The pizza is genuine NYC PIZZA with specialties of Detroit style pizzas and a variety of others…read more Going to NYC a few times a year this pizza tracks well with the style pizza you'd get there it's a blend of the beach and NYC. The service is top tier with the crew members remembering your name while you're in their restaurant not just associating a dollar sign with your name which is nice in this day and age! Would highly recommend for friends and family!

Hands down the best pizza we've had in AMI!…read more But the show stopper...The Chicken Alfredo! It was so delicious! We ordered here several times during our stay and it was fabulous!

Had a chance to try Feast while in the Island. It's located in an unassuming strip mall, so was a…read morelittle apprehensive. Entered the lobby to a small area of 4 booths, then enter a larger room with multiple tables and a small bar at the end. We did not have reservations so offered the only option of the four tables up front, which was fine. Service from Ricardo was on point, prices average $36 for entrees. Each includes choice of starch, and was a great loaded baked potato, but not informed each item on the potato was a $1uo charge.. Salad substitution was available at $6.95 up charge, which I don't understand, so a few points off. Happy Hour ends at 530, which seems a bit early (and we were greeted at 533p, even 6 would be better, again minus points, but the drinks were ok at $8. Menu is heavy on Grouoer choices (and good Grouoer it was), with good sized portions. We both enjoyed our meals and the restaurant is located between an ice cream shop and a bar, if you want to continue the evening. We skipped dessert but they average $12 and sounded great. Food and service were both very good, just find all the up charges on a $36 meal annoying. Will be back and next time make reservations to be in the main room with the Adults!

I do not recommend getting any risotto dishes here. The risotto is horrible and is more like mush…read moreor mashed potatoes. Actually, it looked like mashed potatoes. And the Braised short rib on the risotto looked more like deli roast beef sliced up super thin. I ate the meat off the top and left the risotto after one bite. My friends ribeye was paper thin but it was cooked medium rare It was expensive and the food was disappointing.

Great place to get a drink! Went two times during our vacation and we loved it! The bartenders were…read moresuper sweet and the service was good!

We called and ordered 3 large custom pizzas. They told us it would be ready in 25-30 minutes. My…read morehusband left our house after 25 minutes for the 10 minute drive to the bar. They had forgotten to put our order in the system until we after we arrived and asked to pick it up. They put the order in and we paid about $120 with tip for the three pizzas. My husband waited for over an hour at the restaurant. No discount received. Many apologies from the staff though. Ultimately, the pizza quality was fine but one of them (pepperoni) had an abnormally sweet crust- like sugary sweet. It was odd. We all commented on it, not great. Pepperonis themselves were very tasty. Otherwise the pizza would have been decent for the beach. I don't like giving local island spots bad reviews since we've lived half our lives here for 20 years but that was a disappointing experience and our first ever experience at Bortell's.

Easy pick up, good pizza…read more We called and ordered for pickup. As crowded as it was, the food was ready - and the pizza was good.

The restaurant is casual with a beach feeling. They have indoor and outdoor seating. Inside they…read morehave a gas rotation oven. The staff is very friendly and helpful. We ordered a salad first with extra dressing. It was very fresh. We even noticed the salad station was very clean and organized. We had a large pizza AMI. It was very good. It was a little floppy from oven base not hot enough since they were busy. We had a couple of cold beers to go with our dinner.

Food was realllly goood... Folks were nice…read more. Quiet clean place.. Prolly will go back before we leave vacation and get the pizza

Fast service. Very friendly operators. Everything we got was good. Would definitely come back.read more

The grouper and coconut shrimp was the bomb! I can't wait to come back again. Sophia was our server…read moreand she was very good.

Love the grouper tacos and AMI sunset drink. First time this year was missing the place.read more

Friends have recommended this family run market in Holmes Beach so we gave it a try- great…read moreassortment of goods- fresh meals, grocery items, pizza, olive oils, baked goods etc. We bought meatballs, lasagna and chocolate chip cookies. The lasagna with meat (sausage) was restaurant quality and delicious. The loaf of bread they gave us was outstanding as well. The cookie was the perfect, delicious ending to a meal at home. This will require us to visit more frequently, especially now that the snowbirds have left.

We love coming in here and looking at all their products. The atmosphere with all the meats…read morehanging, pasta, wine, etc. is nice. We ordered a pan each of Meat Lasagna and Shrimp Scampi on linguine to pick up ready to eat for dinner. We added a couple bottles of wine and it was all delicious! They were very helpful in helping us make our choices. They sort of go at their own pace but for us well worth it.

Best pizza I've had in a long time. Even the pizza snobs at the office highly recommend this place…read morelol

Best pizza I've had in a long time! Good, thin crust and generous toppings. 100% recommend.read more

This place has absolutely awesome Pizza and incredible family running the restaurant…read more Unfortunately, the restaurant was severely damaged during hurricane Helene so they have not been an operation in a while. However, I hear they are reopening and I truly hope it's the case because not being able to have their food for so long has made many people realize how incredibly amazing this place is. If they open and you get a chance to try them ... run, don't walk and enjoy every bite. You don't know how good a family restaurant really is for how much you'll miss it until it's gone!

My little Italian Grandma passed several years ago. This pizza and sauce brought tears to my eyes…read more It tasted like my childhood the gravy/sauce is so good. The gluten free crust is the best I have ever eaten. Truly authentic Italian. Thank you Oma's!

Although I don't normally review chain style restaurants, I felt the need to on this one. My…read moredaughter was hungry on vacation late at night and a lot of the other places were closed. This dominos location was only 3 minutes from our location so we placed an online order to be picked up. Domino tracker app was updated to "in the oven" almost immediately after order, so I figured they just updated it on their end to keep their times down for corporate. I was mistaken and the pizza and wings were literally done and in my hands in 8 minutes. Keep this staff around because they are not messing around. As far as the food goes, it was better than I had remembered dominos as I haven't had it in quite some time. Wings have never been my favorite there and they are a little mushy. But the sauce was good. Staff was also very nice upon pickup. Building was typical dominos strip mall location but seemed to be clean

I've been standing in here for an hour and they still haven't taken my order. This is the most…read moreunprofessional establishment I've ever had the pleasure of stepping foot in