Small Pie is located in such a charming part of Bay View, just a short distance from South Shore Park. The large patio offers both sunny and shaded seating, making it a great spot to relax. Inside, the space is beautifully decorated with cute wallpaper and smells amazing as soon as you walk in. My favorite item was the Sausage & Egg Jam Sandwich, which was only $10. The homemade blueberry jam was definitely worth trying! Made in-house, it added the perfect touch of sweetness and flavor, creating a delicious balance of sweet and savory. The pie was rich, decadent, and very tasty, though I felt $9 was a bit pricey for a small slice. Thankfully, the coffee came with free refills, which helped balance out the overall cost. Overall, it was a lovely experience, and I'd happily stop by again to try more of their menu. read more

I love getting breakfast at Smallpie. My favorite food items are their hand pies - specifically the southwest black bean. I also like their granola and various breakfast sandwiches. The service is a walk up counter and they make the food fresh. They offer several n/an and alcoholic beverage options - the cherry limeade is refreshing! They have a smaller indoor seating area but larger seating outdoors. Dog friendly. read more

SmallPie - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Talk about a bustlin' restaurant. Of course, this place is jam packed on a beautiful Saturday. Service was smooth and patient. Ordered a SportTea and it was perfection, as I hoped. Definitely, will go back! read more

Milwaukee Mud Pie: Honeypie Cafe opened in 2009 in the Bayview neighborhood on the south side of Milwaukee. They serve Midwestern-inspired food using homegrown WI ingredients. Their daily menu includes an all-day breakfast (something all restaurants should do) as well as an exclusive weekend brunch menu. In 2018, SmallPie opened a short 1.5 miles from its parent location. All of both location's pies are made individually by hand with Wisconsin butter, milk, eggs, oats, cream and (when available) Wisconsin and Midwest grown fruits. For my first visit I had to try their "all-time customer favorite", Milwaukee Mud Pie. It's a chocolate shortbread crust filled with a baked fudge layer, a layer of crushed chocolate sandwich cookies (off-brand OREOs), and a layer of chocolate cream filling. Topped with freshly whipped cream and more crushed chocolate sandwich cookies. I really wanted to like this and I'm not trying to dump on them, but I honestly prefer the frozen pies from Marie Callender or Edwards. Something about it just makes it fall flat for me. Possibly it's not sweet enough, but overly rich from the whipped cream. Personally, I prefer something more like Cool Whip as opposed to actual dairy cream. On the plus side, the chocolate short bread crust and brownie-like fudge layer had an excellent texture. It would have been nice having another pie to judge them with, but slices of both versions of their banana cream pie were unavailable. For me, this is an avoid as it's no way worth the calories with tastier (and cheaper pies out there). *This is was a 2 star pie, but I don't want to hurt a business based on my personal tastes so 3 (average) stars for effort. Doughboy_Food_Reviews read more

See all

We came here in the morning to try something new and grab a small bite to eat. We walked by here several times and finally decided to stop by before we started working for the day. I had the bacon biscuit which had Wisconsin honey inside it. It was really good and the honey definitely made it pop. Unfortunately, there was a hair (not mine--it was too short) in it which turned me off for the rest of it. Alyssa got a couple of pastries that change daily. She said they were really good and that she wanted to try more another day. The pastries were the perfect amount of buttery and flakey. We also were able to sit outside and watch people shop for garden herbs and plants in their little plant area. We both just had nitro and house coffees that were amazing! Next time we walk down there, I'd try it again but if there's another hair I'll probably never go again. The service was great and helped with explaining what was in each item so I could make a more informed decision on what to eat. read more

See all

This is such a cute little shop! Grabbed some breakfast to go for my family and a couple drip coffees. The savory hand pies are so yummy, buttery and had great flavor. Quiche was nice as well, but I felt a little skimpy on the add ins. Nice flavor though. My parents got coffee and said it was a touch on the bitter side. Cute spot, dog friendly, nice staff! read more

It was quiet on a weekday morning which was exactly the vibe! We sat outside which was perfect as the baby could be in the shade and we could be in the sun. Friendly staff. Both had a breakfast food item and a drink. Door county cherry limeade was amazing! And iced chai was great! On the way out I grabbed a couple of bakery items- salted honey pie and an oatmeal cream pie! Delish! read more

See all

Amazing patio, beautiful ambience and I love the garage door and open concept inside. Staff is attentive and knowledgeable, but seems to really struggle keeping up with food orders, maybe they were understaffed when I went? The food tastes as good as it looks. My biggest gripe is that 20oz nitro cold brew was $11.50, although it is really delicious. read more

See all

Love to stop by SmallPie for a snack or a SPORTea on my way to walk by the lake. I'm a big fan of their savory hand-pies. Their giant cookies are a home run. Their kale salad is also delicious. Cute patio, kind service. Lots of street parking in the neighborhood. Enjoy! read more

See all

I'm not even a pie guy. But even I know an excellent pie when I see one. And if they got your name in the title, as was the case with the Door county cherry pie we had from here, then you know it's gone be good. And it was. Everyone should try this... read more

Tasty sandwiches and decadent pie slices make SmallPie a perfect spot to enjoy some tu I be delicious in their delightful patio or to go.

Came here because YELP actually published a "best pie in every state" list while we were in Milwaukee, so of course we had to come try it. We got 3 slices for $26, a fruit one, a french silk, and a milwaukee mud pie. Pros: - Prices may seem steep, but the pie slices are HUGE. Also the french silk and mud pie were DELICIOUS - I even ate the rest of the mud pie the next morning and the taste still really held up. This place is literally a hidden gem. It tasted exactly like the best version of what I expected out of each pie. - Despite a very humble space, the outside area is very chill to take a bite of pie in - The service was very efficient - Has a bathroom - Not too busy, fast staff response 10/10 would come back to Milwaukee for this, probably my favorite thing we ate during our trip! read more

SmallPie - pies to buy! - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Small Pie is a cute little space with a small outdoor patio when weather permits to have delicious treats and bakery. We ordered a pie online for pick up as a gift for our daughter and hubby for their 3rd anniversary. It worked out super easily and well. The gals were kind and friendly at the store and our pie was ready to go at the pick up time. We also purchased a gift card as a gift for a future pie. This was warmly received and super delicious. If you're looking for a unique and sweet special (as the pies are costly , but made with quality ingredients) gift for someone- consider one of their pies. YUM!!!!! There isn't a lot of parking availability. But, you'll manage. :) If you are elderly or can't walk far- maybe look into being dropped off so you can sit outside and enjoy your bakery - or inside. The seating is limited inside and it is small inside. But then you can look at the pretty case of desserts and think about your next visit. read more

SmallPie - Inside looking at the yummies available to purchase. - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Stopped here for a quick lunch to go. Overall I like the location, ambiance, food, and staff. They were friendly and pointed me to the food menu when I looked confused trying to find it. I grabbed a turkey pepper sandwich, 12 oz iced chai latte, and slice of key lime pie. The only reason I'm docking a star is the pricing. Those three items costed $30 and I do not think that's justified. The food was great, don't get me wrong. I think maybe if the sandwich came with chips or a side or everything was a couple bucks cheaper, I would come back more often. read more

See all

The price of their pies has gone up but I feel like the quality has decreased. I will say the service is great, and the ambiance is always neat and clean. read more

Great spot to get some delicious treats for brunch or when having a sweet tooth. They have different pies and pastries that are all worth it. Different flavors for anyone, including vegans. They do have great service, they answer the phone and are polite. When you go in person they great you and make sure you're getting the correct items that you want. They have different crafts beers and wines. Ambiance is pretty cool and chill. Lots of locals so by that are walking their dogs. So get your dessert before they run out of it. Stopping by again. read more

See all

I had no idea SmallPie was a subsidiary of Honeypie which is closer to our home. Located in a hidden commercial pocket of Bay View, SmallPie is housed in a cute transformation of a gas station. My wife and I walked in and oohed and aawed at the cookies and pies on display. I tried to joke and kibitz with the two women working this warm Thursday morning in February, but they didn't like me. No smiles, warmth, or interaction was forthwith. They were all business. We purchased a bunch of stuff: 5 slices of pie and at least 4 cookies. Prices were very high, but the slices were big. SmallPie ain't cheap. My chocolate chip cookie was good, but the Toffee cookie was great. My favorite pie was pistachio. Chocolate pie let me down. In summation, the baked goods were well made and enjoyable, but the price point might cause me to hesitate. I wasn't in pie ecstasy. The lack of engagement by the staff wasn't encouraging. My sense of self needs positive reinforcement. Milwaukee used to be much friendlier. Tribalism isn't good for mental health. read more

I wish I wasn't in a rush or watching calories because EVERYTHING looked delicious. I had a breakfast Sammy and it was delicious. The fresh herbs, the thick bacon and the heavenly croissant made for a great start to my day. read more

There were five people working there today, The service is SLOW. I got two pieces of lemon pie. I saw the ones beat up in the pan, but they had a whole new Pie. I went home with lemon pie mush. Not something to serve to a visitor!! Last time I ordered a chocolate whip pie and went home with coconut cream. Of which I'm allergic to. I went today to support the plant business. I live within walking distance. DONE read more

SmallPie - Lemon supreme. - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

A great little spot to grab lunch in Bayview I recommend the chorizo and potato hand pie Dogs allowed read more

SmallPie - Good boys allowed - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

As a newcomer, I read lots of reviews about SmallPie and HoneyPie. As a former professional baker with a penchant for pie, I was excited to let someone else do the baking for me one day last week. With the sun shining and temperatures in the low 60s, I threw Jardine, my Jeep ragtop, into D and hit up SmallPie on the way to South Shore Park. I ordered the savory handpie of the day and a slice of banana cream pie (a variety I never make at home). Minutes later, when I reached into the bag for my first course, I drew out the warm handpie enveloped in baking paper made slick with butter. A lot of butter! Many days later I'm still trying to figure out if I, genetically predisposed to be a butter-lover, was turned off by the excess or impressed with the pastry chef's devil-may-care overuse of it. Either way, the savory filling was so underwhelming that I don't remember what it contained, but I do remember it needed a lot more herb and spice as well as a squidgy-sweet element like dried apricots (or raisins, if one must). The banana cream pie was very good, fresh as could be (little's worse in pastry than days-old BCP). My grandmother, mother, and instructors at culinary school spoiled everything for me by making me very aware of what excellent pie crust is all about; SmallPie does a decent job I can recommend. Next up will be coconut cream, soon! But I'll leave the handpie in the display case. Prices were shockingly high, but that seems to be par for the course these days. read more

Everything was so good! Cute outdoor space. Loved the sandwiches & pie was also great. Would definitely recommend for a lunch or snack! read more

See all

This is the cutest place in the middle of a neighborhood. The service is friendly and fast. The food is delicious and you get a lot. Sitting outside is so wonderful but they do have a few seat inside as well. Great bakery also. read more

I just love SmallPie. Their handpie are amazing. The mushroom one is great, I'm a big fan of the breakfast hoepple popple ones, and today I had the spring roll one. It had a nice kick! Might be my new favorite! The Girl Scout Lemon pie is the pie of the month - go get it! So refreshing and good. In addition to ours, they have delicious bars and brownies. All these treats can be enjoyed to go or on their patio. They also do their own delivery and curbside pick up. Highly recommend going here. I've been here twice in the past seven days! read more

See all

I am a loyal SmallPie fan - their herb chicken hand pie is a buttery breakfast treat and their sweet pies are delicious too. We love the gas station breakfast sammy as well if you're looking for a salty/sweet mix. I appreciate the beautiful native plants on their patio and the indoor/outdoor seating options. We often get some coffee to go along with our pies. The food at SmallPie has always been fresh and delicious and the quality is always excellent. I feel very lucky to have such easy access to this restaurant in the neighborhood! read more

SmallPie - Herb chicken hand pie - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

A cute little pie and coffee/tea joint. Huge garage doors that could open to a patio with seating - alas it was cold and icky the day we went so we had just dream of returning in the summer. The pies were great. The coffee was from Anodyne and was nice and roasty and dark. Service was attentive and friendly. All around great place to get a snack or dessert. read more

SmallPie - Look at this sweet old periodic table on the wall! - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I love this place. It's walkable from my house, there are plenty of choices for food and drink, and it's dog friendly! During covid they have been great about keeping people safe. My only complaint is that my vegan partner rarely has an option. Some vegan hand pies sure would be appreciated so we can both eat something warm! The dog always gets a biscuit and I really hope they're able to make it through the winter. Much love you guys. read more

SmallPie - Dog on the patio - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

A lovely conversion of an old service station into a neighborhood cafe with quality coffee and a nice assortment of food and other beverages. I opted for a breakfast hand pie. A perfectly flaky crust with a tasty hash brown and sausage stuffing. The staff was extremely friendly and efficient. The price point was spot on. Even if you are not in the neighborhood like we were, it would be worth turning off the main thoroughfare (Kinnickinnic) to stop by. read more

This was a nice surprise - great spot for baked goods! We were driving by and I noticed the sign and thought it'd be great to try. We had the following items: -Milwaukee Mid Pie -Triple Chocolate Cookie -Chocolate Chip Cookie The mud pie was excellent - rich and chocolatey, enhanced by the different textures...I appreciated how the bitterness of the chocolate balanced out the sweetness of the pie. The cookies were great too - moist, buttery, sweet, but with a nice saltiness. The quality of their treats is first-rate and you can tell they only use the best ingredients. I'd definitely visit this spot again. read more

I spent spring, summer, and part of fall biking past this adorable little pie shop/cafe on Oklahoma in Bayview looking longingly at the line in front, but just never getting around to stopping. The area always feels new england-y and vacation-y to me, with the lake so close and lots of cottages and tree lined streets. Fast forward to a cold Halloween afternoon...I scanned the online menu early in the morning before my ride figuring it would be quieter due to the weather. By afternoon when I got around to going, the online menu had shrunk quite a bit - as others mentioned they run out of stuff. I went with cookies and cream pie and holy cow did it not disappoint. It was a vanilla pudding with a cookie crust , covered with whipped cream and more cookie crumbs. The pie was really good so I'm going with 5 stars...that being said I hate to again be "that person" but I thought it was kind of expensive. There's a $1.5 "convenience charge" to order online so after the $7.5 slice, $1.5 charge, tax and tip, it was an 11 or 12 dollar slice of pie. I know I'm sounding grumbly and the pie was delicious, but the convenience fee for ordering online seemed excessive. All that said, adorable pie shop in Bayview :) read more

SmallPie - the outside of a restaurant with tables and chairs - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Their website posts all the pi's that you an try when there, but when I stopped by and sat outside, which was nice with area for dogs, there was no pie to choose from other than just two or three in the case. This was about lunch time in early fall. I was disappointed. read more

I go here for desserts and the cherry limeade. The latter is so delish - can't think of anything I've had like it outside of Door County! I've tried the sandwiches and don't love them. Really the desserts are the star - you can pre-order pick-up orders here, which is great for a party. The best pie that's always on the menu is the chocolate cream - TRY IT! If there's a line, it will move quickly. Folks are always nice when I'm ordering or picking up. When I do come here to eat something, their patio is LOVELY - awesome spot to catch some rays and drink coffee. Or that cherry limeade (real cherry juice) read more

Very cute small place that has some indoor sitting but more outdoor space as weather permits. Has delish bakery & service is counter. Nice little place to check out. read more

I loveddd this place when it opened, but the last few times I went it was pretty disappointing. My last visit I got a slice of pie, a handpie and a coffee for almost $30. I'm willing to pay that for something quality, but it was all fairly mediocre. My husband said the handpie was small and very dry. The cold brew was insanely sweet and not worth $9. The most disappointing was the pie. I've always loved their pie but the portions and toppings are smaller than in the past and they've raised the price again. Also very little variety. The staff is always incredibly friendly, but move slow and have little knowledge about the products. (they had 3 different variations of chocolate pies that looked the same and no one knew what the difference was). Overall just not worth the price. read more

SmallPie has the cutest outdoor patio and best pies EVER. Literally ever. If you like pie come here. They also have sandwiches they are good and other cafe items. The people who work there are always friendly and accommodating. The neighborhood is lucky to have it--and my dog loves sitting outside too! read more

SmallPie - Dog friendly outdoor patio. - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Food is delicious. It is our go to place for a fast-casual breakfast, especially on a nice day. The patio area is great. Staff are nice! read more

SmallPie - Sunrise Melt & a savory hand pie - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Always great service and I love the rotating selection of pies. Everything I've tried so far has been delicious!

Nestled on an island in bay view this hidden gem is one to check out . The pie selection is to die for. I ordered the blueberry lemon pie online and it was ready when promised. Easy pick up process and loved checking out the displayed bakery. Will be back ! read more

SmallPie - Blueberry lemon pie - Cafes Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Partaking in this year's socially distanced Pumpkin Pavilion meant driving around Bay View, admiring the spooky Halloween scenes in stranger's front yards. From simple to outrageous, the nighttime drive looped around displays of cobweb-laden trees, ominously-lit houses, and a variety of faux graveyards. We were driving around the backstreets, getting a little lost, until I recognized one of the shops on Delaware Avenue. "Oh hey, that's the main road up ahead... You want some SmallPie?" At night, SmallPie's little shop glows like a beacon, shining the way to sweet and savory baked treats in Bay View. It's impossible not to be lured in for a quick treat or meal when you're on Oklahoma Avenue. The food is delicious but humble enough that eating it on the couch or pairing it with New Glarus doesn't feel demeaning. You know? Flaky and filling, they have a good variety of vegetarian and non-veg options. I've gotten both the black bean and the Spanikopita (spinach pie) options, and I really can't decide my favorite! Although we almost never eat on the couch, the feel of a handpie is so comforting, that it felt right to sit in the dark and watch some TV, munching on our dinners. Sometimes, you just can't break the moment bothering to try to take a better photo of some really delicious food. Besides our savory handpies, we also couldn't not be tempted by the sweets on display. Both employees passionately praised the Pumpkin Maple Cake when I asked about it, so I chose a square of that, while Caleb got a thick slice of Milwaukee Mud Pie, dark brown, decadent, and rich. Either one could have been shared among 3 people, but we just saved the extras for later. And I'm so glad we did. I thank myself later whenever I remember to savor a dessert as delicious as that Pumpkin Maple Cake. Visit SmallPie for the holidays and anydays. They're open early and deliver too! read more

See all

Gas Station breakfast sandwich was great. Went for lunch and had quick and friendly service. More of a pick up spot though.