas and island creamery visits we can fit in. It's been almost a year and we're still talking about it. Can't wait to come back!

Easily the best thing I've had in Chincoteague. If you are in town it's a must. The pizza was…read moreperfectly cooked with a nice crispy crust. Everything tasted fresh.

The food is decent. The service was kind and impressionable. And the ambiance gave "hometown"…read more Everything you'd expect from something a small town.

Food is very good and good fast service ! Waitress is very polite her name is Lauren. Very good!!!read more

Great pizza. Efficient online ordering. We ordered take out and the food was prepared quickly and…read morethe online tracker was accurate

Food was good with prompt service. Prices are fair. Pizzas…read moreare very good and subs are large and filling. Typical sub shop atmosphere.

We ordered a sandwich & pasta about a month ago and instead of ordered red sauce, received Alfredo…read more Thought we'd give another try ordering the same about 3:44 pm and should know our preferences by now. After the tracker said had been delivered we called to actually ensure not misdelievered, interrupted before could ask question and was told had several deliverie. Forty minutes after tracker said was delivered actually received the pasta. This was over an hour and a half after ordering a sandwich & pasta. Further the order was not complete and the cheese Parmesan package actually pay for were not included in our order. So called the store at 4:40 to tell them and 40 minutes later still waiting. Called the store an 2nd time about Parmesan cheese and was told she was on her way. When asked for clarification either on her way or had not left the store yet, the employee stated had not left the store. so it is now 5:28 PM and finally have Parmesan cheese. This time when finally delivered cheese, there was a PASSENGER whereing a hoodie. As my daughter was handed a bag with the cheese, the employee stated to her "when you forget, I put more in the bag". We did not forget. But very sad takes two hours, to get this order.

Me and my family asked for Pan pizza and they give us Thin crust pizza‍ Thanks so much dominos $21…read moregone to waste. Y'all restaurants need to pay more attention to what your costumers are saying!!!

Amazing food, drinks, beer and atmosphere!! Owner was present and friendly!! Definitely going back!read more

They've got a great and continuously changing selection of beer on tap as well as bottles and cans…read more Food is good and the service is attentive and friendly.

"Out-of-this-world" doesn't even begin to cover it. Last night, on my actual birthday, I walked out…read moreof Amato's carrying two steaming boxes that basically turned my 2025 into a perfect year in one bite. First, the Large Cheese. This is the pizza your childhood dreams of when someone says "pizza." The crust is thin but has that magical leopard-spotted char on the bottom, the kind that makes a satisfying crack when you fold a slice. Sauce is bright, just tangy enough to keep you reaching for another bite, and the cheese... dear lord, the cheese. It's a molten blanket of whole-milk mozzarella that stretches like it's auditioning for a slow-motion commercial, then snaps back with that perfect oily sheen. No grease pool, just pure dairy glory. I ate three slices before I even made it to the car. Zero regrets. Then I opened the Sicilian and actually said "holy sh*t" out loud in my kitchen. This thing is a glorious brick of happiness. The corners, those fabled corner slices, are basically fried cheese cubes hugging a pillowy, olive-oil-soaked interior. The bottom is crisp like focaccia that went to war and won, and the sauce on top has that slow-cooked sweetness with little specks of herb that make you feel fancy even when you're eating it straight out of the box with your hands like an animal. The cheese caramelizes right at the edges, turning mahogany and nutty. I'm 99% sure this pizza added years to my life. I've had pizza in New York, New Haven, Naples, and Detroit. This random Tuesday-night birthday pickup just kicked every single one of them down the stairs and took their lunch money. If you're within 50 miles of this place and you don't go get these two pies, I'm sorry, but we can't be friends anymore. 11/10. Would sell my remaining birthday cake for another one right now. Go. Right now. Thank me later.

Mushrooms on the 16-inch large regular pizza were from a jar, rather than fresh. Yuck! Pizza had a…read morevinegary taste.

This pizza was probably the best pizza I've ever had. Meat, meat, meat and the pepperoni Detroit…read morestyle. Extra cheese, extra toasty. Just wow! We paired it with Black stallion Cabernet... we also got 2 meatballs as an appetizer. We are coming here again in 2 weeks during WineFest. I can't wait! Kris our bartender was fantastic. Very attentive and friendly. Cute and and small restaurant and the patrons were also friendly.

Jenna provided superior service. Very friendly and attentive…read more Onion tart pizza was excellent. Portion size perfect to share. Meatball sliders are amazing. Make sure you get extra sauce on the side. Inside seating or outside seating. Plus bar seating. Unisex bathroom downstairs plus an upstairs bathroom. Parking on the side of the building. Highly recommended