This place is huge with so many drink and dessert options. If I'm local to this neighborhood, I…read morewould most likely be coming here more often...like a lot often. They have so many seatings and the vibe here is sooo good. I ordered the Nutty White Chocolate Latte with almond milk and it didn't occur to me to wait on the drink but rather went to the seat and take selfies with my good friend. Our cashier literally went out of his way and brought the drink over. Later the Batista also came over with the extra drink since they made extra with the regular milk. Overall, I enjoyed both drinks. I found the one with regular milk tasted so much better than the one with almond milk.

Visit Date: May 3, 2026…read more All I want to do is go to the cafes listed in my LI cafe passport book for Christmas but my friends keep picking different coffee shops that are not in my book which is slightly annoying to me lol I made a plan to meet my friend Shani and she wanted to check this place out. I got a regular coffee with half and half because I also got the crepe and wanted to not have sugar on top of sugar if I drank a sweet drink and had a sweet dessert. I ended up choosing a crepe, they had no dessert with peanut butter in it which would have been my first choice. The crepe was okay. I ate half of it and my boyfriend ate the other half when I saw him after coffee. I found this place to be just okay, I gave it 4 stars because it was good but it didn't wow me and I think they made it too trendy looking and too hyped up. The service was also very good the man who helped me answered my questions patiently. So I liked this place but wasn't really wowed by it.

Dinner at Kismet Coffee in Bay Shore tonight was absolutely delicious and completely exceeded…read moreexpectations. While they're already well known for their excellent morning coffee, their dinner service deserves just as much attention. The confit chicken with truffle mash was outstanding--perfectly cooked, deeply flavorful, and incredibly comforting without being heavy. The truffle mash was silky and had the perfect amount of truffle without being overwhelming. The ox tail with polenta special was another highlight: rich, tender, and slow-cooked to perfection, with layers of flavor, kind of like short rib. It was my husband's first time having oxtail, and definitely not his last. The experience was made even better by the friendly, welcoming staff, who were attentive without being overbearing and made the evening feel relaxed and inviting. A huge bonus was their espresso martini menu, which can be made with decaf--a dream for anyone (like me) who's sensitive to caffeine at night but still wants to enjoy a great cocktail. They have events and live music most nights of the week and you can just hang at the bar if you prefer. Kismet Coffee is so much more than a morning stop. If you've only been there for coffee, you're seriously missing out. Do yourself a favor and check them out for dinner--it's a hidden gem in Bay Shore and absolutely worth the visit.

Did not try the food. Espresso was horrible. I could smell…read morethe bitter beans as they were being ground. Has any of these baristas tasted espresso at a good Italian restaurant? It's never bitter. Please buy a better bean and train your employees the finer points of making espresso shots! Sorry, but steaming a gallon of milk and throwing in a few terrible shots does not make a quality coffee drink.

My favorite place to eat dinner, best chef in town!!!!…read more We visited for Valentine's Day, which is a rarity for my husband and me. We've actually never gone out for Valentine's Day before. But we've visited Roto a few times for dinner, and they truly have the best dinner options in town. The dinner menu rotates, so it feels like you're going to a different restaurant every time, but the options never disappoint. This time it was a fixed menu, and when I tell you every serving was perfect, no detail was overlooked. The caviar play on sour cream and onion was amazing! The short rib was tender, melt in your mouth good. Even the little gem salad had the most amazing flavors, perfectly balanced! My favorite was the chocolate cake, delicate and not overly sweet. I'm not a sweets girl, and I ate the leftovers the next day, did not share! The service is so attentive. We visited once for dinner, and the second time the server already remembered our favorite wine. The ambiance is absolutely perfect for a date night. I will continue to visit. Bonus, they also have amazing lunch and breakfast options during the day!

Stopped in for a pickup order on my lunch break. It was pretty busy with a long line, but it moved…read morequickly. I ordered the Cuban sandwich, which came with house chips. Customer service was fast and friendly, and the decor felt modern and chill. When I got home, I was a bit surprised by the size of the sandwich, especially for $19 and change. Being from Florida, I'm used to much larger Cuban sandwiches, so I had hoped to split it. That said, the flavors were solid and everything tasted fresh. I'd definitely consider stopping in again, especially to dine in and enjoy the atmosphere. While prices are on the higher side, it seems like a nice spot to sit down and take in the vibe.

I've wanted to visit My Town's Cafe for a while, and I'm so happy to say that I finally stopped in…read moretoday with my husband. It's such an intimate spot that feels relaxing and comfortable- definitely a place to stay for a while. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and well organized. We ordered a few items: The Noah- Iced Banana Matcha (a new favorite it was so good, loved the banana foam) The Amanda- Tiramisu Americano (not sweet but bold flavor, pairs well with a sweeter dessert to balance things out) The Chocolate Chip Muffin, Blueberry Scone, and Rainbow Cookie Cake were terrific as well. I'd happily recommend this place to others and look forward to returning.

This is a mom and pop shop that has amazing different coffees and teas. I love to support the small…read morebusinesses especially when it is a good one with a good brand and a great taste. The service was amazing and the ambiance is nice and cute. We got it to go but you can sit in there and enjoy your coffee and cakes or cookies.

My go to spot locally to chill, WFH, and get some breakfast and coffee/tea before starting the day…read more Owner is one of my fave people, so sweet and she always remembers my crazy orders lol. Bagels always fresh and they use deli quality cream cheese (not that store bought stuff). They also serve hot sandwich's (ready-made once they gone, that's it!), tons of pastries, ready to go yogurts and coffee beans by the lb. Monthly specials always in line with holiday themes (March - St Patty drinks, February - Valentines Days, Fall - Pumpkin spice vibes, etc) It feels like a cabin living room which is cozy and intimate. If you're studying or doing work, team will bring your order to you and you can pay from the table you sit! Love these guys and def a local staple for sure.

Came here for the first time for a coffee run and they did have a lot of coffee and pastry options…read more I decided to go with a coffee that was barista choice but it was not the best choice in my opinion. I ordered a triple expresso shot with their butternut cold foam. The expresso shots were a bit watery and it felt like they gave me cold brew and not expresso shots. The foam on top was a bit liquidy as well and not thick as most cold foams are, The staff was friendly but overall, I would probably come back to try something else and possibly work from there as well. The place felt cozy and quiet and super welcoming !

They're back! My favorite breakfast/lunch spot just reopened at their new location 101 4th Avenue,…read moreBay Shore, NY! It's the perfect place to grab a coffee, tea, or even a glass of wine yep, they serve wine now! The vibe is super chill sit wherever you want and they'll bring the food right to you making for great service! They used to have a cozy little spot on Main Street, but now they've upgraded with a bigger space, a bigger menu, and room for more people. Everything is made fresh to order, with a creative twist on every dish. I had the avocado toast and it was amazing different seasoning, super flavorful, totally their signature touch. The space is clean, welcoming, and has that "you'll want to hang out here" feel. I couldn't wait for them to reopen, and now that they're back, I'll definitely be a regular!

Place is the new hot spot in Bay Shore. Clean and bright with both indoor and outdoor seating. Have…read moretaken out before but today sat at the bar. Excellent! Great coffee, great cocktails, phenomenal food! Definitely get the steak sandwich and tunacado. Delicious!!! The staff is awesome and don't make you feel like you're a burden. The menu is not typical at all and I love it. Plenty of choices for everyone.

Like he was a killer had the Italian dressing on the side it was excellent. We keep going back for…read moremore.

If you've lived in the area, you know that we've always gone to Leggios…read more Been going for over 50 years. New owners, who have cleaned up the front of the store but maintained the integrity of the famous Italian hot or sweet classic sub , right down to the same wonderful bread.

Just another Dunkin' located in the middle of a shopping plaza, but without a drive-thru. Customer…read moreservice was adequate, though nothing stood out. I did notice the prices here are higher than at the Dunkin' closer to my home. Overall, there's nothing particularly special about this location, but if you need a quick Dunkin' run, it gets the job done.

Unfortunately the donuts wasn't fresh I guess this time of night they been sitting there and they…read moreare not making new ones. It was only 6pm but that's the only thing I can think of. Next time I won't go around this time if I go back because they're better donut spots with better flavors but I wanted a classic glaze and jelly. The ambiance is not as clean as I would like but I'm in and out of there.

I was doing laundry a few doors over from this restaurant and wanted something to munch on. I…read morebriefly looked through their menu and what piqued my interest was their a la carte tostadas. I knew immediately that I wanted one but which one? Well everyone raves about the birria so I made my choice. My tostada was made fresh, the shell still a little warm from the grease and crispy. The birria was good but it kind of just tastes like a basic stewed beef to me, unremarkable. The guacamole was nice and fresh... but! It was way over salted. I had to brush quite a bit off because paired with the birria it was a salt bomb. Also I love cheese but I wasn't feeling the cheese on this one. It didn't have much flavor so it felt like it was there for the sake of it, I took it off. Now the tostada tasted good after my alterations but it shouldn't be better after removing ingredients. I would like to try another tostada, maybe their al pastor? And I'd hope their guacamole is appropriately salted.

Great food! Birria is delicious. Owner Tatiana so gracious kind and helpful. Great experience…read morewill definitely be back!!!