Really good pizza. Best on the island by far! Didn't love their Italian dressing but everything else was great!

The place is pretty awesome, for it being a small storefront. The parking situation could become hectic since it's not as large. Pizza was okay. Honestly, Marco's pizza can be better. More filling. If you're looking to not have something as heavy or filling, it is perfect. We did have to wait a little bit after the time that the website mentioned it would be ready, but not too long. read more

See all

Solid pizza for a quick service dinner after a long day at the beach. Happy we gave this spot a try. read more

Pizza Social - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

See all

As you can see in the photo, they have an outdoor area for eating, which is perfect this time of year with beautiful weather. They also have a few tables inside. We didn't need table service so I'm not sure if they have it; you order sit down and they bring your food. All the staff was very friendly and helpful. The vibe is fun and upbeat which you realize as soon as you park. We opted for inside seating; the music was just a smidge loud, but fun. Pizza: Thin crust, Chicago style isn't usually my preference; however, this was probably the best thin crust Pizza I've ever had. The toppings were perfect, not too much not too little and the crust was cooked to a crisp perfection. We'll definitely comeback with friends or family. read more

See all

Super fast carry out times- we ordered garlic bites, chicken bacon ranch pizza and pepperoni pizza. No complaints ab any of it! It has a different style crust which is chewy and not as tough. read more

Overpriced gross pizza mostly bread barely any cheese and sauce. Don't waste your money. Super loud and tight quarters inside. Service was okay a tad slow but friendly i just expect decent pizza for a small 14" that they call a large at over 20 bucks read more

Pizza Social - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

Pizza was great but the staff needs to work on their attitude. We walked in on labor day weekend on Sunday (8/31/2025) and it seemed like the girl at the register hated her life. We received what I would call "stank face" and coldness. We (being an all Asian group) didn't get recognized at all when we ordered. Not even "hi, can I take your order" Or even a simple "hi how's it going?" Although it is funny how the group that ordered right after us (not asian)... Received a "hi, how are you? Have you been here before" welcome caught us off guard... I'll leave the imagination and what you wanna call it up to you. Service and attitude goes a long way. read more

The restaurant is casual with a beach feeling. They have indoor and outdoor seating. Inside they have a gas rotation oven. The staff is very friendly and helpful. We ordered a salad first with extra dressing. It was very fresh. We even noticed the salad station was very clean and organized. We had a large pizza AMI. It was very good. It was a little floppy from oven base not hot enough since they were busy. We had a couple of cold beers to go with our dinner. read more

Pizza Social - AMI pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

See all

I strongly recommend to order takeout. We visited on a Sunday night around 6 PM the biggest challenge was the wait time for the food. And they were fair about it and they have a sign out by the front door that said the wait for the pizza was an hour and 15 minutes. We got multiple pies and they were all good. The Greek salad and. Parmesan garlic bread bites were also very good. Those came out fast. Service was friendly and quick to deliver the non-pizza items They mentioned that in the summers, they're usually pretty booked like this. Next time we would order for pick up. read more

Pizza Social - Parmesan garlic bites - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

See all

Got two 10" take out pizzas and garlic knots. The garlic knots were really basic. Not even knotty and very flat. The pizzas were decent although very expensive. read more

This place came highly recommended so I expected great things! Unfortunately, we left disappointed. We got a cheese pizza and Hawaiian pizza. Neither had much flavor and the pizza was very thin. I appreciated that it wasn't overly heavy or greasy but it didn't really leave us satisfied. Service was just ok, we took it to-go and the workers were friendly enough. Sad to say that I would not go back or recommend this place. read more

Easy pick up, good pizza. We called and ordered for pickup. As crowded as it was, the food was ready - and the pizza was good. read more

This pizza is amazing. Might be the best I ever had. The pepperoni was small and roasted with slightly crunchy edges. Perfect sauce. Not too sweet and not bitter. The crust was thin but so good. I don't usually eat the crust but I did this time. Absolutely delicious after a day of sun and surf! read more

Finally a place in the area that knows how to make a good pizza. Good undercarriage. Premium toppings. Excellent service. Friendly clean atmosphere. Good prices. I will definitely be back. I'm a local and I've been looking for decent pizza for almost 5 years in this town. You have a new loyal customer. read more

Pizza Social - 14 inch social. Nice and crispy. Very flavorful. - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

The best meat lovers' pizza I've ever had. Balanced well, not overwhelming with meat. Wings are delicious--lots of beer options. The chocolate peanut butter dessert was fantastic! Matt was excellent and attentive with our service. Had lots of tvs to watch Sunday football games. read more

Had a great pizza from there. asked for it to be well done and they cooked it perfect. smaller pepperoni size, but a great pizza and also had a salad. There were about 8 people cooking the pizzas and almost all of it was take out. smaller eat in area, so don't go expecting a large expansive location. A good pizza at a good price. on AMI, the choice if your on the north part of the island. read more

From Chicago .... THis pizza was just ok. It was island expensive. Some people in our group thought it was fine.

This is a gem of a place with great food. We stopped in before heading to see the sunset on the beach. What did we order? We got the AMI pie which had Red sauce, italian sausage, pepperoni, bacon, banana pepper, mozz It was absolutely delicious and worth the wait (the place was HOPPIN'!) read more

Pizza Social - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

See all

Ordered to-go pizza's on our first night of vacation from here as we didn't want to grocery shop after a long drive. Wish we would've tried more pies but ran out of time (and money) to try more of the menu! The pizza was delicious & we got our order in 15-20 minutes after calling it in on a saturday night. We ordered a plain pepperoni pizza & the buffalo pizza from their specials. My favorite was the buffalo with their fire roasted chicken, mozzarella cheese and topped with ranch dressing. Excited to try more pies if we ever make our way back down! read more

Pizza Social - Buffalo - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

See all

The pizza was good. Just what we needed while at the beach. It was ready when I arrived for takeout.

Pizza was delicious!! Had the cheese, pepperoni, and veggie highly recommend all. They are upfront about wait times but it wasn't too bad! read more

Pizza Social - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

Good pizza , by the beach! Fresh ingredients, friendly service and pizzas are made quickly. We eat here every time we visit Anna Maria island! read more

Got a half and half pepperoni and margarita pizza. I loved my margarita side, my husband liked the pepperoni. Both enjoyed it but think it's a bit expensive for what you get, in our opinion. Would still recommend! read more

Pizza Social - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

Delicious pizzas! Everyone was super friendly and pizza was made fresh in front of you! They were very fast!

Pizza crust was pre-made and the chicken topping was rubbery like it came from a packaged chicken salad kit

Very good pizza perfect ,Lots of flavor and not greasy which I like perfect crispness read more

Pizza Social - Pizza and garlic dough knots - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

Not what we had hoped. Crust was terrible. Pizza lacked flavor. Highly reco Pizzano's over Pizza social. read more

Grey casual place pizza if fire. Crust could be more crispy or thin for my liking but still really good. Fresh ingredients, great service and great pizzas. read more

See all

Visited here today as the start of a girls trip! We got the taco pizza and the beach please pizza. The food was amazing and service was amazing. There were outdoor seating options as well as indoor. I loved how the inside and outside gave off a very beachy vibe! Can't wait to share more reviews throughout the trip! read more

Pizza Social - These are the pizzas! - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

See all

Ok, I can't remember if I left a review last time. Great place and the piazza was even better than I remember it. Highly recommend the taco pizza, social, BBQ and Buffalo. One 10 inch is good enough for 2 people. Service is great too, people here are very nice read more

See all

Cute place with good pizza! Pizza was good, their system was efficient and quick! Loved the customization option for bases and toppings. Glad we stumbled upon it! read more

Ordered pizzas here on our first night. Pizza is good, made fresh and cooked right: but make sure you order with plenty of time. Told us 1+00 hour wait and our pizzas didn't go in the oven until well after that time. I understand busy, but you would think this happens every tourist season? But what do I know. Worth a try, but don't order last minute and make sure you have time to kill. Crazy busy and way under staffed! read more

Small but mighty! We are self proclaimed pizza snobs and stopped in here our first day on the island, while we waited for our beach house to be ready for the week. We got a cheese and margarita and both were fantastic! My husband, who's from NY, and very particular about his pizza, said it was some of the best pizza he's ever had. My 9 YO so who usually only eats 1 slice, he had 3 and asked if we could order more. Highly recommend! Only downside is finding parking, and apparently we were less than 20 feet away from a cross walk and got a $50 parking ticket. So the pizza was extra expensive for us, but at least it was great! read more

Pizza Social - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

We come here all the time - primarily get to go. Super easy to order and even at the busiest times it takes 30 minutes tops. Not a big restaurant but the pizza and salads are awesome. read more

Excellent pizza. We ordered delivery for social pizza. Used a 3rd party delivery service and everything worked out perfectly. Had the Greek salad and was surprised how good it was. Social pizza is on our list for pizza in this area. read more

Pizza Social - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

We saw the reviews and decided to try it for a night in to watch a football game. They did not disappoint. Wood fired pizza with a semi sweet sauce and a New York flop. We enjoyed the 14 inch social and AMI. Lots of toppings and competitive prices. They had a pleasant Christmas theme displayed. We ordered online without issue for pickup. Friendly staff. Very limited parking. I would recommend. read more

See all

Ordered a large Windy pizza! Absolutely the best pizza in Florida! Service was excellent! A very well maintained environment clean and Andy does a great job with his staff and keeps his customers keep coming back!! Don't pass by you won't go wrong!! read more

This place is not a typical tourist pizza joint. I almost always try a margherita pizza the first time visiting, as I did here. This was superb!! AMI is where I love to come and just enjoy the island atmosphere, I'm about an hour away from the north end of the island. You do pay a lil more but it is a tourist area. The quality makes it worth it. When it comes to pizza, listen to Gino !! Other items I can't speak on though. read more

Pizza Social - That delicious margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

Raw, nasty. Cleaned our own table. Bathroom was gross. No ice in machine. Skip this place read more

Pizza Social - Honestly this place has a lot of potential but the pizza came raw. Multiple people besides us also were sending their pizza back. Gross - Pizza Near Me - Anna Maria, Florida

It was good, I ordered some cheese pizza, and ate about three slices, although the quality was good, it was nothing out of the ordinary and the flavor was kind of bland, I most likely will not return to this location, but there are not a lot of choices for pizza on the island. read more