The service was very good. Old school Italian hospitality. Family owned business that is close to…read moreus, so we thought we would give it a try. Pizza was thin crust. Sauce was good. All toppings were delicious. Garlic bread was good as well. Give this small business a try! No real ambience to speak of as it was a pick up and takeout place.

Good sausage Lots of toppings…read more Take out this pizza. We like ours well done. Nice thin crisp crust.

Used their party room today, service was great, pizza was great. Definitely recommend!read more

This place has alot of tables and spots at the huge bar. I was told the building is the old…read moreShakeys pizza. We went with 5 people. Four people shared 2 pizzas (lots of leftovers) and one had the garden basil chicken sandwich. Everyone thought the pizza was good. Fresh, plentiful toppings. The garlic bread was average. Garden salad was huge, fresh and delicious. Chicken sandwich was a great, healthier option. Service was a lacking. Chicken sandwich was forgotten about. It was ordered without mushrooms but then came with them on. Sodas weren't refilled, and it wasn't very busy. Still rating 4 stars for the food.

It continues to be the best gluten-free pizza we found in a two county area…read more The trio of Great craft cocktails, great pizza, and Saysha as our server and you have the perfect Hattrick on a Saturday night

Recently I completed a 7-day stretch of trying at least one new-to-me restaurant per day. Day six…read morewas at Red Mill Inn & Pizza. Red Mill Inn has been near the top of my places to try list for a while. It was a smoky day due to Canadian wildfires, so I sat inside instead of out on their nice looking patio and ordered cheese garlic bread and a large sausage pizza. I enjoyed the cheese garlic bread. It was a very thick piece of bread that was crunchy on the outside and super soft on the inside. I'd gladly get it again. The pizza was good, not great. I appreciated the crispy edges from the oven it's cooked in, but something about it didn't wow me. It was so thin that I ate more than I probably should in a single sitting. I'd likely try something else if/when I come back to experience the patio. Shout-out to Rosie. She was an awesome waitress and I actually called back to confirm her name so I could mention it specifically in my review.

What took me so long to come here?! I've been eyeing this place for ages and finally got the…read moreopportunity to try. I am so incredibly glad that I did!! They had a special pizza, which was red sauce, mozz, ramps (which is a type of onion), pepperoni and a garlic drizzle. This pizza was so delicious. We also opted to try the Smolwaukee pizza; this did NOT disappoint. The buffalo wings were amazing and I was really eyeing the bbq ones but opted for the buffalo. I'm not too down with this hot honey fad, so they were able to keep the hot honey off, which I appreciated. They had a Buffalo ranch that complimented the wings so well. This spot does stop serving food May 7th and transition to their food truck. The space is then used to rent out for events and such. I truly look forward to eating here again!

Super busy Night decided to come over because my birthday and I wanted to celebrate and this is the…read moreplace to be. Still all the staff is very attentive and nice regardless of how busy they are. The atmosphere is great and it just so nice. Pizza is delicious. I just love it with the touch of honey. The fact that they have the Detroit style pizza on Wednesday is amazing. Everybody seems super happy and enjoying the conversation the food and even though it's noisy ( in a good way) it feels like home. The paper plate for serving is actually a nice touch because it goes with the theme of everything in this restaurant I just love it the decorations the colors and the friends pictures on the walls.

My favorite pizza! The sauce is so good and the crust is perfect. I also love the cheese bread…read morewhich comes with the pizza sauce on the side for dipping. Very good service every time we've ordered. The meal deals are perfect for our family of 5 and they also offer different specials throughout the week that we take advantage of ($10 medium pizzas daily from 12-4pm is awesome). Our kids love it so we ordered a couple of the XL pizzas for our daughter's birthday party and it was a hit. Definitely our go-to spot. Check them out!

5 stars for service and 4 stars for pizza. The guys were friendly and positive from the moment I…read morewalked in. It appears they do take out/ delivery only which is what I wanted. Pizzas were ready fast too. We were very impressed with the pizzas for the money, a solid value and we'd definitely reorder if traveling thru the area again. It's a no frills place and the price reflects that; much better than paying $30 more to carry out from a prettier place. Give em a try.

We always like the pizza here and I realized I have yet to leave a review! They have a small spot…read moreon Oklahoma but plenty of parking. The inside waiting area is a bit small but it smells like delicious pizza! We saved enough of the box coupons (10 of them) to get 50% off our stuffed pizza. However, at the register, we saw a note that they'll stop accepting those as of Sept 2026 so be sure to use your pizza box coupons soon! We ordered earlier in the afternoon because it was Super Bowl Sunday and were told an hour fifteen wait which wasn't too bad of a wait considering the circumstances. The pizza smelled and tasted delicious!

This is mostly takeout because the dining area is small. Pizza was recommended by many people…read more Crust 8 it was not cracker thin but had a good yeasty taste Sauce 8 the sauce was very standard. Not overly sweet Toppings 9 the Italian sausage was very flavorful and they didn't put on too much or little Value 7 I thought paying almost 20 bucks for 10 inch Milwaukee special was a couple bucks on the high side I like the pizza but if you want real cracker thin crust this isn't the place but the crust is still really good.

Great food. A lot of different options on food. If you haven't been definitely check them out. I've…read morealso ordered on Door Dash and never had any issues! Dine in or take out check em out!

The pizza was OK but the prices are outrageous. There are way better options if you stay…read morelocal/family owned for literally half the price.

I really enjoyed visiting Balisteri's for dinner as it looks and feels like a true neighborhood…read morerestaurant where the locals like to eat. I do to. Street parking was all I could see available and It was free. After being seated in one of the large rooms I was presented with a large menu that took me a few minutes to make my decision. After getting my nice waitress's opinion I went with the pasta bolognese for $20 that came with a side salad. While waiting I noticed all of the families dining here and I knew that I was going to have a good meal. The complimentary bread basket arrived quickly with butter. This bread was ok tasting but was a little on the dry side for me (3). Then the side salad showed up and I was pleased with its size. Almost like a small entree. It was very good tasting being a quality made salad. Less than 15 minutes later the entree appeared and looked very good. It was a generous size and I had some extra parmesan sprinkled on top. The fettuccine, mushrooms, sausage and meat sauce along with the 4 cheeses all came together and made for a satisfying and filling meal. After this meal, I was happy and would be glad to return. Also the waitress was warm and friendly. I would be happy to return as this is a very good place to come for a meal! You don't go home hungry.

Always delicious Italian. One of our favorite pizzas but went for parts this time…read moreGood service Traditional Italian restaurant feel

First time didn't disappoint! The pizza was yummy and we'd be here more often if we lived around…read morethe corner. The Caesar salad was good but was drowning in dressing. We're super curious about the weekly specials, so we will be back.

The pizzas are great and so is the lasagna. But let's talk about the buttery garlic bread...because…read morewow! It's rich, flavorful, and honestly the highlight of every visit. If you know, you know.

UNBELIEVABLE SERVICE. Really understated operation but helllooo thin crusty cheesy goodness. wow…read more get the sausage!!

Can't even get ahold of this restaurant. Who knows if they are even opened, I tried calling and…read morecalling